First timer . Good location . Very close to RT 1 ... it is placed perfect close to other shops too - like Walgreens , Manhattan bagels etc. wanted to pick a couple of slices of pizza for lunch . Lots and lots of parking available outside the restaurant . There is also good seating facilities inside to dine in. Interiors were ok but it's of tables inside . Pizza was actually good . Very thin and kinda crispy and nicely made . My kid loved it and finished it all. Service was also good. Guy was very friendly and was able to give the order in less than 5 mins . Price wise it was ok. Not too expensive and not too cheap :). Costed me about 6-7 $ for a couple of slices which wasn't bad . Thought of giving 4 stars but this place deserves a 5 star . read more

See all

I travel into NY and NJ periodically. When I do I like to grab some known foods of that area. I love NY / NJ Italian food, pizza and bagels. This restaurant was ok but I would not consider it a NJ pizza stop. The pizza slices did not look very fresh. The service was friendly but it was tough asking questions as most employees did not speak english. There were a few tables and the restaurant seemed mostly clean. read more

See all

When in Jersy , have to order some local pie . (aka pizza) This is our 2nd time ordering delivery/ takeout from Tony' s and it came at the perfect time as we just came off the plane . Our order: half cheese half onion apparently is a big Jersy thing.Although I typically like a crust that is a little less toasty and a bit less cheese, it still was what I would expect from a NJ pizza. Their garlic rolls were the bomb and were served with a rich , slightly salted red sauce. We also ordered a traditional meatball sub that was scarfed down in less than 5 min by the family.It was a footlong and they said could have used a bit more red sauce .I missed trying that one since gave up red meat years ago. Give it a solid 4 . Return : probaly read more

See all

Came here while waiting for my wife to finish her mani/pedi. It has an old-school vibe the moment you walk in. The guy at the front needs to smile cause. Lol. It felt like he didn't want to be there. The pizza is ok. I could have used a little more sauce for my personal liking, but it's ok for a quick bite. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - Plain slice - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

I'm deeply disappointed with my experience at this place. As a queer Hispanic customer, I was treated with mockery and passive-aggressive behavior by the staff. From being ignored, to being referred to indirectly using terms like 'mi ciela' in a clearly derogatory tone, I felt unsafe and humiliated. When I asked for a refund and recorded the interaction for my safety, the staff tried to backpedal, but the damage was already done. This isn't just bad service--it's homophobia. read more

I love this place. The food is fantastic. My favorite is the pasta fagioli soup with lots and lots of beans. And now serving Tacos I got the chicken tacos today soooo sooo good. The side room is great for gatherings or big parties The staff is so welcoming. read more

Not the same. The store, furnishings, decorations are identical (purchase was lock, stock and barrel, I guess?) but that's where resemblances end. These new owners are friendly, that's for sure. And the place looked cleaner than I have ever seen since our first of many visits these last 10 years. These reasons justify my two stars. However, there is definitely a language barrier despite sincerest attempts. And regrettably, most importantly, the food is blah at best. My chicken cutlets were rock hard and flavorless. The pasta was cooked perfectly, but having to gnaw on the main protein was exhausting. All of the pizza looked old and dead. We weren't interested in trying them, even though our tradition is to have a plain slice while looking at the menu. I guess that's how it explains two tables in front for slices and two small families in back when it's smack dab in the middle of lunch hour on a weekend. I wish them luck and may potentially visit again if I see the reviews here become more positive. read more

So I stop in to get a slice now I know I will take some flack for ordering Hawaiian pizza but I like it I don't like that it was in the oven so long that it felt like day old bread not pizza at all. And as I sat and waited for my two bricks of pizza I noticed that every person picking up had a problem with there order. My advice look elsewhere read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - To long in the oven - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

It's a shame there are different owners.. Not friendly and they could clearly see I wasn't happy. Told the order would be ready in 15 mins, well that turned to 40 minutes. I asked for the pizza well done and this is what the bottom looked like. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - Supposed to be well done - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

Nice chicken salad wraps and very good pizza. Nice service, and nice people. I'll be back.

Tried this place out for the first time- we got Grandma's pizza and wings. Wings were great! Seasoning was Grandma pizza was well seasoned, but needed to be cooked longer. There was a lot of oil on it and it soaked the bottom of the box. It also made the pizza very soggy. Not sure if it was just the Grandma style pizza that we got, that is like that. read more

Miss Tony and John. New owners very nice but food not the same now. Was our place for over 30 years. Went from great to average. Chicken park was best in Edison. read more

Authentic Italian pizza And the guy also sounds super Italian Did not disappoint Pizza is very good read more

When you buy a slice of pizza it's great. Got a medium to go it was awful! Looked like a small it was fat not even rolled out. Just a bad pizza no matter how you slice it! Won't go back. There's also a language barrier read more

I ordered a pizza pie with pepperoni and they gave me half a pie without pepperoni. I mentioned to Tony and he put more pepperoni on the pie. When I got home, I noticed that half of the pie was still without pepperoni. I went back to get a refund. He told me it was a mistake. Then he asked if I understand English. Is that how a customer should be treated? I wouldn't go back. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

It's apparent that there are new owners. The red sauce is much different and definitely NOT better, it's tastes like tomato paste. It's too bad because the food used to be good. Never loved the pizza. The wait staff is absolutely awful and it's obvious that they are NOT trained. We've been 3-4 times now and it's been disappointing each time. We went Saturday night for dinner and received silverware in a paper bag , no napkins (I had to get up and get them for our table) and we had to send one of our dinners back. Our waitress never came by our table to follow up and the other waiter had terrible body odor. Pre-pandemic, we used to dine there twice a week or so but I doubt we'll be going there again. It's too bad since. read more

I heard through one of the postings that there are new owners here. I haven't seen Tony in my last few visits. I don't recognize anybody the staff. They all seem to be Spanish speaking. Pizza still seems good to me. I live 15 miles away but I always come back here since I had an office nearby years ago. Good crisp pizza. I recently tried to thin crust Sicilian. A little greasy but still crispy. White pizza as always was superb. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - White Pizza - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

I had the Veal Parm with Shrimp Parm and Spaghetti. The Veal was bland and had a funny taste to it which might have been from old oil. The Shrimp Parm was also not good. I must admit the spaghetti and sauce was very good. My wife had the Chicken Parm which was just ok! The salad that came with the meal was very skimpy and was disappointing. The bread was the highlight but I didn't come for the bread. The pizza is just average. I know this place has been here for a long time and is in a great location but I will never go back to eat here again. I hate to be so critical but I want people to know when spending your hard earned money you want all your food to be delicious and this place is just not cutting it! read more

We had this restaurant provide us with a spaghetti dinner for 5 people. They did a splendid job! We requested sausage and meatballs, which they layered on the tray of spaghetti. Along with a beautiful garden salad, two types of dressing, two loaves of garlic bread and extra loaves of plain bread. I've always been a huge fan of their meatballs but finally after many years eating here, I had their sausage. The sausage is just as awesome as their meatballs. Thanks Tony's for catering to our needs. Job well done! read more

Stopped in for a quick slice with my boyfriend. He got a slice of chicken parm and a slice of pepperoni and I got a slice of chicken parm and a slice of white. Overall, the pizza is flavorless to be honest. I added salt and pepper to my pizza just to give it some kind of flavor on top of red pepper flakes. I eat a lot of pizza. So maybe I'm just spoiled but I'd much rather go to Ferraro's down the street which has actually really good pizza if not occasionally inconsistent. read more

First time being here and ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. The pizza was ok just a little thin but the chicken tasted good and not enough buffalo flavor. The workers looked bored when we walked in and the atmosphere is comfortable. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Best pizza, awesome stuffed shells, never disappoints. Pastas are great too. Everything is great about Tony's pizza.

Too bad owners changed. Meat balls great,spagettie tasted like CANNED spagettie,salade fresh and nice. Too bad.

I was totally let down. I chose Tony's great things about this place. When I arrived at exactly the time they had said to get there, They had given my pizza to somebody else. The guy then looked at the pies on the oven and gave me someone else's pie. I knew that there was an issue when the box was cold. Sure enough when I went to eat the pizza it was cold as well. The worst part is they are over priced I paid $16 for a cold cheese pizza. No toppings just a plain cheese pizza. Ridiculous. I will never come here again I will never think about coming here again in fact if people ever asked me about Tony's I will tell them to go to dominoes because at least they will get a hot pizza at dominoes. read more

I was meeting up with my uncle for lunch on my last day back in NJ before heading to the airport. He asked what I wanted to eat and even though I already had pizza on this trip I said pizza as I can never get enough of it while I'm back in this part of the country. There is good pizza where I live (surprisingly) but most of it still isn't as good as the pizza on this coast. Tony's seems to be my uncle's go to pizza place for slices. It had been a long time since I'd been. The place still looks the same from what I can remember of it. Honestly I don't really care what it looks like. Is the pizza good? Yes, it is. A plain slice is always my first slice. I always get at least one. Along with that I had a slice with chicken, red sauce and ricotta. I'm a sucker for ricotta on a slice of pizza. This slice was full of chicken. The crust was nice and thin, but not too thin. All in all a very good slice. What else can one say? read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - chicken with ricotta slice and a plain slice - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

If your on Amboy Ave. You want a slice. They are always good . Same guys for decades. read more

Ordered a sub with fries which had large portions and their bean soup reminded me of the way my grandma used to make when I was a little girl, waitresses were super friendly and attentive and the prices were reasonable :) I very much enjoyed my meal! read more

Tony's is 100% the BEST pizza available in this area. Yeah, there's plenty places that serve good pizza, but this place? PERFECTION! I've lived most of my life in the Edison area, but have lived around the country and traveled this country and the world, having had pizza all over the place. What makes Tony's so great is that they serve exactly what one would expect from a pizza joint in the NY metro area. I love all kinds of pizza, but when it comes to Tony's, my favorite is just a plain pie because I can't find one like it anywhere in this area these days. One would think that something as simple as dough, sauce and cheese would be easy, but it is not easy, and it's something they have been doing perfectly for years! The beautiful thin crust, the tangy and slightly sweet sauce, the fresh, nicely portioned cheese on top. A perfect balance of sauce and cheese. It brings me back to the way every pizza place used to be around here, back in the 70's,80's and even some of the 90's. These days there's so many places focused on fancy and crazy toppings, which I all Love, but sometimes you want just a good jersey pizza. I've had pizza throughout Italy and, although one should never compare pizza in Italy to pizza outside of Italy, Tony's is right up there with them when it comes to quality and tradition! I highly recommend eating pizza right away, preferably at the restaurant, so that the steam of the box doesn't take away from the beautifully crispy crust. I'll actually drive home with the top of the box open just to keep it crispy if I order a pie to take home. Their other items are great, but the pizza is AMAZING. Sometimes when I travel I come home craving their pizza, what I call a REAL pizza, because I've had so many horrible ones in my travels. The customer service is ok, and maybe once in a while the older owners may be a little grumpy, but I know from firsthand experience that serving central jersey folk in a restaurant can make ANYONE grumpy, especially if you're around hot ovens all day. My experience with serving the public in restaurants has shown me that I'm surprised there aren't more grumpy restaurant owners out there! Also, hey, it's jersey, come here for the great food but don't expect us to kiss your bottom! After all, it's the food that's important! THANK YOU TONY'S for always providing EXCELLENT food! read more

In 1973 when I lived in Edison I had to drive to South Plainfield to get good Pizza from Tony's. Then they opened this store a couple miles from my house. I live in DC and when driving anywhere near this area I stop for the beat Pizza in NJ. Crust is thin and Edison. The right mix of sauce and cheese. I love this place. No frills, no BS just great Pizza. read more

Tony's Restaurant & Pizza - cars parked in a parking lot - Italian Near Me - Edison, New Jersey

See all

Was in the area and hubby was craving pizza. He went to car to get a mask and I went in alone. I walked in and all three workers stopped and stared the older one gave me the meanest look i immediately felt out of place. They older guys starts complaining about something all the while not looking up. I stood there for a minute and no one greeted or asked me what I wanted until a woman walked behind me and then the older guys says who's next. My husband walked in behind me and whispered to me it smelled like mop water, I told him I changed my mind and we left. I should have figured something was wrong for a large place to be practically empty during lunch hour on a Saturday. Didn't buy anything but based on some other reviews I didn't miss much. read more

PROS: This is a very nice pizzeria! Their place is half restaurant half pizzeria. The menu has a lot on it and the prices are great! The staff is very nice to you and are quick with your meal. The pizza that I ordered tasted great and the place was very clean. CONS: The bathroom was a little beaten up and the restaurant was cramped. OVERALL: This place is great to eat at! This is one of the greater pizza places around. Don't worry, there's enough parking for everybody in the shopping centers lot. read more

We live locally and have had the pizza a few times and it's a pretty good pie for the neighborhood but my god is the service awful. It always seems to be an inconvenience that you're there paying them for your pizza. the older gentleman usually tosses your card at you and doesn't say anything even when you say thank you. It's not a pleasant experience even though the pizza is good I don't think we'll return. read more

Been here twice now for slices. Both times pizza not fresh. Guy behind the counter, seem like the owner or something... Was berating one of his employees about something in Italian. This guy has no customer service etiquette either. Would not recommend and will not return. read more

Tony's is the best Pizza, and Italian food around. I've eaten all over the area, and there are a few places that are very good. But Tony's is my favorite, and if you love Italian food, and Pizza, you have to try it. Always great Specials, and service! Large meals for a very good price! You get antipasto salad, warm Italian bread! Full Italian menu. Large dining room. Try it! read more

Very good Italian food and pizza at a moderate price. The cheese steaks are very tasty and delicious.

Great pizza. One of the best in the neighborhood. Definitely would recommend if you want some good pizza close by.

Terrible customer service. Didn't great me as a customer. Through my debit card at me as well has didn't say have a nice day or say thank you . Terrible service if I could give a 0 star I would read more

Tony's has a solid regular pie, good sauce, cheese, etc. However, I ventured out yesterday and ordered a Margherita pie. Let's just say it was not their best, sauce was bland, fresh tomatoes under the cheese? That's not a traditional Margherita. I was very disappointed. Definitely not ordering that again. Listen, if you're looking for a good regular pie, Tony's is the place. Going forward I will not be ordering any specialty pies. Tony's, please get a better Margherita pie! I promise I'll come back. read more

Always consistent quality in pizza & waitress always pleasant ! Great customer service Better than La Rosa in Metuchen for customer service & food is better Plates are always clean read more

The service is fantastic. The waitress Andrea is top notch. She's very friendly and always makes sure you have everything you need. The food is fantastic as well read more