We ordered Two Sisters Pizza while in Williamsburg for the night. We ordered a pizza with Italian Sausage and were delivered a pizza with kielbasa on it which was absolutely disgusting. We also ordered hot wings....which were literally dry fried chicken wings with three packets of Texas Pete hot sauce provided on the side. No ranch or blue cheese just hot sauce packets. Total waste of money read more

We have been Two Sisters customers for years. The pizzas were made with real cheese and the owner had fresh basil in the sauce. The new owners don't seem to be following in the same footsteps. We tried it twice just to make sure it wasn't a one time thing. Skip this place, you can get the same at little Caesar's and pay less. We are so sad to have to search for a new pizza place. read more

Got a medium Hawaiian pizza. The crust was so hard that it was inedible. The actual pizza was so bad that even my two year old, who spent the better part of the day saying, "PIZZA! Pizza!", only took about two bites. I've seriously had frozen pizzas that were way better. read more

The food is amazing here and also the the customer service. The owner came out to check on us and to make sure we were enjoying our food. We love this place and so happy we found it. The burgers are made fresh, chickwn wings are very tasty, gyros are very delicious and fresh. We will come back to this place every time we visit Williamsburg. *They serve all halal food. read more

A 10 minute walk from our house. Local pizza joint next-door?! Awesome! Sort of... There is nothing implicitly wrong with two sisters, other than it being a little overpriced. A greek salad and a 3 topping pizza was $30! Not unheard of, but still steep. We also tried the subs... stick with the pizza. It's by far one of the more superior products on their menu. ***TASTE*** They use cheap meat on their subs and are stingy on the ingredients. The sub was thin and light so if you're expecting that hardy New Jersey sub look elsewhere. You get more food and more for your dollar at the likes of Jimmy John's. The pizza tasted great, but if you're looking for top notch, try Daddy-Os, or if you're looking for a great price, do Brick House. They sure are convenient though... we'd probably stop back in again due to convenience alone, but were we driving by Brickhouse or recommending something to our friends we would gloss over this place. I'm all about supporting local, but I think we were a little disappointed in Two Sis. I wouldn't disway people from going though - give it a try for yourself! ***DINING IN??? Don't. This is more a carry out joint as suggested by other Yelpers. It's small and not particularly warm. read more

Huge servings for a really decent price. Paid less than $10 for an amazing calzone that will last me another dinner. It was my first time here and the family that runs the place was incredibly friendly. Their selection of food is incredible and beyond what I expected, especially for a relatively small restaurant. I never had baklava before and tried some they made earlier that day -- it was sooo good and I definitely recommend it if you have never tried it before. As a side note, they have a nice variety of cold canned sodas (carrying both Pepsi and Coke products). I would definitely recommend this place for tourists and locals alike. read more

It's a good place. I had the manti and it's the best one I've had so far in the US. The pizza was ok. The place is a hole in the wall type of place. It has a very family feel to it. The service was prompt and polite. read more

We love this pizza place! They make great pizza- big ones! The dough is good, as is the sauce and cheese! They also have homemade baklava that I get every time. It's clear this place is run by family and they make their food with love. read more

Over priced bad food. But good service. Nice people running it. But food was no bueno.

Awesome place. Homemade food! Excellent friendly service. Food was fresh . Don't forget desert. The baklava is fantastic.

This was another great stop on our trip... Service: Was friendly and attentive. A little unnerving as we were the only customers and the gentleman behind the counter was staring intently. Im sure it wasnt meant to be like that. Had a jovial conversation about what part of ny we were from. Food: Was great. New york style foldable crust. Good chew. Extra spicy pepperoni. Lots of fresh cheese. The white pizza was stellar. Very garlicky. The only thing is i wished both the spinach and ricotta had been spread across the dough instead of deposited in scoops so it would be easier to eat and taste all the deliciousness at once. But thats minor as it was totally worth it. And ending with a piece of their home made baklava was fantastic. Syrupy and nutty. Pastry perfection. Atmosphere: Is sort of non-existent. Its a little shop in a strip mall. Its tidy and a bit cramped. But that doesn't matter. You come for the pizza and not the decoration. It is a little pricey. And its definitely set up that way for tourists. But it is no worse than the price you would pay in NYC. Also as i said, its totally worth it. read more

I'll preface this by saying that I have no idea what Two Sisters even looks like inside. This is our go to spot for take out or delivery pizza and the hubs is always the one who picks up! Pizza here is consistently high quality, they almost always get our order right (1 time we ended up with garlic bread instead of cheese bread and we order a LOT). The people are friendly and they send out a good Greek salad. When I'm feeling indulgent I order the baklava. This is our family spot if we don't feel like cooking dinner, for nights we want to order dinner sent to the neighborhood pool, for neighbor hang out nights etc. If you're in the 'burg, try it out! read more

Very nice owners here. I recently ordered a meatball Stromboli for take out. It was very delicious. I've had a pizza from this place and it was also very good. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Meatball Stromboli. Tasty. - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

I ordered a large pizza (half specialty white pizza w spinach and half cheese). After getting off the very confusing phone call I was told it would be 40-45 minutes for delivery ten minutes away on a Thursday night around 7. The crust was thin and the sauce was watery and the cheese came off completely when you took a piece (on the cheese half). On the other half the spinach was under the cheese, it was spread all over with huge chunks around it. Too much for my taste. Overall a waste of $25. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

We really like the pizza and really like the baklava. The owners are friendly & make you feel welcome when you walk in the door. Delivery and pickup are the mainstays of the pizza business so dining in is small so be aware. read more

This Long Island girl says..... AWESOME!!! Nice family and fantastic food sure to impress anyone and they do a fantastic catering menu! Guaranteed to make your mouth very happy indeed. read more

Gets a two for the baklava only!! 31$ for baklava and ziti ....what??? The ziti comes with meat sauce - no mention of that on the menu... I cant eat it!!!! They did not ask to replace it...? I Originally asked for a greek salad - she told me it came with a salad - so i then let her know i didn't need the extra salad ... she said she could put olives and some feta on the side salad and then charged me for it... it was wet and wilted - gross!!SO SAD!!! This is why people do not shop mom and pops!!! The baklava has always been good but with this experience I WILL NOT RETURN - ultimately, i paid 31$ plus the $ i gave the driver for a tip for baklava.. no baklava is worth that price!!! read more

Great pizza and lots of other meal option.Pizza-Pasta-Kebobs--Gyros-Salads-Baklava-Hot Subs-Platters-Deserts( Baklava-Cheesecake) Owner is great guy.This restaurant knows how to serve you food and knows how make your day delicious. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - a collection of copper pots and pans - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

I have to say I'm shocked at the high reviews. The pizza here is awful. Limp pizza is not something I would call good. I literally had to eat it with a fork and knife because I couldn't pick up a slice in my hand. Sorry folks. This is not good pizza. read more

The meat pizza and hot wings at this place were very good. The owner and her grandson are so friendly, they really make you feel welcome. The ambience makes this place great! I would definitely recommend it to anyone who lives in the area. read more

Absolutely terrible service. I ordered a pizza, gave my address, and they said they would deliver. An hour later, still nothing. I called back, and apparently 3 Miles was too far for them to deliver and they never even made the pizza. I had to call to find this out? They didn't even have the decency to call me back and let me know they wouldn't be delivering. I ended up waiting an hour for no reason and feel like an idiot. Never ordering from them again. read more

Not a bad little spot for a pizza. NY style pizza that I would describe as average. There is seating for about a dozen people and no booster seats for children. Probably more of a carry out spot. Service is friendly. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - Slice of the meat pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

See all

I keep reviewing this wonderful place because I consistently eat here. The owners care about their customers & it shows. This time around I got the Margherita pizza and it was phenomenal. Delivery is really fast, and it's always been hot. Great food, great owners. read more

Two Sisters Pizzeria - DELICIOUS -- margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

Excellent gyros. We went in the door expecting to order pizza, but changed our minds when we saw the gyros ($7.50) on the menu. We were not disappointed. I had the chicken and my son the lamb. The generous portion of meat was expertly seasoned and the taziki sauce was great. The pita bread was light and tasty. My son's only complaint was the lamb could have been a little more tender. With a plate of fries, we were both stuffed. They also sell baklava, and you should not leave without trying it. It was heavenly. We split a two-piece portion ($4.25), and we couldn't have eaten any more if they gave it to us. read more

Fast delivery and everything was just like the pictures we saw. Excellent Manicotti that came with garlic bread and a side salad.

They make the worst pizza that I have ever had, and that includes frozen. The cashier/pizza cook was rude and unfriendly.

Good pizza in a small restaurant. Only seats aprox 12 folks. We ordered two pizzas and they were out to the table in aprox 15 minutes. Very pleased with the food. If you're looking for something different than the franchise pizza joints give this place a try. read more

Glad I discovered this place. My fiancee is recovering at Patriots Colony and we wanted something different for dinner and one of the nurses recommended this place. We ordered a cheese pizza and it was delish!. Not greasy and I liked the crust. Next day was Mother's day so we ordered the manicotti, came with salad and garlic bread. So good! Both the delivery people were friendly. Please try this place. read more

Very nice to place an order for delivery. Order arrived within a reasonable time and was still hot and very good! Great pizza for the price! read more

The pizza was nice and hot but very greasy. I feel the grease sitting in my stomach. Was disappointed

This place is a joke. I called for a delivery, they said they deliver. I was at a hotel exactly THREE miles away. He told me they don't deliver that far.... Where do they deliver?!? Within walking distance? How are they in business? Don't advertise that you deliver if you don't!!!! Should be zero stars. read more

Our go-to pizza place in W'burg. Authentic, NY-style pizza. REAL crust - not the bread they try to pass off as crust at the chain places. Gooey, greasy cheese and perfect sauce. The sausage and pepperoni do get pretty greasy - one paper towel to sop up the extra does the trick for me. And it's so worth it - absolutely delicious! read more

THE BEST PIZZA in Williamsburg, hands down. I'm from NY. I lived here for a while & tried pizza from everywhere. Let's just say, we miss this place even now that we live back in NY! Pizza w/pepperoni & mushroom and DELICIOUS White pizza were our favorites. read more

YUM!!! Just moved here and were looking for a good pizza place. I'm from NY and it's hard to find pizza that lives up to my expectations! Two Sisters nailed it!! Best pizza I've had in a long time! We will be repeat customers for sure and can't wait to explore their menu more!! You can tell they take pride in their business too! read more

Since we moved, we've been looking for a go-to neighborhood Italian place; we happily found it last night. Great food, friendly service, reasonable prices. What else does anyone need? The pizza crust was perfect and the meatballs were outstanding. I can't wait to go back. read more

Pizza wasnt cooked picked a slice up everything dumped right off....watery sauce large chunks of onion. 21+ dollar large pizza

Great place for pizza and a sub! Very friendly Italian owners. I had the Meatball Parmesan sub and my wife ordered a small pepperoni and mushroom pizza, which she says is the best we've found in Williamsburg!:) read more

Wonderful little locally owned place. Turkish owner named it after his two daughters. He was so nice and so attentive. The place is really clean. The menu is simple-pastas pizza subs and a few Greek / Turkish dishes. The Greek salad was outstanding. So fresh and dressed with just oil and vinegar and some oregano. Lots of nice chunks of feta. Served with delicious garlic bread. Meatball sub was absolutely delicious. Medium meat pizza was huge, NY style , and so tasty and well prepared. ... Nice crispy bottom. The homemade baklava right out of the oven was superb!! Great Saturday lunch!! read more

Second visit here while traveling through VA's historic triangle. Great pizza, I will return.

Ordered from here on Monday after reviewing Yelp. Not only did it take over an hour for delivery, it was terrible. Everything was cold. We ordered pizza, cheese sticks and wings and it was awful. I had to put the pizza in the oven to make it edible. The cheese sticks were disgusting. THe Yelp reviews are deceiving. Waste of money and everyone was still hungry. read more