We bought 6 Sonny angels from Tons of Toys in Madison NJ and they came with many defects, not certified Sonny angel seller though it was marketed as one, do not recommend. read more

Packed store but lots to look at and super helpful staff!!! Has some hard to find items from Japan and Europe but you have to take the time to look. read more

As an out of towner, I couldn't tell if the reviews for this store were real or fake. They're real, this place is awesome. The photos looked much better than the other store (that was closer to my hotel) so I came here instead. Was approached by a helpful customer-friendly guy who showed me everything that they had in the categories I wanted and left me to it. I worked in customer service for a while and was impressed. Way more selection than the big chains, it was actually same and more diverse stuff compared to the big box stores (in my town Target often has the best toys, but they often only carry the same things - this place had that and more!). They had stock of stuff you can usually only find online (Ex: Brio, Gabby's Dollhouse, even some die cast planes that I normally can only find at a certain online shop). Whoever is ordering the stock here gets it. They aren't simply reordering the same old stuff you find everywhere else. Prices were on point too! Didn't feel like I was "paying up" for this place either, because we all have budgets at the end of the day. He did offer to wrap the toys, but my kids could care less about wrapping so I declined. He asked if I was sure and I said yea, let's skip it. If I lived here, I would regularly support this shop. Their prices are competitive, and the customer service cannot be beat. I wish we had stores like this where I live! read more

Whatever you're looking for... they have it at Tons of Toys! We were immediately welcomed as we walked in. Everyone is ready to you locate your item in the crowded aisles of toys! We were happy with the price. It's a fun place to browse. read more

The best selection of toys. Their customer service is top notch. The only place to buy toys for kids!

Always excellent service, with staff who know their products. My grand-niece and nephews are always happy with their gifts!

Love supporting local spots and this place is no exception. Super friendly staff. They have a wide variety of toys (including newly released, hard to find ones). They are a tad more pricey than a Target but the personalized service is deifinitely worth it. There is parking in the back (plus an entrance) or park on the street and enter through the front. Super helpful when you are in a rush. Bonus - they wrap your toy for free. Awesome spot. Enjoy! read more

I was in a jam! My grandson's 6th birthday and I could not get to him. Called Tons of Toys and Sebastian was phenomenal. He helped me shop, texting the images of the items my Maxi would want, wrapped up the present and even delivered the gift. Get this, without knowing, I called about 10 minutes before closing. I love the customer service, the grace and courtesy. Will never shop anywhere else for my 5 grandchildren's toys. read more

There are certain types of retail establishments I am very comfortable in. Chinese restaurants, comic book shops are among them. Another kind? Toy stores. Large, small, medium, having online shopping options has not dampened my enthusiasm for toy stores, even smaller ones like "Tons of Toys". From the outside, "Tons" is welcoming with large stuffed animals in the front and toys in the window. Inside is shelf after shelf of toys packed in tight, creating a bit of a wonderland effect of colors and childhood joy. I saw everything from "no bake" donut makers, Rock'em Sock'em Robots, Star Wars toys, remote controlled vehicles, dolls and of course board games. The staff was very friendly and offered help twice. I also noticed for a small shop, their prices were very fair. In some cases only a dollar or two above prices you'd see at Target or Toys R Us. I was quite impressed! This is a great little shop to pick up some toys in Madison. Definitely worth a visit! read more

Very nice store. Great for grands shopping for the kiddos! Helpful staff and free gift wrap

This place is adorable! They are filled floor to ceiling with toys and the workers are friendly without being bothersome. What I really like is they have a lot of toys that require children to play using their imagination. They have a lot of creative projects and art projects for all ages. They also have adorable (and safer) wooden toys for babies and toddlers. They have some great toys for nostalgic gifts. My mom comes here whenever she is in town to buy reasonably priced creative gifts for the kids in our family. Very sweet store :) read more

This is a small chain of family owned toy stores and a great alternative to the big box chain stores that we all know. If you are looking for personalized service when you are looking for that gift for the special kid in your life than check them out. The store is much larger than you would think and they have a very large selection of all the popular toys. They also offer free gift wrapping making this perfect for those like myself that are gift rapping incapable. read more

What a great store. I love shopping here for my son. The owner and staff are all so nice, go above and beyond for their customers. A true pleasure to have in the area. Good variety and I always find something here. Lucky to have this spot! read more

Stack floor to ceiling with toys, Tons of toys lives up to it's name. They have a wide variety of toys for age groups 0 to 12ish years old. The staff is exceptionally helpful and good humored. I was able to do most of my Christmas shopping for the kids in my family in very little time. As many of my reviews indicate, I am small business friendly, located on a Main street, they are a perfect example. Pricey, yes they are, but Tons of toys also provides free gift wrapping, and if you are savvy, they offer a 15% off coupon, but it expires before December. In my opinion, the convenience of free gift wrapping in addition to no shipping or handling, makes the price gap small. Please be advised, they do not appear to have much for video games or larger toys. (bicycles, power wheels etc) Bottom line: Excellent Customer service and good variety beats Lord Satan TOYS R US, and evil overlord Amazon any day. read more

Tons of Toys and its excellent staff provided us one of the happiest moments of the lockdown period of 2020. Locked within the confines of a small ranch house that made us wonder whether we were experiencing cabin fever or had actually bought a small town version of the Overlook hotel, our family had developed an unhealthy puzzle obsession. Burned through two decades of dusty, backlogged puzzles in about two months. The Beast of Quarantine demanded more, lest its worshipping natives become restless. With few options available, Tons of Toys answered the call. Literally. Their wonderful staff somehow made the process of choosing a puzzle by phone more fun than it had any reason to be - there is no reason, to be clear. And these guys KNOW their puzzles. We arrived at the store for an easy handoff, only to be given one more surprise. The puzzle was wrapped in layers and layers of wrapping paper. Every time you thought you'd reached the puzzle - more wrapping paper. And then MORE wrapping paper. My family and I were laughing so hard that I genuinely had to stop and momentarily force myself to breath. The puzzle was great and lasted a week, but this store gave us an experience and sense of happiness that has lasted for many months since. Best toy store ever. read more

TofT is AWESOME! They have it all, the owners/employees know their customers, and the gift wrapping is beyond compare. Truly exceptional. The prices are only slightly higher than Amazon. TofT is an anchor for downtown Madison, and definitely one of the reasons Madison is a great place to live! LOVE! read more

Can you buy toys for cheaper on Amazon? Yes. So why do you go to a place like this? The typical story you get is to support local businesses, but I'm of the belief that best product for best price wins. I do buy a fair number of toys on Amazon. However, two reasons to shop at Tons of Toys: 1) Instant gratification. My kids want a toy and I want them to get it right away. They love being the ones to pick it out. And, it teaches them math because I give them a budget. 2) The guys that run this place are super helpful. I'd say we buy almost all of our gifts from here because they offer helpful suggestions about what to get. Also, it makes it easier on locals to exchange. I went in there wanting a toy that helped with spelling and words. They suggested Zingo. Kids loved it. All of their suggestions are spot on. So, the product here is the fact that you get great product suggestions from people who like kids and toys. read more

We love this place! Probably the only place we ever get toys - the guys are great, and they always wrap the presents so beautifully. Support your local towns!! :) read more

I was in the store today for the first time and was very impressed. I was especially impressed with one of the employees, Tyrec, because he was super friendly and was super helpful with helping me find what I was looking for. read more

I would recommend this. The staff has a good sense of hummer and are very helpful. They have a very large variety of toys, I mostly go there for the trading card games and they have an amazing variety in that category. I would really recommend it. read more

The best toy store in the area! This place is great and the people that work there are so nice. They have stuff like legos, action figures, and video games. Definitely recommend going. read more

Awesome expierence! I dont know much when it comes to shopping for toys so really all I did was let the staff show me around and inform me of what toys were real popular! When I went to pay they offered to gift wrap it and for a guy like me it was a no brainer, not to mention there kind of funny behind the counter! Either way it was super convient and the gift was a huge hit! Thanks Tons of Toys, you guys came through big! read more

These guys just love toys and always ready to help....check them out on Facebook!

Not crazy about this branch - the staff weren't very knowledgeable about making a recommendation for an 8 yr. old girl's birthday present...they're more like college students with a part-time job. The better branch is the Tons of Toys in Chatham...the main proprietor Keith is way more knowledgeable and helpful than the Madison store (because the Chatham store is closed on Sunday, I went to the Madison one and experienced the lackluster service). read more

I like Tons of Toys. I've had better experience at Madison location rather than the Chatham location. I like the owner....always very friendly, helpful and willing to wrap anything you buy. My only complaint is that they can be pricer on certain things. I try to shop local as much as possible, but if a toy is 19.99 at Toys R Us, and is 24.99 at Tons of Toys, I will buy it at Toys r Us. That markup is just too high for the price point on the toy. So, I usually double check. I am willing to pay a little more, but not $5 on a $20 toy. Anyway, I shop here as much as I can and hope they stick around until my kids outgrow them! read more

Is very messy. Hard to locate toy you are looking for Like a small big box store nothing special

I just brought the girls i babysit for (ages 6 and 10) into the store and let them pick out whatever they wanted. They could've spent hours in there if I let them. Owner Chris was helpful as usual and the kids love him. Rainbow looms are the hottest thing now so girls got new limited edition refills they couldn't find at any other store so they were super excited. They also got some tie dye bags for school and lip gloss. They even got this cool y'all ball to play w outside with their dog. Always impressed with these guys and the array of stuff they carry. Side note: if you don't wanna park on Main Street there is always parking on the side street by the store and there is a parking lot in the back. read more

Simply the best toy store in NJ! The nicest staff who will help you pick out toys in any price range and wrap them up for you. They remember their customers names and the names of children that come to the store. Also they make great videos- check out their Facebook page. read more