Riley answered the phone to take our to go order on 2/27/26. I was having a horrible day and all I wanted was the Steinbrenner calzone, my favorite. I saw it was no longer on the menu.... I was devastated but I thought I'd call and ask any. She was telling me they just had a little meeting about how much they missed it and that it's an off menu item. She went the extra mile and asked them to make one for me. I was so grateful! She had amazing customer service and really turned my day around! Thank you Riley and andolinis!! read more

If you are in Tulsa this place has some of the best pizza you can find. Quality ingredients really make the difference. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Stumbled onto this place while traveling and hungry. It wasSUPERB from start to finish. Had the best server and food was honestly the best I've had in a long time! Would love to return someday IF I'm ever back in Oklahoma read more

See all

Great decor, friendly staff. Server came by quickly and checked on us regularly. Stellar pizza! Very nice gluten free thin crust. Not crispy but still nice texture, flavor and chew to it. We had BBQ chicken pizza - sweet bbq sauce and amazing, fresh cheese. The onion strings add another level of texture and flavor. Also got a Frederico - fresh ingredients, love the white sauce. Excellent meal with leftovers to enjoy later. read more

What a great experience! We started with garlic knots that sat in melted garlic and butter, which was amazing. We were also impressed with how many pieces we got. I think everyone in our group had at least four. Then the pizza came out. We ordered the all meat large because we thought the family was hungry enough to finish it. We were wrong. My kids thought each piece was the equivalent of two pieces anywhere else. It was loaded with toppings and tasted amazing. The staff was very attentive and I was quite impressed when I ordered a beer how quickly it came. Overall, an excellent experience and we would highly recommend it! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Garlic Knots-again, what was left. - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

We stopped by Andolini's yesterday while passing through town! Did not disappoint one bit. We had a large group, so a variety of meal choices. The Pizza was Great! Fried Mozzarella was amazing, Garlic Knots were great! Our waitress was very kind and took great care of us! This place is well worth your trip! read more

See all

All things were excellent! Service, food, atmosphere - wonderful! Get the pepperoni jam fest pizza and the Italian butter cream cake. delicious! read more

Soooo yummy and great service as always. Both of the Demarcus are amazing! Quality is always the same regardless of dine in or take out. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - 1|2 Scamorza DeMarco 1|2 DeMarco of Brooklyn - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Wonderful pizza and ice cold fresh brewed root beer. We had the combination pizza and it couldn't have been better. Absolutely delicious!! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Saw Andolini's advertising San Marzano tomatoes and in-house made mozz, so had to give it a try while in town for business. What I got was a doughy undercarriage.The sauce was cooked down and too sweet. The mozzarella was slightly better than average. The basil was fresh. It's edible, but it's not a true Napolitano Margarita. It's better-than-average American pizza wearing Italian colors. They must've had an off night! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Delicious and great service! The manager was very welcoming and helpful. He explained that Andolini's pizza has NYC pie inspiration and the pizza dough is never frozen. There are a ton of specialty pizzas to choose from and the menu gets updated with new combinations. He helped my group pick out which pizzas to order based on our taste preferences. All were delicious! Can easily tell from the taste that all the ingredients are super fresh read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Fantastic pizza! We stopped by and ordered a pizza to go. The owner was exceptionally friendly and helped guide us through the menu and even poured us some water as we waited. We were told that the pizzas were a Tulsa-style pizza inspired by New York. Coming from the tri-state area, I could taste the NY in it. The pie had great dough, not floppy, nice sauce, and an A+ on the toppings. So far, I would say they have the best toppings in town. I highly recommend Andolini's, and it's now in my top 3 pizza list! I will certainly come back to try the other pies. read more

We ordered the margarita pizza with pepperoni. It was ok. I felt it was a little salty. They topped it off with extra-virgin olive oil.. which I've never had Pizza like that before. I didn't really like it. I felt it was to oily. But on the bright side. The service was excellent. The gentleman that helped us was so nice and informative. The ambience is really cool. It's an old building well decorated for its purpose. This is located in a cool area called Cherry Street. I would recommend it just because everybody has different taste. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Margarita pizza with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Oh my GOODNESS!! This place was so amazing!!! The food was amazing and so good! Casey & Asia were soooo sweet!!! DEFINETLY RECOMMEND! They're my ALL time favorite servers ive ever had in a resturant! THANKS SO MUCH!! The place was so warm and cozy! I love the decorations and the lighting inside, very comforting!!! Will be back lots and lots of times! read more

See all

We come in town for horse shows. Every single time we have to come in multiple times while here. It's the best pizza you'll have. The garlic knots are on point, the salads are always so fresh, and service is always great. You won't be disappointed. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Best pizza we have had in a really long time! They are a tad heavy on the toppings, as we felt like the combo pizza had too many green peppers on it. Inside, the ambiance is nothing special, and they make up for it with the food! We did find it very very expensive for a pizza joint, but we would still come again. The coolest part is that they bring out pizza dough for the kids to play with while we wait! My daughter loved that! We got the combo, Two kids cheese pizzas, a beer we were overcharged for but didn't notice until later, and a Vodka lemonade. My husband and I both agreed that the crush was amazing. The server was very attentive. I didn't get any photos because I left my phone accidentally! read more

Door dashed food and so disappointed. Food was ice cold, waited over an hour after the order was Placed, had to call and check on order, and then the food was cold and salad was Horrible. No Parmesan, croutons,etc. Won't be door dashing this again. Have been going there since they a Started in Owasso. Disappointed read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - We love Anolinis but this is the bread order for $2 when you carry out. It's so disappointing!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

There are many places to get pizza in Tulsa and I do have a few favorites. Andolini's is sometimes my favorite but not always. In other words sometimes their pizzas really hit the mark for me and other times miss the mark. This past Monday night they really hit the mark. The special that night was buy one pizza get a second pizza at half price. You have to mention that to the server when you order or you won't get the deal. We ordered the Demarco of Brooklyn with San Marzano tomatoes, house made fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, Pecorino Romano and first pressing extra virgin olive oil. The crust was thin and slightly charred around the edges. In other words it was perfect. The second pizza was the Triple Pepperoni Jamfest with cup and char pepperoni, hot honey, deli pepperoni, pepperoni jam and julienned basil. So delicious and again with that wonderful thin crust. Can't say enough positive things about how delicious both pizzas were. read more

See all

After being turned away from other eateries (because we had a dog), we were pleasantly surprised that we could have our dog in their outdoor street-side space. Stephanie, our server, was extremely accommodating, and Jason took the time to tell me the history of the old building they were in. Even though we drove 4 hours to Tulsa, it feels like home! The food was good, the service was personable, and the overall experience was memorable. read more

Best slice of pizza in Tulsa, and it's not close. We have had pleasant experiences dining inside, outside, and to-go. Service has always been very extra helpful. We enjoy coming here or taking out nearly every week! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Triple pepperoni jam fest - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Gave this another try and everything was just perfect. Service and pizza were fast, the meatball app was as good as ever. This is possiblity one of my favorite pizza joints of all time. The crust is so soft and chewy. Just wish they had some honey for them! The hot honey tastes more like a garlic sauce to me and isn't spicy, the kids liked it best. But the house ranch is absolutely amazing and a good runner up to honey for crusts. Also there is a spot for pizza pickups so don't worry about parking for to-go orders. This is a top pick for me in all of Tulsa. read more

We ordered take out online and pizza was ready pretty quickly even considering that it was a weekend. Pies are huge and the options are unique. Both pizzas were delicious, slices are cut big. We ordered garlic and cheese knots. Garlic knots were amazing, cheese knots were a little too greasy, they were literally dripping. read more

Here visiting from California for a tournament. We came on Sunday afternoon for a late lunch. The place wasn't busy at all. We were seated right away. Host was friendly and welcoming. I love the rustic feel of the restaurant. It's more bar setting with a layback vibe. For drinks I ordered a bloody mary and it was great, but I wish it was a big stronger. Food we ordered half combo and half athenian on our pizza. Pizza was delicious and ingredients were fresh. Overall we enjoyed our food and the staffs were all great! Our waitress was delightful and she took great care of us. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Wife's pick and what a banger Great Atmosphere sat near the bar (everything is close by the bar) but got a cider beer that was amazing and a glass of wine ordered homemade mozz pucks rate them some of the best I've had then got a half and half pizza you can't go wrong here service was exceptional and watching the expo put the finishing touches on the pizzas and apps shows why they are so amazing saw the eggplant app come out and looked gorgeous and they we're constantly dealing with door dashers but didn't hurt the customer service go here now!! read more

See all

Wow, I had waited three years to eat here again what's wrong with me? They talked my wife into both desserts and wow if you like rich chocolate, the Oreo is the way to go and the Italian buttercream just melts me and the whip cream don't get me started. Just try and save room. You can always eat the pizza later. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Italian Butter Cake - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great pizza , I ordered a large and it was huge. I ordered over the phone and picked it up. Was met by a very fast and friendly staff read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This is my go to place for pizza. The service is extra good and the pizza is creative and delicious. In my opinion it is the best pizza in Tulsa! read more

I am glad to know there is such a high quality pizzeria available in Tulsa. The food is excellent. I am torn between the Roman SOHO and the Dom Demarco which I like to add pepperoni to. The online ordering is simple and easy. The delivery system is in a class all its own the would make Uber shy away. They have it all going on, know what I mean. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Dom Demarco - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great service, our server was really friendly and honest with her recommendations, food was really good, my blackberry mint julep was amazing! Very laid back ambiance, I like it! Will definitely come back before we leave Tulsa. read more

See all

Treated ourselves to Friday Night Pizza! New to the Tulsa area and wanted something tasty to enjoy at home. This was by far one of the best pizzas we've had in a very long time. We ordered a 20" Triple Pepperoni Jamfest - (cup and char pepperoni, hot honey, deli pepperoni, pepperoni jam, julienned basil) Sauce, taste and flavor was excellent! Ordered online and did curb pick up. Attendant was attentive, professional and friendly. Quick and easy process. Beautiful nice easy to find building. We will definitely be going back to try other options. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - 20" Triple Pepperoni Jamfest cup and char pepperoni, hot honey, deli pepperoni, pepperoni jam, julienned basil - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Food was great and came out quick! Pizzas were very big and very good! Would definitely come here again to try other food! read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Jakkellin was amazing and out pizza was supreme. Go to andolini's on Cherry street. Beer was also on point.

Riley is an absolute ANGEL of a waitress!! Tonight was the first time here at Andolini's on Cherry Street. My wife has been sulking for years about finding a good pizza since she came to Oklahoma. We did just that with this BUSY little hole in the wall. The guys on the kitchen line put on a spectacular show and their efforts shine through in the finished incredible pizza that came to our table steaming hot and full of old world flavor! The manager, Hanna was engaging and so pleasant checking on everyone and the bartender was top notch. This place is our "GO TO" from now on! read more

Andolini's is one of my favorite restaurants in Tulsa, particularly the location on 15th St in Tulsa. The food, service, staff members and ambience are always perfect . You will have a very enjoyable dining experience at this restaurant too! The last thing I ordered were the garlic knots and Italian Creme cake, which goes perfectly with one of Andolini's handcrafted pizzas that you can watch being made. What are you waiting for?! Head on over now!!!! read more

Andolini's is my favorite pizza joint in Tulsa! The atmosphere is fantastic, the food (everything I've ever had) is amazing, and the vibe is easy going, lively and classically reminiscent of an old pub. The servers are attentive and pleasant, the staff is always moving fast. My favorites are the Mozzarella Slices, Arancini and the Combination Pizza. They've got an amazing beverage selection as well. 20+ Beers on Tap 30+ Beers in bottle/cans Lots of Wine and Cocktails Check them out as soon as you can! read more

See all

We were in a bit of a rush and they were slammed! That being said they were extremely helpful, and prompt with our order in spite of the whole staff being in the weeds. The bar tender was kind, attentive and working at breakneck speed. She even took the time to ask why we were visiting even though she was obviously very busy. We were extremely impressed. Not to mention, the gluten free crust is some of the best I've ever had and the salad and pizza toppings were excellent as well. 10/10 experience. I wish they had this restaurant where I live, definitely worth a visit. I will be coming here every time I'm in Tulsa. What a treat!! read more

Fantastic! Best pizza ever! We're from Oklahoma, but learned about this place while doing a Maine trip. We found a pizza place called Zeppa's in Ellsworth, ME and the proprietor said Mike was responsible for his pizza recipe! Road trip! We went to the beautiful flagship Cherry Street location and were there during lunch. We indulged in the all you can eat special. What a deal! Outstanding pizza, from the simple to the complex! Stop by if you are in the Tulsa area or make the trip! Well worth it read more

See all

The pizza came out hot and smelled amazing. The crust had just the right crunch with a soft inside. The sauce had a rich tomato flavor that blended well with the cheese. Toppings tasted fresh and generous. The staff made sure my order was ready quickly. I can't wait to return for more. read more

If you're in the mood for fresh and leveled-up pizza, this is your place. We came in for lunch, and while it was not empty inside, there was room for us to be seated quickly. Our server quickly got us menus and took drink orders. We ordered mozzarella slices and arancini. My word. What a delightful and crispy treat. The arancini is cheesy and has a lovely hint of basil, and the mozzarella was perfectly seasoned and fried crispy. We ordered the combination pizza, and we got a big one so we can have leftovers later. In my experience, Andolini's is the best fresh in- restaurant. Take out is also very good, but there's something about it coming right out of the oven that boosts the experience. The price is higher than your other chain pizza places, but it deserves to be. I highly recommend it. read more

See all

I order the Demarco of Brooklyn pizza and it is delicious, it was so good I forgot to take a picture before I devoured it. This has become one of my favorite . I also got the Greek salad and that was not that great. The lettuce felt kind of old and it was a bit brown also had only like 3 tomatoes. The other issue is the parking, they have a very small parking lot in the back of the restaurant and is always full specially during the most busy times. Is hard to find a spot open. This is why I don't dine in. read more

Andolini's Pizzeria Cherry Street - Demarco of Brooklyn - Pizza Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all