While in town for work, I stopped here with a coworker for a quick lunch. She is a local from the area and recommended it as her favorite spot. We shared the buffalo chicken chips with bleu cheese crumbles and they were fantastic. I had the chicken bacon ranch panini with a cup of the italian wedding soup. Both were decent and the sandwich was HUGE, it was enough for two filling meals. The place was busy for lunch on a Tuesday but there were plenty of places to choose a seat whether at the tables or the bar. I took a star off for the service because she only checked on us one time and she put another table's whole order on our check. read more

Timeless Destination - Chicken bacon ranch panini with italian wedding soup - Pizza Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

See all

I think I've just had one of the best steaks I've ever had. It was a little more on the done side than I prefer, but it was so tender I don't care. It was Topped with bacon, blu cheese, and a basaltic reduction. Yes, it sounds a little odd but it works if you enjoy blu cheese. The price wasn't too bad. The staff was attentive and friendly. Honestly, if the steak had been just a little less done I would be giving 5 stars. read more

This was the first time we stopped here and it was worth it. It was a late lunch and we had the Chicken cheesesteak and the chicken firecracker wrap. Both were very good. The meals came out pretty quick but like I said it was a late lunch about 2:30pm and no one else was there eating but two others at the bar and they just had drinks. I would stop there again if I'm in the area for sure. We ate at the bar and the atmosphere was a very nice place. read more

My boyfriend&i ordered out from here while visiting Wellsboro and hands down offered the best food. I had the chicken firecracker wrap which was super filling and had great flavor, the fries were okay, if you your fries on the softer side then check out the fries. my boyfriend had the chicken parm which was rather bland but it was still better than the Red Skillet which we had a few ate prior. Would recommend this place to anyone stopping by Wellsboro. My only complaint is that the menu online is NOT updated with new prices so we did pay a little more than expected read more

Food was mediocre for the price. We sat outside, liquor license did not cover outside seats, which was ok with us. Staff was friendly. Atmosphere was good. read more

Timeless Destination - Pizza Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

See all

A fine spot right on the main drag with great, friendly service. Actually one of the best burgers I have had at a restaurant. It tasted truly grilled, with a smoky juiciness to it--the sort of thing only home cooking can usually do. Outdoor seating with great views, too. read more

I find the name of this restaurant a little confusing because I think it could possibly be more of a bar with a limited menu as opposed to an Italian restaurant that serves alcohol. Anyway, I had a white pizza that I very much enjoyed. The crust was soft and pillowy and it had the right amount of cheese for my taste. The service was also decent however, it was a Monday night and the place was a bit sleepy. read more

Almost 4 stars. We liked it just fine, it's just not special enough to say "Yay, I'm a fan". The tossed salad was a step above typical. It had more ingredients than you usually see, and was very nicely arranged. Then we shared a small pizza, the "original" style, which we found very tasty. (This pizza does not have tomato sauce - it's a "white" pizza.) The decor is interesting and friendly. There are two distinct areas, one with bar and tables, and the other having only tables. The latter one is more suitable for family or group dining. Service was good. Bathrooms were clean if a little worn. 2 house salads, 2 iced teas, 1 small pizza, and one coffee came to about $30 before tip. read more

Timeless Destination - Pizza Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

See all

Very nice laid back atmosphere! Great food amazing salads and entrées! They were a lil late with an appetizer and took it off the bill right away. The buffalo chips are awesome!! Very nice beer selection, our server Donna was on top of everything and was very friendly. read more

Timeless Destination - Pizza Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

I found the service to be poor, the portions small, and the prices too high. There seemed to be some disorganization among the staff as if they had not been well-trained. In all of my 69 years I had never, until I ate at this restaurant, sent my entree back to the kitchen. I ordered a panini that was served slightly warmed and not at all toasted. Will not return. read more

E.V.E.R.Y.T.H.I.N.G. Was DELICIOUS!!!!!! Tissy was wonderful!!!!! Wings, boneless wings, cheese fries, jalapeño burger, white pizza, pepperoni pizza, crab Alfredo ravioli ALL OF IT WAS FABULOUS!!!!! 4 people ton of food, leftovers to go! Highly recommend!!!! read more

Great little restaurant in Wellsboro. I recommend the salmon dish. Prompt service and great atmosphere. Give this place a try if your in town. read more

Awwwwweeeeesome !!!!!!!!! This food was awesome and so were the drinks ! The waitress was the sweetest! I think her name was April? Really happy with this experience and definitely would recommend. read more

Meat lover pizza was good. Not too greasy considering the amount of meat (very generous; we had garlic breath the rest of the night) Kudos to the staff; tough conditions yet overly helpful and considerate read more

This wasn't our first choice for lunch but honestly there wasn't much open for lunch in Wellsboro. This is a fairly large building with lots of dining and bar room. We were six adults who just needed to get lunch before we got cranky on our way to see Pennsylvania's Grand Canyon. Being led to a dark back room and a table raised from the floor against a wall, I was reminded of going to a rock club in the 70's, so I had some fear about what we would get for lunch. What we found was a menu large enough at lunch to suit six adults including to vegetarians, a pizza lover, a salad lover and someone looking for a good cheesesteak outside of a metropolitan area. We were greeted with a round of waters and a large beer selection. That held off the wolves while we made our way through the menu. It took a while to get our food but that is expected during pandemic travel. We felt that with a small staff we were lucky to get beer in addition to food that everyone really liked. Wellsboro is a nice town with lots of places to eat and drink, unfortunately very few that are open for lunch on a Monday. Next time I'm in wellsboro I'll go back to Timeless Destination without question. read more

this place was so terrible. apparently they got a new chef and they clearly have no idea what they are doing. everything was tasteless and once we said anything, nothing was done. do not waste your time or money there read more

The sirloin steak was good crab on top of it wasn't so good. The waitress was overwhelmed and at one point she didn't even come to see us for about 15 minutes. I don't believe it to be a fault of her own she was probably in the back assisting the chef and plating the meals. I was spending over 150- $200 there and I told the waitress I didn't like the wine and she didn't even ask me why or had any concerns about it. The owner or manager seemed to hide in the bar area when he should be asking tables and customers how they feel better what he can do for them. He must be cocky he does have a lot to learn and improve his business to a 4 star rating. read more

This is one of our favorite "haunts". The food is delicious. Menu offers something for everyone. Family friendly. Staff is super personable, friendly, and go the extra mile. Highly recommend to anyone visiting Wellsboro. read more

This place has a great atmosphere. We sat in the lounge area, at a high top table. Our server was Alicia (Sp?); she was very nice did a good job. The food was good and tasty. First time here, not my last... Recommended: yes! read more

We were visiting the area for a few days and wanted to eat here on a Wednesday evening after research on Yelp. I was disappointed that the dinner menu did not have the Firecracker Chicken that I craved but the waitress promptly got one for me. I was charged dinner price but was well worth it! My wife had the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pannini and enjoyed it as well. We both ordered fries "extra crispy" and they were awesome. We had $10 in "Wellsboro Bucks" that our B&B provided us so, with a draft Coors Light and tip, the charge came to just over $19. We decided to return the next night and I had the Philly Firecracker wrap and my wife had the Three Cheese Pannini. Both were very good but I would order the Firecracker Chicken next time because it was a heartier sandwich. I also ordered the pasta salad this time and it was not bad but I would order the fries next time. We sat in the dining area - not the bar - so the atmosphere was nice (I'm not saying the bar area isn't nice - it appears to have high tops and TVs mounted around the room ala sports bar) BTW - In my opinion giving an establishment one star because it doesn't have a vegan option is ridiculous. If you are so restricted on your diet, research or ask ahead of time. You are punishing them for not serving what you want. read more

See all

We stopped for dinner, starved after hiking and sightseeing all day. Our waitress Mikala was so welcoming friendly. She helped us make the perfect choice for our dinner. The pecan crusted chicken salad was the best I have ever tasted in all my travels. Large portions and delicious prepared food. Our group was very pleased from soup, salad and main course. I wish I could comment on desserts but we were too full from their generous portions to even eat another bite. A must stop place for great food. read more

My sister attends a university nearby and suggested we go here. Service was great. The french fries are out of this world. My sister ordered the chicken parm panini. It was ok, but got soggy on the bottom. I ordered the turkey, avocado panini. It was a little bland and the cheese was not melted. I liked the atmosphere, the dark wood, the bar area was welcoming. I would certain give it another shot. The french fries are amazing, don't pass them up. read more

Just popped in for lunch real quick. Steak salad was legit. Had to go back to work but would have really loved to try a few of the beers they had that I have not really seen before. read more

Timeless Destination - Steak salad looks and smells soo good... And the taste did not disappoint. - Pizza Near Me - Wellsboro, Pennsylvania

Vegan review- stay away if you are vegan, unless you're just dying for a salad. Their pasta has eggs in it. Disheartening that a sit down Italian restaurant cannot doesn't have vegan options on the menu. read more

Um, do not let the newish contemporary look fool you...the service is old fashioned (EXCELLENT) and the food is fresh. Definitely trying dinner here some time. We don't get to Wellsboro often but would come back here on our next visit. read more

See all

Despite being recommended in town I was disappointed with the quality of food. Pasta Fagioli was good but average. The steak in the steak salad was way overcooked and tough/chewy with some steak medallions actually burnt. Pleasant outdoor seating. Friendly wait staff and a nice selection of beer. For their sake I hope I caught them on a bad day. read more

I came here starving after a day of hiking and backpacking and left stuffed and satisfied. This Italian style restaurant had a myriad of options; I chose the eggplant lasagna and my buddy got spaghetti and meatballs. Portions are huge and prices are beyond reasonable for the amount you receive. read more

Really dislike how waitstaff hangs around lurking in the background-not classy. Salad was pretty good. My salmon had a nice char, but the 'dill sauce 'was bad. Tasted like thick flour with no dill or flavor. Mashed potatoes were tasty but cold. read more

This restaurant was a wonderful find in a small Central PA town! The decor is creative. The food is fabulous. The owners and staff are terrific. I enjoyed the "Ossobuco" entree which was terrific. read more

See all

My husband & I just went to Timeless for our 19th Anniversary. It's under new owners now & the food was terrific. My husband had a Philly Cheese steak & fries & I had the best salad I've ever had. It was the Waldorf salad with grilled chicken on top. I was going to have Balsamic dressing, but the waiter suggested the grape vinaigrette. Glad he did because it was terrific! The waiter was a really nice guy, friendly & great service (wish I remembered his name). Prices were decent too. We will definitely be going again. read more

Timeless has amazing food! My boyfriend and I love ordering their Buffalo Chicken Pizza with either fries or their nachos or their wings. We usually order out for take out, but the resturant itself is gorgeous and surprisingly spacious inside. The wait staff is really nice as well. The only down side is once you move away from the pizza and appetizers or sides is the food can be a bit pricey. read more

This is probably the most upscale restaurant in the area, it features a lounge with a bar down below general seating. Everything looks very nice (except the janky bathrooms) and classy. A good place to go if you're trying to impress someone. In my experience this place is kinda overrated. They charge a lot for what I find to be [overrated food]. Don't get me wrong most of the food is good, but it's nothing I dream about (and I do dream about food haha). The quality is hit or miss. The staff seem to cycle out.. And I've met some rough ones but as of recently they have been friendly! Of all things the staff I have always noticed to be professional. They always have an array of desserts but honestly do NOT buy them they are over priced and hit or miss quality. The bar is not well up kept and not all the liquor listed in the menu is available (or might be empty). *this is more of a dressy place read more

My boyfriend and I were in town for a night and had lunch here after a busy morning hiking. We both loved our meals. I got the turkey, bacon, avo panini with a side of pasta salad. He got the Philly firecracker and a side salad with maple vinaigrette. The dressing was so good! Was not expecting to like a maple dressing but it was surprisingly refreshing. The service was good and the decor was good enough for me! Would definitely go back if we're ever in town again. In a town without a ton of options we were definitely satisfied. read more

Mediocur at best. Burger was a patty not hand made. Over cooked and a cold bun. Nothing too write home about. I probably not return while in Wellsburo PA. read more

Worst pizza in Tioga County only 14 slices of pepperoni on a large pizza for fifteen dollars unsatisfactory a half star at best

A great place to eat. The people are friendly, food is excellent and service is fine. This is a locally owned business and well worth your support. read more

Beautiful day in Wellsboro. Stopped for lunch. Wife's crispy chicken salad was Great. I love Ruebens when I see them on a menu. This one was exceptional. Thick, sloppy, on dark rye bread. One of best I have had. We be back read more

Great food, with attentive service. We had salads and the turkey,bacon and avocado panini. Dessert also delish!

For this area...this is a good place to eat. It has decent vegetarian options and the staff is always very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere is comfortable and the bathrooms are clean. There's not much going on in the way of fancy food up here in Tioga County but Timeless Destinations does a good job. read more

Not happy at all! Both the service and food were unacceptable. We were seated promptly in the front dining area and was asked if we would like something to drink. My wife ordered a glass of merlot and I ordered a beer. Ok so far. When the merlot came it was ice cold and my beer came in a bottle with no glass offered. When the appetizer came I noticed that there was no silverware on the table and I figured I would ask here for some utensils when she came back, well she didn't come back and my wife had to get up and ask another waitress. Then my wife's salad came with the dressing on the salad (my wife had asked specifically to have the dressing on the side). It took 17 minutes to get a glass of water and when I saw here BS'ing with people from another table, I got up, put the money down for what we ate and drank and walked out!!!! I have never experienced this level of customer service anywhere in the world where I have travelled and I travel frequently. Never again will I go back or recommend this place. I'm a little surprised because of the good reviews previously. Maybe there is a new owner or the manager was not on duty that night. read more