Delicious!!! Great food and service. It was the perfect romantic setting for a date night with my husband!

I love that they deliver now but also enjoy going into a nice sit down. The people there are super friendly!

The food was overall good. I loved the bruschetta crostini (albeit missing the calamata olives) and the garlic chicken was amazing...the chicken was tender and the creamy tomato sauce to die for. Husband had the flat iron, which was flavorful and pretty tender, but swimming in a bit too much mushroom gravy (hard to find the steak and cut it without it flying all over). We also had crab cakes and they were just ok; seemed pre-prepared. Is the bread and tomato oil still a thing? Sounds amazing in the reviews I just read, but didn't see it on the menu and it wasn't offered to us. Our server was polite and efficient, but we sat for almost 15 minutes before we were approached and offered water (I happened to have a tickle in my throat and really needed it, or I may not have noticed). We will be back for another try! read more

Very good food but service is usually quite slow when busy. Somewhat cramped and small indoor area!

I went there with friends! Had a pasta dish manacotti, I did not like it. Compaired to other Italian eateries. I don't think the food is worth the money it's a slightly high-priced I don't think I'll go back again atmosphere was nice. read more

It's nothing special. Had linguine and clams. Next trip was pizza. Service was slow, and bartender didn't know how to make a Moscow Mule.

I was delighted to find this new restaurant at just a short drive from our STV vacation home. I took a friend to lunch there in mid-May, and we were not disappointed. Great choice of dishes that were well-prepared, tasty, and reasonably priced. ( I had a salad and my companion had an Italian sandwich). Our server appeared to be a high school student and she was a bit less than enthusiastic (well, maybe just bored), but the service was adequate. The ambiance was very nice. Tablecloths reminded me of lunching in Europe. We had only one complaint, and that was that the chairs (although cute) were very, very uncomfortable. The seats are small, flat, and hard. The backs are straight. If we tried to shift to get more comfortable (and we are both average-sized women), we would nearly slide off the chairs. Not very relaxing. We decided that we'd like to come back, but may need to bring stadium seat pads with us next time. Too bad that was the one big negative, because the chairs are obviously new. Aside from that, it was great. If they add some comfortable seating (maybe some nice cushy booths?), they'll get lots of business from me. read more

Love the eating establishment. Great service and great food. Thanks for always a pleasant experience.

Another amazing meal. My bi-monthly VEAL treat at the only place remaining in the Phoenix area that provides a great piece of veal and a great meal. Have tried many other Italian places in this area and usually end up with either a "tough" piece or one with "gristle" in it. Normally get piccata since I enjoy capers. A little out of the way but well worth it. Kudos to the chef Dan and all the others. read more

This was my second time there. The veal was tasteless and dry the first time I tried it, and it was just as tasteless and dry the second time. It came with a side of spaghetti, and the gravy was also very bland. I gave them two chances. There won't be a third. read more

Ordered the house special 14" Pizza to-go. Walked in and was immediately welcomed and helped. The restaurant itself is small with a nice warm, authentic atmosphere. The pizza is INCREDIBLE to say the least! My husband took one bite and said, "this isn't dominos that's for sure"! I'm looking forward to coming back to sit down and enjoy more on the menu! read more

Best pizza! Great customer service. Highly recommend you try if you haven't. Go to drop in Florence

low key location in a small mall, pleasant atmosphere & staff. took a pizza to go (meatlovers - thin crust, fabulous) at lunchtime and ate their fettuccine w/ grilled chicken accompanied by a green salad and bread (both tasty). the fettuccine'n sauce were wonderful tho' the chicken was fairly dry. nice size portion, fine cutlery, well made margarita, an excellent find in a small town. read more

One of our favorite restaurants. We have always received excellent service and food when dining in. I say this because I do not want to dissuade someone from trying out this gem. We ordered a large margarita pizza online for pick up. I arrived early and left with the pizza fresh out of the oven. When I arrived home 5 minutes down the road we opened the box to a soggy pizza. This was an unfortunate experience. This was our second time ordering out for pizza and our prior experience was excellent. Hopefully they can tighten up their quality control out of the window. read more

I was visiting Phoenix and my cousin lives in Florence, so I took a drive over to see him and his wife who actually live in Anthem. They were telling me about this new restaurant that opened on Thursday, and although I was hesitant to go, because I own an Italian Restaurant on Winter Springs Florida, I said let's give it a try, as I love to critique the competitors. I must say that they are doing everything right. The food is fresh, tasty and hot when it came to the table, and the Tomato Oil is "spot on"! Such a nice little restaurant in the Community, I'm sure this will be a welcome establishment to all the surrounding neighbors. Good luck to the Barker and Valentino's!!! read more

Wow. It's the only word that can come out of my mouth right now. We decided to give this place a try tonight. My husband went in and ordered 2 pizzas. Words can't describe how good their food is. If their PIZZA is this good I can only imagine with their other dishes are like. This place is the real deal, people! Amazing flavor. You can taste the freshness of it all. Their pizza crust is by far, the best I've ever had. In fact, we all held a vote and hands down it's the best pizza we've ever had. Ever. And trust me. We're a picky crowd. Would rate this 10 stars if I could. I can assure you, I feel so lucky to have this new place just down the street from me and we will be back. On a regular basis. UPDATE 5/23/14 - We went in and had dinner in the restaurant. Between the 3 of us we ordered Pasta Combo, Fettuccini Alfredo, Shrimp Scampi and the Calamari appetizer. Everything was delicious, fresh and perfect! We also found out that the owner makes his own Ravioli in house and it was obvious. Still TEN STARS! read more

Every visit we have had has been good with service and food, accept one. Tuesday appeared to not be a good day to go, service was down dramatically, but the quality of the food was spot on, once we got the food. read more

This, my friends, is a diamond in the rough. The aesthetics lean a bit toward a high end restaurant, but it is anything but pretentious. The staff is very attentive and the food is fantastic, if a bit pricey. The lasagna is as authentic tasting as I've had since I was last in northern Italy. The desserts are freshly made and to die for. On your way out, pick up a bottle of the tomato oil that they serve with the bread...we keep a bottle on hand at home all the time now. For being tucked away out in Anthem (south), this place is an absolute jewel. read more

After two strikes with the previous restaurants that occupied this space, we may have a hit on our hands this time! I stopped by here for lunch with my wife yesterday and we loved it. One thing that I noticed almost immediately was how much attention this place is attracting. When we ate here in the past (previous restaurants) , we NEVER saw any customers walk through the doors during our meal. While we enjoyed our lunch yesterday, I think we watched at least a dozen or more people come through the doors either as customers or curious about the menu. The staff here is extremely friendly and helpful, and so far our experience with the food has been outstanding. I tried the Italian combo sandwich, which is served on warm bread and tasted amazing. My wife had the eggplant parmesan sandwich and loved it. The portions were a little larger than we expected but we couldn't control ourselves and finished the entire plate. They have a really nice menu and we will definitely be coming back for dinner in the near future. Good to see a place like this with a bar that carries a nice wine selection. Definitely worth a visit! read more

See all

I visited valentinos ordering pizza and cannoli it was awesome, I highly recommend the cannoli. I have not had cannoli like this since I lived back east and they are hand made on site. Pizza was great, I could really taste every ingredient. It brought back memories of the New York/ Jersey area great place! read more

Excellent food! They catered Frontier Tattoo Company's sixth anniversary event -- lasagna, bowtie pasta Alfredo and Chicken Marsala. Everything was fresh, hot and delicious! The food was ready when we got there to pick it up and the price was very reasonable. Love this place! read more

At last somewhere my wife and I can go as regular customers. You have to check this out if you live in the San Tan/Queen Creek or Florence area. We went last night with our family and it was great. We will be checking out the Sunday Brunch and lunchtime sittings too. Food - Excellent ***** Service - Good **** Price - Low to Moderate $$ We have every intention of going here on a regular basis. read more

My wife and I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. We were under the impression that, due to a large number of customers, this place could produce a great pizza. We were wrong. This pizza had about 12 to 13 small pieces of pepperoni on it. The sauce was was totally unseasoned. In fact it tasted like and had the consistency of tomato paste. Crust was soft and not cooked through. This place makes me miss Mama's Kitchen which made a great pizza! I grew up in N.J. and I know pizza. I don't know what their other menu items taste like but, after this experience I'll drive to Costco or Barro's for my pizza fix! read more

What a find! After living in Bay Area in Cali i got spoiled and didn't find many restaurants in San Tan Valley. I found this place on Yelp and yum! Excellent food - it was all great and the staff is fantastic! Our waitress Tabitha was superb and this is our new favorite place!! read more

One of my favorite places to eat! Great staff and yummy food. Sometimes they even have music!

We called for take out pizza. We really enjoyed the pizza, good Italian sausage on it. They said the wait was 25 mins but we picked up the pizza and got it home in less than 25 mins. Good crust, could have had a little more of the good sauce and had lots of mozzarella! read more

We lives near by and easy to walk to this restaurant However it took so long to wait for the food deliver when we ordered

Finally! We have a fine dinning establishment. I have eaten here now 3 times and perfect every time. The pizza is great and of course the pasta is superb. The wait staff is very friendly. The food comes at a decent pace. Just can't say enough good things about this place. Please stop by and enjoy this restaurant. Support your local owners. read more

Very good food. Wife had prime rib and I had chicken rigga. Both were excellent. Wait staff was very friendly and always checking in on us. Highly recommend. read more

Was super excited to try this restaurant, always heard good things. I was super bummed with the food though. The eggplant parm was soggy and spongy, the calamari was rubbery and no flavor. Staff was nice but service for takeout took an hour and it was expensive (especially when we didn't eat much of it). Overall it was just sadly disappointing, we were SO excited and then let down read more

Finally, on my 3rd day in Florence, I found Valentinos. My meal consisted of blood Orange martini with a salad. Entree was Osso Bucco Pork over Risotto. Wine: Liberated Sauv Blanc. Dessert: Tirimuso with Cafe Italiano. Tummy full. Mind and emotional health: harmonious, happy, sated, yada, yada, yada. I'll be back in February and be here the first night. Great job all. read more

Finally a real Italian restaurant nearby where both the atmosphere and food are inviting and fresh. I have not only eaten at many great Italian restaurants and deli's back east, I have eaten in Italy as well and can tell you, these owners are doing it right. They are a welcome addition to other establishments who take their food quality serious. Feels great to have choices and even better to see the genre of Italian Food in the area redeemed! read more

Excellent authentic Italian. Great staff. They even cater to our gluten-free needs. I highly recommend!!

Wow seriously delicious you would never expect it but this place was awesome all around great service and great food will definitely be coming back here. read more

We came here based on yelp reviews, we were not disappointed! We had a large party (7 adults, 2 small children ), we made a reservation. for Friday night and were told we could only be seated outside. It was a beautiful night, so we had no problem with that. Upon our arrival, we were given the option to have the outdoor heater on, for my 81 year old grandmother, this was very convenient. Our server (I cannot remember her name) was wonderful. She was very courteous, attentive, and patient with two small boys accompanying us. We started off our meal with the bruschetta, it was delicious! We even considered ordering more, but opted for the bread and tomato oil that came with our entrees. That stuff was no joke! We even bought 3 bottles of the dipping sauce to take back to NM with us! Between the 6 of us (my grandma had dessert and wine only) we had the shrimp scampi, stuffed shells with meatball, chicken parm, chicken riggies, veal piccata, and one other dish I cannot recall. With the exception of myself, every plate was eaten clean! I made sure to box up my leftovers and am looking forward to having it for lunch tomorro. I highly reccomend this place. If it weren't 8 hours from home, we would come back often. read more

I have been craving a Fried Haddock fish fry since leaving Western New York 11 years ago. I not only found it at Valentino"s, but it was the best one I ever had. The Caesar salad was also top notch !! read more

My favorite place to go for lunch or dinner. The pizza is top notch, their French onion soup is to die for too. My husband always gets the special with sausage and ravioli's and it's out of this world. I really can't say a negative thing about this place. The lunch atmosphere is very quiet and nice and dinner is more poppin and busy but still fun. The staff is always wonderful and I'm always meeting new people that eat there that are equally as nice. And my 3 year old daughter talks about this place all the time. Our whole family loves it! read more

A little disappointing from order to eating. I ordered a vegetarian slice(I think 2.50$) to go, I was told 15 minutes( when I checked on my order the waitress told the gentlemen, I told him 15 minutes), 20 minutes later my slice was ready. The slice was presented in a styrofoam to go container. That is a first for me. The slice it self was small compare to other NY Style pizza places in AZ. The dough was gooey, the cheese was goopy, and the sauce tastes like tin. My vegetarian toppings were grilled and soggy. Not a savory experience, to say the least. So I called to relay my experience and was told sorry they have some glitches. I hope to give them another try, but my expectations are not that high I've had some of the best pizza in New York and I've also had some of the worst pizza in New York. And frankly this not as good as any of the worst pizza I've ever eaten in NY. read more

Last month i was there with me beloved brother and found a healthy pleasure to see public every where.... When I walked in I saw a beautifully decorated dining room with 2 and 4 top tables with classy glass place settings and white table clothes. About 9 of the 15 or so tables were full of people talking and laughing and they all looked like they were really enjoying their food. Ours server, Rebecca, arrived within a minute or so, and took ours drink order. We asked for the sweetest white wine they had and a coke.Jen Barker, one of the owners (Rob Barker, her husband, is the other owner and chef) brought me my wine and introduced herself (she was tending bar). Jen is very pleasant and was really interested in knowing what I thought after I told her that Jeffrey recommended I stop in. We also ordered appitzers ( calamari ), that was fried and seasoned perfectly, 2 entrees ( eggplant parm and veal ) both were delicious and a pizza for the young one....the pizza was DELICIOUS as well.Everything taste freshly prepared and nothing frozen or from the can type of place. I will return many times and bring my friends!!!!!! read more

Very overpriced for what you receive. Servers could be more attentive and atmosphere is very tense and not organically pleasant.