When I first heard about tonari, a japanese-italian fusion restaurant in dc, I wasn't sure what to expect. At first glance, the menu is classic Italian fare--pasta, pizza, and appetizers like burrata and garlic bread. However, a closer look (and bite!) reveals the Japanese twist behind each dish. This is a cozy, vibey atmosphere--perfect for a date night--so be sure to make a reservation if you want to squeeze in.
The service was nothing particularly spectacular, and even a little slow at times. They also messed up our order but quickly corrected it. Note that the kitchen closes early, so while we made our reservation for 7:30 PM, we had to order our dishes before 8:00 PM, unbeknownst to us. The dishes also came out pasta first, then appetizers, then pizza, which was a little strange.
For starters we ordered the burrata, which comes in a sichuan chili oil and orange sauce and served with slices of orange on the side. The burrata was creamy, delicate, and paired well with the tart crispness of the orange. I wish the sichuan flavor was stronger, but the chili oil was still a good addition. The fresh orange slices were also a great addition, cutting through the flavors of the main dish and providing a nice palate cleanser for the following dishes. The highlight of the night for all of us was the Korean-style garlic bread. While I'm not sure what exactly was "Korean" about this garlic bread, the brioche was light, fluffy, and the garlic butter and cream cheese filling struck the perfect balance of creamy umami. My only complaint is that the garlic bread wasn't bigger.
For the pasta, we ordered a classic marcela and the recommended mentaiko. The classic was nothing particularly special in terms of flavor or presentation, with al dente noodles served in a tomato sauce and with a side of ricotta, but the pasta was executed well. The best dish of the night for me personally was the mentaiko pasta, which was served perfectly al dente in a silky sauce and topped with nori and chili threads. The cod roe, as opposed to topping the pasta like I expected, was integrated into the sauce to create a more glossy texture and add a hint of fishiness to the pasta (but not overwhelming!). This dish highlighted the Japanese flavors that I expected to find, with the pasta remaining the star of the dish.
For the pizzas, you can order a half (2 slices) or a whole (4 slices). Because the pizza is all Detroit-style, the portions are small but filling. The gorgonzola is strong, but not overwhelming--but you definitely have to like gorgonzola to enjoy this one. The honey and pistachio were a fantastic pairing, but this pizza did come out a little sweet, which some people may not enjoy. The tonari classic is a classic pizza slice--cheesy, covered in tomato sauce, crispy, and melts in your mouth. Nothing particularly special about the flavor profile either, but I imagine that adding anchovies (for an additional $4.00) would certainly augment the experience. The japanese philly was my personal favorite of the three pizzas we tried. I was disappointed that I couldn't taste the soy and mirin braise on the meat, but the pizza itself tasted exactly like a philly cheesesteak, just in pizza form.
For dessert we ordered a panna cotta, which comes with honey, fennel pollen (???), and a blueberry and prosecco granita. While the panna cotta was wonderfully light, creamy, and not overly sweet, I could've done without the granita on top. The blueberry and prosecco don't pair well, lending the panna cotta an overly sweet, alcoholic taste that takes away from the refreshing dessert.
While the food is certainly excellent, the portion sizes are small, so expect to spend a decent amount of money if you come here on an empty stomach. However, I'd definitely come here again to try the rest of the menu. read more