This place was literally so good. They have gluten free cauliflower crust that was actually great, the pepperoni is SOOOO GOOD and even the ranch is good too. I like the vibes and it wasn't too busy on a Saturday night at 6:30. Our server was funny and cool too. We will definitely be coming back FYI the 20" pizza is ACTUALLY gigantic read more

See all

This place came highly recommended rated for the Tuscaloosa area, so we had to try it for sure. Simple spot that looks like it took over for an older restaurant. They had a nice selection of pizza but the Detroit style caught my eye. We were not expecting this kind of quality in Tuscaloosa. The crust was perfectly golden and the toppings were very fresh. Additionally we had the homemade tiramisu for dessert. Very delicious. Service was on point from our young waitress. read more

See all

Absolute fire pizza. I love trying pizza in different towns and this is some of the best pizza I've ever had, truly. Next time I want to try the pan, but the New York style was really good. I went there because of the reviews but it was even better than I expected. read more

Very expensive (overpriced) but food was good. Would recommend if you're looking for a good bite to eat, but if you are on a budget, I would not recommend going here. Almost $50 for a pizza that only fed two people. read more

Don't be scared off by the rough picnic tables out front. This is a great little pizza place. The young woman who served us was very friendly and very helpful. She was on point with the food, refills and everything we needed. The salads were fresh tasting and the pizza was delicious. Definitely worth a visit! read more

See all

As someone from the New York/New Haven area, I know my way around pizza. TuscNY is the only pizza I've had in this area that comes close to what I love. There's a lot of very mediocre pizza here. Go to TuscNY -- but call first; they're not always open when they say they'll be. read more

Great Pizza. Loved the crust and tons of pepperoni. A little pricey but excellent pizza.

Great pizza. I tried the 20 inch pep. First time having it after purchasing it many times for my kids. Now I'll be jealous every time in the future! Staff was welcoming and friendly as soon as I walked in the door. The restaurant is modern and open and looks like a great place to spend an evening with family and friends. See you soon. read more

TuscNY Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tuscaloosa, Alabama

First time in Alabama and all items were not delivered. I was told this was the place to order from and I feel scammed. They should have sent the rest of the food instead of the refund. Not happy. Even gave the driver a $20 tip. Unbelievable read more

I have been wanting to try this restaurant for a while, and our schedules just don't line up. Today, I was in Northport and it was Friday, so I knew IMMEDIATELY where I was going for lunch. We ordered the Mama Mia Detroit style pizza, Caesar salad, pasta with tomato basil sauce, and brought some pistachio cheesecake and tiramisu home with us. First...I love a good thick Detroit style pizza. I've watched the Facebook videos of the garlic confit, and knew I had to try this pizza. The crust is crispy, yet super airy and pillowy. The garlic confit is to die for. I could have eaten it with a spoon! Paired with the sauce, roasted garlic cloves (because we all need more garlic), and the sliced meatballs, this pizza is the perfect bite. Do you want amazing pizza, with a laid back atmosphere, look no further. read more

See all

Pizza was ok or average. I live out of state so maybe I have better pizza places outside of this community. Local students have said no good pizza places so just not the best area for great pizza I guess. read more

Food was awesome! Our server was attentive and nice also! The pizza was humongous and definitely enough for 3 people. Definitely will be back for additional desserts. read more

See all

There is something iconic about a New York slice. No disrespect to other pizzas, but it is what I grew up on and after searching for the past 20 years, I've finally found it right here in Tuscaloosa. TuscNY Pizza has the taste, texture, and foldability of a perfect NY slice. We ordered a large cheese because there are no toppings to mask the taste. It was truly perfection, we shook our heads the whole time we ate not believing we'd finally found the taste of Little Italy in a clean, cute Alabama pizzeria. We also ordered cheese bread loaded with garlic and it was delicious. The dough was perfection and could have been sold as its own product. Topped off with two wonderful cannolis we were already discussing our next trip. Did I mention we got the large cheese and it was so big we had enough leftovers for the kids at home. Reheated in the oven at 375 for 10 minutes it was as fantastic as when it was fresh out of the oven. TuscNY fed my soul not just my stomach. I can't recommend it enough. Thank you, Josh and Dalton. read more

Such a yummy pizza spot! Can't wait to go back and try their desserts too. Everything was delicious and the service was perfect. Happy to find a local pizza place that does a good NY pizza. Music was also a good mix of 90s hits. read more

See all

Being from the northeast I can say that this pizza is great! My favorite is the mushroom with fresh ricotta dollops on top! Would definitely recommend this over any other pizza place in town! read more

Let me preface this by saying that: I. I (the guy) do not enjoy pizza. I really don't care for pizza unless it has apples, cinnamon, and sugar on it. AND II. I've been to Sicily and Rome and I know fresh pizza! So here's how we ended up here: After me and my wonderful grudgingly watched a terrible "comedy" movie about pizza on Tubi (we know ), we had a craving for pizza! We searched around and found this place that had pretty high ratings already so we went. The place was packed and had a fresh pizzeria odor in it (already a plus). The hostess asked if we'd like to dine at the bar since there was only us two and we agreed. As soon as we sat down, our waiter (sorry I forgot his name but I'll edit it when I find the receipt) was attentive, considerate, and overall ON IT! Our waiter asked if we'd like to start off with any drinks as they had a $2 off special going on. uh, sí señor. I (Jaguar) had a lemon drop martini while my wonderful had a mule. Yes, they were delicious but what made them great was this one simple thing most restaurants fail to do consistently: they put an adequate amount of alcohol in it! More alcohol = more happy patron = more of our mulah going into patronizer's pockets, so thanks for the great drinks! We started with an appetizer of the fried ravioli and it's the greatest fried ravioli we've ever had in our short lives. The marinara sauce was FRESH. We then ordered our pizzas and they came out picture perfect and with perfect flavor and fresh crust. Anyway I'm about to eat the leftovers (I stole her's) and go to bed happy. We will be back! read more

Placed an order at 6:24 pm for a pizza to be picked up at 7:15. My husband, waiting and waiting, only to be told at 8:10 that they burned the pizza, but we could wait for them to make a new one. Absolutely terrible customer service. Would give 0 stars if that was an option. read more

Barrett literally saved me the person working the register ignored my allergies but Barrett remember me as a reoccurring customer and saved me. I couldn't be happier with the service here and the memory of the workers. Thank you for having caring members like Barrett. read more

The BEST Pizza in Tuscaloosa... Hands Down. Regular crust is awesome and the Sicilian crust is a must try! Always great service from Lauren as well. read more

TuscNY Pizza - Regular Crust Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tuscaloosa, Alabama

Wonderful! Our server was very helpful and always able to find! He recommended some delicious options but we decided to get the Sausage onion and pepper's pizza. I will say it with a little difficult to pick up so ask for a fork. But very flavourful and I can't wait to try another pizza! read more

See all

Several suggested this place so I had it on my bucket list. We finally tried it and got 3 small pizzas and a small salad. The salad dressing was good.The crusts on all 3 were thin. Not salty and had a good taste. The margarita one was pretty bland. Not much cheese. The sauce was good. The spicy one with sausage was eh. The sausage wasn't bad but it was the pizza was eh. The honey pepperoni one was the best one. The biggest disappointment was there was no bartender so they we couldn't get the "spritzer" that was advertised on a sign. Not sure if this was a Sunday thing or staffing issue. We also noticed that despite the sign advertising pizza and pasta there was very very little pasta offered on the menu. The canolli looked good but we didn't get it. It's worth a try, you may love it but for people that eat pizza too frequently we found it average. read more

Great food and service. The lunch special is my favorite. 2 pieces of pizza and a drink. Reasonable prices

Rock solid pizza. Multiple types to choose from. It's pretty much pizza only with only a couple of other choices which is a bit disappointing. Still, this is a really good pizza place with people who clearly want to provide great food and service. When we are in Tuscaloosa, it's a go to spot for us. read more

I ordered a 20-inch cheese pizza with extra cheese. The pizza was good but greasy. This NY-style pizza had approximately eight slices. I was hungry and ate a slice when I got in the car. read more

TuscNY Pizza - 20-inch Cheese pizza with extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Tuscaloosa, Alabama

Just got my carry out pizza order. No problem with the pizza, it was "okay". My complaint is $45 charge for a large cheese pizza with half sausage and mushrooms. Seriously? I've never had a $45 pizza, but this was nothing special. All I can say is the menu photos on Yelp are wrong (I was expecting $28). Maybe surge pricing because it's a game weekend? I won't be back. It was average at best. read more

I was born in northern New Jersey, grew up in upstate NY and have spent a lot of time traveling this country. This pizza is one of the best pie's I have ever had. Tuscaloosa is lucky to have this establishment here. Get a cannoli! read more

Horrible service, good pizza, like really really really really really really really shitty service

Staff is friendly. Pizza was ok after they redid. The first pizza was burned and they still served it to us. Cannoli taste was not what I'm used to. Cheesecake was okay. Watch out for the large pothole in the parking lot and possibly hitting your bumper on the asphalt when exiting onto the street. read more

Food is ok but we paid $80 for 1 cheese pizza, 1 pepperoni pizza and 2 cannolies. In addition, they give you a pick up time, ours was 1:15 after we ordered and it wasn't done when we arrived. Update: after being told my pizza was 12 minutes late and they didn't want me as a customer, I reviewed my text messages with my wife. At 7:46 I texted her that the pizzas were coming out. Pizzas were delivered to me at 7:50. So they were :35 minutes late. read more

We love this place. Went there for J's bday last year. Great ambiance and vibrant waiters. Sadly, our recent attempts to go have proven to be difficult. Are you guys still even open? Haven't been all summer. Where have you gone TUSCNY...... read more

I really loved my pizza! But it was overpriced and the soft drinks were served in cans! If they get that fixed it will be a great place!

The pizza was so good I forgot to get a picture. The Detroit style Gold Standard amazing. We also had their special tonight which was a bacon chicken ranch with their fresh pesto. We asked for some of their fresh pickled jalapeños to add to our slices. Just enough heat for my palate. People in Tuscaloosa don't sleep on this place. read more

TuscNY Pizza - We brought the dessert home. - Pizza Near Me - Tuscaloosa, Alabama

The pizza is good. We've ate here twice. Once inside and once to go. You can feel the love in the pies. I'll give them that. Im a Jersey girl... so I grew up on Mom and Pop shop pizza, in the North East... it def has that feelS Ingredients and toppings are super fresh. The sauce... it's a little bitter for my taste... BUT, that could come down to tomatoes... not the best time of the year. And if sauce is home made, as I suspect... that could be it. It will stay in our rotation... maybe i'll try a white pizza! I wish we could try it more often... but prices are a bit high. ( Another thing that can't really be helped if your using good quality ingredients). We also had the cheesecake.. which was good. And I was super excited about cannoli! They were good.. but soggy. And had a M&M on each end? If I could make a suggestion... fill the cannoli with cream when it's ordered so the shell stays crisp... and keep a bowl of slivered toasted almonds or mini choco chips to dip the ends in... All in all. I'm impressed. read more

The pizza is great and closest to NY pizza I could find. The service is good and everyone is really friendly. It gets pretty busy and the restaurant is relatively small. But the food is great! read more

Crispy crust, savory sauce, delicious pepperoni all married together made the perfect pie for my pallet. The desserts looked delectable and the salads fresh and green. We will be returning for more pies from this spot!! read more

I'm only giving four stars bc Yelp will probably take down a five star review. This is seriously great pizza, deserving of five stars. The Detroit and Sicilian pizzas have thick crusts, but it's not greasy at all like a deep dish pizza. The quality is great. I've only done takeout, so idk how the table service is but Tuscny will definitely be in the regular rotation for takeout. read more

Great NY style pizza! Looking forward to eating in and hopefully delivery soon. They have a limited beer selection, but I imagine it might expand over time (sadly no IPAs). read more

Man loves pizza, I saw what he said to Dave Port iy, and honestly he's right. TuscNY is a bit pricey, but you ABSOLUTELY get the bang for your buck. It is understandable why it was not reviewed by Barstool (a little bit out of the way) but it is AMAZING pizza cooked with heart and passion. read more

Don't close for another hour but won't take orders. If you can't take a order and get a pizza out in an hour you need to quit.

Amazing pizza, be it NY thin/Sicilian or Detroit style. 5 stars for the food. Insanely priced, and yeah they only use premium ingredients so I get the up-charge. Just really hope it's sustainable in a tertiary market. read more