Another great ice cream place to add to the list! The variety of flavors and new flavors I haven't…read moreseen was really great to see. The s'mores ice cream was divine. I love how they were able to get that graham cracker taste and it not be over powered by the other notes. Service was great, the ladies were so nice and gave us great recommendations.

I've always loved Jefferson Dairy. We were headed to mini golf and stopped in before to get our…read morefavorites. I love Elephants Never Forget and it never disappoints. Hubby went for the supersized "The Jeffrey" which included Dirty Diaper (my other favorite), Elephants never forget, Lake Hopatcong Mud. It was topped off w/ chocolate cream cookies, whipped cream and of course a cherry on top. They are always super nice and let you sample any flavors you wish. When it's nice out, they have chairs and picnic tables for you to sit, relax and enjoy!

A great family business that supports our kids with all sports. Their ice cream and cakes are…read moredelicious.

This is the best ice cream I've had in my entire life and will be gladly driving an hour for it!read more

Delicious ice cream and my kids love it here!! Something about the giant blue chair gets them so…read moreexcited to sit out in the back!!

Delish! Great choice in flavors & the ice cream is so good! I loved the pistachio! The area…read moreoutside has some benches for you to sit on but other than that that, there is no place to really enjoy it.

We came here at night and it was pretty empty, it took a minute or two for the person who came out…read moreand greet us - she was incredibly sweet and very nice. I decided to get their Dulce de Leche milkshake without the whipped cream on top. The milkshake was OK, it didn't really taste like Dulce de Leche, but that was to be expected since I haven't been able to find a place in New Jersey that is accurate with that taste. I do have to point out that the ice cream they sell here, from looking at the containers, is "Gifford's Famous ice cream," so it'll match other ice cream places who use the same supplier. The prices were reasonable and there was a fair variety of ice cream, but it not being "homemade" (though they don't claim to be) is what isn't great for me. I believe they have a couple tables inside that you can sit on which is nice, and it seems like they also sell crêpes, but I didn't see them on the menu, though I did see the machine.

Meli's just opened recently. We were happy to be able to get some ice cream on a hot day. It was a…read morelittle expensive but it was very good. Now that we know less than 8% of plastic has been recycled, plastic is toxic and effecting our health, it would be nice to see bamboo utensils and less plastic containers.

Based on the name of the shop I expected there to be more nut-based treats. They primarily sold…read morecandy which I'm not a huge fan of. The only thing I saw had nuts was the chocolate bark with almonds which we got the dark chocolate version of it. I'm honestly not sure how long the chocolate has been out for I didn't seem that fresh and it was $8 for four pieces so pretty pricey for something that was mid and forgettable. would not recommend any of the 'fresh' items. shop was dark and a bit dingy.

One of the cutest spots in Sparta. There's an authentic feeling you get walking in here, that…read moredoesn't seem to occur in just any sweet shop. The building itself boasts a cozy, cabin feel-a building style, uniquely known to the Lake Mohawk Area. The warm feeling you experience walking into the store is equally matched by the ownership. Yvette is a true "Candy Lady." She loves what she does and is always willing to go above and beyond for her customers. So many unique goodies. All of the classic candies (Razzles, Violets, Candy Cigarettes) will evoke nostalgic memories. The Jelly Belly wall has every flavor you could imagine- and ones you wouldn't even think of. If you're a chocolate lover, good news... the chocolate treats made in-store are not only DELICIOUS, but nut free and egg free as well. THE GELATO IS TO DIE FOR (chocolate coffee and pistachio are my favorite!) If you're ever in the Lake Mohawk area, it's definitely worth stopping in. There really is something for everyone.

I've left a 5 star review for Windy Brow's coffee and farm store, but would like to leave another 5…read morestar for their wood fired pizza and ice cream!!!! It was such a beautiful night, my parents and I came and we each got our own pizza. Pizza came out in maybe 15 minutes, we sat and waited and just chilled. It was a beautiful night. I am so appreciative that Windy Brow has a vegan cheese option, so I could be included! I got the Margherita pizza and subbed vegan cheese. The crust and dough were incredible - so fluffy, perfectly crispy, amazing thick crust. The vegan cheese was also great, and the sauce too. Just a perfect pizza. My dad got a regular Margherita and loved it, and my mom got the fungi pizza with mushrooms and was raving about it. My boyfriend got the pig and fig and (of course) loved it as well. We all raved to each other about how amazing everything was. For a farm to do something like this when they don't need to, shows that they love what they do! You can really feel the love in the pizza. We then got ice cream after since the ice cream stand was still open. I got the vegan dark chocolate sea salt (literally incredible, perfect consistency, I love hard ice cream so this was amazing), my boyfriend got Madagascar vanilla and said it was a perfect classic vanilla, my dad said the cherry vanilla was the best he's ever had, and my mom who doesn't love ice cream got the lemon blueberry butter cake and was raving about it. Phenomenal job!!!!! So appreciative to live near a spot like this. Blessings!

We were excited to come here and check out the ice cream, pizza and bakery. Perhaps we arrived on…read morean off day, but the ice cream was only okay - we got the sweet corn and honey as well as the Madagascar vanilla. My husband thought it tasted watered down and while I didn't dislike the sweet corn and honey, I wouldn't need to try it again. They do have really cool flavors, and maybe it was my own thing, but I didn't really want to ask to try too many of them as the lines are long here. I tried the taylor ham and french toast one and while interesting... wasn't for me lol The girl taking the ice cream orders was fine. One thing I will say is my little guy is an ice cream loving toddler (as they tend to be) and he had one bite of the ice creams and passed. We were both pretty shocked. Even after several tries, he was not interested... The bakery/store was cute, but not much left. Prices were also a bit steep - $6 for a tony croissant. Perhaps earlier in the morning when they might've been fresher, I would've considered it more, but it looked like it had been sitting. The girl at the register was very nice though. We had originally wanted to come to try the pizza, but when we arrived around 5pm on a Sunday, it was an hour and a half wait even if we wanted the pizza to go. The guy over there was really nice and apologetic even though he didn't need to be. Hopefully we can try it at some point if we're ever nearby again. additional note - there are only 2 port-a-pottys for restroom needs.

You don't need to look any other place other than the dairy swirl on Route 94 on your way to Vernon…read moreand I gotta tell you you will be amazed and you will put this down as your best ice cream place around. I know we will.

friendly staff the answer the phone and have low-fat and sugar-free offerings. What more can you…read moreask for?

best ice cream place in the area. i live in mount bethel and have tried places in bangor, nj, and…read moreanywhere near and this beats all of them. me and my boyfriend always go here and love it. (and he's picky). the service is amazing, they get your ice cream out in no longer than a minute always, it's cheap, and there's a lot of variety. the ice cream is also very very good. love this place i could not think of any cons!

I cannot lie, we only been in Blairstown since the first of July. We been going to this place…read morealmost everyday. The customer service is great. Liam is great he gets to know the customers and makes the ice cream just as you like it. The ice cream is amazing, well it's ice cream and ice cream is always great. You can go inside to order and sit outside with your tasty treat, or roll through the drive through and get it to go. Blairstown Dairy is in a great location and the setup is perfect. You will not go wrong with stopping in and grabbing some ice cream. I prefer the blenders and my wife loves the chocolate peanut butter. He occasionally has specialties like his campfire which was great as well. You need to just check it out.