Truly amazing!! Long line out the door. Order at the counter & sit on the porch. Reasonable prices & very large portions. This is very quaint, not fancy. The Fried Green Tomatoes were OUTSTANDING!!! They had honey drizzled on them- mmmmm!!! The salad was SO good. It was beautifully presented, but I dove in too fast to get a pic. Great combo of flavors. My group loved their meals as well. They have beer & seltzers too. The patio was full. Family seating & a nice way to meet your community. There is a little playground in the back for children. Dogs welcome outside as well. I HIGHLY recommend! read more

See all

Did not get what I ordered. I ordered a fried oyster basket yet I got fried oysters on a roll. It was good but not what ordered. Fried green tomatoes were tasty but wet. Friendly staff. Won't go back. I don't like to send food back. I either send it back and don't pay for it or never return. So probably won't ever return. Patio just ok. Nothing special. read more

Quick service, beach ambiance, pretty good food! If you're getting the fish or the daily catch it is fantastic, would repeat for these types of items. We got the salmon Baja bowl and daily catch basket (Drum). The clam chowder is okay (but we're from California so take that as you will) and the poke bowl is ok. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Salmon Baja Box, Daily Catch: Drum Basket, Clam Chowder, Poke Bowl - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Very yummy lobster roll and fish tacos! There isn't any seating inside though so be prepared to sit outside in the heat. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Definitely worth checking out in Amelia island! We heard it's where the locals go which is always a big bonus in finding a goood restaurant. We grabbed lunch here and it was really delicious. The blackened shrimp and lobster roll were my favorites! The blackened shrimp was flavored sooo well! You do have to sit outside which is the only thing but they had plenty of fans and it was mostly shaded! The service was great and very fast! read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

On our last day in Fernandina Beach, my wife and I headed down to Timoti's for lunch. Touted as one of a few local restaurants serving fresh locally caught shrimp, I made sure to order shrimp for my lunch, specifically the Baja Box with fried shrimp. My wife, who was jonesing for clam strips for some reason, decided to order fried clam strips even though I cautioned her they're not known for clams AND we'll be making a separate trip to Cedar Key (clam capital) sometime soon. Anyway, my dish was good. The shrimp were well prepared, tender and not rubbery with crispy breading that wasn't too greasy. The cilantro ranch dipping sauce was a good compliment. My wife liked her clam strips even though some pieces were a bit chewy. The batter was nice and crispy and didn't seem greasy but she thought it had too many little pieces. Oh yeah, those hush puppies were quite good! Good ambience and decent value for fresh seafood. Lunch for 2 with tip came out to just under $32 with tip. read more

See all

Omgggg the food here was sooo goood!!! The blackened shrimp is to die for packed with so much flavor and the lobster rolls were very fresh. Some of the best seafood I've had in a while. The service was amazing and the ambiance was nice and very mid friendly too. I would drive back to Amelia island just to come back here. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Blackened Shrimp Basket - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Cute fast casual seafood place. Outdoor seating only which was perfect on a nice sunny day in February but maybe not so nice in summer. Counter service where you order and they literally shout your name when it's ready. They shout loud when you sit near the window! Server was very friendly. The Po Boy and cucumber salad was delicious. Check it put read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Counter service - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

The wait staff here was super friendly and pricing is very reasonable for the type of food and town. Food came out very quickly and the whole place seemed pretty clean. Only complaint would be that I didn't get much of the meat. I ordered on the box but I understand that tuna is expensive. Overall great spot and will be back due to reasonable pricing and great taste for some island food. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Rice Box - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Great fresh seafood spot! Street parking or public parking (payment required) available. Order at the counter. Really enjoyed the shrimp tacos and cucumber salad. They also have a playground outside in the back which was nice for the kids. read more

See all

The food is amazing. Had the special which was red snapper tacos, so fresh and tasty with the blackened seasoning. Hush puppies don't disappoint either. read more

Located in the downtown historic district, this place is simple and good. We stopped here for lunch and had a Chicken Caesar salad and the Lobster rolls. Seating is outdoors only. Would definitely recommend a stop here when you're in town. read more

See all

I ordered a take out lobster roll. When I got home, my bag contained 2 rolls of what I guess was shredded lobster. They were okay, but I had my heart set on chunks of lobster, so I was disappointed. I'm new to the area, so I'll try them again to check out their actual lobster roll. read more

Visiting from out of town and was in the mood for Seafood. The restaurant has a rustic vibe with wood tables outside to dine on. You order inside and they call your name to pick it up at the window. We ordered to meals to share. The first was a fried clam basket served with fries and two hushpuppies. The clams were fresh and tender with a light batter. Very tasty. The second meal was $20.00 lobster rolls. More like lobster spread. Very disappointing for a town adjacent to the water. The bathroom needed updating as well. read more

See all

Finally, welcome to 20th century seafood dinner pricing! However, be aware that you must eat outside after receiving your order. As you can see from the photos the decor is more upscale than an ordinary shak. Service was prompt and, upon placing my order, food was meticulously prepared and tasted fresh/fantastic. Steer away from the maine lobster roll as it tasted more like lobster salad and will disappoint. Upon my return, I will try something broiled or baked. read more

See all

I have been here several times now over the course of a few years. Always consistent, fresh food and well prepared. Very casual, outdoor seating at large picnic tables but tastefully done. Clam chowder is very good, the fried shrimp have some corn meal in the breading which adds a nice crunch and texture. Fish sandwich is always good. Food is prepared to order and arrives hot, staff is friendly and competent at what they are doing which you don't always see. I plan to be back. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Shrimp Po Boy, clam chowder and hush puppies - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We visited the area over the weekend and happily came across this little "shack". It's counter service and seating is outdoor picnic tables. While the space is cute and the weather was ideal, I can see where this would be inconvenient in the heat of the summer or rainy days. I ordered the clam strip basket and my husband chose the fried shrimp....fresh and not overly battered. We were both very pleased with our meals. Will definitely recommend and keep this place in mind when visiting the area in the future read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

Great place to grab a quck bite with outdoor shared seating. The portions are worth the price and the food is pretty tasty. The orders came out fast too and food was presented well. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - When that Baja Box wasn't really meant to be shared - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Service was great-very friendly. Atmosphere was comfortable. Restaurant was clean. The food was good. I had the crab cake sandwich. I've had better but I've also had worse. Prices were very fair. I recommend this place to grab a quick bite read more

Loved everything about this place! Great family friendly place. Good prices, great food, even better service!

Really great food. I had the fried shrimp basket which was fried perfectly and was plenty of food. My Wife had the Tuna Poke bowl. The loved it. You order at the counter and go outside to sit at communal picnic tables. While the line may be a little long at times, they crank right thru it. There is just a roof over the dining area but no walls. Still it was very comfortable when we ate there. Can't wait to go back next time we're in Fernandina! read more

I would recommend this place. Good Food, nice atmosphere. Would definitely come back again.

Great reasonably priced salad. Food good for the price. Reasonable kids menu. Good for quick seafood that won't break the bank. Only outside dining on picnic tables. Not much meat in tacos. Outstanding hush puppies. Baskets excellent. read more

Great prices Many options No inside dining Pets welcome! Coke Zero! Fried Green Tomatoes were amazing Tuna Poke was great Sample wife's shrimp platter. The shrimp was good the fries were good the coleslaw need (way) more sauce And the hush puppies were just okay. read more

See all

amazing food! quick service! i got the chopped salad - best figs i have ever had! it has a food-truck esque vibe.. out door seating only. i would definitely recommend visiting read more

See all

Order inside at the counter. Dining is outside or to go. They have Coke products including Coke Zero. Eating there they call your name out the window. I got the shrimp basket which was priced well for the amount of food you get. My shrimp and fries were great. The slaw had zero dressing. It was dry shredded cabbage mix. The hush puppies were my big disappointment. Two big ones, but there are peppers or something inside and the taste was different than usual. I normally love hush puppies so it's a bummer. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Order inside - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

We came about 15 minutes before closing because friends were there and wanted us to come. It was very cold out and I didn't want to be "that person" taking too long to order right before closing, so I asked how the New England clam chowder was, and I was told "very good" by the girl behind the counter, so I went for a bowl. My husband ordered the fried shrimp basket. I was disappointed they put my soup in a paper cup and put it on the tray while my husband's food was cooking. I also didn't realize it was outside seating only. My disappointment continued when I took off the lid of my now cooling soup and could see visually it was not remotely New England style clam chowder, but didn't even have a chowder consistency. I just decided to just eat it anyway and was shocked how tasty it was! I ate every last drop enjoying every bite! No, it didn't taste like New England clam chowder either, but there was a lot of fresh clam in it and none were chewy. It was an extremely tasty clam soup, for sure! My husband's shrimp basket looked liked really nice sized shrimp, perfectly done. I didn't try them, but he said they were fresh and delicious. The fries were possibly fresh cut fries, but good regardless. The staff were very friendly still checking on us even though it was after they were closed. I would definitely come back. read more

Title: Tell me something good....Timoti's Looking for good eats? Nice patio area? Friendly staff with superb customer satisfaction? Family friendly? Appropriately priced? Did I say delicious and fresh options to satisfy any palette? This is the place. Calamari is light and fresh but perfectly fried to perfection, start there. Seaweed salad is different and if you like seaweed you will love it. Shrimp taco (blackened) is my favorite. You can choose between flour or corn tortilla. Lobster rolls are good as well. Idk why I had yet reviewed this place, as it is one we frequent with each Island visit. Oh just stop reading and go, thank me later. read more

See all

This was our first stop in Amelia Island. The food came out quickly and was fresh! I recommend getting the side of calamari and the fried fish sandwich. The poke bowl is simple, not a lot of garnishments. I recommend getting the extra tuna. Enjoy! I wasn't a fan of the shrimp tacos because I like mine without a lot of extra toppings. But a great experience and look forward to trying more foods next time. read more

Food was great and service was quick. A perfect spot to grab some quality seafood and sit outside on a nice warm December day! read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Lobster rolls, shrimp basket, Clam Strips, and Chicken Strips - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

We had this on our list to visit prior to even leaving our home in the north east. It checked all the boxes - it had a playground for kids, delicious food, and an overall great vibe! It lived up to the hype entirely. My son loved playing while waiting for our food and my husband said the shrimp was the best he's ever had. Service was super friendly and quick even with a line. If you have kiddos (or if not!) this place is worth a stop for sure! read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The best parts are the reasonable prices and playground for kids. Draw backs are there's only one person taking orders inside and the line takes a long time to get through and the other is there's not enough tables. None at all inside and picnic type tables outside so be prepared to share with others. The lobster roll was the only thing I tried and it was good. Not as good as up north but still satisfying. The bread is just a Texas toast which could have a more butter flavor. All in all happy with the visit. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Menu - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

Will not return due to owner supporting paid parking ordinance. Used to like it, but even before this current malfeasance the quality of the food was slipping. Live on island and will never go back. read more

Food is amazing! Shrimp and cucumber salad. The ambience is nice outdoor picnic tables and a playground for kids. Dog friendly! Service is fast but there is usually a line!! read more

Food was excellent. Fish tacos well prepared (altho no sides - husband still hungry- he should've ordered more food). My salad was huge and delicious. Staff friendly. Sat at picnic table with nice folks. V casual and quick! read more

Wow, great food, and I would give it 10/10!! Everything I ordered was so fresh and tasteful. This place is a must!!! Came around lunchtime and the line was pretty long but once I ordered and sat down, it came pretty quickly. Must order the lobster roll and the shrimp tacos and basket!! What I ordered: - Shrimp basket blacked with fries, slaw, and hush puppies - Blacked Shrimp Tacos - Lobster Rolls: T's lobster salad served in two New England-style rolls - Fried Green Tomatoes read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

The food here is so good! I got the fresh catch of the day, which was drum fish. It was so light and flaky. Delicious! The line was really long, but the service is fast and efficient. The seating has large picnic tables and a little play set for children. Very cute. We will definitely be back when we come to Fernandina Beach. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Catch of the day basket (drum fish) - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

One of the few restaurants I was able to check out in Amelia island outside of the Ritz Carlton. My family with 2 young kids ended up staying at the resort mostly for our 3 night and didn't end up venturing out at all. I did pick up some take-out from Timoti's our first night in Amelia island and it was amazing. Very reasonable and great portions. I ordered 5-6 different items and it was less than $65. Highlights were the Tuna Poke bowl, the rice box and the fried fresh catch of the day. Everything was fresh and flavorful. Their poke sauce had a good combination of acid, salt and umami. I wanted to go back for lunch, but sadly didn't get a chance to. Until next time! read more

See all

Fernandina Beach has a hidden gem, Timoti Seafood Shack. They have crowds of hungry patrons, covered outdoor bench seating and some of the most delicious seafood in the area. Timoti is casual, a personable staff and one of my top three dining favorites on Amelia Island. We had explored the food scene prior to our trip but always verify with locals. Even though they are small in size, they compensate with excellent food. Timoti was perfect for lunch and set the bar very high. We ordered the blackened shrimp and fries, and twin lobster rolls. The blackened shrimp were stacked with flavor, perfectly cooked and only left me wanting more. The twin lobster rolls were over-flowing with fresh / sweet lobster, minimal filler and a great roll with a slight crunch. As good as these two dishes were, the fries need an honorable mention. They were crispy on the outside and perfectly cooked on the inside. There are no weak links at Timoti Seafood Shack. If you want really great seafood packed with flavor, Timoti Seafood Shack needs to be on your bucket list. My only suggestion is to order two orders because one is just not enough. Thank you for an amazing meal. read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Blackened shrimp with fries, Crazy Good! - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all

I didn't expect this place to be as good as it was ! It is casual, seating, mostly outside and no AC but the weather was tolerable. I ordered the shrimp basket with cucumber salad & fried green tomatoes. The breading of the fried green tomatoes was on the sweeter side but everything else was delicious! read more

Timoti's Seafood Shak - Baja bowl with coconut rice and blackened fish... this was really good! - New American Near Me - Fernandina Beach, Florida

See all