Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tinder Hearth

    4.3 (51 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated a few days ago

    Tinder Hearth Photos

    TINDER HEARTH ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Tinder Hearth

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Pepperoni pizza.  Delish crust.  Just still out!
    Diane H.

    There was a good bit of hype about Tinder Hearth because you have to reserve on Monday morning at 9am for a spot that week. I was able to get a reservation but the metrics were wrong. Instead of 2 people and 3 pie, we were a party of 4 with 2 pies. This was fixed by email on Tuesday. I live about an hour away, and am not much of an adventuresome eater. So clams and chorizo on the meat pizza didn't work for me, and the vegetable too had some things I didn't like. So we had a cheese pizza and a pepperoni pizza (ordered when we got there). The pizza was ok. Nothing spectacular and I wouldn't drive an hour to get it (nor worry about reservations) The grounds were beautiful ~ on a farmhouse. We sat at picnic table near an area full of screaming, running kids. The port a potty was not very clean, 3 of us decided to wait for another time to stop.

    Tomato pie pizza
    Kieran S.

    Great environments and even better pizza. Reservations must be made but it's not too hard. Although it is outside and a bit buggy it represents to me how fresh all their ingredients are as they have a garden out back. In fact, an employee was saying how the potatoes used on one of the pizzas today was just picked that morning. I'm sure anyone would thoroughly enjoy this pizza

    Entrance
    John S.

    I really wanted to love this place! Good reviews; rustic barn atmosphere; homemade pizza, bread, and pastries; and middle-of-nowhere charm. I made three visits, to be fair in my review. On the first, the wood-fired pizza was highly forgettable. I can name a dozen or more pizza places in Portland that serve up a better pie. On the second visit, I waited a half-hour for a $10 croissant. The pastry was excellent, though. On the third visit, I ordered take-out. Let me pause here and try to give some advice on the ordering process. If you go, be sure to visit the web site first. You'll find quite a bit of text explaining how and when to order bread, pizza, and pastries. One may only order at certain times - it reminds me of the cable guy hours: "He'll be there sometime between 12-5PM." Back to my third visit, I called and the employee spent five minutes telling me why I could not order takeout over the phone and needed to come in, order, and then wait for however long it took. When I got home, the entree, salad, and cake were all half the size of anything I saw being delivered to tables at the restaurant. And, they forgot the flatbread with my curry. It was the only included side to the curry. And, if you love curry, you understand that dipping the bread in the leftover sauce is the best part. And, the tiny meal was $40, including tip. Over three visits, staff ranged from very nice to somewhat dismissive. The food was fine. If you're going to visit, be prepared. Review the web site. Expect an average meal at a high price. And enjoy the drive.

    As good as they look croissants
    Delora B.

    Worth the drive. Quality. Quality. Quality. This place will make you want to move to Maine.

    Cinnamon bun made with croissant dough

    See all

    7 years ago

    The best fresh bread and pizza around. Call to find out the baking schedule and the pizza schedule. They also make Spelt bread. Delish!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of JG W.
    2
    482
    2389

    11 years ago

    Helpful 5
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Peter M.
    336
    22
    6

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Tinder Hearth

    Strong's Public House & Patio

    Strong's Public House & Patio

    4.3(26 reviews)
    4.6 mi
    $$

    Excellent find! What a fantastic pizza!…read more We were staying at the fancy tent place up the road and were pretty hungry and fancied a beer or two. Whip out the trusty Yelp app and we are on our way to this wonderful little gem! I have found this app to be a great tool for finding local gems like this. We arrive and it's a bit under construction from the looks of it. This is a family business in the truest sense. They do all of the work themselves, at least when I was here. He is adding on to the place and creating more seating. He manned the oven and she waited on the tables and I feel like there were some of their children working in the back as well. There are a few other families there with us. One other from our campsite that I noticed when were arriving. I love the fact that the stones for the oven came from the ground right out front of the place while they were digging it up to build the patio. How cool is that?!?!? He told me all about it when I asked if he had built it himself. He hired a mason locally he said. Ok. Pizza hits the table. Wow. I could list 42 adjectives describing how good it was, but you just need to go see for yourself!! Perfect crust though!! Perfect! Do that as fast as you can! Come here by plane, train, auto, snowmobile, tank. Whatever. I even heated up the leftovers on a stone by the fire at the tent. Stupid good leftover too!!! Thank you to the Stones for a great meal and wonderful hospitality!! '26 - 25

    It was our first night in Blue Hill, ME and we decided to try this restaurant. We got the pepperoni…read morepizza w/ ricotta, meatball sub, and hot apple drink. The pizza had a perfect crispy crust and was delicious. So was the meatball sub. The drinks were also superb. The place was not busy and we were able to sit outside under the lights. Had a lovely time!

    Photos
    Strong's Public House & Patio - Stones from excavation the patio built the oven.

    Stones from excavation the patio built the oven.

    Strong's Public House & Patio - Pepperoni pizza w/ ricotta, meatball sub, hot apple drink

    Pepperoni pizza w/ ricotta, meatball sub, hot apple drink

    Strong's Public House & Patio - Cool oven. The stones were excavated from the patio area out front.  A local mason then built the oven to his specifications

    See all

    Cool oven. The stones were excavated from the patio area out front. A local mason then built the oven to his specifications

    Bucksport House of Pizza - Pizza

    Bucksport House of Pizza

    4.2(59 reviews)
    13.2 mi

    We were a party of three dining at Bucksport House of Pizza, and the whole experience was genuinely…read moreenjoyable. We ordered the calzone, the Mediterranean wrap, the teriyaki wings, and the steak and cheese sandwich, along with a couple of tall beers. Every dish was fantastic. The calzone was delicious and perfectly doughy, the Mediterranean wrap was super yummy with Greek salad dressing as the sauce, and the steak and cheese was generously filled and very satisfying. The only thing that could have made the meal even better would be having the teriyaki wings tossed in the sauce rather than receiving it on the side. Our server was excellent--friendly, attentive, and totally on the ball. We genuinely enjoyed her banter, and she added a lot to the overall experience. The atmosphere was a highlight. From the deck room, you get a relaxing view of Fort Knox, the Penobscot River, the docks, the railroad tracks, and the river walk. It's a peaceful spot to enjoy good food and a cold beer, and we left very happy with the visit.

    We were there on 9/11. One of the guys we met there was a firefighter who was at the twin towers…read morewhen they collapsed. I am a firefighter paramedic and I was honored to be able to talk to him and hear his experiences while he searched for survivors in the rubble. He had given a talk at the 9/11 ceremony at MMA earlier in the day. A large group of Castine firefighters came into the restaurant and I wanted all of us to sit together. We were sitting at the bar. Dino, the owner, graciously opened the deck which allowed us to all sit together and I was able to treat everyone with their meals. Everyone was so understanding and allowed me to treat these fellow firefighters as they should be respected. Thank you BHOP staff. We all appreciate what you

    Photos
    Bucksport House of Pizza - Yup there it is... Amanda is the first bartender I've ever met in my 57 Years of Navy Aviation that wouldn't stand behind her own cocktail

    Yup there it is... Amanda is the first bartender I've ever met in my 57 Years of Navy Aviation that wouldn't stand behind her own cocktail

    Bucksport House of Pizza - The best new App!

    The best new App!

    Bucksport House of Pizza - Front entrance

    See all

    Front entrance

    Tinder Hearth - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...