If you are a vegetarian, do NOT order cheese pizza by the slice. They only make one pizza to sell by the slice (half pepperoni, half cheese) - and I got plenty of pepperoni with my slice. Yuck! My husband ate a slice of the pepperoni. It was really greasy, the crust was thin, but dense. He is not picky and loves just about any pizza, but liked nothing about this one. read more

Amazing local spot. We had the spicy Hawaiian and it was by far the best pizza I ever ate.

All of the reviews are spot on. If you visit Kaua'i expect everything to happen on 'island time' and you will never be frustrated. Yes, everything costs more than the mainland, but transporting goods over thousands of miles of ocean is not cheap. Great pie and open atmosphere. read more

This pizza place was such a cute experience! We ordered the Tiki Man Pizza which had roasted pork.....it was so delicious! Wish I could have that pork on pizza all the time. Every bite of the crust tasted like fresh fluffy garlic bread because it was topped with garlic sauce and delicious. There was also live music which was a man who had a beautiful voice and sang native Hawaiian songs with the help of his Hulu dancer/wife. They were adorable! Will return and definitely recommend to visitors and locals alike! read more

Don't come here for pizza. Drinks and entertainment is koo but the pizza we ordered was burnt.

Our pizza was hot and fresh. Great crust, sauce and cheese. On the veggie pizza the vegetables were crisp and fresh. Service tonight was great - our waitress was attentive. Great experience. Pricy. But it is what it is. read more

We just randomly stopped by, had a great experience, drinks were great and we thought the pizza was great. I highly recommend stopping by for lunch. read more

Five stars for the atmosphere, great music and friendly service. The calamata salad was great. The pizza was crispy and cheesy but slightly salty despite having veggies on it. Nevertheless, I would definitely go back to have a few cold ones at the bar and listen to great tunes. read more

Pizza was decent, but service was terrible. The lady taking orders truly acted as if she did not want for us to eat there. She must have told us 4 times, 'It's going to be more than 45 mins.' We received water ONLY after I asked. We received a tablecloth for the door positioned across saw horses (I kid you not) only because someone spotted us and must have felt guilty. Not a great experience. Not our best experience dining out in Hanalei. read more

I don't know when the last reviewer was there but I have to disagree in that the pizza was excellent. My wife and I shared the garden pesto pizza and the kids split a Hawaiian with extra cheese and they may have been the best pizzas we've had in a while. We're kind of partial to toppings (we like our spaghetti chunky instead of soupy) and both pizzas were full and deliciously filling. I recommend this pizza place to anyone who will be in the area after dark, ESPECIALLY with kids! read more

We never got to try the pizza. This "pizza restaurant" is actually part of another restaurant and I guess pizza is just one of the many things that they supposedly serve when they get their shipment of pizza. We wouldn't know what else is good there, as we went there specifically for the pizza. My husband and I are both APEs (Adult Picky Eater)s and pizza is the one thing we can both eat. The host, who looked a bit like Moby, was super weird and emotional. Seemed like he might have been having some sort of a breakdown the day we tried to eat there, anyway, he made us wait 30 minutes meanwhile the table we eventually got was empty and ready the whole time we waited. He gave us some weird lengthy explanation as to why he couldn't seat us and kept checking on us at the bench we waited on, giving us weirder and weirder excuses. Eventually he sat us. We told the waitperson we already knew what we wanted. Cheese pizza. "We're out of pizza" she said. Are you effing kidding me? Moby could have told us that 30 minutes ago. We started to get up and Moby comes over to explain that yes, they are out of pizza but doesn't like to tell people because he "(feels) that the entrees don't get enough attention). Like I said, we have special diet issues and don't eat just any old thing, I glimpsed at the rest of the menu, saw nothing I would eat on there, and definitely nothing my husband would eat. So as soon as Moby's back was turned, we snuck out, hungry and pissed off. We snuck out because I was scared he'd see us leaving and try to convince us to stay because the entrees apparently have feelings and are neglected. Take your meds and change the name of your restaurant from Tiki Man Pizza to Tiki Man Entrees. Seems like a lot of locals go there to see local musicians play and to drink. If you like local celebrities from a town you're not from, getting drunk and going, "Whooo!" and a homey feel, and spotty service, and no pizza, go there. It's very cramped, the host is crazy, and they don't have pizza. But they won't tell you that until you've waited a long time. We found a Hawaiian grilled cheese place that also served plain Mainland grilled cheese, luckily. But the whole experience put us in a bad mood. read more

Good food, happy people, but slowest service ever. We were not given menus when we walked in. Had to chase down one of the two staff members every time we wanted something. Pizza was pretty good, but not worth the 2 hours. Great place if you have patience, not sure if it's really worth it if you don't. read more

Not only was the pizza bad, but extremely over priced, even for Hawaii. On a rainy day in Kauai I decided to try the local pizza. After reading review I thought that I would try out Tiki Man Pizza. It was a huge mistake. I called in the order from our hotel, and when I walked in it smelled like old fish. The $22 for a medium/small pizza was a shock, but i has hopes for the flavor. The pizza was burnt, and the crust tasted like it was frozen. It may have been the worst pizza I have ever had from a restaurant. Everyone in our group tried it and had the same sour expression. I recommend avoiding this restaurant! read more

Looked forward to eating here but unfortunately never got the food. Waited an hour and a half and finally gave up After 45 minutes we were told the kitchen was backed up. Bartender was rude and manager just said " we have about 20 people waiting for food." Too bad. Many other good choices in this nice community. Wouldn't waste time at this one. read more

The crust is great. Also the traditionally cooked kalua pork pizza was a great local flavor choice!

A very classic pizza joint. Basic cheese/pepperoni pizza by the slice or customize your own full pie, also regular menu options, too. Live music, lots of other guests, some of the longer tables may be share by multiple parties. Overall, a good pizza and a good time. read more

I came here because I read the great reviews. I really wasn't impressed. I was looking for an alternative to the recently closed Hanalie Bay Pizza. I must have expected too much because everything tasted mediocre at best. The cheese tasted funny and the pizza was ridiculously thin. The guy working the desk was very friendly and had great customer service and patience when we were trying to order. But I wouldn't find myself ordering another $28 pizza here again. read more

Can't say anything about the food, but if you're looking for a good happy hour with awesome Mai Tais, go here. Great ambiance and nice people working. read more

BEWARE of TAKE OUT. They charge you for the Takeout BOX, not a dollar but $6. I do not know how they justify it, oh they don't they just charge you that much. Also the girl who takes your money, then used the same hand to sprinkle the basil on a pizza, isn't that some kind of health code violation! read more

We live part of the year on the North Shore. We love TAHITI NUI, which is in front of TIKI MAN, and have had TIKI MAN pies several times in the past. Last week, we ordered a pepperoni pizza and a cheese pizza. Both suffered from severe cheese nostalgia--only a wistful memory of what cheese is. Both were overcooked; both consisted essentially of thin dough with a thin veneer of tomato sauce, and perhaps a tablespoon's worth of cheese. As for the pepperoni pie, my heart went out to the few samples of pepperoni. They just looked so lonely. A few nights later we tried the new HANALEI PIZZA. Expensive (everything on Kaua'i is), but excellent. HANALEI PIZZA recently underwent a big change and now produces really great pies. TIKI MAN--what happened? read more

Went here on a recent family vacation to Kauai. Showed up with expectations of good pizza and a bit of a wait. As expected, we were told the wait would be 30-40 minutes for a table so we decided to have a seat outside of the restaurant at a picnic table just below their outside balcony. My 3 children saw pitchers of water above them on the railing of the balcony and asked the waitress if they could have a cup of water. "Moby" as one of the other reviewers refers to him came out and said that he could not allow any "beverage service" to the table were sitting. We explained that it was just their water and he said NO. We were a bit put off by that so we decided to simply order the Pizza to go. Some waitress with a really poor attitude came to take our order and told us it would be at least 30 minutes. We decided to walk down the street and go to the local market for some bottled water/drinks for the kids. Upon returning, we sat back down at the same table outside to wait for the pizza that still wasn't ready. Moby came back out and literally tried to take the water bottles out of my kids hands. I told him that he had said that he couldn't provide beverage service outside but made no mention of us getting our own water. He proceeded to tell me Without Any Explanation that No One could drink anything at that table. I offered to stand with the kids and he said they would have to leave the premises. I told my wife to walk out to the side walk and I'd get the pizza. The waitress came back and said the pizza would be ready in another 5-10 minutes and she needed payment. I handed her my credit card at which point she told me they couldn't accept credit cards that particular night. Mind you, this is now about 45 minutes post ordering and waiting for the pizza. I told her she should have told me that when I ordered the Pizza and she made no attempt to apologize. I told her I didn't think I'd have the $50 plus dollars and could she discount the CASH ONLY purchase just a bit so I could still buy the pizza to which she said NO. At that point I left and took my family down the street for an Excellent Meal at Bubba's Burgers which cost 1/2 the price!! This place has no class and no training or care about customer service. Can only imagine that they stay in business "Barely" from the local patronage. That being the case, maybe they should simply put up a sign that says "Locals Only". We are a really easy going family and generally roll with the punches very easily. We've been coming to the Islands for over 30 years and this was some of the worst Aloha I have ever experienced. DON'T GO!!!!! read more