Cute ice cream shop on Siesta Key. They have a large selection of flavors but I wish they had more…read morefruity and tropical options. The prices is expensive, even compared with nearby ice cream spots. The smallest cup is $5.75.

We visit at least 2x when we stay on Siesta Key and love the ice cream here. They used to list…read moreallergens on the flavors at the old location which was helpful when we brought visitors. Now you have to ask for every flavor if they have nuts and it would be helpful to know before sampling.

Yeah. Being that I grew up in Northeast Philly - it's " Water Ice!!!" Not Italian Ice. If you're…read morefrom Philly you know Rita's is ok. Other local places are better. Moving on....I got the Banana. It's ok. Way too sweet and without any Banana in it. So I'd stick with Vanilla, Chocolate or Lemon Ice. My partner got a Gelati which she enjoyed. It's the best Water Ice you can get down here so I'm good with it.

All my stars are for the young guy working alone on a busy tourist heavy night. Hard working not…read morecomplaining greeting everyone , making the ice, refilling the custard machine, running the cashier I mean everything. Where was his help?! Where was the owner ? Well done for the young man the world needs more of you.

The ice crème was great! Not only do you get ice crème, but you get a show! They put the bowl…read moretogether (what you chose) and then they mix it with nitrogen! The workers were really nice and it was very clean inside. I got a create you own. It was great!

8/10 good stuff…read more eaten here a ton as it's a very short distance to travel. service is nice, they show you their process of making the ice cream itself which is a unique feature. their brand of nitrogen ice cream is very novel among ice cream places located in sarasota and its quite good, as it has a very wide selection of flavors, toppings, and even bases. the ice cream itself is delicious as well. only real complaint is that due to it being flash frozen it has quite the "icy" feel; it's akin to getting your tongue stuck to a metal pole in the northern winter. this is really just a nitpick on my part however and i do recommend trying this establishment if you can.

The three women that serves us were amazing and the ice cream was notch!! My daughter is picky and…read moreshe loved it!

A small location right of the beach. The person behind the desk was very accommodating despite…read morebeing indecisive on my choices of ice cream. I choose vanilla bean which was excellent. I'LL BE BACK.

Cute little ice cream parlor with a game room attached and a huge outdoor sitting area next to a…read moreminiature golf and a driving range and a huge restaurant. I had some coffee chip ice cream with hot fudge and my wife had a chocolate ice cream and they were terrific young ladies reserved it were great, and this is an easy five star

From the owner: Welcome to Evie's. We are locally owned and operated and were established in Sarasota, Florida in…read more1997. We have grown to 5 locations to better serve you. Evie's cares about our customers and will strive to do what ever we can to deliver a top notch experience. Please use our site to navigate through the additional businesses we offer at each location. Feel Free to contact us if you need any additional information. Thank you , Evie's.

Met the man, Pete! He's so proud and passionate about his business. My favorite ice cream shop in…read morethe Sarasota area. I'd drive in from Orlando just to get a scoop of the Lemon Poppyseed and Coffee and Oreos ice cream. Dunken is the resident dog and has got the best sniffer in the industry. The parking lot is a little dark but you can see Pete's flashing lights in the window and the inside is full of cute whimsy and helpful signs about his products! This isn't a shop that just sells ice cream and Italian ice. Pete pours his passion into each home made flavor he makes vetting out high quality ingredients and natural colorings (such as blue spirulina, turmeric and beet powder and kale) which I appreciate the most! He's outstanding at his job making every customer feel welcome and serving up a product he should be very proud of!

I love a good ice cream. We stopped on a Sunday. There weren't any customers in the shop. They had…read morea good selection of ice creams all made by the owner. We each got a bowl with two scoops. The texture of the ice cream was great but the flavors were weaker than I prefer. The place was clean and decorated cute. The hours are odd so I wouldn't make an intentional decision to visit but I might stop in if I happen to be in the area and they were open.

Amazing spot with authentic icepops made locally with some ultra unique flavors you won't find…read moreelsewhere in Sarasota. I love the the real kiwi pops and chocolate covered frozen bananas. They also have ice cream and fruit waters. Amazing prices, everything is around 2/3$. I'll be back often.

One of our favorite ice cream places in the area! We lived on Bee Ridge so was very close by-…read moreowners from Italy are super nice and we brought our puppy dog in a few times. The flavors are wonderful (I'm a mint chip girl myself) and they have lots of other European chocolate, sweets, etc., to purchase.

Just went for milkshakes and we would've been better off buying chocolate milk, the most watery…read moreexcuse milkshake I've ever had