TLDR: Fun take on Japanese Italian fusion. Pricey at times, but definitely worth at least one visit. Come for the pizzas.
Vibe: 5/5. Tonari has a beautiful restaurant nestled in the heart of Chinatown. Taking a modern izakaya approach to their decor, the downstairs has a bar as well as several 4 top booths for small group dining. Upstairs they have a huge traditional tatami seating area (you take off your shoes and you sit in the floor with your legs in a recessed part of the floor under the table) which is a fun experience for larger groups. They also have a massive table top garden on display on the 2nd floor which is worth a look!
Service: 5/5. During our visit, we dined with a large group of 9 and Tonari was very accommodating. We had to make last minute head count change to the table and had no problems doing so the day of. During our meal, our waiter did a fantastic job at keeping the table well stocked on drinks as well as clearing plates as we progressed through the meal. We ordered with the intent of dining family style which can get a little hectic with the addition of extra serving utensils, plates and the passing of food. However, Tonari did a stellar job at accommodating this and I highly recommend trying the menu in this fashion in order to get a full taste of the menu.
Food/Drinks: 3/5. Toting their style of food as Wafu Italian (Japanese style Italian), Tonari does deliver a unique take on food, but at some points fell short on execution and value. During our visit, we ordered more or less the entire menu in order to be eaten family style amongst the table. I feel this is the only way to order at unique restaurants, as it gives everyone a chance to try everything and not be limited to a few dishes. In addition, we ordered several cocktails, a pitcher of negroni (draft) and a bottle of sake for the table. The bar program at Tonari is nicely thought out, with plenty of fun twists on classic cocktails with Japanese ingredients. I especially enjoyed my Drunk Oji, which had a deep smoke note similar to eating BBQ from the Laphroaig and Toki whiskey mixed together. On to the food, the first round was appetizers which we ordered the polpette, burrata, Caesar and robata style shrimp that was on special. Everything came out nicely and tasted fine, but honestly nothing stood out as must haves. Our second course was designated our pasta round, consisting of the curry kinoko and mentaiko. Both dishes were interesting, as we started to taste the playfulness between Japanese and Italian ingredients. The mentaiko pasta dish definitely came out on top, having a nice umami flavor from the nori and cod roe which paired perfectly with the creamy creme fraiche sauce. Our final round was the main attraction, pizza! We ordered whole pizzas of the clam, mushroom and mentaiko. The 2 pizzas we were most excited for, the clam and mentaiko, fell short on expectations. Both felt a little undercooked when compared to the mushroom pizza and just didn't have the flavor profiles we were expecting from the ingredient list. The mushroom pizza faired much better, as it was cooked just a little longer to achieve a nice crisp crust and letting the flavors of the sauce and brick cheese open up. It could of just been a one off situation with our two pizzas, so don't write them off just based on our experience. The pricing at Tonari was a little on the high side for what we received. Each 4 slice pizza costs in the neighborhood of $25-30, which is a stretch in my opinion. Pasta dishes, which could be a satisfying meal for 1 person w/ appetizers, hovered in the $15-20 range. In addition, all tables are automatically charged a 22% service charge in place of tipping. Considering we typically tip in that range regardless of service, we were totally fine with this, but felt it was worth making note. All in all, everyone walked away from our meal satisfied and happy, but just felt for the money we spent it would of been a more memorable food experience. read more