This is my second (updated) review for this restaurant. We are not local, and we stumbled upon it about a year ago when we were in Lancaster. This time, while traveling, we drove out of our way just to pass through Lancaster and stay the night just so we could some genuine Brooklyn style pizza without having to go to the Big Apple. This time, like last time, it was some of the best pizzas I've had, and I'm sure it may be the best in Lancaster. It is true NY style (Brooklyn) pizza made by New Yorkers. The restaurantier is a NYC transplant, and he brought with him that NY pizza. Simply stated, it's awesome. All the staff is polite, cordial, and engaging. They don't waste any time in creating your meal and making you love every bite. They offer a rather extensive menu with good variety, but we have only tried the pizza, and we love it. read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

We wandered into Thoze guys pizzeria after a long exhausting day at Dutch Wonderland. Great atmosphere of a neighborhood pizza joint. Informal feeling, which was great when we were walking in with three kids. The staff was friendly and the food was amazing. Super authentic and hit the spot. The marinara sauce with the garlic knots was something I could drink out of a faucet. Also loved that they had individual slices available so we could try an assortment for the family. read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Great service! Great Italian food. Homemade Italian family recipes. Eggplant rollatini and linguini with clams were excellent. BYOB

Always get great pizza there, but this past weekend I ordered a small cheese with xtra mozzarella. Disappointed, crust paper thin, sections of sauce and definitely no extra cheese. Not what I usually get from there, quality has always been great. read more

Slice take out order - Bubbly large cheese pizza with each bite entirely crust. Subpar cheeseburger sub. Loaded garlic knots appetizer cheese wasn't melted but sauce was decent. Price was average. read more

Always go to Vinny's fresh hot pizza and Stromboli the cheesesteaks are to die for also the cheesecake is good

Pizza was ok. They did have gluten free pizza which was good but not great. The pepperoni pizza was average. I ordered a house salad and it was the saddest most pathetic salad I've ever seen. Basically lettuce and tomatoes. Service was ok but again mediocre. Everything about this place is average... read more

My husband and I decided to visit Vinny due to coming here last year and loving their steaks. This time we will NOT be back! It wasn't what we ORDERED! We ordered a chicken cheesesteak. The first bite of the steak you can tell it the cheese or meat was old. It had a bad smell and aftertaste to it. My husband's cheesecake had mayo on it. We DIDN'T select Mayo when we ordered. He hates Mayo! We will not be returning! We threw everything in the trash. Yuck! read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Theez Guyz are the real dealz!!! Great food made with fresh ingredients done the traditional way, can't get anymore authentic. Our first time in and was made to feel welcome right from the door. This is what I remember as a kid a pizza shop was like. read more

Where to start? Vinny and those guyz pizzeria, have never been there before. This is my first time walking in, and I was surprised by the atmosphere. It was very welcoming, slightly bougie I liked it a lot. The people were very nice. I was directed to the front desk for my mobile pick up order, a large cheese and a large meat lovers, including mozzarella sticks. Upon opening the box I was surprised because unlike the normal meats that pizza places use on their pizza, I was welcomed with what appeared to be natural fresh cut meats. Which by the way, were absolutely delicious. The cheese pizza was sloppy and greasy perfect hangover food And 10 out of 10 recommend. Best New York style pizza in Lancaster. Thinking of going somewhere else? Fugettaboutit! read more

Found this place on Yelp! Small, clean restaurant off the beaten path. Service was prompt and friendly. We had the margarita pizza. Delicious. I highly recommend. read more

Service was very good and our order was timely. The pizzas could have been cooked a bit longer. Pretty skimpy on toppings as well for the price. We might give them another try but probably not with the many other choices in the area. read more

We ordered 10 pizzas for a soccer team dinner w delivery to local hotel. Good pizza and great service. Loved their discount for ordering via Slice too. read more

Haven't had pizza this good since I left New Jersey 15 yrs ago. We'll done!! Ny Style Pizza read more

Visited this wonderful Family establishment on Father's Day, watching the whole family work together was such a joy! So much so we chose to eat inside. I personally enjoyed the NY style pizza and my sister in law loved the "regular" salad. The amount of cheese!!! She was in heaven! The picture on the website is not accurate. My niece (3 years old) ate her pizza and everyone's crust Would definitely visit again read more

Best pizza in Lancaster, hands down! Might look a little out of the way but you will not be disappointed in the pizza read more

Great pizza! I'd definitely recommend. Friendly. They deliver. Lots of good options. My go to pizza place.

Good pizza place. When you arrive, people meet you outside to take your order and it doesn't take super long to make either. We ordered two large pies one was cheese and the other was margartia. Both were yummy. Not the best pizza I have ever had, but there was absolutely nothing wrong with it. I prefer a crisper crust but that is purely preference. This crust was also good. Great flavorable sauce, good amount of cheese. In the margarita, it had the fresh basil on top. No complains full belly! read more

We were looking for something to eat late Saturday night. Found this place on Yelp. We had a large pizza and French fries. It was great! Really tasty pizza and the fries were crinkle cut. I'm attaching a picture of the menu. They do take debit/credit cards. read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - the menu - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Decent pizza. Not necessarily my style, but good. The slices were generous in size. I found the crust was just a bit too dense and crunchy for my palate. The cheese was OK, not anything special, but not bad either. Saucing was well executed and tasty balance of sweet and savoury and acid. read more

If you want half cooked soggy disgusting pizza fast this is the place to go. Lightning speed delivery and lightning speed delivery by me into the dumpster. And this has happened 3 times in a freakin row. They brought back a new pie all 3 times, first two times it was just as nasty, the third time the pie looked better but still incredibly soggy. Never again. read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Clean inside and clean bathroom. They have great pizza! Very quick service too, definitely recommend!

Great pizza and rice balls. Staff is welcoming and on point. Pizza is great especially straight out the oven.

During a discussion of great pizza in the Lancaster area with a fellow Pizza aficionado I was told about Vinny's Pizza. It's in excellent Thin crust pizza which is my preference. Although they do sell Sicilian style. As I've mentioned before using good sauce and quality cheese would seem to be obvious but the vast majority of pizza places especially pizza chains don't understand that. Vinny's is a nice neighborhood pizza and sub joint check it out read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Two slices and a drink for $5. Sorry the camera wasn't quick enough to catch both slice. - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Visited several times since we are close. The last few times the cheese steak was extremely salty, sub rolls hard, pizza was over cooked/burnt. The last time the pizza was half cooked. Dough was soggy and chicken was half cooked as well. We returned the pizza and was told a refund would be issued. Had to go back a second time to get the refund. Not sure what happened since Covid but I won't return. Neither will my family or extended family. Sad since they are so close to my house. read more

Great pizza and Stromboli, call ahead for pick up, not a lot of sitting. Definitely going back.

I order a pepperoni roll and it was burnt and uneditable. It was so bad I threw it away.

I miss Vinny....since the newer owner it has gone down hill. He has a nasty attitude. And it seems has gotten so popular that you are sure to get the wrong order. I have not order from hear in over a year and it will take another year to forget this one. I ordered a cheese pizza and got a extra cheese pepperoni and sausage pizza. Not even cooked raw dough and a pool of oil. Not agin for at least a year.... read more

My wife and I have been ordering Vinny's for years and we just did again yesterday. Large cheese pizza with banana peppers. Their banana peppers are so fresh and hot. They show them off in large jars on the counter. Worth the higher prices! read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

See all

Attention: Marylanders! New York style, thin-crust pizza has almost -0- rise. Hence, the term: thin-crust. Thin, crispy, and delicious. Mmmmm.... So please go eat a crab cake. read more

Ordered takeout for the first time based on the reviews. Food was not as ordered, but delivered hot and fast. Order was meatless, delivered food had ham. I am not against meat, thankfully. Shop was closed by the time the error was discovered. The taste was fine, but probably will look elsewhere. read more

Family was in from out of town and we needed a quick and easy dinner. Had a terrific pizza, cheesesteak and boneless wings. Everything was great. Even our youngest picky eater loved it. Quick and friendly service. Wish we lived closer! read more

Pizza at its very best..!, I have 28 years experience in pizza Buisness plus I was a pizza maker. I recommend this place, food is amazing, aways great aways made with love and on time...! Great chesse great service they have delivery dine in and take out, plenty of parking space and place is super clean with sport channels on for costumers like me. Recommendations, please start with pizza and wings and finish off with a philly cheese steak, the menu has been updated and was a wonderful and a success for the costumers as for the Buisness I believe. ANOTHER GREAT RESTARAUNT PLACE IN LANCASTER ANOTHER A+, this is my hot spot my little piece of heaven to dine or call for delivery o and by the way they have a app called SLICE where you can order..... read more

Not New York City style pizza, not New York anything. This is very much a Lancaster style pizza. So doughy I chewed more than I've ever chewed in my life. Maybe it was under-baked? Also, No sauce. Did I mention no sauce? So dry. I was so hungry too. I could actually see where the sauce dried up entirely during baking! What the heck? 2 stars for decent cheese and good topping placement. read more

I've been going to Vinny's since I was 4 and he was in East Town Mall. They changed to Vinny's and "Thoze Guys" and I can immediately tell the place wasn't as clean and there were 3 people in the place, none of them I recognized. The changes have all been for the worse. The pizza's smaller, they charged me full price when it's Monday and you're supposed to get a large for 9.99 + tax for cash. I know Vinny had to retire someday, but these new guys just ruined it. read more

Ummm......well, the drinks were cold. Cheese pie dough was handled/ beaten too much, -0- rise, sauce was non-descript, cheese (shreds mozzarella) had a good tug, nice & salty. The pepperoni pie was burnt, not charted, burnt. The drinks were cold read more

Great tasting pizza! Loved the NY Italians vibes in the place! Can definitely taste the fresh ingredients, especially the sausages they used for their pizza. Will be a repeat customer whenever we're in town with the kiddies visiting Dutch Wonderland! GO RANGERS! read more

Was in Lancaster in a weekend vacation. Originally from South Philly. Wanted a good pizza. Found this spot on Yelp. Got there ordered. What a pleasant surprise. Excellent pizza great salad. Good service. Great experience. Highly recommend! read more

Friendly staff, they accommodated my last minute order of 7 large pizzas with a smile. Pizza was delicious. Unlike most pizza shops in Central Pa with a preoccupation with dough, this pie was a textbook New York style. I will be back. read more

Delic!!! Just moved close by and happy to have found a great pizza shop so close!! Vinny's was recommended by a local and it was every bit as good as said! We've ate there on several occasions and have been pleased every time! My only complaint if i would have one is their hrs r a lil restricted, they close much earlier than what we were used to at our previous pizza shop. Then again when your pizzas that good maybe you can call it a night at 8 or 9! Highly recommend! read more