Why aren't there six stars? Tonight I couldn't decide between the lasagna and one other menu item so I asked the delightful young lady behind the counter with the terrific smile and cheekbones for her suggestion, and that was the lasagna. I have paid over twice the amount I was charged at 'Nice' Italian restaurants for lasagna but what I enjoyed from Two Bros' was more than twice as good. I was raised in Italian family so I think I can be a fair judge. The only problem now will be to resist going there once a week for an order. And the bread that was included was much better than the average "garlic bread" that's slathered with some yellow grease, garlic salt and paprika. Theirs was a nice and quite authentic dinner roll. So yeah, 6 stars. read more

It was good food. That being said, it's getting 4 stars over 5 because I specifically asked if they had a single serving of like garlic bread with the ziti I ordered and they said no, but they had garlic Knots I could purchase. Then when I got my order thy brought our garlic bread! ‍. So I paid almost $10 for garlic knots when I didn't have to. But other than that, it was actually good! My husband and daughter got the pizza slices deal (Good Deal). I'd come back... I just wouldn't order the extra bread again. read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

It was my first time going here and I wasn't sure what to expect. The service was great. The restaurant was clean and small. The food was just okay. The pizza was fresh but it lacked flavor. The dough was bland and a bit thicker than I expected. I personally wouldn't go back but I do know a lot of people like it so I'd recommend trying them out. read more

See all

We have Celiac- and finding good gluten free places is usually a challenge.... they were extra careful- And Knowledgeable the pepperoni has bread crumbs in it!! so we had the salami.... but the ranch is GF and the GF pizza is very thin... the ingredients were fresh and the pizza was so hot and cheesy read more

Good little local pizza restaurant in the Creekside Market Place. We ordered online and picked up. I think we got a large, half pepperoni/sausage and other half vegetarian for our non meat eaters. The pizza came out hot, it was a good size, very affordable. Fresh ingredients. The crust was soft and pillowy. I didn't mind that kind of crust, my husband prefers the thinner crust and hard crust, although he doesn't eat the crust anyways. The place was clean, had some tables and some diners. Located in a busy plaza. Overall, not too bad. read more

See all

Got the vegetarian pizza and I was so surprised at how many olives came on it. I love olives on my pizza but I think this was a bit too much for my liking. It was still tasty though. The crust was soft with a slight crisp. I actually ate some of the crust which says a lot for me. The middle of the pizza however did get a little too soft and moist which led to a little bit of a soggy bite. read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Vegetarian - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

Highly recommend. Great food. Chicken Parmesan Sandwich was excellent. Calzones were super tasty. Worth trying!!

Easily the best pizza in town. I came in randomly one night, an hour before closing, after a hard gym sesh, looking for a good cheat snack, after days of salads and carrots and eggs finally broke me. Walked in and was greeted immediately, solid start, and always a great sign. Nice and cozy atmosphere, brick-walls like you're in brick oven, and the smell of "delicious". One of a few local spots that sell pizza by the slice, and this is what got my foot in the door in the first place. When I walk into a new pizza joint, the first thing I look for are the single slices still left on the display. All the pizzas were quarter or half-circles, which lets you know that the place you're in is pushing some serious pie. The other local spots I've visited up until now had entire pizzas displayed, barely even touched and begging to be sold, but here, in front of me, was a whole medley of different and delicious slices. They all looked delicious, and my choice was not an easy one. In the end, I settled with the cheese, a solid baseline to judge a pizza shop from. I knew it just looking at it, but from the first bite, I knew I found my main pizza spot, and one to share with friends and family. This place has nailed the art of pizza, without a doubt. Sauce was the perfect blend of sweet and acidic, the bottom was perfectly crisped, and the cheese was greasy enough to know it's quality, but not enough to ruin your morning. Was helped by Stefano both times I went in this week, super chill guy who goes out of his way to look out for all the customers and makes sure your experience there is a good one. Fire pizza, reasonably priced, and great hospitality. My experiences here this week have cemented this spot as my go-to pizza spot. For my diet's sake, I wish I never stepped foot in here, but only because now, whenever I'll leave the gym, I'll know that the best pizza in town is right down the street. read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Perfectly greased, self-seasoned. Couldn't wait to take a picture before taking a bite. - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

See all

Wow. Just, wow. Two Brothers Pizza is the most authentic Italian food I have ever had. From the moment you walk in, you know you're in for a treat. Their baked ziti pasta is out of this world--the sauce (or as they call it, gravy) is unbelievably rich and flavorful. And don't even get me started on the cheese ravioli. The raviolis are so fresh and the gravy is a total home run. The pizza is also flawless. Honestly, there is nothing to complain about here. I also have to shout out their garlic bread--it's absolutely to die for. The owner is a true gem, very humble and grateful. I told him how amazing the food was, and he just bowed and said "thank you, bro." You can tell he truly loves what he does. Keep up the great work, Two Brothers! I wish you all the success in the world. read more

My favorite Two brothers. I've eaten at Two bros from Italy since I've been in grade school at their original location in Oceanside. Fast forward 25+ years and I still have nothing but compliments to them and the great food they put out. Some locations are better than others, as I've been to them all. But I'd have to say the San Marcos location is the best of them in my little opinion. Appreciation! read more

We ordered their baked ziti and spaghetti with meat sauce. Both dishes were very good with large portions. A great value for all you receive. The service was good and the food was ready before the promised time. read more

Went here on a recommendation from a close friend...and after trying Two Brothers From Italy we're still best friends!!! Food from Italy has become so popular these days and the Two Brothers From Italy really has reason to increase the love of Italian food. Service is friendly and helpful. We ate in and food was delivered promptly with the food piping hot!!! The dining area was cozy with the pizza parlor atmosphere. You can tell a lot about an Italian restaurant by two touchstones: a deluxe pizza and lasagna. I had the Two Brothers Deluxe Pizza. Crust was soft and crispy at the same time. Perfect balance of meat to cheese to vegetables ratio. Delicious!!! My partner in crime tried the Lasagna. Very hefty and oozy with cheese and a great meat marinara sauce. Did not disappoint. We finished our Italian meal with...a cannoli!!! Creamy and delicious. A definite favorite to go back to in San Marcos. Ps. Again, the leftovers are even better the next day!!! The tells you about the quality of ingredients to me!!! read more

See all

Man what happened to this place! The pizza used to mediocre at best, probably about 3 stars, I recently retried it and absolutely hated it! I don't know if they changed the recipe or something, but the pizza was so bad! 1 star, Do better. read more

Service was great.. pizza i give it a 2 out of 5.. im not sure what it was. But you know when you are really hungry and everything is good....Well i was really hungry and this wasn't good. Disappointed. I should I went to in n out. Great service though read more

omfg!!!! this is the ultimate pizza pasta calzone sub calzone spot!!! i dare you to try the paolo sub! the best sandwich ive ever had & i'm a 50 year old sicilian from the east coast (philly!!)!!! legit read more

Walked in on a saturday afternoon and ordered an original calzone. 10/10 for service, clean tables, clean bathroom and a great attitude from all the employees especially the guy at the front with glasses. The calzone was HUGE and super filling! Truly what I needed!!!!! read more

Ordered pasta with marinara sauce and two meatballs to go. The pasta was delicious fettuccine (my choice) made fresh with a clean marinara sauce and tasty meatballs that blended perfectly with the pasta. Perfect lunch and dinner for later. Plenty of food for 1-2 people. Always done on time when you order to go on Yelp. Service great and ambiance is casual but very nice. read more

BOOM!!! It's taken me some time to find a real Italian Pizzeria, the kind I was familiar with in the Northeast and I found it. It's called Two Brothers from Italy. We ordered a bunch of food to be delivered last night and the entire family, including my Pops who was visiting from Connecticut, we very impressed. Kids loved the pizza and fettuccini (and all 4 ate it without complaining and took some to school this morning.... high props!) Pops loved the sausage subs (they are monstrous) and even my wife enjoyed it who is a bit of a healthy eater. Prices seem fair, food is delicious. read more

Ordered from here today for the first time took home and order a baked ziti and a calzone. The calzone supposedly was a small thing was as big as my head. Serving size was tremendous Chuck full of ingredients. Cheese galore. Perfect balance. The baked ziti was Good. Lots of extra cheese. I will definitely be coming back again. read more

Tried this place a few times, overcharged three of those times. Last time the order was lasagne, stated on both menu and wallboard as $14.99. Picking up the order, in a completely empty restaurant, the guy says, "That will be $18.99. I pointed to both the wallboard AND menu laying there and the idiot starts gaslighting, "They forgot to change the prices," and then another lie and another until finally stating the meat sauce on top was $4.00!! I was disgusted. I drive by this place every day and it is almost always empty. No wonder they have no customers. They are F*****G GRIFTERS!! On to the BBB.... read more

This is my go to pizza place. They've never disappointed me with hit or miss quality. They're always delicious. I tried another place tonight that had higher reviews nearby but was so disappointed and realized I haven't written a review for Two Brothers from Italy that they so deserve. They got my 5 stars for their consistently delicious pizzas read more

We went for the pizza but found the meatball sub and baked ziti (10 out of 10) way better than the pizza! My only recommendation would be to ask for a side of marinara / sauce with the sub. You don't want it directly on the sub to where it gets soggy but a side to dip in would be spectacular. Pizza was ok but not great. We ordered for delivery through doordash though, so maybe fresh right from the store would be better. We'll try that next time. read more

This was the 1st time at this location and we thought it'd be as good as the Oceanside one we've eaten at and got takeout from. Called in our 2 sandwich order and was told 25 minutes which is what it took. More bread than meat or cheese so was unhappy with that. But Two Brothers still has the best cannoli and we sure enjoyed those. read more

Yay!! A pizza review!!! This little hole in the wall is tucked away but is worth it to look for... we had a calzone just to add some fun and their meat one is delicious...yes we know it's a folded pizza...it's still fun...what we didn't realize when we ordered is they offer a Sicilian style pizza...it's a deep dish pizza...we aren't a fan of thick crust, but this one was tasty, the sauce and great cheese was worth it as well....we couldn't finish one slice though...it's a LOT of bread!!! But still good... The service was great even though they were getting close to closing time they served every one with a smile and didn't turn anyone away. We will be back read more

If you are from the East Coast and you want a good pie... this is the place. Thin crust, good sauce, etc. A must try!

Unexpectedly?? The calzone was fricking HUGE!! If you get this you're def sharing with a friend or date or whatever bc there's no way you're gonna finish all of this by yourself! Staff is super friendly and patient while my friend was deciding on what to order. There's some seating outside and my friend and I had a good time! Worth the price bc it's just so filling and delicious!! read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Original Calzone - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

The pizza crust is excellent--crunchy and fluffy. The staff are super friendly, and there's a spacious outdoor patio that's perfect for pets. The food was hot and fresh, and I'd definitely return. On Wednesdays, you get an extra-large pizza for the price of a large, which is a great deal. Two Brothers from Italy is definitely worth a visit. read more

See all

Fast service with custom veggie pizza slice got pizza fresh from oven, with fresh veggies read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Veggie Pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

Looks can be deceiving. This quaint little pizza parlor in the middle of a busy shopping center may not seem like they would serve an authentic, tasty airy, savory pizza. This place has got to be one of the BEST pizza shops in North county! The dough is amazing and the flavor of the sauce and cheese come together to give you the perfect delicious bite every time! I will definitely be back! I was pleasantly surprised, and HIGHLY recommend!! Thank you Two Brothers for an Awesome pizza experience! read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Pepperoni and Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

This is the best pizza place around! Better than pizza hut, domino's, little ceasars, and every other pizza I've had in my life. This truly tasted like home cooked pizza from scratch. I could taste all the different ingredients and it was heavenly. I now have a new favorite place! I highly recommend. I got a medium pizza for two people and it was a perfect amount. We had two slices left over for the next day. The employees here are also super kind and welcoming! read more

See all

Great customer service from all the staff and especially the young lady who took my order. The food was excellent as my previous visit and was glad to see that they had buffalo hot wings this time. This is my go to pizza spot. read more

Strange to think that pizza joints that aren't New York Style have fallen by the wayside for me. Because of this I have been thinking of only going to East Coast Pizza back in Encinitas as well as making my own Whitestone and Margherita pizzas at home (apologies to my father for the last set which went into our dying oven). And that's a shame, because when we finally got off our butts and ordered takeout from Two Brothers during the pandemic, we realized that we'd been missing out on something pretty grand. I had a Sausage and Mushroom Calzone. The crust was chewy, flavorful, a great amount of gluten in the mix, and had that light burn to it to help caramelize. Honestly, a well done shell. And the interior was full with enough cheese and fillings to easily stretch out this one calzone across three meals for myself. With their great marinara to dip in, this not only satisfied, but was a damn good value for the cost. My wife had the Roast Beef and Cheese Oven Baked Sub. She found it a bit dry, but I'm also pretty sure she had it without Italian Dressing. It's difficult to replicate the juiciness of a fresh cut slice of Roast Beef in deli form, especially after spending a few minutes in the heat of an oven. Our son had a Gourmet Style Pizza with Pepperoni, Sausage, and Tomatoes. Everything on it was delicious, as expected, with my favorite bit being placing the tomatoes on after baking which kept them plump and fresh feeling. The only issue I had was how perfectly round and uniform the crust felt. It honestly seemed like it was pressed by a machine instead of hand tossed or rolled and curled over a table. Regardless, Two Brothers is definitely worth a second trip. There are some things on my list of meals I regularly want to eat, and calzones are definitely in that top twenty. read more

My go-to pizza place even though it's out of my way and they don't deliver outside San Marcos. Delicious every time!! Never had a bad experience, cold pizza, and though it's a tad more expensive than other shops I have never felt overcharged for what I got. Recommend 10/10 read more

Heard on NextDoor that their Calzones are the best. Oh my. Between Regents Pizzeria Calzones and the Calzones here? No contest. It's worth the twenty minute drive to hit up Regents. My Calzone was served with two small containers of marinara sauce on the side. The marinara sauce was cold. Just room temperature. I've tasted better bottled sauces than this one came with. The Caesar Salad was just a plate of cut up Romaine with some croutons sprinkled on top. A light scatter of Parmesan and a tiny cup of dressing perched on the side. Not even tossed. Overpriced for what you get. read more

Two Brothers From Italy - Their Baked Ziti is actually $14.95 for a lunch portion. Not $10.95 - Pizza Near Me - San Marcos, California

I had the best experience here, we order pizza, pasta and salad, the flavor was absolutely amazing, also the guys offered the best customer service were so warm and friendly, We ate at the place and we have absolutely the best experience will definitely be back soon read more

I'm a pasta lover and stopped in for the spaghetti and meatballs. The pasta was al dente just how I love it. The sauce was flavorful, delicious and the meatballs were just as delicious. Our group also ordered lasagna which was cheesy and a big hit. The calzones were crispy, the dough was delicious as well as the meat inside. All around the food was delicious and I recommend. Unfortunately it's a pizza spot and the pizza could be better, but we were there for the pasta not the pizza. read more

Been here many times but my favorite is the pasta with two meatballs to go. Yes the slices of pizza are good at lunch time & the sandwiches too. Calzones seem to be popular also. But my go to for carry out is the pasta with red sauce and meatballs. Lasagna with meat sauce is my second choice. I enjoy taking it home to enjoy as the dining area is small here. Great lunch deals and everything is delicious. Always great food and good fast service when I order online. read more

My go to Italian food. I've tried the meat calzone, the baked ziti and the rigatoni with meat sauce. Everything is very reasonably priced and it all seems to be pretty legit to me. Definitely would recommend! read more

Best pizza in San Diego County! We drive over an hour to get their pizza. Another hour to get home! Really nice people who work there too. read more

Chicken parm Meatball sub Pepperoni pizza - not so much Door dash was horrible, pizza got here cold read more