A must eat place if you are visiting Lancaster, in my opinion. Very good food, very clean, great customer service, indoor/outdoor seating.

Delic!!! Just moved close by and happy to have found a great pizza shop so close!! Vinny's was recommended by a local and it was every bit as good as said! We've ate there on several occasions and have been pleased every time! My only complaint if i would have one is their hrs r a lil restricted, they close much earlier than what we were used to at our previous pizza shop. Then again when your pizzas that good maybe you can call it a night at 8 or 9! Highly recommend! read more

Vinny & Thoseguyz DO IT RIGHT... Ill be back for more of the chicken parm slice. The dough is nice, not soggy, the right crunch. The sauce pops. Cheese isnt like other pizzarias where it tastes like sawdust, its real fresh. read more

My favorite pizza in Lancaster. This pizza is NYC style, large foldable slices with a thin & sweet tomato sauce. Awesome crust. Right amount of cheese. Spot on seasoning and flavor. read more

See all

Delicious! We had a few slices of pizza, fries and mozzarella sticks and all were hot and fresh. Great location right off Lincoln Highway and just down the street from he Outlets and Dutch Wonderland. read more

Seeking New York style pizza, this is the place to go in Lancaster!!! Growing up in New York and then moving to the Midwest this is what I miss most, pizza. So happy to have found this place to get a taste of home while visiting family!!!! read more

Just passing thru from dutch wonderland. Pizza and the chicken parm were greeeeat. Recommend it

Vinny's now known as Vinny and THOZ GUYZ is great pizza, easy no hassle no BS service. Excellent stop while beer shopping across the parking lot and Remember cash only under 5 dollar minimum. read more

Real awesome pizza as it should be. By an Italian named Vinny. Also outstanding cheesesteaks. Worth going out of the way for. read more

Thoze Guyz Pizzeria - Pineapple does indeed go on pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - Lancaster, Pennsylvania

85% crust 5% sauce and 10% mozzarella. The crust was very good and I fed a family of 7 for $16 bucks that hit the spot after a long day of traveling. Just can't see it being 5stars (which is why we went) if it was being rated for their pizza. They do have a selection of sandwiches/subs that I didn't try. The mozzarella sticks were nothing special (esp at the price of $1per stick) Good in a pinch and always happy to support a local restaurant. read more

Best pizza this side of jersey ! Ya want jersey an I mean northern jersey where I from not imitation southern jersey this is place to go ... I drive 30 min to get it ... Can't be beat a hidden gem that's been around for many years ! read more

Was traveling and found this place on Yelp. Ordered a calzone custom how I wanted it and it was the best calzone I've had in a long time. Service was great, food was even better! read more

I'm a pizza Connoisseur and this is by far the best pizza in Lancaster County that I have found so far. Clean place and friendly staff as well! read more

Amazing ham calzones!! The sauce on the side was a little runnier than I like, but it was so good, that I didn't mind. The calzones were perfect. A nice thin crust & lots of filling. Just perfect. One warning though: If ordering anything that requires a fork & knife, like a calzone, take it home or bring your own fork & knife. But otherwise, the food was great, the prices are reasonable, & the staff was pleasant. read more

We went here with 5 kids starving for good pizza. Drinks were not served till we got our food which took a while. Pizza was not good there was something wrong with the cheese. Mozzarella sticks were good. I would not return here!!!! read more

Theseguyz are great! Food is delicious and always delivered before est delivery time! Prices are great too. No matter if it is pizza or cheesesteaks or salads, it's always the best! read more

Vinny & ThozeGuyz Pizzeria has very good authentic pizza. We just had cheese and pepperoni but it was yummy!

Awesome food !!! My wife and I are from NY and this was a taste of Home with a Philadelphia twist! Great food clean place fast service! I had a cheese stake the wife had 2 slices of pizza everything was freshly made and delicious! This is our pizza spot for sure read more

As someone from New York I wanted actual good New York Pizza In PA and Vinny's is some of the best authentic New York Pizza of all time out side of the City. read more

I have been going to Vinnys for over 20 years. It is consistently the best pizza in our area.

Passed this place everyday taking my hubby to work always wanted to try it; tonight we finally did; I ordered a Large Cheese pizza which was on special for $9.99 tonight and ordered cheese fries; now the pizza was amazing, while sauce was a bit thin the flavor was so good it didn't matter. I prefer a thin sauce not a thick chunky so it hit the spot. The cheese fries were good and the owner was very friendly and welcomed me as soon as I walked in the door! So this place is then Brooklyn style pizzeria and its because of flavor and quality!!! Will continue to order from here now on!!! read more

The BEST white pizza I have ever had in my life! And I have had a lot of pizza. We are only in the area for a few days and we have already had it twice! Yes, it's that good. Usually there is not enough garlic...or too much - perfect amount here! The crust, cheese - both amazing. I wish i could find pizza this good at home! Although, i would probably eat too much pizza if i did. I highly recommend! read more

We were in town for a soccer tournament. Found Vinny's via Yelp and made the call. What you should know: 1. We called an order at 4:45 of eleven different pizzas with a request to pick-up at 5:45. When we arrived at 5:44, the last pizza was coming out of the oven. Impressive. 2. The pizza itself was excellent. Solid crust, good tomato sauce, good distribution of toppings. I'm standard east coast big city a**hole about pizza but this place is for real. 3. I had asked if they deliver. They said, "you want the best, you gotta drive." #Facts. So if you're in town for soccer, disappointed with your hotel, worrying about all that driving to be washed away in a rainstorm, go to Vinny's and at least you'll have great pizza. read more

This is seriously the best pizza. The crust is always perfect and the cheese to sauce ratio is right on par. The guys are always really nice when I go in there. It's a little pricey but totally worth it. read more

Pleasantly surprised at how delicious this pizza was- after reading the reviews I was convinced we should try it out. The guy making pizzas was super friendly and kind- made ours fresh and made sure we were satisfied. Would definitely eat here again! If we lived closer I'd be ordering takeout all the t read more

Best pizza in Lancaster county. My only issue is if you order a sandwich and ask for something like tomatoes on the side, they charge for it, even though they typically come on the sandwich anyway. read more

Our experience was the polar opposite of the previous reviewer. We found conditions clean and the service prompt and friendly. The pizza was delicious. read more

Pizza is ok,stay away from sandwiches,light on the meat,got lots of veggies if you're into them,not great for the $$. Stay away from sandwich special,soda,chips,real rip,$9 for special,not very special,rolls are very good ,would taste a lot better if had more meat on them,the cheese steaks are pretty good read more

Hands down best pizza in Lancaster. We used to frequent j&r pizza near park city (owned by Vinny's brother) but when he sold it it went down in a big way. I will drive 15 extra minutes for their pizza. Fries and sandwiches are great too. I noticed someone posted something about not getting there drinks immediately...odd because I have been given my drink before I pay or eat every time. read more

Best pizza in Lancaster county. My only issue is if you order a sandwich and ask for something like tomatoes on the side, they charge for it, even though they typically come on the sandwich anyway. read more

Have been to Vinny's often thanks to friends who told me to give it a try...food is always delicious!! Was stuck on the steak sandwiches for a long time, I am a creature of habit. But last night I stepped outside my box and ordered a cheeseburger sub...OMG, was be best thing I've ever eaten. Plenty of burger and cheese, fresh veggies and a perfectly toasted roll!! I sat with dear friends so focused on my sammich I was in a world of my own, didn't say a word to anybody...do yourself a favor and go get one!! read more

Best NY style pizza in Lancaster. Unlike most of the pizza places in the area, Vinny's does not pile on the cheese. Born and rasied in NJ I can't even eat most of the pizza in the area. This is traditional Naples pizza! read more