First restaurant that we tried in Williamsburg and it certainly didn't disappoint. It was much smaller than expected but it tasted wonderful. We would definitely recommend it to any pizza lovers out there! read more

See all

Pizza and people are great in this restourant. Subs are also great. I have been in williamsburg for 6 months and it was my best place to eat. Good family good people and delicious foods read more

If your from the northern east coast and love that fresh topping, call your crust gotta love it pizza this place is the spot. Pick up or delivered the pizza rocks. I haven't tried the other stuff but based on the pizza it's has to be good. read more

Really good, family owned business! We got the Stromboli and it was absolutely fantastic. We ordered our food to go and it was ready in 15 minutes. We will go again next time we are in Williamsburg. read more

Very good thin crust pizza. We had the Greek salad and Greek pizza. Both were very nice and a very close to what we were missing from the NY Metro area. Needed a little garlic and would have preferred oil cured olives to plain black. We are being picky here. Very good quality thin crust pizza here! We will be back! read more

Really likes the pizza! Ordered a small margherita and a large meatball & black olive - our 2 staple "test pizzas". Two Sisters passed the test! The crust is slitly crisp but the cheese is golden, bubbly, and gooey. The meatballs were excellent! We are from Long Island and and Connecticut and very picky about pizza. The crust could use a tad more flavor and the large pie should be 18 inches, but the sauce is really lovely. I definitely recommend, light years better than "The Crust" or chain places. If we return to Williamsburg, we will be back! read more

Awesome pizza...stay away from the garlic bread, though. The place is small but quaint, and it is a local family business open for about 16 years. We met a family eating gyros and calzones and they said they were fantastic. Beware, the salad is a head of iceberg lettuce with purple cabbage on top and your drinks only come in cans. read more

Delicious pizza! We had the White Pizza the best I ever had! We're new to the area, I think I have a new favorite! I met the owner and his daughter great folks and again delicious pizza I'm anxious to try the meat pizza the pictures look great and I know that they won't disapoint! read more

Nice little place in Williamsburg. We got the Hawaiian pizza and it was fantastic. Rarely do my girlfriend and I finish and entire 12" pizza together, but this one was perfect. I recommend it. read more

Excellent meatlovers pizza and baklava. The pizza was a good as the north end in Boston. It's a small pizza restaurant but the service felt like fine dining. The owner came to our table and provided silverware and plates. read more

Delicious Hawaiian pizza. Flaky, not-too-sweet baklava, is a must. But the real reason to go is that this is an honest family place. I was helped by two young women, who were polite to me, but were so sweet to a much older gentleman who was clearly a regular. You don't see this type of service often today, and it will keep me coming back every time that I'm in town. Thank you. read more

Small place and very homey. Owners are very nice and cook the food fresh. We were visiting Williamsburg area and Googled this restaurant. Wish it was closer to home. DELICIOUS. The baklava is a must.... read more

This is probably the only place I eat pizza at. It's authentic and very nice. I've eaten here many times and I'm always blown away by the food. Customer service is excellent and they will always go an extra mile. They do delivery as well. So if you are looking for a good nice intimate place to eat, this is the go to place. read more

The pizza is marvelous. The service is ok. I don't care for the atmosphere it doesn't make you feel comfortable eating at the establishment. I will get carry out from now. And as I was leaving I did get the baklava and wow moist sweet flaky. Definitely a carry out delivery type of restaurant. read more

Two Sisters is the best-kept pizza secret in Williamsburg. It is a small, family-run business whose employees and owners are committed to making delicious NY-style pizza for Williamsburgers in the know. They do technically deliver, but it requires one of the two people working in the kitchen to leave and drive their personal vehicle to your home. So make the trip to the restaurant instead--you'll be glad you did! read more

This pizza is okay.I wasn't that impressed with the cheese though it was average and fell off easily.The whole pizza was a little bit floppy.Overall this is just a mediocre pizza place. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Great food at this family owned restaurant. It's close to our house, so it's very convenient to pick up subs and/or pizza for the whole family. The family is very friendly also! Highly recommend the steak and cheese sub! They always remember who I am when I pick up the food! read more

First off I love to find the hometown shop, and I grade pizza hard. This place though was awesome, I'm staying at the governors green and wanted them to deliver, which she replied we usually don't but we will tonight. It took about a hr and 10 min to get but worth the wait, the owner (which I assumed) and her daughter ( assumed again) brought it super friendly, which I was pumped because I figured it's got to be more homemade, which she told me was a homemade crust, and sauce. To the pizza it's a thinner crust but thick enough to support toppings and not just fall apart, it's got a breaddy taste to it not sweet, and not too blah either not to bad in my opinion. The toppings were great! Plenty of cheese and sausage shaped like pepperoni, mushrooms could have been a little thicker but they were fine. Cheese was greasy but it's cheese so what are ya gonna do? All in all it was great kids loved it wife liked it, I liked it so good job 2 sisters pizza! Definitely recommend! read more

Pizza is made the "old school" way. Dough is pressed out with fingertips and then gently hand-stretched using knuckles -- no rolling pins. Liked how they did not try to be fancy and show-off by throwing dough into the air, which generally leads to an uneven, thin crust in the middle. Crust is tasty and vegetables are fresh. Tomato sauce isn't too strong. read more

We were visiting from CA and read on yelp about this place. We were very disappointed in the pizza and the Greek salad. Wouldn't recommend this place for pizza. read more

Our favorite take-out place in town. The owners are always pleasant, and the pizza is perfectly done NY style, with great crust and nicely seasoned sauce. The pies are huge and reasonably priced. I often reheat slices for breakfast the next morning -- a few minutes in the toaster oven, and the crust crisps right up. Homemade baklava is a bonus! read more

We became pizza snobs after leaving in NYC. This is the best I've found in the area. Owners are friendly and while it might be more expensive than the chain pizza places... You get what you pay for. read more

I am updating for all of visits I have done recently, repeatable great pizza, great guys working there too very friendly on phone and in their little place read more

I don't know what I like more about this place: the food or the service. The food is outstanding. I ordered the chicken gyro and my boyfriend got the Philly cheesesteak. Both were great and perfectly seasoned. Don't even get me started on the baclava. It was sweet and flaky just as it should be. The service is just as good as the food. Everyone at the establishment was welcoming and cheerful. I think I found my new regular place to eat. read more

This is as good as it gets in the area, and I grew up on real Italian NY and NJ pizza. The owners are actually 2 greek brothers, who purchased the place from the 2 sisters. They are always friendly and make a great pie! (pizza!) . It is our "go to" pizza place.. we drive 30 minutes just to get it..it's worth it if we want great pizza. Tried some others.. voted "Best in Williamsburg".. and my husband and I can't figure out how that happened.. because they are places we'd never go back to again...they were horrible. Whoever is voting needs to ck out this place..it puts the rest to shame. read more

Gyro was good as was the salad but the chicken parmesan was soggy and the sauce tasted like canned tomato sauce. It was edible but not good by any means. The pizza was soggy and crust was underdone. Maybe it was just a bad night but unfortunately we won't be giving the sisters another try. read more

We ordered a large pizza for delivery. It came hot and fast. We are always a bit timid when trying new places because we have been disappointed so many times. Two Sisters did not disappoint. The pizza was fresh. You could tell their sauce is homemade and the crust was crispy just like we like it. If you are looking for a chain-style pizza, order from someplace else. This pizza was the best we've had so far and my husband even called to tell them how great it was. read more

Good, local pizza. Not the absolute best I've ever had , but in the top of the places we've tried in Williamsburg & certainly the best delivery in this end of town. We look forward to dining in some time. read more

It is as good as it gets. Very friendly people who have great food. If I lived locally I would be a frequent customer!

Great little restaurant. Staff was super friendly. The mozzarella sticks and pizza were delicious

The Greek salad was okay, but the pizzas we ordered tasted pretty good. The kids like the cheese pizza, and we got a supreme that was delicious. I did not like the fact that they didn't have water, ice or fountain drinks. Bottled drinks can be expensive for large families like ours. Staff was not that friendly and inviting. Place is very small. read more

My wife and I came here on a day when the power was out all around town. Needless to say they were busy, but when we placed our order they told us that it would be a 30 - 45 min wait. An hour and a half later we finally got our two pizza's that we ordered and when we told the guy that handed us our pizzas about our wait time, he just shrugged his shoulders and walked off. He didn't even have the common courtesy to say that he was sorry for the wait! And to top it all off the food wasn't even good at all. It's overpriced pizza that is just as good as the chain restaurants except with poorer customer service. My wife and I will not be returning. read more