Upper Crust is one the of local gems in Fredonia. I have been enjoying their food and coffee since 2010 when I first came to Fredonia for college. Although they have had a change in ownership the recipes have stayed the same and the inside got a huge upgrade. When my family is in town from long island they almost always request Upper Crust for at least one meal. I suggest the tomato mushroom soup and the wally sandwich. read more

I went to college in Fredonia 13-15 years ago, and I went to Upper Crust A LOT. After trying many other sandwich places and bakeries (even in NYC), Upper Crust is still a destination eatery for me. I'm going to do a few rebuttals. One reviewer thought $9.00 for a sandwich was too much. I've had $15.00 sandwiches at Katz's in NYC with NOTHING ON THEM except for meat. The bread at Upper Crust is homemade and the ingredients are fresh. The sandwich is ginormous, I can't eat a whole one. A half-sandwich for $4 and change is enough to fill you. I will pay such prices for excellence and quality. Go to McDonald's if you don't like it. Another reviewer complained about no French bread. Yes, that would be nice, but I doubt it would sell well considering the demographic. Go to Buffalo for that. Wait, I can't really recall from-scratch bakery french bread in Buffalo (I lived there for four years), unless you buy it from Wegmans. Limited selection? Maybe, but the stuff they do, they do really really well. And it's really consistent. (I ate there 9/25/12, five years after the last time I ate there. Exactly as I remember it.) There is only so much of a budget for ingredients. You can't spread yourself too thin. You end up shorting yourself on quality and consistency. As for the potato rolls, hmmm. They were mighty yummy. It would probably be nice to have them all the time, but maybe it's just not feasible anymore. Consider our crappy economy and what it's done to the restaurant industry. When I lived in Fredonia, I would buy a loaf of bread and walk home, tearing off chunks and stuffing them in my mouth. It is THAT GOOD. And the cinnamon rolls are the still the best I've ever had. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Cinnamon Rolls - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Fredonia is a small town for sure, but this place is definitely one of its crown jewels! It's a cute little bakery in the middle of the village. The inside is cozy and it draws an array of people. From students at the college to locals, everyone enjoys Upper Crust! I've never gotten their coffee, but their lemonade and hot chocolate are to die for! Neither are overly sweet and they pair nicely with their baked goods and sandwiches. Their breakfast burritos are so flavorful and hit the spot in the morning! Their paninis are also amazing, I'm trying to work through their menu before I graduate this May! Their baked goods, though, are some of my favorite things in Fredonia. Their cinnamon rolls are huge and delicious, their chocolate chip cookies are gooey, and their coffee cakes are on another level. They taste of cinnamon sugar and happiness! I love this place. Wish I could bring it home to Buffalo with me when I graduate. read more

I miss having my soup in a real bowl with a real spoon. Plastic and cardboard is just not working for me.

Fredonia is a bit of a culinary wasteland... but Upper Crust is one of the few gems. Phenomenal baked goods made in house, same for the bread, the soups... pretty much everything that can be made in house is made right in their kitchen and everything is delicious. Any time I pass through Fredonia I have to stop here. Cinnamon rolls, creamy potato soup, eggplant panini or sandwich... all winners. They also sell organic fruit and have vegan cheese as an option, so they're as woke as a place in Fredonia, NY can be. read more

Love their potato soup!! Cookies and other baked goods are also delicious!

I always prefer to eat local instead of at a chain, so I decided to go a few miles off the interstate to have lunch at Upper Crust while driving from Niagara Falls to Ohio. My wife and I both think it turned out to be a great idea. I had a tuna sandwich, and she had a roast turkey sandwich. Both were excellent -- the bread was soft and delicious, and my wife thought the roast turkey was most definitely real, not the thin cheap stuff you get out of a package at the grocery. The tuna salad had olives in it, which I thought was odd before trying, but I gave it a go anyway and loved it. The desserts looked great, but I didn't try any of them. The space is simple but fashionable. You order at the counter and then take a seat anywhere. The food came out in just a few minutes. It is clean and neat, and the staff are very nice. There is one coed restroom at the back. Park on the street or in the lot behind the building. read more

You can't go wrong here, unless you are gluten intolerant! Veggie soup and Med Sandwich with a lavender Arnold Palmer. It was all SO fresh and flavorful! Staff are a friendly bunch. This is my third visit. Very consistent. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - You have to love a place that even thinks about the pooch! - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Whenever I visit Dunkirk/Fredonia I always stop to get some Tomato Mushroom soup. One day I'll figure out the recipe! It's incredible. Prices here are a little higher (not much) but the quality is way worth it. Get the blueberry scones! read more

Upper Crust Bake House - "Daily Special" - soup, salad, and fresh baked dipping bread. - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

Local cafe that's a staple of Fredonia. It's been around for years and the quality hasn't change. Their soups are to die for everyone raves about their creamy potato, but not being a fan of creamy soups I prefer their veggie or turkey veggie. It almost has a sweet taste to it! I can honestly say it's my all time favorite soup. The sandwiches are served on homemade bread with top quality meats. The pastries and baked goods are tasty and if u get a chance to try their potato rolls, don't pass it up. Last I knew they only made them on certain days. It it's pricey, but worth it. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - A "Wally" turkey breast, Apple, lettuce, and a special dressing on homemade bread. - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

See all

Cafe has a peaceful but active ambiance with plenty of places to settle for a morning of well-selected roasts and tasty pastries. The ones I really liked were called "clouds" - kind of like a blueberry muffin/scone thing with frosting that you may have dreamed about. The turkey sandwiches were similarly amazing- especially the grilled one. read more

We are pretty selective about our food stops . Maybe " anal" is a better word . The Upper Crust is now our place to go . Coffee is really good , and the sandwiches are OH MY WORD sooooo good !!! We called ahead and our lunch was ready for the road . Probably a good thing because had we been sitting there we would have eaten more .. I saw some yummy looking desserts . Staff is really friendly too which is a bonus . Also , we parked behind the restaurant in a free parking lot . read more

Really good service, friendly staff and great atmosphere!! I came here with my girlfriend and best believe this is the spot for a good sandwich. read more

Another visit to this great restaurant. Unbelievably great food. Tomato mushroom soup was so good. Made me think i was in the garden. Mediterranean panini split for two was also excellent. I love artichokes and eggplant, add fire roasted tomatos and another winner. Polished it off with the best brownie, again. Large enough for two. read more

The sandwiches at this place are not only healthy and beautiful but enough for two! My husband and I live this quaint spot.

Always top notch!!!! Highly recommend! The service is happy, prices are very fair, and quality is alway perfect!

Excellent find this morning! GREAT coffee. Baked goods look amazing. Breakfast sandwich was delicious with flavorful pesto. Can't wait to come back. read more

Tomatoe Mushroom soup is always so so good & pairing this soup with Turkey Cheddar Panini is just 10/10. I love coming here, the staff is always so friendly. Definitely would recommend to anyone who wants a meal that'll warm you up on a cold, chilly fall day! read more

The Waldorf + Tomato Soup will change your liiiiiife. Reasonably priced, locally sourced, and the pride of Fredonia, this is a must if you ar looking for a great lunch. Make sure you take advantage of the AMAZING freshly baked desserts, the cinnamon roll, the double chocolate chip, and the lemon loaf are some of the bests! This is a great place to meet with friends. Friendly service! read more

Great place for sandwiches, healthy bowls, soups, smoothies and more! Our favorite stop when in Fredonia!

This place is incredible! There is no sandwich and I mean none that beats the Billy Club. Ham, fried eggplant, cheese peppers... seriously amazing. They have great coffee and you will need it to wash down the Blueberry Cloud. This thing should be labeled Blueberry Heaven, no other words can describe it. read more

Home baked goods...cookies, breakfast pastries, scones, cinnamon buns, etc...also great soups....sandwiches, coffee, tea soft drinks,etc...cozy atmosphere.... read more

The service was unfriendly. We were here on vacation and couldn't wait to visit a local coffee shop. We were not greeted w any kind of friendliness. Our questions were annoying I guess. We left feeling like an imposition to them. Too bad, we were looking forward to coming back. Will just visit Tim Hortons instead. I'm not one to leave a review if it wasn't good but this was a bummer. read more

Met a group for lunch. Wish I could give this place 5 stars because the food was very good but with the increase in everything due to COVID I expected more. There is only 1 price marked on all that they serve. $9 for a salad and when you went to pay staff said the price was $11 and the sign has not been changed yet. Nothing else was marked, not breakfast items, sandwiches, bakes goods or coffee. I also asked for a decafe coffee and was told they don't have decaf. I was shocked this is a bakery!!! As I mentioned, everyone was happy with their food as well as baked goods unfortunately we did cut it short because the air was not working very well and everyone was uncomfortably warm. Please Upper Crust, put prices on your menu. I would guess when you buy your restaurant supplies you want to know what you are paying for just as your customers would like to know. read more

During a day out in the country (yes, Fredonia is "the country" to me... don't judge) a bunch of friends and I stopped in this adorable sandwich shop for lunch. The setting is lovely and the people behind the counter are all friendly and helpful. I had the "Tommy Club" which was not a "club" sandwich at all (which is supposed to have three slices of toasted bread cut into triangles), but rather just a sandwich on untoasted bread. Very good homemade thickly sliced bread, but perhaps a bit too soft because all of the ingredients kept squishing out. It was jammed packed (yes, that's a good thing) with FRESHLY ROASTED turkey breast, bacon (previously cooked and refrigerated), letttuce, wonderful ripe tomatoes, onion, and two types of cheese (American and provolone) and slathered with mayo. It was a very good sandwich. They also serve salads and soups and pizzas and "egg-rritos" and paninis.... and there's a bakery case filled with wonderful looking (and judged by the ooohs and aaahs) of my table-mates wonderful tasting baked goods. And, there's a complete coffee bar with enough hot and cold choices to rival any "Starbucks". Cute, yummy, and independently owned. Fantastic! (Just please, don't call it a "club"). read more

Wow! What a gem of a find! Made a quick pit stop on our way to Niagara Falls and I am so excited to find this spot! It's a bit small but incredibly cute and comfy feeling. It's almost a little community feel and your table is right next to your neighbors. The bread is incredible! A nice crisp crust with a melt in your mouth Center. I had the turkey sandwich and it was one of the best I've ever had! The mayo was also excellent and homemade. I also had the potato soup and wow! A half sandwich and bowl of soup is so filling and it just hits the spot. It's simple ingredients coming together perfectly. I also tried the lavender lemonade and it is the bomb! I am obsessed with all things lavender and this did not disappoint! The lemonade is homemade and just the right amount of sweet and tart and the lavender adds just a very light floral note and is not at all over powering which I was a bit afraid of. The prices are reasonable for the quality and amount of food. If you're in the area or are traveling 90 take the extra two miles and stop. You will not be disappointed! read more

See all

I'm so glad I found a flyer for Upper Crust Bake House at a hotel near Chautauqua Institution. What a find! Delicious soup and sandwiches, good for vegetarians and omnivores alike. The coffee choices looked out of the ordinary and worth another visit. Friendly and efficient service, too. read more

I'm from Los Angeles, so our standards are pretty high when it comes to food...because we can get anything we want and have some of the best cupcake chains around. But...I was SHOCKED at the AMAZING cupcakes and cookies here. WOW...if you are passing through upstate NY on your way to Eerie, PA and you want an amazing treat off of the highway a few minutes, then I highly highly recommend this place. Fredonia State University students are very lucky to have this a stone throw away. I seriously need to have them ship me some bakery items. I absolutely am craving a chocolate cupcake. read more

I stopped by for a cappuccino. After placing my order four more customers came in. So the cashier decided to stop making my order to take the orders from the other customers. After waiting 10 minutes I get my drink, which tasted very bitter and also had coffee grounds in it. Disappointing. read more

Great little deli bakery with scrumptious bread, great coffee and the 'best soup on the planet'. Their half sandwiches will feed most at a reasonable price, and the deserts are rather epic. Definitely stop in for lunch. read more

Best bread ever! And I bake my own. This is a counter service restaurant with a study's and a one-page menu. I had the turkey sandwich. In a June the tomato tastes like real tomato and the lettuce was fresh. And the turkey was thickly sliced. Had a nice mocha, too. read more

A great place for a bite to eat. An earthy feel with a nice variety for food choices. I had their Roast Turkey Cheddar panini 1/2 with a bowl of creamy potato soup. Nice chill environment right on Main Street. A group of 4 had lunch together. Their menu boasts of sandwiches, paninis, a variety of soups as well as scones and other unique baked goods. If in town...check it out. A great place for a special meal. read more

Really great food. The sandwiches are pretty big so I would recommend a half. I got the Wally sandwich and it was really good. The servers are really nice and do a great job of cleaning and bringing out food. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

The sandwiches here are awesome. They don't have a big selection and nothing really stood out to me but i went with the turkey club. I'm not the biggest fan of turkey, but the thick slices of turkey were so good. The great turkey along with the fresh ingredients, and ridiculously thick, slightly doughy bread really made for a great sandwich. I'd give 4 stars, but the sandwich was like $9, which would be ok in midtown manhattan, but not in fredonia. read more

Upper Crust Bake House - Turkey Club - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

I still crave the turkey club with a bowl of potato soup. I haven't been here in years, but i think about it sometimes. They also have really excellent coffee and pastries. The whole grain breads are cut in massive thick slices and stuffed with fresh deli meats. I do not know what they do to make the potato soup so delicious, but it should be illegal because I am suffering narcotic-like withdrawl symptoms. read more

This place is amazing. Gigantic sandwiches on homemade bread and homemade soup. What more can a girl want? read more

Upper Crust Bake House - 1/2 Tommy club with potato soup - Bakeries Near Me - Fredonia, New York

I just love this place! Chautauqua Country is a tough place to find a good vegan lunch, but they have a great meatless chili and several other vegan options. There are lots of good coffee and tea choices and fresh flavored waters. I always bring home the lemon loaf and the cinnamon buns are amazing. The staff is friendly and helpful. read more

See all

I really wanted to love this place as it does have some vegan options. I only tried the vegan breakfast burrito, but it was super bland. The ingredient list is good. But none of them have any salt, pepper, or spices. I didn't taste any spinach or vegan cheese. Lots of salsa saved it somewhat. I also tried a vegan chocolate chip cookie, which was loaded with chocolate, too much so. And had chips of salt on the bottom. Too chocolatey and salty for my taste but not horrible. I might come back and try other options at some point. read more

All I ordered was a lemonade and sandwich and for some reason this takes over 30 minutes. My boyfriend got a burrito and lemonade. Lots of people came in before us and their food was ready before ours. I had to ask them several times where my food was and every time they said "it's on the way" .... Why were other customers prioritized when they ordered after me? read more

Welcomed merge of hometown integrity and big city creativity. We tried the recommended 'cloud' pastries- one raspberry, one blueberry. Lighter than a scone, though similar in appearance. Less dense than a biscuit, but similar in taste. Fruity like a pie, but slightly less gloppy (good gloopy!!!). They were unique and delicious and definitely merit a second taste when I'm in the area. Many other fine looking pastries of the more traditional description. The aroma of butter and sugar in the air suggests to me they would all probably be delicious. They offered a couple of ice coffee flavors, and the ability to create and mix your own flavor. This was very welcome on a hot summer day. Definitely thumbs up, and a strong recommendation. read more