Great service and excellent selection! I had a great time trying on watches, and the person helping me, Grayson, was really helpful.

Was in the neighborhood meeting with my oncologist, and went for a walk afterwards . I happened to see a Thom Browne shirt I really wanted on the mannequin. I asked if I can try it on.... The ATTITUDE I received bc they just dressed the mannequin when I walked in took my breath away. I walked out of the shop. They will never see a dime from me ever again. read more

Service was terrible , and the manager has way to much of a power trip. She's making 18$ an hour she's needs to calm down . As well as racist . Do not recommend going to this location ! read more

Disappointing experience. Incorrect listing despite prior confirmation, slow resolution, and poor accountability. Not recommended. read more

The RealReal is a luxury merchandise consignment company. The regular customers tag the company TRR. The TRR app is very highly rated. It appears to me the company has stores in neighborhoods frequented by people with the financial ability to purchase luxury items. There's several in NYC. Just like the many other luxury brands consignment shops in the Upper East Side I browse these days. I like to get an idea of the value of some of the brands I own. I recommend you go in with the items you want to sell and be prepared to wait for assistance if necessary. You may want to consider getting there when the doors open! I'm attached to the very few items I have spent a lot of money buying. I always ask my daughter first before I think of selling or donating my belongings. Typically she says to keep it! Try visiting TRR. It's a great learning experience in my opinion. read more

Whoever's responding to the reviews on Yelp, I just want to ask you if you actually do anything about these reviews? Because it's been almost 2 years since my last visit, and nothing's changed when I went back last week! Your security guards are still rude, still weird and overall the in-store experience here is straight up garbage. One of the security guards literally thinks he's working for ZEUS network for Baddies or something...why was he in that "ready-to-pounce" stance???? I hate this store so much y'all. read more

Over priced bags and barely any selection like what is advertised. Very disappointing. Can go buy brand new for the price they are charging.

I was having issues online to purchase a Hermes. I called the Madison store immediately, and got Jada the SA on the phone. SHE GOT RIGHT TO IT IMMEDIATELY!! Helped and walked me thru the process on the phone step by step. Ive been waiting for this specific bag for 3 years! I cannot express my gratitude to this woman Jada for taking the time and being so patient with me. She is most definitely an asset to THE REAL REAL. Great , caring supportive employee! Thank you from a very happy, loyal , repeating customer. read more

Really great staff they are so courteous, genuine and helpful with co-signing shout out Tiffany. The storefront fits right in on Madison it's very sleek inside. A bunch of hot items why not skip Saks or Nordy for a trip uptown for grails. read more

Unfortunately this store was disappointing. I love shopping the online store way more. This location was tiny and didn't have any variety of options. Everything was super pricey. read more

3 stars because their staff on the second floor are very friendly, welcoming and knowledgeable. Now the staff on the first floor are a mess no shade. Minorities get treated poorly here And security guards are extremely rude. When i visit thisnlocation i make sure i have items that will required the assistance of the staff on the second floor that way i dont have to deal with the disrespect and the nasty looks. I do agree with one of the 1 star reviews I will still recommend if you looking to sell bag, watches... get an instore appointment and you will have a beautiful experience read more

Excellent all staff is very courteous knowledgeable and helpful thank you Trust the goods Will go back again soon read more

I sent my bag at the end of November, but the luxury specialist was really bad at communication. So, I asked them to change my luxury manager when I dropped the bag off, and they said they did. However, the new luxury manager never emailed me, so I don't even know who my luxury manager is. I reached out to customer service, but they told me they don't have the luxury manager's contact in their system. I was told I had to wait for the luxury manager to email me first, but as of today, 1/9/2025, it's been almost two months since I dropped off my bag. My bag still isn't listed for sale, and I have no idea what's going on. I've called and emailed several times for updates, but all they ever say is, "We'll write a note and share this with our team." The next day, I'll get the same response via email: "We will review this issue and get back to you." But no one ever gives me an update. I don't understand how people manage to sell their items on The RealReal. They're so unprofessional, and no one takes responsibility. All they do is pass the problem along to "the team." I even had an offer to sell the bag somewhere else, but The RealReal takes 30 days to return the item. Because of this delay, I lost the offer and wasted a month and a half trying to get updates. Despite all my calls, emails, and texts, my luxury specialist still hasn't reached out to me. Their service is absolutely horrible. If they don't improve, they'll be out of business soon. . read more

The RealReal on the Upper East Side has a nice selection of luxury consignment items, but I found it a bit cramped. The staff was friendly, but it felt a little overwhelming to navigate. Prices were reasonable, but I expected more rare finds for the hype. Overall, it's decent but it could definitely use some improvements! read more

I've been using The Real Real (TRR) for years, first the site then the UES store. this review is about the store mostly. - like any store in the ues, this one too caters to this clientele. I was selling personal jewelry and wanted to know what TRR's valuation. I met their jewelry expert after scheduling an appointment over the phone. I choose to meet instead of having all my pieces picked up and later returned after inspected, which I have done before and will speak about at the end. -they pick up in manhattan if you have over 20 pieces. Back to the store, after much research, selling and buying experience as well as speaking to people who work at TRR and that basically Chanel, Hermes and High end Brand jewelry are the only things that could sell at a fair-ish price AND, I knew that with the jewelry brands I had the price would be agreed upon before with them. I had the ring valuation. at the RR, he gave a similar price (about 15% less) Here is what I choose to sell this time, an H.Stern piece at a pre agreed upon price. It sold after about a year. In addition I chose to sell things I was not interested in dealing with and did not care at what price they would sell. They did then come to my house, picked up many things and then returned about 5 items including a tibi suit bought at intermix with tags (they said it was dirty I was annoyed as I know for a fact I try clothes on and I am sure that when/If return said clothes with a deodorant stain IE, they will clean it (I HOPE). and 2 pairs of shoes which they said had flaws. The website is decent but the store selection is catered to the UES customer. I don't mind going in if I have time, but it is not a store I am inclined to go (as a secondhand store I want to get a bargain, or find really cool vintage pieces. THIS. IN NEITHER. As a seller I want it sold at a fair price. I dont believe TRR services well Either (unless you have a Chanel flap, a birkin, ... very desired Brand items or jewelry) Personally I bought one designer item from them and my experience was good. I was pleasantly surprised at the fact they sell/accept some brands that are not known in the US market but are fantastic in their countries. Unfortunately the store doesn't reflect any of that. The customer service is mediocre unless they want you to consign with them. 2.5 stars for the site service for the buyers. read more

Been buying and selling with them for quite a while and never had an issue. That was until last week. The way it normally works is that a rep comes to my home, inventories what I have to sell, packs it up and takes it with her. It shows up on their website anywhere from 2 to 3 weeks afterwards. Quite easy and no big deal. I get my check a month or two later. Again, no big deal. The issue is that their reps change frequently. My new rep texted me no less than 10 times when she assumed her new position and insisted that we have a phone call to discuss my needs. Unfortunately, I really don't have time for that. Last week I bought a couple of things that I decided I really didn't want. It was too much of a hassle to return, so I called her figuring that she would be thrilled to hear from me and have the opportunity to pick up some things that I wanted to get rid of. Not so. She demanded to know what exactly I was selling and wanted pictures. If I wanted to take pictures of what I was selling, I would sell them on eBay and make all the money rather than the half that RealReal pays. After about 20 minutes of texting which again, cost me more money in lost income than I would have made selling the items, I told her to forget it. For me, it's all about convenience. If the process becomes tedious I'd rather dump things on eBay or drop them in a donation box. For now, I'm done. read more

As a former buyer and a former seller, I can tell you that the consignment operation at this office is highly incompetent, resulting in great distress. In addition, The Real Real online customer service is abysmal beyond belief. In fact, The Real Real owes me money and it's not worth the continued effort and time to even collect it. The merchandise at this location is nice and frequently a good value, hence the two stars. read more

Had a bracelet sent over very smoothly from online and overall great experience! The entire process went very smoothly and efficiently read more

The RealReal - Upper East Side - Bracelet - Women's Clothing Near Me - New York, New York

Love the merchandise! Mariela, the Head of Shop, and the Expert team are all extremely knowledgeable and provide excellent consignor and customer service! read more

Love the service and they were prompt with customer service. I really liked how they all came to ask if I was ok, even when I was just making a decision. Opey was awesome with the customer service. Helped me with all my needs. Thanks! read more

The RealReal - Upper East Side - Women's Clothing Near Me - New York, New York

Great service and helpful advice! I got a pair of sunglasses for a great deal and was helped very quickly. read more

The RealReal - Upper East Side - Women's Clothing Near Me - New York, New York

Mariela is the best! We found 2 perfect gifts! Amazing! Love shopping here at the real real read more

The RealReal - Upper East Side - Women's Clothing Near Me - New York, New York

I've been shopping with TRR at both their locations in New York City as well as online. I also sell with them and I've been doing business with the real real for 11 years. From the real real, Iv bought dresses, shoes, boots, sneakers, handbags, wallets, coin purses, blazers, jackets, shorts, pants, slacks, dresses, gowns, 4 mink coats & jackets, watches, rings from every designer from Hermès, Chanel, Louis Vuitton, JMendel, Ralph, Lauren Black label, Prada, and many others. Quite frankly, I don't understand many of these bad reviews . I think when people buy from a consignment store, whether it's online or in the store, they need to read the item and look at the photos . BEWARE! When an item says good or fair, you're not going to be receiving a brand new item it's going to be visually used. I understand problems with consignment stores roundabout, basically screwed me for everything that I gave them. They're a horrible company and I'm glad one of their stores closed. I'm shocked they're still in business but the real real do try to help their clients. I don't know their employees behavior in the very beginning when they opened, but I know now and for the last several years, they try to make their clients happy . They definitely are a multi million dollar business so I believe that many clients that sell and buy are very happy with their decision . Also, be wary, and think carefully, if an item is not to be returned. I think many times people jump at things without looking at photos, reading, descriptions, or sending real real an email with questions . I love the store. I love the company. I will continue to do business with them buying and selling. read more

I LOVE Love love the real real virtually and I don't live near one. I always wanted to go in person. I imagined a huge vintage paradise and I could try on fabulous clothes and assess fit without paying for returns/ shipping like I usually do.... No reviews actually reviewed the shop just random one-off experiences selling (but that because this location and I imagine the other ones in Manhattan are really only for intakes- I learned that quickly) In person shopping is vastly over priced and pretty much hideous "white elephant" type of clothing. The Jewelry is nice but I really wanted the vintage shop experience and this is more of just where they take-in and not sell a large quantity. Many people came in with vintage clothes in bags to sell. Seriously it was like 2 -3 racks of pricey Chanel/ (not classic looking more like the trendy one-off pieces) and all priced around 4-14K. And then a lot of Chanel/ Birkin bags for a lot. I mean if I'm in manhattan and want to drop that $$ much I'll go to Bloomingdale's and I'll buy new. read more

Do not list any thing of value or desirable with TRR. A few years ago they were great not anymore! Don't list anything with them you're better off selling on your own. Resolution is impossible you get nothing but the run around and lost time corresponding with a number of different people. TRR - don't bother asking me to DM you if you want to resolve this reach out to me. Don't do it! read more

I purchased a FAKE Furla handbag from The Real Real. I went to NYC Furla store, and they showed me the issues with the bag. I thought there was a problem when I did not receive the item as pictured on the website. Impossible to get a response from their customer service. I sent bag back to their Secaucus location, still waiting for my refund. You never get to speak to the same person twice. Last phony was Heather. Don't waste your money. read more

The WORST luxury reseller EVER! Don't you be a victim of marketing, it's all about money and sucking it as much as possible up! They LOST (or stole?) my $3500 Burberry leather jacket and never found it! They refused to get me the same or similar Burberry leather jacket. When I asked them to reimburse me the loss they just refused. A month (!!!) later they agreed to give me just $800, even though the jacket was like new. Stay away from these cheaters and don't waste your time! read more

See all

An AMAZING STAFF: Thomasina, Gavin, Josh, Jeremy & Jessica (online) was & are SUPERB!! They were welcoming, very professional, pleasant & informative on the phone, I never felt rushed and the outstanding customer service that was extended to me was stellar. Oops! I didn't have an appointment, and Jeremy was AWESOME and made my consignment process flawless! THANKS AGAIN FAB MADISON AVE - THE REALREAL FAM! Season Greetings! read more

The RealReal - Upper East Side - The RealReal Madison Ave location - Women's Clothing Near Me - New York, New York

Consignment was a simple process, even as a first time seller. The staff was well versed in the terms and went over all of the main points. The survey I received afterwards asking me if the staff covered these points confirms that they train their staff well. read more

Great shop - small retail selection but can order anything online on TRR's website and comprehensive consignment department. BEAUTIFUL jewelry selection too (danger zone!). They are VERY careful taking temperatures when you enter and have plenty of sanitizer available too. Highly Recommend! read more

The selection here was beautiful! I found so many pieces that I loved. The customer service was also really wonderful - they were super helpful. If I lived near the area I would come back all the time. read more

a great selection at the store today and a super friendly staff. transition your closet for fall and go stop by!

Excellent service and products!! A great selection of jewelry, watches, handbags, clothing and shoes.

Mariela was amazing! The store has great finds and service, and I left with an item I'm very happy with.

I would highly recommend this location. I had an incredible experience here and I worked with Makan and Mari and they gave me a warm, personalized experience while shopping. They listened to my price range and were not pushy! They were super sweet and helped me every step of the way while educating me on my item. I will be coming back because of them. read more

Had such a wonderful experience in this RealReal store, they have a variety of limited edition items that you can't even find in boutique retail! Opey helped me out this time and he was so patient to answer all my questions - it was a busy day today as its a weekend and though I went back and forth to ask him for his service, he was always uplifting and positive. Much recommended! read more

I consigned a valuable ring and it disappeared No doubt someone there disappeared it. Be careful. read more

An additional update after posting a bad review for this company. They reached out via message to "correct" the mistake and asked for my email which I provided and now I have emailed them 5 times following up on my missing case. Also have another damaged item which was never addressed. I can't believe the Real Real is still in business! If I could leave negative stars I would! read more

Store managers and sales associates were great in helping me source the bag I wanted to get!

Absolute scam of a company. I dropped off my AP Watch at this location and as a thank you for consigning such a high priced item I was issued a $200 credit on my account by a in store manager. This manager told me that the credit will never expire however, he lied! The credit had an expiration date of 2 months and after it expired I reached out to the online customer service representatives and they refuse to believe the face that I was told the credit will have no expiration date so now I lost $200 because the store manager LIED to me. SCAMERS!!! read more