I love sweets and couldn't wait to try this new cookie spot! When I arrived I seen there was a walk…read moreup and drive thru. No inside seating. I ordered: Chocolate Covered Strawberry Latte Blondi Rocky Road Smores M&M Cookie Peanut Butter Cup I loved it all! My favorite definitely was the blondie brownie! It was a sweet treat for sure! I had a really good experience!

Sussex County's sweetest new addition!…read more Davis Cookie Co is hands down the hottest new sweet treat spot in Sussex County. This is a family owned drive-through cookie heaven -- you can roll right up and grab fresh-baked cookies, decadent brownies, refreshing lemonade, creamy ice cream, and amazing lattes. One of the most unique things I tried was their iced coffee served in an actual ice cream cone -- so fun and so delicious! They also have a walk-up window and a super cute outdoor seating area where you can hang out, play games, and even catch a movie night on their projection screen. It's such a great family-friendly environment, but it would also make a cute, casual spot for a first date or just getting to know someone. Everything is baked fresh daily, and they even ship nationwide so you can send care packages to friends and family (or yourself -- no judgment!). I absolutely loved my experience here and can't wait to go back. If you have a sweet tooth, this is a must-visit!

Libre is such a cute new spot in town, a French-inspired café with a warm, modern vibe. The space…read moreis beautiful: soft lighting, velvet seating, gold accents, and plenty of greenery and flowers that make it feel cozy yet chic. It's the kind of place you actually want to linger in. I stopped in for a quick treat and coffee. The espresso was smooth and bold, served in a gorgeous black and gold cup, and the desserts looked almost too pretty to eat. I tried the chocolate cake (both the whipped cream with sprinkles and the ganache-topped slice) along with a caramel-topped panna cotta. Everything tasted fresh and felt thoughtfully made. It's a perfect spot for meeting a friend, grabbing something sweet after lunch, or even just enjoying a quiet coffee in a beautiful setting. Definitely happy to have a place like this in the neighborhood.

Stopped here after grabbing lunch with some friends. They told us it's a new location, only been…read moreopen a few months. I tried to check-in, saw it wasn't on Yelp, so I had to add it. I fell in love with the place the moment I walked in. It's located in a small strip mall, so a good amount of parking. It has a bright, modern, warm inviting interior. Staff were super friendly, service was quick, & most importantly the coffee and desserts were perfection. We had a latte, large espressos, they do espressos by small or large, not single, double, or triple, & an assortment of desserts. Everything gets an A! This would definitely be a go-to for me, if it weren't so far away. I guess the next time I visit these friends, I'll have to make a return visit.

customer service was beyond great, even though I don't live in the Stroudsburg area the baker/owner…read moreallowed me the option of shipping, which came to me very fast... suggestions that were recommended was on point and most importantly the kookies were great, me and my family enjoyed every bite. the kookies were still fresh and this is off of one of the recommendations of owner/baker.. 5 all across the board..

From the owner: There’s a cookie for everyone in your life…read more Indulge in the extraordinary at our cookie shop, where uniqueness meets flavor. Elevate your taste buds with our gourmet cookies crafted from premium ingredients. From classic favorites to innovative creations, our variety ensures a treat for every palate. Serving the sweet cravings of NYC, we redefine the cookie experience with a blend of quality and diversity.

The taste of real Italian Gelato comes to Pompton Plains!…read more This was a fantastic experience from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a clean, modern look that made it a great place to relax. The owners spared no expense and it shows. The owner (German) and staff were friendly and patient, offering samples and helping me choose from a wide variety of flavors. Almost two dozen flavors to choose from. The gelato itself was outstanding--rich, creamy, and full of flavor. I tried a combination of coffee, peanut butter and pistachio, and all were incredibly smooth and authentic. The kinder Bueno was insanely good. You could really taste the quality of the ingredients. The portions were generous, and the presentation was simple but appealing. What stood out most was how fresh everything tasted. It felt like the gelato was made with care, not mass-produced. Prices were reasonable for the quality, and overall it felt like a great value. I would recommend this shop to anyone looking for a delicious treat or a cozy place to hang out. Plenty of easy parking. Thank you, German for your kindness.

Great place! Great people! Great flavors! A true Argentine…read moreHeladería! They also have amazing coffee!

Gave this place 3 stars because the ice cream is good portions are below average and big upcharge…read morefor toppings we ordered 3 large cups one with sprinkles only one with hot fudge and dry walnuts and whipped cream and another with one topping it came out to 37.00 a bit pricey ... don't think we will be returning

This is not only my family's favorite ice cream shop of all time... their soups and stews in the…read morewinter are scrumptious! The owner is the sweetest man and we smile when we're on the way over, anticipating an enjoyable visit. Yummy and excellent quality from the food to the people. Love Sticky Fingers forever! So glad we have it close by.

Wonderful, super-moist cupcakes in a variety of amazing flavors!…read more I've been getting mine through the Cinder Inn during COVID-19.

Carl was great to work with over the ten months from ordering til our wedding -super responsive and…read morereassuring. They created a beautiful birch tree that was DELICIOUS. I highly recommend this business. You can trust them for your wedding!

So delicious! Picked up four of these homemade pop tarts at the Honeybee farmers market in Somers…read more(where owner/baker Melissa happened to be), and they were so good. Such flaky crust and fresh fillings and frostings, especially when warmed in the toaster. I got the s'mores, wild berry, fudge brownie, and cinnamon sugar, and loved the s'mores the most! Can't wait to try more, especially as seasonal flavors pop-up throughout the year and her pop tarts are at more shops and events. So happy for Melissa and her growing business. 5 stars!!!

The best pastries and cookies! Love supporting Melissa, she's so kind and hard working. Always…read morecreating new seasonal flavors and listening to her customers!

Based on the name of the shop I expected there to be more nut-based treats. They primarily sold…read morecandy which I'm not a huge fan of. The only thing I saw had nuts was the chocolate bark with almonds which we got the dark chocolate version of it. I'm honestly not sure how long the chocolate has been out for I didn't seem that fresh and it was $8 for four pieces so pretty pricey for something that was mid and forgettable. would not recommend any of the 'fresh' items. shop was dark and a bit dingy.

One of the cutest spots in Sparta. There's an authentic feeling you get walking in here, that…read moredoesn't seem to occur in just any sweet shop. The building itself boasts a cozy, cabin feel-a building style, uniquely known to the Lake Mohawk Area. The warm feeling you experience walking into the store is equally matched by the ownership. Yvette is a true "Candy Lady." She loves what she does and is always willing to go above and beyond for her customers. So many unique goodies. All of the classic candies (Razzles, Violets, Candy Cigarettes) will evoke nostalgic memories. The Jelly Belly wall has every flavor you could imagine- and ones you wouldn't even think of. If you're a chocolate lover, good news... the chocolate treats made in-store are not only DELICIOUS, but nut free and egg free as well. THE GELATO IS TO DIE FOR (chocolate coffee and pistachio are my favorite!) If you're ever in the Lake Mohawk area, it's definitely worth stopping in. There really is something for everyone.

They were great. Best Limoncello cake I ever had. Sad they're out of business…read more Hard to find good cake in that area.

Stopped in after a great late lunch for dessert. Found this place on Yelp. Parfait. Chocolate cake…read more Crumb cake and cookies. And Carrot Cake. The service, the desserts and the interior were all like home made. The owner working hard and taking pride in her work. Liked.

Great ambiance, food, and service! 10/10 BLT sandwich and crepe. The owner is very kind and has…read moredone a great job.

Very local space. Indoor and outdoor seating. Super friendly and relaxed staff. All the food tastes…read moreso fresh. I have been here for breakfast and lunch. There are always unique options which I love. If you're in the area try it!