Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tricia's Cafe

    3.8 (142 reviews)
    ModerateCafes, Salad, American
    Closed • 1:30 pm - 9:30 PM

    Order Tricia's Cafe Takeout or Delivery

    Tricia's Cafe Photos

    TRICIA'S CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Tricia's Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Menu
    Asa L.

    OVERALL/WHAT TO KNOW: -Really great Cajun-inspired sandwiches! -Seems like a great, laid-back place to hang out and have lunch (or any meal) with friends -Will definitely go back if I'm in the area! ARRIVAL: -Got to-go orders from here twice in the same week during my lunch break around 3pm. -It was largely empty, there were maybe 2 other people there. -It doesn't look like much from the outside, but it was one of the closest places to my work and I thought the menu looked good so I gave it a shot and am glad I did. FOOD/DRINK: -I had the Blackjack Chicken Poboy and the Bogey chicken sandwich. -Both sandwiches were great. Chicken was expertly prepared: not too dry, not too charred (on the blackjack sandwich), not greasy from being fried (on the bogey sandwich), delicious seasoning. -All the ingredients tasted fresh and high quality, including the seeded rolls. More than that, all the ingredients worked really well together. The sauce on each sandwich complimented each preparation of chicken perfectly. The lettuce and tomato were not thrown on incidentally either (as they often are with sandwiches). They rounded out the flavors and textures in a way where the sandwich would not have been nearly as good without them. -I was tempted to get the fries, but I thought the sandwiches were an ideal lunch option on their own: filling, fair portions, great price for the quality, not too heavy, and delicious. SERVICE: -At both visits, there was a friendly man behind the bar that took my order and promptly brought me my food when it was ready. ATMOSPHERE/LAYOUT: -The vibe is of a laid-back sports bar combined with a diner. There is tons of vintage sports memorabilia on the walls and a large tv behind the bar. There are more tables and booths than bar space or high tops, which is what makes it feel a bit more like a diner.

    Jenn S.

    Owned and operated by one family for over 20 years. The restaurant is named after the Matriarch of the family as her son proudly said so. I like that family are all involved in every aspect of the business. Decor is pretty and clean and totally inviting for young and old. The prices were very reasonable and portions very generous. Crab cake sandwich has an abundant amount of crab meat and seasoned simple with old bay and then lightly coated on breadcrumbs. The Philly cheese steak sandwich was tender and flavorful with large slices of steak. I'm usualy not a come slaw eater when it just comes complimentary on the side but theirs is totally home made and I could vats of just that! Ample parking and convenient to get to, I will definitely be back!

    Cheeseburger with bleu cheese
    Tony C.

    Excellent decor and vibe. Very friendly staff. Booths are small and cramped making eating with four people difficult. Fries were very tasty

    Fish and chips w seasoned fries tartar and a side of creole mayo
    Jennifer S.

    Took my Mom for dinner tonight and it definitely did not disappoint!!! In fact, it was fabulous and we really enjoyed our entire experience... Friendly and warm staff, cool decor and atmosphere...and the food was delicious! Ordered coconut shrimp and bourbon shrimp for apps...both were really well prepared... Coconut shrimp had a fresh toasted coconut flavor and was paired w a yummy orange marmalade! Bourbon shrimp were sticky sweet and slightly tangy cooked w onions and bursted w flavor! Mom and I both had the fish and chips for our entrees... 3 nice cod filets beer battered and so crispy on the outside while the inside boasted tender, fresh and delicate cod! Served w fries (I chose seasoned and Mom had steak fries), tartar, lemon, and coleslaw (this was the only thing I didn't care for, but my Dad makes the best slaw so nothing usually compares). Oh, and get a side of the creole Mayo to dip ANYTHING in it...so tasty!!! Used it for my fries and fish a little too! Overall, a lovely place to frequent and a staple I will happily add onto my go to spot list! If you've never been you need to go! P.S. Their prices are incomparable to most Babylon restaurants...dinner with a 25% tip (and the 4% cc service charge) was only $65! We didn't drink, but for 2 apps, 2 entrees (with leftovers) and an Ice-T, I think this is a very good price point for the quality of food and service we received.

    Mixed
    Mercedes C.

    Caught Tricia's after a quick detour and one thing led to another and landed in Babylon Village looking for the nearest gas station after we left Robert Moses Beach- before heading home. Time-wise, it was cutting right into our Dinner and for us, Tricia's was a quick come-by. Pub-ish style, some Bar seating, Booths and smaller tables. Place may not be spacious but for the short time we were there, Tricia's was comfy. Baseball posters and old-fashioned tchotchkes make up the style here- with an excellent Music mix of Aretha, Cat Stevens and Dion. Blackened Fish Tacos were good and replete with Fish. Hubby's Crab Cakes were also good and commented on the wonderful lump crab. Waters weren't filled right away- and to me, that bit of attention- was needed, but service was pleasant and rounding it out with a 3+1/2. The neat thing about Tricia's was- food was good and price was right for a quick bite.

    Main menu
    Josh H.

    Good menu, great prices. Food was better than average bar food. Fried clams were ok, sweet potato fries were a little thin and oily, but good. Didn't need a dusting of sugar! My daughter liked the burger. I would go back and try other items! Thanks!

    Free pickles!
    Doug W.

    This is a local love for sure! It's official. I wish I could say I've been dining here for years, but sadly I've overlooked this gem for some time. Not so sadly though, I will be back soon and often. Tricia's has the absolute best burger deal, it was cooked perfectly medium rare, seasoned wonderfully, and treated fantastic! What I mean to say is it was such a quality burger, dressed with crispy curly bacon and a Cajun aioli, Swiss cheese all in an awesome bun and quick grilled to perfection. This was a supreme treat, not only is this an amazing burger it's an awesome deal! For $10 you can choose any of their 8oz burgers and five shrimp any way you want them. TEN "DOLL-HAIRS!" Man what a great day I had here at Tricia's. I'm upset I haven't been sooner, I've always wanted to check them out and just hesitated every time. The menu looks dope with all their poboys and specials, I can't wait to explore and indulge. Our server was a cool dude; super friendly and helpful, always making sure we were well taken care of. A fat juicy perfectly cooked burger, 5 shrimp, the most amazing sweet potato fries and a buffalo chicken and bacon sandwich all for under 23 bucks!? Good coleslaw came with the sandwiches and a bowl of free pickles for us to share was a nice touch as well. It's these kind of local dive bar cafe joints that keep pulling at our heart strings and filling up our bellies for years to come. Truly an awesome day all thanks to this awesome meal at a great price. Wait, I don't feel I conveyed how great these sweet potato fries were... take the best ones youve had and throw them out, these were so much betterererer; Yeah I said betterererer; they were super fresh, super crispy, and super melt in your mouth fantastic. I don't even do sweet potato fries much anymore and I'm craving more of these bad boys. The maple syrup on the side... that could be helped out, I'd prefer less of a sticky sweet heart attack and more of a maple mustard mayo jobby, but the cinnamon and brown sugar fries were bomb af. Please visit and leave your pretension at home.

    Complimentary pickles!
    Shannon K.

    This place is to die for! I'm newer to the food scene in Babylon Village but I already know this is a staple for me. It's more of a hole in the wall type of restaurant and has a homey, vintage feel to it. It was pretty dead when I came on a Sunday afternoon so service was quick. The waiter was really nice and seemed happy to serve us. While you're waiting for your food, they offer complimentary pickles and coleslaw. What a nice touch! As for the food- 5 stars all the way. I ordered the buffalo tender sandwich, which was pieces of fried chicken topped with bacon, bleu cheese, and buffalo sauce on Italian bread. OMG so good. If you like a lot of buffalo sauce make sure you order extra and slather it on your sandwich. I ordered sweet potato fries for the side which were perfectly seasoned and crispy. It was served with a cinnamon maple syrup type dip. Very sweet but still delicious. Overall this place is awesome. I'm looking forward to coming back and trying more items from the menu. It definitely shows that they really care about your food and your experience here which is always a plus!

    Creole Burger

    See all

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Karen H.
    12
    81
    19

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rita J.
    3
    96
    128

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    A hidden gem of Babylon Village. Great for a burger and fries. Limited drink options.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of A N.
    0
    11
    0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of IK I.
    0
    115
    0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Tricia's Cafe

    You might also consider

    Jack Jack's Coffee House - Inside

    Jack Jack's Coffee House

    3.8(188 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    •$

    Jack Jack's is a cute little spot for coffee and people watching. It's a family and dog-friendly…read morecafé. The avocado toast is delicious.

    Updated Review: February 28, 2026 I came back to Jack Jack's…read moreafter my original review in 2016. I was a little hesitant after my first experience but they were listed in my LI Cafe Passport book I got for Christmas and I want to go to all the spots in that book even if I'm revisiting. My second experience was much better so I'm upping my review to 4 stars. The staff was nicer this time. I opted for a pour over because that's what the book recommended and I got the cherry vanilla latte as well with half and half. I was able to sit in the coffee shop because I had dropped my son off at a birthday party and had a little time before I picked him up. I caught up on watching Friday Night Smackdown before elimination chamber with headphones on of course so I wouldn't disturb other people and I finished a book I was reading. The seating was nice, an optional variety of different kinds of seats and lots of seating. The latte was very smooth, you could definitely taste the coffee more in the pour over but that was good, the coffee went down nicely, not a lot of bitterness. So Jack Jack's redeemed themselves in my eyes almost ten years after my first review and I would be able to recommend going to them. Babylon Bean will still be my favorite coffee shop in Babylon but both of them are nice to visit. Original Review: March 22, 2016 I came here after picking up my jacket from the dry cleaners. I didn't like it very much at all and am happy to say my heart and my business will continue to go to the Babylon Bean! The baristas did not seem happy at all when they helped me. They weren't rude but they weren't sweet or nice either. I chose a brownie to eat and got a cup of regular coffee. The coffee was okay, not horrid but for sure not great. The brownie was disgusting. I couldn't eat the whole thing ended up throwing it on the ground for the birds to eat. This place also has a hipster vibe, sometimes I can dig it but sometimes I can't. So in my personal experience if the babylon bean and this place had a throw down I would always favor the bean!

    Photos
    Jack Jack's Coffee House - Front.

    Front.

    Jack Jack's Coffee House
    Jack Jack's Coffee House

    See all

    Pharmarista

    Pharmarista

    4.6(11 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    Absolutely love this place. Such a unique idea having a great coffee shop right inside a local…read morepharmacy, and you can tell there is genuine care behind what they're doing. The coffee was excellent, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the service made it feel like more than just a place to grab a cup and go. What stood out to me most was the sense that this business is built around serving people and the community. As a Christian, I always appreciate coming across businesses where faith seems to be reflected not only in words, but in the way people are treated. It reminded me of Colossians 3:23: "Whatever you do, work at it with all your heart, as working for the Lord." Great coffee, great people, and a business I'm happy to support. May God continue to bless this place and the people behind it!

    Almost walked right past on my way to the nail salon thinking it was just a pharmacy. I had to stop…read moreand do a double take because of the coffee sign. Luckily I was early so I made a u-turn and stopped to try the coffee here. In fall spirit I had to try the pumpkin-spice dirty chai. I was asked if regular milk was okay and was so thankful because I almost forgot that I was lactose intolerant. They have several milk substitutions including macadamia, oat, almond and soy. After paying I was asked if I wanted a single or double shot. Usually coffee shops charge by the shot so I went with the double. Honestly, im not a true pumpkin spice fanatic so I liked that the pumpkin spice flavor wasn't overpowering. It was the perfect mix of pumpkin and chai flavors for me. I started chatting with the barista/pharmacist and he let me know that they will be switching out the specials soon. I will definitely be back to try the next seasonal flavors.

    Photos
    Pharmarista
    Pharmarista
    Pharmarista

    See all

    Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery - Strawberry matcha

    Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery

    4.5(77 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    •$$

    Fantastic food, great service, and incredibly creative menu options executed really well. Our…read moreserver was passionate about everything they had and made great recommendations. We ordered the Captain Corn & The Swine French Toast and Noemi's Pupusas Clásicas. Both were excellent, but the French toast was a standout. Not overly sweet, the cinnamon paired incredibly well with the pork and the cornbread, and the kernels of corn baked in were a nice touch. Love to see a creative menu like this. So many interesting options, it was hard to choose. The space is beautiful with great natural light from the high ceilings. If you find it a little loud, they have some high tops near the bar that are quieter and more private. We'll be back.

    Food 2/5. We got the Haechi Scramble and the Lean Back Omelette Both were tasty, which makes the…read morerest more annoying. The haechi had some kind pancake underneath which was soggy. Food took about 30 minutes to come out, and we were literally the only ones in the place. My wife had digestion issues after eating. Also, the coffee cups are very small. We needed about 3 refills instead of 1 which we would normally get. Service 4/5. Our server was attentive, friendly, walked us through the menu without being pushy. He checked on us. Ambiance 2/5. Cozy spot, good music playing. But the chairs are metal with zero cushion, and there's a bar across the back of the chair that digs right into your back if you lean back at all, so you end up sitting forward the whole meal. First floor flooring looked dated too. Cleanliness 3/5. Floor on the first level wasn't that clean. Given the digestion issues afterward, makes you wonder what's going on back in the kitchen. Bathroom was fine though, passed a quick swipe test. Parking 3/5. There's lots nearby but it's a bit of a walk, and you cross a street that gets busy. Street parking exists if you can find a meter. Value 2/5. $50 with tip for two people. For the wait, the stomach issues, and those chairs, that felt like too much. Overall 2/5. Service was solid but it couldn't make up for the food problems and how uncomfortable the seating was. Not going back.

    Photos
    Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery - Upstairs

    Upstairs

    Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery
    Millie's Mimosa House & Eatery - Banana Caramel Latte

    See all

    Banana Caramel Latte

    Sergi Coffee & Roast - The counter area

    Sergi Coffee & Roast

    4.3(82 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    •$$

    Cute little coffee shop right off of sunrise highway. From the outside it looks like an old shop or…read morehouse but once you walk inside its a cute coffee shop. There are a few tables inside for your to sit and enjoy your drink and/or food. Its very home inside but also a little dark. The staff was friendly and answered all the questions I had when trying to figure out my drink order. I ended up getting the iced Strawberry shortcake latte with oatmilk.. it was soooo delicious. It was a perfect balance of sweetness and coffee and it did have a slight taste of strawberry shortcake. They also have food options that I didnt try but all looked good. Pastries, sandwiches and to-go boxes. If your passing by, definitely stop by and try a latte!

    I've been here on one other occasion and couldn't remember how my experience was so when I was in…read morethe area I needed my coffee fixed. I decided to stop in. I didn't end up not purchasing anything because at the register I asked her if there was any milk included in the churro cold brew, which was one of the spring specials. She rolled her eyes at me and said how else would I make the cream without milk. I'm lactose intolerant so this is why I was concerned. for her to be rude and talk to me that way i decided to leave without purchasing . I make my own cold foam with oat milk so I know that it's possible which is why I asked.

    Photos
    Sergi Coffee & Roast - Spinach Pinwheel 3-7-2026

    Spinach Pinwheel 3-7-2026

    Sergi Coffee & Roast - Menu

    Menu

    Sergi Coffee & Roast - Iced brown sugar cinnamon latte | @copenhangry

    See all

    Iced brown sugar cinnamon latte | @copenhangry

    Brownstones Coffee West Islip - Modified breakfast bowl

    Brownstones Coffee West Islip

    4.2(706 reviews)
    1.4 mi
    •$$

    I have learned to go after typical breakfast time because it is so packed! The food is delicious…read moreand I like to try different meals. You cannot go wrong with anything you choose! Yummy! Rated 5 stars!

    First time at Brownstone, greeted by a big jazz mural on the wall, the vibe is as old fashioned as…read moreyou can get right off the bat. In no rush on this beautiful morning, so I figured I'd order the biggest plate I could've ordered and just soak the vibe in, appropriately called The Feast with a glass of apple juice. So they came in with the wrong order, so what? At least they quickly got it fixed and brought out my real order, no need to throw a fit this early in the morning. Anyhow, as for the meal itself, they're not trying to reinvent the wheel and that is perfectly fine, really just came for the vibes. The meal was satisfyingly traditional overall. Is it worth going back to though? Unfortunately no, because there are better sit down breakfast spots on the island, wasn't really worth the distance, in my opinion. Some minor complaints are that coffee drinks weren't refilled and syrup cost extra by like ¢.75, but they're really minor, nothing to really fuss about, personally though I liked it but it was worth it for the one time for the vibe alone. I would recommend only if you're close to the place.

    Photos
    Brownstones Coffee West Islip - View from the booth facing the entrance. Is the Prospect Jazz Club real? Bonus points if so.

    View from the booth facing the entrance. Is the Prospect Jazz Club real? Bonus points if so.

    Brownstones Coffee West Islip - Eggs and hash

    Eggs and hash

    Brownstones Coffee West Islip - Outdoor (New establishment)

    See all

    Outdoor (New establishment)

    Tricia's Cafe - cafes - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...