We biked down here from our rental home to have a drink and grab pizza. My sister insisted on Ticheli's and said it'll be the freshest brick oven pizza we can find here. We ordered the supreme version and sat by the live music while we waited. I can't complain about the wait time because it is 5 people in one tiny shack cooking away, so all I'd say is be aware there will be a wait. Like an hour I'd expect. We didn't know this and we're trying to make it in time for sunset on the beach with the pizza, but ended up missing it because it took an hour and 15. Not a big deal since there's so much shopping, drinks, live music all nearby but just be aware! It was also worth the wait. Delicious and perfect for our beach picnic! read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

See all

All around great experience. I ordered over the phone and they were very accurate with the pick up time they gave. Very friendly staff. We ordered the Margherita Pizza and it was amazing. We actually ordered it a couple times on our trip. Would highly recommend. Don't worry if the wait time is long. Grab a beverage and enjoy the live music. read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

The pizza was delicious!! The dough tastes way better than any pizza dough Ive had. The cheese is also delicious. I'm not sure why they have low reviews when the service was great, and yummy pizza! Love the outdoor seating with music playing, honestly a great vibe for you and the kids. read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Hawaiian and a regular veggie with white sauce for both and no olives no capers but we added pineapple.jalapeño. It was so good - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

Ticheli's is hands down my favorite place when visiting Rosemary/Seacrest! Every time I visit, I can never pass up the chance to get my hands on the best pizza ever! Ryan, in particular is SO awesome, thoughtful, and kind! My husband and I love this place even more with his and everyone's AMAZING customer service! The wait time is long during busy dinner hours, BUT FOR GOOD REASON. It's. SO. WORTH. IT. If you ever get a chance, go to Ticheli's and eat the best pizza on the beach while enjoying the most beautiful sunset!! read more

See all

Overpriced mediocre pizza Claims to be wood fired but I've had better frozen pizza than this $22 for a 12" pizza with very little sauce and toppings on cracker thin pizza dough Itsa no good! read more

The pizza is delish!!! We had the Tony's Traditional and the Meatball. Both were incredible. Love the atmosphere with music playing in the amphitheater. We had a great evening!! read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

Run of the mill beach pizza. Nothing was terrible but overall the flavors were pretty bland- the sauce was not well seasoned (to our liking). Great for kids palate- adults found it just ok. read more

Pizza crust was like a store bought pillsbury. Pizza sauce was mediocre. Pepperoni was even tasteless. Greek salad was mostly iceberg lettuce. read more

We've been Rosemary beach too many times, but we've never had pizza from this tiny pizzeria. This first time, we made a phone call and picked up the pizza in about 40 minutes. It was delicious. I ate a whole veggie pizza. wood-oven pizza you should try it. read more

See all

These guys are the best in the business. Hands down the most delicious pizza I have EVER had. My son insisted on eating their pizza every night for 6 days straight and I couldn't blame him. The people and service are amazing. Felt like we were eating at home. The wait was not bad either, 10-15 minutes tops. Highly recommend this place. Keep up the great work! Will be back again on our next trip :) Your hospitality is unmatched. Thank you. read more

We are from Buffalo, NY and are kind of pizza snobs. This brick orb pizza is legit. Would not have expected such delicious thin crust pizza on the FL panhandle. We will be back for sure! (By the way, great atmosphere for kids with the live music out front and craft beer next door for the adults.) read more

This place is hard to describe, it is a walk up pizza stand, in the park side of a circle drive for a shopping center. The pizza is marginal at best. The dough was chewy and soft and I asked for extra done. The ingredients were fresh but not warm. We tried three types because they are 9" personal size. We got an artichoke, a pepperoni and a buffalo chicken. They did pile on the ingredients - just needed to be in the oven another 10 min or get the oven hotter. A good walk up pizza place for the kids. Strange place. I will not be back! read more

Great pizza, fast pickup service and really nice folks! My only regret was not ordering more!

The best pizza on 30a!!!! Great staff and atmosphere! Ordered 6 pizzas for 9 people and every piece was gone. Definitely will eat there again!! read more

Loved their pizza - yummy crispy crust. Liked that you can get 8" personal size of their specialty pies since we all like different kinds of pizza. Greek salad was large (would feed 3) and very good. Prices reasonable. You pick up at the window and there is plenty of outdoor public seating in the circle for dining. read more

Great food and fun atmosphere! Loved the grouper sandwich! Will definitely be back next time.

Wood fired Pizza.. it was delish.. but a long wait (hour and a half) .. but worth the wait... enjoyed the good live music under the gazebo, shopped and it was ready before we knew it! We had the "Mama sweep the kitchen" and it was delish! read more

Pizza is okay--sauce has a decent flavor but crust leaves something to be desired. Mozzarella sticks, breadsticks, and pasta were all pretty bad. Obviously a good location though and pleasant to sit outside and listen to the music at night. read more

This is a busy place that turns over a lot of pizza. It's the closest place to where we were staying so we tried it out. Good pizza but a little pricey for what it was. $18 for burnt crust. Thankfully it was close enough to walk to. There is table seating close by but we chose to take it back to where we were staying. Two people can split one pizza. read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Tony Italian Classic - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

We knew it would be busy so we showed up at 4:50. We were the first order at 5, our second party placed the second order a few minutes later. Friendly staff, seemed fine. First order came out at 5:41, second came out 25 minutes later! These were the first two orders of the night! Pizzas are medium sized, $20, vaca prices as expected. Supposed to be wood fired. Thin crust with decent toppings. Sorry, but I have a kamado joe grill at home and my pizzas are far better. These just tasted like they were cooked in a hot oven. We had pasta, salads, meatball subs, cheese sticks. Everything was fine but bland. The Greek salad was good, but the bread sticks tasted like they were microwaved. Our kids were all happy which means nothing had any flavor. It would be fine if it was cheap and fast, but it was neither. We won't be back. read more

Owners were friendly and attentive. Pizza was very good and the cheese and ingredients were very fresh (I'm from Chicago so pizza standards are pretty high). We came here after a terrible dinner at George's down the street. Really fun atmosphere with a nice covered gazebo area to eat your dinner! read more

Had the all meat pizza while we were listening to live music down at Peddlers. They were very busy, but they turned out the pizza very quickly. It's done in a wood fired oven and the crust was thin and crispy, which I love. I thought that the spicy sausage was exceptional and it was done just the right amount of time. It's definitely a little pricey at $20 for what amounts to a medium pizza, but considering the area and the fact that everything's a little high, I thought it was still good. Two excellent pizza options within 20 yards of one another with Pizza By the Sea so close, but this place is very good. read more

We always get pizza the first night in at the beach and with us arriving around 7 PM this was the closest place besides that brick and mortar Pizza by the Sea next to it. Walking from Rosemary to get 3 pies was ideal versus getting back in the car to get it so we gave it a shot. First of all you can tell by just calling and talking to the people that they are down to earth and I really enjoy that with all the ritzy stuck up people around this particular area. They made sure to read my phone number back to me and they would text me when the pizzas were coming out of the oven. It is busy so give them plenty of heads up. We got there about 15 minutes before our order was ready so I grabbed a delicious beer while listening to live music from a joining hut in the plaza. On the last sip they text me the pizza was ready and walked it back home. It was delicious so good that my six year old son wanted another pepperoni pizza a couple days later which we went back and got. Great owners, great workers, and even better Pizza. read more

Convenient. They do delivery after 3 pies of pizza. Grilled cheese was good, pepperroni pizza was ok read more

See all

Just spent a week and a half in Seacrest and had the pizza here three times we loved it so much. The meatball pizza and the margherita with sausage were our favorites. The dough with the imported flour plus the sauce are made fresh daily and it makes a world of difference. Won't mention any names but there is another pizza joint close by that cannot compare to the quality of Ticheli's. read more

Ticheli's Italian Pizza - Meatball slices - Pizza Near Me - Seacrest, Florida

Ordered four different pizzas: The Chicken Ranch; BBQ Chicken; Mr T's all meat; and traditional pepperoni. We chose this eatery because it was #1 on Yelp. BBQ chicken was the best of our four choices...sweet sauce that balanced with savory white chicken meat. I would purchase this one again. The pepperoni and the all meat were ok. Meats were tasty but the sauce had little flavor and the crust was tough. The ranch chicken was terrible...like someone dumped a bottle of thick ranch dressing on a burned crust. Too much ranch white sauce and the crust was black...should have been tossed in trash and another provided. We will definitely choose another pizza establishment wheN we return to 30A. The one size offered is 12 in pizza and the costs of the four above were 18, 18, 20, and 18, respectively. If taste had equated with cost, no biggie; however, the quality was inferior to CiCi's. read more

Greatest pizza in Florida 10/10 will come again, the worker I think his name was Ryan threw me on the best Hawaiian pizza, service was incredible, food was delectable and would come everyday if I could. Definitely check it out! read more

WOW! So good! A great selection with traditional pizzas and a fresh take on other ones. Fresh ingredients, friendly service, and homemade sauce. Don't miss this one on 30A. I came all the way from Alaska to taste a slice of heaven. WAY TO GO! ... also a nice surprise ... they provide gluten free crusts as well. read more

See all

Pizza is ok, I've had better. The atmosphere is what makes this place. Out door seating and live music. The meatballs are frozen, not homemade. read more

Ok so if you are looking for very good authentic pizza then this is not the place. If you are looking to satisfy a craving then maybe. I am from Jersey and this pizza is simply not that good. I just had the "sweep the kitchen" and I was surprised they had charged $22 and not used fresh mushrooms on the pizza AND it was not even 16 inches. The crust was a bit different but tolerable. We also had the green salad and the tomatoes were frozen. Everything else on the salad was good. read more

I was going to give them the benefit of the doubt, but then I saw similar reviews to what I experienced. My biggest issue is that it was advertised as a solid, authentic Italian pizza joint with a wood-fired grill. However, it was incredibly bland. The dough was mushy and not thoroughly cooked. Very below grade, especially with how expensive it was. The breadsticks also seemed microwaved. This is the quality of pizza I would expect at a theme park. The location is cool, but expect below average pizza. read more

We've eaten here a couple of times our last two vacations in Rosemary. We always enjoy the pizza and the staff is very friendly.

Told an hour wait. Ok. 2.5 hr later? C'mon now. You should be better than that. Pizza was a 6/10.

Really great pizza! Had the Tuscan, Southern Ranch, and the Chicken Bianca. All were incredible.

Outstanding pizza, some of the best I've had. It is very thin crust which I love. The guys working were very friendly, offered recommendations, etc. There is a bar right next door so you can sit outside and enjoy a beer or wine with the pizza. Will return when in area. read more

Haven't even had the opportunity to try this establishment because they will never answer their phone. don't bother ordering delivery or take out. They're too busy jerkin their meat instead of taking calls. read more

Absolutely the best pizza you will ever taste. The owners and operators represent their Italian heritage beyond expectations. Their food will make you feel at home, but with an Italian vibe. They offer a nearly endless number of combinations and options. Authentic Italian pizza represented extremely well. Happily offering pizza, and a variety of other food options. 10/10 planning to return. read more

Great people even better Pizza! Wonderful scenery to sit and have a little Beer and Pizza combo!

This place is soooo good! They let you do half and half pizzas. The Tonya Italian classic is the bomb! There's a pavilion where you can eat your pizza outside and the Peddlers Pub next door has great beers on tap. read more

Horrible. The cheapest, lowest quality ingredients, canned mushrooms and olives. Yuck! Expensive and slow as well. Surely there must be better pizza around here. read more