Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Tylers Bakery & Cafe

    4.7 (3 reviews)

    Tylers Bakery & Cafe Photos

    TYLERS BAKERY & CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Tylers Bakery & Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 14
    Thanks 0
    Love this 17
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Tylers Bakery & Cafe

    You might also consider

    Connections Cafe - White Chocolate Raspberry Tart

    Connections Cafe

    4.4(33 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$

    I haven't been back to Ligonier in a while but plan on getting there soon…read more I loved this little cozy place with a good bit of seating and very eclectic. I'm a strict vegetarian who eats some seafood. The coffee is excellent. I got the French press. Loved it. And I had a plate of food at the time and loved it too. Can't wait to go back. It is a bit pricey, but it's worth it be because of the quality and care that is given. I'm always looking for really good coffee - not weak- and this passed the test.

    Today we came here to celebrate a friend's 60th birthday. We strolled the shops in Ligonier and…read morethen came here for our lunch. They were super accommodating to us, allowing us to BYOB and providing not just some delicious lunch entrees but a phenomenal dessert to top it all off. This is an order at the counter and then be seated type of establishment. You can choose from gourmet grilled cheese, a soup of the day, a frittata or soup of the day and several healthy salad options. We ordered and our food it was brought to our table within a few minutes.! Fresh lemon water was offered and filled when empty. I pre-ordered a dessert, a white chocolate raspberry tart, and we absolutely loved it! The cafe is nicely decorated with artwork and there is a section of Free Trade wares for sale in the entry area. Prices are very reasonable for what you get. High quality foods served by a very nice staff member in a pleasant atmosphere. Try it next time you are in Ligonier for a shopping day.

    Photos
    Connections Cafe
    Connections Cafe - Gourmet Grilled Cheese

    Gourmet Grilled Cheese

    Connections Cafe - Always fresh ingredients on the menu.

    See all

    Always fresh ingredients on the menu.

    Diamond Cafe - Home fries with peppers, onions, and cheese

    Diamond Cafe

    3.8(19 reviews)
    0.2 mi

    A small local quaint breakfast spot that we stumbled upon one morning after a ski trip. Coming from…read morea big city I was blown away by the prices, $5 for French toast !!!! Count me in! The French toast was delicious, felt like your grandmothers cooking. The coffee was fine, what you would expect from an establishment like this. Would probably not order the orange juice again (it had that from concentrate taste). The model trail and quirky framed pictures really gave this spot personality, and the two ladies working were very sweet. If you're in Ligonier this couldn't be more central. All in all a great comfortable spot for a quick bite.

    TLDR version, seems to be an okay place if you are a local but don't bother if you are looking for…read moresomething even remotely memorable. Being from out of town, we were looking for a special spot for lunch with the same charm and draw of Ligonier overall. During our selection process I had written off some other reviews talking about how the fact that this is a local scene detracted from the experience. When we arrived, three of the six tables in the place were occupied by a group of locals talking about whatever. No problem, great, glad there is a sense of community, but the closeness of the seating and the setup of the place meant that me and my spouse didn't really have our own conversation. We weren't invited into the conversation dominating the entire place but did have to listen to it, including the cringe comments on a couple different social issues of the day. I wouldn't normally mention the conversations of patrons in a review but by the same token this business felt the need to display some fake Trump $1,000,000 note on the cash register. The inside decor of the place feels tired, lots of old articles on the walls and a random collection of trains, Elvis, and classic car stuff. All faded/fading. Our server appeared to have just rolled out of bed, threw on a miscellaneous t-shirt, some crocs, and showed up to work. The menu consists mostly of stuff you probably already make at home. There are more options/distinctive items however at the GetGo gas station down the street. For what it was, the food we had was good and the pricing is at least commensurate with the food. These factors saved the two stars in the rating. Wishing we would have walked out shortly after sitting down. Ligonier has so much more to offer. Hoping this review might help someone else not make the same mistake.

    Photos
    Diamond Cafe - Menu

    Menu

    Diamond Cafe - Daily specials

    Daily specials

    Diamond Cafe

    See all

    Out of the Fire Cafe - Prince Edward Island Mussels

    Out of the Fire Cafe

    4.3(550 reviews)
    11.9 mi
    $$

    The mushroom soup alone is the worth the trip. I went on a random Wednesday at 4pm not ski season…read moreand it was amazing. The staff so attentive and friendly and a poke bowl yummy

    Cute spot out in the country. Very specific hours of operation so be sure to check the times they…read moreare open for meal service. The outdoor patio is beautiful but quite a few ants, nats, and mosquitoes. Menu is full of great options. Everything tasted wonderful; the mushroom soup is a well known staple around the region. The burrata pita bread was a little soggy, but tasted great. The smash burger had good flavor combinations but was definitely not a smash burger as the patties were full thickness. I would call it more a double bacon cheeseburger and it arrived overcooked, but the peppercorn aioli was a nice touch. The salmon salad had perfectly prepared salmon and I loved the dressing. In the future I think I would omit the tomato and cucumber because there were so many ingredients I feel it took away from the dish. The wedge salad special was great. Very blue cheese forward but I enjoyed it. Would be even better with some smoked bacon on top. The salmon dinner was well prepared, fresh and the presentation was on point. All in all, I would definitely come back and give this place another try. Also, with some fine tuning this cafe will be well above par for this area.

    Photos
    Out of the Fire Cafe
    Out of the Fire Cafe - Delicious over-stuffed house-smoked salmon sandwich on fresh ciabatta

    Delicious over-stuffed house-smoked salmon sandwich on fresh ciabatta

    Out of the Fire Cafe - Humming bird feeders surround you as you eat outside.

    See all

    Humming bird feeders surround you as you eat outside.

    Bittersweet Cafe - Angry bird as a wrap

    Bittersweet Cafe

    4.5(327 reviews)
    34.3 mi
    $$

    This spot is so fantastic. The outdoor spaces are amazing - with beautiful landscaping and plants…read moregalore. I asked a couple questions about the menu and was immediately directed to the BLT by a woman in the kitchen. Wow I wasn't disappointed. It was sooooo good. The bread was toasted perfectly (so it didn't kill the roof of my mouth), the tomato's and lettuce were fresh, the bacon crispy, and that basil mayo. A life changing BLT if there is such a thing. A couple side notes I appreciate. Bittersweet's marketing team deserves. Ton of credit - they have some awesome swag available for purchase. Also, this is a Christian oriented cafe with bible verses, messaging, and music. Love it! And finally, check out the story about Bittersweet's roots, its commitment to addiction recovery/support, and the owner's son's story/passing. The name "Bittersweet Cafe" will take on a deeper meaning (the news articles can be found in the walls before the counter by the bathrooms). Cheers Bittersweet, thanks for having me, and God bless!

    Visited on a Saturday in between tours at Frank Lloyd Wright properties. I love the ambiance,…read moredecor, and meaning poured into this place. The food was delicious. Servers were friendly and hospitable. The only downside is waiting in line to order and then waiting for your food. This is probably not the place to come when you have a time crunch, but if you can eat a leisurely meal, come on! I had the Bittersweet chicken salad sandwich and we shared a peanut butter mousse dessert, both were great!

    Photos
    Bittersweet Cafe
    Bittersweet Cafe - Table numbers with a vibe

    Table numbers with a vibe

    Bittersweet Cafe - Blessings wall

    See all

    Blessings wall

    Tylers Bakery & Cafe - cafes - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...