Great premise and fun atmosphere. Fairly simple sandwiches, but spiced up just enough. The Twisted Sister was our favorite. Short walk from the old harbor. Sandwiches and salads are about $8 each. Will gladly come here again on our next visit. read more

Great food great service and a very funny owner! Bring your cash no credit cards. Don't forget to tip!!

Really delicious, freshly made to order sandwiches. The twisted sister with turkey, bacon and avocado was super yummy; also the Brigid's Beach (not positive on the name) with salami, provolone, roasted red peppers. The service was polite and friendly although the wait was a bit long for "just a sandwich". read more

The sandwiches are fine, if you don't mind waiting 45 minutes or ordering a sandwich that is missing five key ingredients. I understand it's an island, but perhaps you shouldn't advertise sandwiches if you don't think you can get the ingredients in stock . . . You do get an extra star for cuteness, and having a hammock. read more

Id never been to block island and was at a loss as to what to eat for lunch because everywhere was overcrowded and overpriced. The line at three sisters was long but everyone eating at the picnic tables looked satisfied so I decided to give it a try. I got a twisted sister (bacon, cheese, avocado, and turkey) and my daughter got a sailor sister (tuna salad on a roll). Both were absolutely delicious and generous in size. While many establishments are frugal in their allocation of ingredients like avocado and bacon, this sandwich shop is not! The tuna was simple--made with mayo and capers, if I'm correct--and accompanied by fresh greens and tomatoes, but was equally as scrumptious as the multi faceted twisted. Thank you for a lovely first meal on block island! read more

We showed up without a reservation and they kindly fitted us in. The food was simple and a little limited on choices but everything we got was great. We tried everything on the menu and each thing was great in its own way. All the seafood was fantastic. It was very nice with the love music outside. Would definitely come back. read more

$8 for a very good sandwich, but bring cash, Outdoor eating only

I'm guessing that Swim C went on an off day and I went on an on day. I hope that they have more on days than off days. This place is so cute. The sandwiches are all basic bases with some added ingredients to make them a little more fancy - I got the twisted sister, which is a basic turkey sandwich with the add on of bacon and avocado. You put avocado on any summer sandwich and I am happy. I wouldn't say this is the best sandwich I've ever had but it was pretty good. Outside of the food, I love the atmosphere here. The backyard (eating area) consists of a hamock, some picnic tables (some under the shade of a sail, some under the shade of a tree, some in the sun), and some adirondack chairs. All of these are sprinkled about and flanked by some interesting garden accessories. Three Sisters is just a little off the main drag of Old Harbor, and I think that is what makes it even more a classic Block Island experience. read more

Really great food ... you can tell they really put time and effort into their sandwiches. The Twisted Sister and the McSister were my favorites. I was also lucky enough to have dinner there twice while we were on the island. If you catch them open for dinner DEFINITELY GO .... the blue fish and the clams were amazing !!! read more

Three Sisters - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

See all

Twisted sister is amazing. I ate lunch and breakfast here while on the island, and wish I could have had dinner! (Damn you, Irene!) Lunch is great- the menu features salads, sandwiches and wraps- something for everyone. Sandwiches are served with chips. Homemade chocolate chip cookies are great! And the drinks outside are self serve/honor system. Breakfast is quaint and personal and DELICIOUS! I love this place, I wish I lived on Block Island, or that the sisters opened a shop in DC! read more

Really, really good hot dogs. Great location, great service and live but non-intrusive music the night we were there. The local authorities have to give Three Sisters the right to serve at least beers if there is any justice in this world and on Block Island! read more

Do you like flies in your sandwich? If so, come here. There are no screens on the doors and windows so insects are all over the food. Like, we know it's Block Island and things are casual, but geez. Bonus: employees are condescending and smug! read more

Three sisters looked like a very nice casual place to grab a sandwich with your kids. Nice outdoor seating area. The problem was with the service. As son as we walked in we were greeted with a what's your order or stand aside. There was one person in line behind me.. When I asked if they had a children's menu I was told that they can have peanut butter and jelly. I was not going to give my business to a place with rude service so I simply said you know what we are going to find someplace else. It was at that point that the lady behind the counter made a snide remark about my five year old daughters hello kitty bathing suit. We ended up getting pizza up the block and I am very glad that we made the decision to move on. Message to servers, you are in a service industry. Don't be rude to your customers..I don't care how good your sandwich is, there are always other options read more

Coming to Block Island I was very hungry and eager to try out the food scene. As soon as I got off the ferry I biked down the hill to find a spectacular and quaint lil' cottage, Called, "Three Sister". "what a rockin' name! I have to try this" I walked into the shop and was greeted by this kind women who asked if I would like a menu. As I looked around I saw the workers taking out freshly made cookies and wrapping awesome sandwiches. I gazed at the menu and the Sailor Sister just jumped at me screaming "EEEEEEAAAAATTTT MEEEEE" I placed my order with the wonderful staff and seated myself outside, and grabbed a drink. The wait was considerably short considering a lot of people were eating. I was rung up by this kind young man and was on my way to eat the best sandwich of my life. SOOOOO fresh SOOOO tasty Just pure love for Three Sisters!!!!!!!!! :) read more

Wow. I can't even express how much I love this place. As soon as I bite into the oh so famous twisted sister, it feels as though I am in heaven. But this feeling doesn't stop there. Of the 10+ options Ms Brigid Price and her excellent staff offer, it is often hard to choose the perfect blend of ingredients to suit your tongue. It is a great place to create memories and the sandwiches are the best on the island (they are even better than subway!) -E, J, D read more

Three Sisters - Having a thumbs up good time at three sisters - Sandwiches Near Me - Block Island, Rhode Island

FRESH! FRESH! FRESH! I had a seafood mix. Shrimp, clams, and swordfish with a side of couscous. Very good. The dinner salad was great. Bring your own wine/beer. (There is a liquor store right around the corner). Highly recommend. A+ read more

See all

Always order a wicked sister sandwich from three sisters. The funky little garden seats provided a great place to sit in the shade as our order was prepared. Grabbed a big chocolate chip cookie which was perfectly baked - chewy , crisp, oozing chocolate chips. We ordered a Blue Cheese salad as well - great to order sandwiches and take to the beach only a block away. Block island classic lunch spot read more

I had an interesting experience here! I ordered Turkey, lettuce, mayo, and cheese. I got Ham, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. I hate ham so there was no sucking it up as I always do. I went to the lady inside and just said I think I got the wrong sandwich. I was told what I ordered was what I got. I told the lady I did not eat ham or tomato so it was not what I ordered. The lady got upset and let her emotions take over. I was not rude or mad. I simply thought I had been given the wrong sandwich. The lady was rude and then grabbed my sandwich, took the ham and tomato off the bread and put turkey on it and then handed it to me and said " Now it is what you ordered." I was so discussed I threw it in the garbage when I walked out to where my family was sitting. Needless to say my family of 9 will never go back and as business owners were very unhappy. read more

Can't wait until Three Sisters opens again. Longing for the days of a delicious Twisted or Big Sister sammy chilling in a comfy adirondack. Great food, awesome location and relaxing vibes!!! read more

Consistently good sandwiches, however the girls who work there are consistently rude, and for no apparent reason. It's almost as if they're doing you a huge favor by making your sandwich. And be ready to order, unless you want a serious 'tude. Better attitude and this place is a four plus star review. read more

TJ Says: We traveled to Block Island via a ferry, to discover unbearable sunniness and heat that we weren't prepared for, given our plans to walk the loop around the island, and our lack of knowledge that there aren't a tremendous amount of options for shade. Approaching the end of our loop, we passed the yard sign for Three Sisters - it just had the time that dinner began, and noted that there would be live music. We continued on and went on a moped adventure. Being the passenger on a moped can be a bit frightening, seemed like being the driver can as well. We returned to Three Sisters for dinner and were the first people there. We discovered that the restaurant staff consisted of a waitress and a man with a grill, and three options or a combo for dinner. Charlie might remember the options, I don't quite recall. I do recall, however, that the food was great, having it cooked right there on the grill was great, the air had cooled and there was a breeze, and we had some entertaining guests sitting near us within a few minutes. You're free to BYOB at this place, and Charlie and I generally prepare ourselves with a bottle of wine when the opportunity for a picnic is near, so we got our bottle out and shared it with dinner. There was live music, it was an acoustic guitar player/singer. We weren't sitting quite close enough to hear her, so this wasn't a main attraction for us, but a nice addition for the atmosphere anyway. Dinner at Three Sisters stands out as one of the highlights from our visit to Block Island. Charlie says: I get the sense that they don't serve dinners on a daily basis here. We went on a Thursday and I enjoyed one of the finest seafood dinners that I have ever had. The options were bluefish, halibut and shrimp with a side of vegetables. TJ and I went for the sampler entree, which came with a little bit of each. The seafood was as fresh as could be and was nearly cooked to perfection by the guy at the grill. There was a friendly atmosphere and the fact that we could dine outside was a plus. That along with the wine and the ice cream sundae that we ordered for dessert made it one of the best dining experiences I have ever had. It seems like I'm exaggerating but I'm not, this place is the real deal. read more

Best lunch spot for casual outdoor seating. I love the sandwich menu and the cookies out of oven are the perfect finish.

Great sandwiches in a cute little place with funky outdoor seating. Great option for lunch, just on the edge of town. They're only open from 11:30 am to 2pm. Apparently, they were also getting ready to start an open-air nighttime seafood grill featuring whatever was caught fresh that day.... That gig is in the backyard seating area and its called "Mr. Sister". Although we didn't get to try it, I can almost guarantee its great, and our in keeper raved about it. read more

What a delightful find! The sandwiches were delicious and the setting perfect. We had a long wait after we ordered but we hula-hooped and sat in the shade and in a hammock and visited with others also waiting nearby. I'd give it 5 stars but the staff people I interacted with were surprisingly cold and unfriendly. Not enough to turn me off from this place, however. read more

Consistently delicious. I recommend the meatloaf sandwich and the McSister. Please know what you want before you go inside through the front door to order! It's a tiny tiny place. read more

My friend Leslie and I stumbled on to Three Sisters during our walk around Block Island exploring. We chatted with the sisters while they set up for dinner and while we did not join them for dinner we promised to returned for lunch the next day, which we did. the fresh avocados on the Twisted Sister was excellent and guarantees a return from me read more

Beautiful outdoor seating and amazing fresh sandwiches. The Meatloaf Sandwich is THE BOMB. Best sandwich i've ever eaten in my life - and i've got 50 years of sandwich eatin' experience across three continets. read more

This little joint has a fun vibe and great food. We stopped in to grab lunch on our way back from town to the beach. They are cooking in a tiny little hut but have the plan well mapped out. You walk up to the front and look at the menu before going inside to order. You then order your sandwich or salad (grab one...or two homemade chocolate chip cookies) and then go out the back door to wait for your food at picnic tables and grab condiments and utensils. The back has tables and umbrellas set up to chow down there or you can opt for takeout (which we did) and head to the beach. My sister and I enjoyed our sandwiches thoroughly and liked that the options were healthy with fresh ingredients. read more

Best sandwiches on the island. Bike here from the ferry, grab a Twisted sister from these hard-working ladies who make EVERYTHING to order, and go exploring. Don't forget to grab a homemade cookie as well! read more

Love this place. Have been coming for years and look forward to their amazing sandwiches and yummy chocolate chip cookies every time. Best beach lunch ever. Twisted Sister and Greek Sister are family favorites. The only thing that would improve it is a better drink selection. I miss the iced coffee and unsweetened iced tea they had years ago, but bottles of seltzer and better iced tea options would be great. read more

Had lunch here today. The lady next to me said it was the best lunch on the island....we were hopeful, but after two sandwiches, one tuna, one corned beef...they were just OK...nothing terrible, but nothing great... read more

YUM! Perfect place in BI to go for a simple, non seafood lunch. Their wraps are fresh, delicious, and generously sized. The actual building is literally the size of a closet, so after you order inside step outside and relax on one of the picnic tables in the yard. This place emits a kinda hippy vibe, with veggie options and a really laid back funky feel. Next time I'm in BI I'd def go back. Walking distance from Old Harbor ferry dock. read more

A good sandwich at a good "island price." Fresh, pleasant service, great cookies and a funky vibe to the outdoor only seating areas. Much better than what you'll find on the harbor. Walk inland a couple of blocks and escape the tourist haunts. You won't be disappointed. read more

This place is the best lunch spot on the island the food is great and the women working are so good! Always satisfied after eating a great lunch there! Would recommend to all! read more

The best roast beef sandwich I've ever had. That said, be sure you know what you want in it's entirety before you walk into the tiny space...think Soup Nazi on Seinfeld. read more

Make sure you bring cash and your patience, but I will tell you it was worth it. Only a small menu of sandwiches which I believe means a better chance of fresh ingredients. I tried the Twisted sister which was a fresh turkey, avocado, bacon and cheddar sandwich. It was great! It honestly didn't even need the bacon. The turkey was very thinly sliced as well as the cheddar which made it melt in your mouth. It was a relaxed atmosphere on a sunny day. We ordered out sandwiches and they told us to grab a drink or homage cookie and find a seat. We found a nice picnic branch and waited for the guy to call our name. Sandwiches came with potato chips which is always a plus for me. I would most certainly return here for a sandwich while in visiting the Block! read more

It's a beach sandwich joint. Everything is fresh, salads are quite good, seating is all outside - casual and fun. When they're slammed, they're slammed. read more

This place is adorable. Great set up - order inside, eat outside on the picnic benches. I got the Greek Salad in a wrap and it was delicious. Casual, fun spot -- will be going back! read more

Great sandwiches. Something for every taste meat mavens to vege lovers If you come at peak hours you are going to wait. nice outdoor dining area read more

We loved this place! It's a perfect location to get lunch and relax. The atmosphere is awesome and welcoming. We had the twisted sisters in a wrap. It was delicious. Though it may take a little not to receive your sandwich, it's worth it. Everything is made to order read more