Food: mediocre crust, don't even have basic warmers for their slices. Food handling seems sketchy. Service: Grouchy and labored. Ambience: Horrible, claustrophobic and dated. Don't really know what they are doing. super costly for what they sell. Stay away. read more

This pizza is so good. And reasonably priced! We also love the garlic knots! It is a sparsely decorated place, so ambiance is not great, but food is very good! read more

We like Umberto's pizza, but today I did a carry out order and when I walked in to Umberto's the temperature inside must've been 90° plus. Just imagine walking into a pizza shop with pizza ovens blasting away and no AC. Yep it was hot. The other problem was when I called and placed the order I was told it would be ready in 25 minutes. So here I am sitting in this steam bath 15 minutes longer than that. Once I got the pizza and opened it, it was missing one of the ingredients that I had requested. I love the pizza but on this visit I'm sorry I've got to give it two stars for the intolerably hot interior of the restaurant, the delay in having my pizza ready on time . Glad I got a carry out rather than having to sit inside this oven to eat my pizza. But as I said, the pizza is great. read more

Umberto's - Pizza ovens - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

We have been coming to Umberto's since he opened and it's still the best New York style pizza in Tulsa. Moses puts all of his love and attention into his food and it never disappoints. Every pizza joint in the world will have its off day due to different employees, but this place is consistently delicious. The garlic knots are still the best I've ever had and the pizza crust is flaky and tender, and the pepperoni is amazing! Be sure to visit him soon! read more

Umberto's - This New York style pepperoni pizza is still the best in Tulsa! - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I walked in at 821pm to an older gentleman with attitude. He acted as if I was bothering him. I felt very uncomfortable and wanted to walk out but I placed my order and waited patiently. The food looks good but customer service is big to me. I am being kind giving 3/5 stars. read more

Greatest little pizza shop, maybe in town. Crust is great, toppings are great, it's a dive, but atmosphere is just what it should be.

Popped in today right when they opened and ordered a meat slice. Arrived at my table piled high with toppings. Not overly saucy, which is great because I tend to order my pizzas with "light sauce". Crust had a nice crunch to it. It wasn't burned at all as many reviews report. Overall, I'd eat it again. read more

Umberto's - Meat Slice: pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, Canadian bacon, breakfast bacon - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

My favorite Pizza place in Tulsa. Unique style pizza. Very good. Definitely recommend. The place is not updated but clean. Been going here for over 10 years. Slices are Very generous! read more

Umberto's - a slice of pizza on aluminum foil - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Ok so this is a serious slice of pizza. I can't say t is my all time fav as there is something about the sauce that just needs some small adjustment but... this can definitely be a weekly visit or a man size box to feed an army or a game! Price is just spot on as well if not more than what you get at those crappy chains... So did I mention fresh and they even put that heated up toppings when you stop by for lunch? Ya boy! And if u get the supreme you really just need one slice.... Oh and get the calzone... split it with a friend and get a slice... pretty legit! Stop by... do it... get a slice at lunch... you will need a nap later! read more

See all

They post menus with prices that are 15% less, them charge a service fee on top of their already misrepresented price. They pointed right at the menu after I caught it and they told me those prices were out of date. I advised they should take them down since they are not correct. They turned around and walked off so they could do it to the next customer.it was taped to the podium and could have been updated with a pen and paper. Medium Supreme price from the menu was $12.75, and $15.00. Actual price was $19.97 with adders. They should honor the posted menu when they acknowledge an error. the prices were an additional 18.5% being added. I don't mind paying for it if they were upfront. Food is good, customer focus sucks. Glad I was not at the gas station using this approach! read more

Umberto's - Add about 18.5% to this before you order. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Want a slice of pie as big as your face for under $4 and savory cheese melting down? Well umbertos is your place to go!! I could just eat the crust!! The pie is delicious and the prices are great!! I'm picky on pie and never eat chain pie.This is the best thing to a slice of pie from NY right here in the heart of Oklahoma!! read more

Food quality has taken a bit of a dive. Often get over cooked calzone but still a good, solid NY style pizza. I'll keep going back for sure.

This is seriously the best pizza in tulsa. A supreme w so many toppings is literally heaven. Fast and friendly service. Love this pizza. Call in your order and go pick it up, literally easy and convenient. read more

Umberto's - Supreme is perfection. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I found myself in Tulsa for the weekend and was looking for an indie pizza spot to feed 4. For starters, Google maps kept showing this place was across the street from where it actually is. Weird but that's not necessarily their fault so that has no bearing on my review. I placed a phone order for pickup and arrived 15 minutes later after being told it would be 15-20 minutes. Once inside, I walked up to the counter and there were 2 guys working. One kept passing me to grab stuff from a fridge and said nothing. He looked at me several times without nary a word like hi or we'll be right with you. A few awkward minutes pass and the other guy finally approaches me. He said it would be a few more minutes - no biggie. When I get my pizzas which were both XL pepperoni, one looked perfectly cooked and the other looked orange. The pizza tasted ok when we first got back but reheating made them gross and exploited the weird overly salted cheese rubber. I took my time to reheat on the stovetop and they were barely edible. I will probably never find myself in Tulsa again but if I do, I'll be trying a different indie spot and hoping for better. read more

I used to LOVE Umberto's. I'd find any reason to swing order from them, but lately I've been disappointed. The most annoying thing is that they are always wrong about how long an order will take to make. The order is never ready when they say it will be. Oh, and they refuse to get a second phone line, so it's almost impossible to get through to place an order. read more

Really good! Great for a quick gathering! Have ordered a couple of times and kids love it.

Waited so loooong to try this place. Right over on Harvard & in that rare occasion I hadn't cooked, hubby said he was headed that way, order & he'd pick it up. I love pizza! Thank you, hubby! The picture below is of the pepperoni/ pineapple pizza I ordered. NOT! I hate Canadian bacon. & I didn't like it. So furious I called. He remembered my order ( too bad hubby's so trusting & didn't check). I informed him of what I actually got & I could hear his frustration. Someone just fulfilled the order by rote. About an hour later (we were starved and ate some of the other one), they rightfully delivered what we'd ordered. Took way too long. No longer hungry. Frustrated, disappointed. We threw out the remaining (a lot, obviously) of 3, 14" pizzas. But those dried herbs they threw on it were still stuck in my teeth. Meh!!! read more

Umberto's - A little dark? Way tooooo many black olives--all you could taste. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

for the past year, i thought umberto's always had 2 locations. i come to find out, i went to the original location before they closed/relocated. like the old location, things haven't changed (in a good way). i got a slice of the all meats (pepperoni, ham, sausage, etc). the slice was so big & piled with toppings, i couldn't even eat the pizza new york style (when you fold it). this was the first time in history that i had to purposely eat a slice with a fork & knife. it didn't hurt to add the garlic seasoning &/or the italian seasoning as well. the wait for my slice wasn't long, i could say the same for the 14" pepperoni that was ordered as well. plenty of options to choose from, whether you choose their signatures or you make your own. slice or whole pizza, you'll be satisfied. read more

See all

The pie reminds of ny. It's always been made the right way and cooked properly so that's enough for me on that, but it is difficult to get through on the phone. read more

Umberto's is a good local pizzeria with fresh ingredients. The place is fairly small and can probably fit 20-25 people at most but they also deliver and you can order take out as well. We had family members taking us there for the first time recently and it was a good experience. We had the Supreme 12" pizza and added a few toppings to it. The ingredients were fresh and you can see the owner Mose and his staff prepare the dough in front of you. You can tell Mose is passionate about pizza and his customers. The New-York Style pizza served here are extremely satisfying! The menu is fairly simple, make your own pizza with the toppings available. The variety of topping is pretty decent. We saw many customers ordering take out that night, the pizza are made when you order so it may take a little time for it but definitely worth the wait! read more

Umberto's - Supreme Pizza with added Jalapeños and banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Always my favorite pizza in Tulsa. I love the pizza and feeling like I'm in a New York Deli.

Unfortunately their days are over. The toppings have been reduced. Definitely not the same crew. Place was dirty. Decor is looking dilapidated. I hope they can stay around. read more

We are fortunate to have Umberto' s . Their Pizza is as good as it gets and the folks that work there are delightful. Thanks for having such a wonderful place. read more

Awesome as always!!!Great customer service and tbey are super consistent with their food and service. read more

Umberto's - Supreme with itakian sausage - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

My husband brought meat pizza and wings home last week while I was sick. I loved it all. The wings r awesome. But, the sauce is to hot. Get it on the side so u can judge how much u want. The pizza was one of the best I have ever had. I recommend everyone try this place. You will go back. read more

The best New York style pizza in town!!! The food is delicious and whenever I get the craving for pizza, Umberto's is up. Please tip the workers, if you pickup. They work hard at what they do. I haven't had a bad experience yet. read more

Great pizza, friendly service! One of the best pizzas in Tulsa! The dough is light and has a great taste and the toppings are all fresh. The pizza was delicious! read more

Umberto's - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Just went to Umberto's after not being there in several years. Just as good as I remember. I'll be going back again.

Sometimes you have to look at just how frequently you visit someplace and bump up that rating. I realized I needed to do this when they started remembering my name by what I order. That is also when I realized I needed to take a closer look at how often we order pizza. Once a week Chris, just keep it to once a week. I still love Umberto's, the pizza is as good as ever. I can't recommend it enough. read more

See all

sadly, because their business suffered sooo much during the coronavirus pandemic, they have "discontinued" their monday, tuesday, wednesday, "carry-out special" until further notice. they still are a great local family owned business. so go by show them some love and support, even if have to pay full price, still get some great food. read more

Sausage rolls are fantastic. I was addicted after the first one. It was so good. I never tried anything else.

Unassuming place. Polite and quick. DELICIOUS PIZZA, heavily topped. I'll be coming back for more. read more

Pizza was good but not the best. It was kinda soggy and greasy. Made the bottom of the box soft and soggy which was annoying driving home with. I also had to wait like 15 min past when they told me it would be ready and then the price of the pizza Was kinda high on top of all these issues. Probably wouldn't go there again-- there's better tasting pizza, service, & quality at other pizza places in Tulsa. read more

By far the best New York style pizza in town. Nice chewy crust and plenty of sizes to choose from. Can't beat the price either. Day time they also offer up by the slice options. Just fold and enjoy.! read more

Umberto's - Canadian bacon and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Had I read the reviews before we came here, we wouldnt have eaten here just because of the answers to comments by a representative of Umbertos. Any negative comment was answered rudely and very disrespectfully. But I didn't and wish I had. We ordered 2 20' pizzas. We had a Canadian bacon & pineapple and a supreme. The pineapple and mushrooms weren't drained so both of our pizzas we soggy. We couldn't even pick up the slices to eat them, we had to use a knife and fork. While we did ask for light sauce, when we got them we couldn't find any sauce at all on either pizza. There were plenty of toppings and the pizza had great flavor. The establishment is very run down and we saw lots of ants around the pop machine and at window seals which run beside the tables. First set of garlic knots were burned so they remade them. Wouldn't say this would ever be a place I would return to or recommend. read more

I've been back! When slices are available they are HUGE ! 2021 Huge not 2020 huge! Massive piles of toppings. My previous posts were harsh ... I know! This recent post is a truthful update! It's Sunday evening checking to see if your open cause I would drive over for pick up. read more

Italian Sausage pizza awesome ! Service was totally amazing! I will definitely come back to Umbertos!

I would personally not come back here. My husband is originally from New York born and raised there. His family has ran several pizzerias in the areas. The pizza is so soggy, flavorless, and with TONS of flour on the bottom of the pizza. they said they sell by the slice but I don't see any display of showing the pizzas. This is not a New York pizzeria. read more

Umberto's - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

If you are pregnant, eat this amazing pizza! Or eat it just because it's amazing. This was my go to pizza while I was pregnant with my son. It's fresh, hot and delish! It is a little on the greasy side so be prepared to use a napkin. Thank you Umberto's for serving the Tulsa area! read more

Umberto's - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

My favorite pizza in Tulsa, other considerations are Piehole, and NYC, in that order.