Got a Carne Asada Torta. An excellent sandwich. The contents - beef, avocado, cheese, etc are 5.0. Didn't feel the same about the bun. Maybe a 4.0. A bit too thick. Maybe too bready. Maybe should be more glutinous? Not sure but it detracted a bit. Short line at lunch. Service quick. Lots of tables. Need to try the rest of the menu items. I will be back. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Carne Asada Torta - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

The sandwich itself was very large and definitely enough for multiple meals. However, it was a bit too heavy on the sauerkraut for me, it could've had more of the corned beef. It was done very quickly and was delicious overall. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Reubenator - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

Outstanding sandwiches! I consider it a stop for both breakfast and lunch. The staff is very personable and helpful and a pleasure to do business with. There are a number of good venues on the island and this is one of them. read more

Lived right next to this place for the longest time and didn't get to try it until after I moved. The sandwiches were solid, but I wouldn't say it was anything standout. Great bread, flavorful fillings. I got the tuna salad sandwich and found it a bit funny with the arugula and dill??? or whatever else they put in there, but overall I thought it was a solid sandwich. My husband got the Duderino, which is his favorite--I would definitely get that next time but it's super saucy so make sure to eat over your tray, lol. The Must Get item here is definitely the sweet potato tots! They come out piping hot and super super crispy. Highly recommend. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

See all

Located in the middle of DT Mercer island, Valhalla is a super convenient place to grab a quick bite. You order at the counter, and they bring the food to you. There are some seating areas both inside and outside. Tables inside were a little sticky but oh well. I ordered the breakfast sausage sandwich. It came out hot, fresh off the grill. Bread was crispy, the sausage was super juicy, and everything came together really well. I would've liked maybe a little more arugula to balance out the sausage/egg/cheese. But overall, a really good sandwich. I'll definitely need to come back to try their other sandwiches! read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Breakfast - sausage sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

**update to the last cater review** The manager of Valhalla reached back out to us last week to us and offer us food to make up for the mishap. They definitely did more than what we anticipated. They gave up 2 wonderful boxes of sandwiches and 2 salads (one arugula and one Mac salad). Our team rave on the sandwiches. Thanks for taking the effort and time on taking care of the customers. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Rubenator sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

My sandwich confused me. It had so much goo it could not be cut in half without squishing all over. I ordered the carne asada torta. The idea was good, but putting it all together made an indescribable mess on the plate and my palate. Way too much mayo, that lacked the promised Chipotle flavor. There were a lot of pickled onions that should have helped cut the richness. But with the mess of a lot of avocado, cheese and mayo, all I tasted was a rich mish mosh. I couldn't even taste the beef. It was greatly overshadowed. So many calories wasted on this lunch! Great roll though. My other had the Thanksgetting. He liked his, and thats why I'm giving a 3 rating. read more

See all

This place came highly recommended from some of the guys at the office and yes, they knew what they were talking about. So many choices I'm definitely gonna have to come back. I loved every bite of my sandwich and already have an idea of what I wanna get next time. I am there. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

Great food, quality hot meals made to order. My scrambled eggs were made to perfection. Good coffee, great service! Will be back for sure.

A little bit of time to create the perfect sandwich. I've been at this location in Mercer Island a few times already and they make some great sandwiches. This location is clean, the staff is friendly, and the sandwiches are filling. Sandwiches are packed with tons of flavour and taste just like the location in Ballard which is also great. read more

Got the Yard Bird sandwich today. Amazing sandwiches here. Lots of places to sit and they welcome small dogs in the entry area to be able to order and leave without having to leave your dog outside while you order. Clean and friendly service. Worth the drive! read more

4.6/5 Wow, just came across this place on Instagram. It was a post about their new "thankgetting" sandwich. The funny thing is, this came fresh after me watching an episode of friends where someone eats Ross's thanksgiving sandwich (the moist maker lol). The algorithm must have heard me and I'm glad it did. This place scratched the moist maker itch. Ambiance - just a pick up counter, open kitchen in the back and a handful of seats. Service - only interact when ordering or dropping off food. She was nice and friendly. Food - these are some FIRE sandwiches. Mine had a turkey, BACON, gravy, cranberries and a stuffing "patty" and it was delicious. These aren't clean sandwiches lol, you will make a mess, but so worth it. The tots were perfectly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside and it paired well with their chipotle mayo. I also had a cup of their tomato soup which was actually one of the better ones I've had. No complaints about the food. This is gonna be a new staple for me. My only complaint is their menu is HUGE, gonna take awhile to try everything, but I look forward to it lol. read more

See all

Picked up 2 sandwiches for lunch and we were a little surprised when we opened the bag and found 2 small boxes. The sandwiches are pretty small so they didn't fill us up all the way but we really enjoyed both the super chicken deluxe and the el duderino! Both were juicy and had tons of flavor. Only complaint is that I wish they were a bit larger! read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Super Chicken Deluxe - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

See all

My family and I stopped by to get sandwiches to bring to Luther Burbank Park. This was our first time trying Valhalla Sandwiches and we're excited for a nice picnic in the park. We ordered online ahead of time and got the CARNE ASADA TORTA and the BUDDHA CALL sandwich. The CARNE ASADA TORTA had carne asada, jack cheese, pickled onions, avocado, salsa verde, chipotle mayo and cilantro on a telera roll. The Mexican flavors were all there, but there wasn't a whole lot of meat and hard to find the meat as it was covered with sauce and onions. The BUDDHA CALL had roasted sweet potato, sauteed spinach, roasted red peppers, crimini mushrooms, manchego cheese, and garlic tahini on a telera roll. This sandwich was our favorite out of the two as it was packed with sweet roasted veggies and the machengo and tahini complemented the veggies well. Make sure to bring extra napkins because these sandwiches are extremely SAUCY- you MUST like sauce and condiments to enjoy these sandwiches. Overall, I would say Valhalla is on par with Homegrown, but perhaps with more variety and unique creations. 4/5 for sandwiches read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Buddha Call - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

Stopped in here after taking our cats to the vet. Since we were eating in the car we ordered Piccolo Itsliano, as it seemed the neatest to eat ( wish we could have gotten The Thanksgetting, it sounded so good). It was ok, plenty of meat and cheese, but so much vinaigrette and pickled onions the taste of the meat and cheese was obscured. Don't expect a hoagie/Italian sub! read more

Went there with a buddy that lived on the island after he strongly suggested it. The food was delicious and the servicing size was really good! The service was super helpful with providing choices and options. I will definitely be back! read more

Delicious and well-priced sandwiches with generous portions! You can even get them served over tater tots or arugula, which is such a fun option. They also offer breakfast sandwiches, which is amazing since there are so few breakfast spots on the island. Great value overall! The pickup process is super easy, and there's plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors--perfect for summer days. A fantastic addition to the island dining scene! read more

If you haven't discovered Valhalla yet, you're missing out. These sandwiches are the real deal - stacked high, quality ingredients, and flavors that actually deliver on the creative names. The Steak Beastie lives up to its name: hearty, savory, and satisfying every time. The Fidel Cashflow is another winner - bold and delicious. We order regularly and the consistency is spot-on; never had a disappointing sandwich from this place. If you're tired of sad, flat subs from the big chains, Valhalla is your answer. Worth every bite. read more

The food was amazing we loved our sandwiches. The service was really fast and we got our food fast. The atmosphere is very welcoming and comfy, you seat yourself. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Valhalla Pork - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

See all

Super super delicious and casual sandwich shop. I got the sweet potato tater tots and the beef steak sandwich. The tater tots were fried to perfection and perfectly crispy / hot. The steak sandwich had the best combination of flavors - hearty and zesty. The meat was nice and tender and the aioli paired perfectly with the bread / meat / pickled veg. We ordered via ubereats and it was ready when we got there. There's no parking lot so be prepared to street park around the block. Staff were super friendly. Great spot if you're craving sandwiches for lunch on Mercer island! read more

Solid sandwich place. Tater tots are a plus! Enjoyed both the sandwiches and the Chipotle Mac salad. They have a a good amount of seating and the service was good. Overall a nice place to grab lunch or dinner. read more

See all

This place was solid. The service was good. The guy behind the counter was very helpful. The breakfast sandwiches are solid. Nothing special. read more

Yummy sandwiches, and the best ever tater tots. Eat them right away, don't drive home with them! Service is very quick, and the casual atmosphere is fine. Outdoor seating is a nice option. Tip: good place for a beer with lunch! read more

i'm here for the customization of their sandwiches! if you're ordering online, pick your poison (aka choose your sandwich) and scroll down to the section where you can add or subtract individual ingredients. take care of those preferences and continue down to the bottom. in the gluten free section, you can choose half tot half arugula bowl and that's where the angels start singing! i opted for the shrimp half tot, half arugula with hot peppers and pickled onions and it was a flavor explosion and a hefty serving which easily filled me up at midday. online ordering and payment were a snap and pickup was as easy as walking in and stating my name. a solid place to suggest for a group since the customization between bowls or sandwiches or half/half allows for lots of happy, full folks when it's all said and done. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - no mistaking where you are - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

See all

I really hate leaving a bad review here, because the staff is awesome and it used to have the single best sandwich in Seattle (the Eggsecutor). A month ago, this would have been a five star review. But the powers that be decided to pull that sandwich off the menu leaving...the peanut butter and jelly, I guess, as the restaurant's new best sandwich. And, to be clear, the PB&J is a really great version of that sandwich, but it's a little tough to justify going out and ordering one of those if you're older than 12 years old. The meat sandwiches have too much going on for my taste, and most aren't built on the grilled sourdough that made the eggsecutor so good. The telera rolls that most of their sandwiches are built on are comparatively bland. I'd love to change this to a five star review. I'd love to be able to recommend this place to people. It has a lot of potential, but I guess management and I have a completely different perspective on its strong suit. read more

Good breakfast sandwiches & lunch sandwhich sandwich.. I always get the Thanksgiving sando@ read more

Service felt rushed, food was heavy with greasy sauces, and the ambiance resembled a fast-food spot. For the price, it was underwhelming--honestly, the QDOBA a few steps away would've been a better choice. read more

They do a decent job. Their tater tots are really good, but their sandwiches leave a little to be desired. They are definitely good, but they don't match the hype in my experience. I've only tried a few of their sandwiches, but their store is literally down the block from me and even though sandwiches are a Top 2 food for me, I never think to try it. That says something in itself I think. read more

Sandwiches are served on really good bread. Lots of great selections. Tater tots were perfectly crunchy Pasta salad had a kick. Chipotle maybe, didn't really enjoy it read more

I'm so thrilled to be the first person to leave a review for this new place. Vahalla took over the space that used to be Mo's. Vahalla is awesome! They have hot and cold sandwiches. They staff is extremely nice and friendly. I've never seen the place so clean. They have a new counter and are on fire! I ordered the hot "Bad Lieutenant" sandwich and Tater Tots. They were great! The sandwich had a nice portion of 2 different meats. It also had a lot of flavor. This is definitely my new go-to place. I can't ask for anything more. Thanks and nice job! Oh yeah, they even have a punch card for buy 10 get 1 free! read more

See all

I think it's a great concept, just poorly executed. Everything is massively over-seasoned. Hopefully, they've made adjustments and that was a fluke. read more

Great food, good service and chill ambiance. I'm here weekly! That should give you an idea of how good it is. The Rueben is the best I've had. read more

This is a great sandwich shop on mercer island. I tried their Big Tahuna Sandwich - it tasted delicious. The staff is super friendly here and helps you out with the order and gets your food to the table when ready. Highly recommend this spot when you're on mercer island. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Big Tahuna Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

I love the food here! They now serve breakfast and the bowls are delicious!! Get the tots they are amazing!!

Tasty sandwiches with consistently strong customer service. The tots are solid, too.

Love the tuna sandwich. Staff is super helpful and nice. It has been frustrating that their hours kept changing. But it feels like things have settled in, and now they are open for breakfast! read more

Best sandwich I've had in the Seattle area in years. It would be even better if they were open for dinner!

Slowly working my way through the menu, favorite so far is Shrimp Po Mo'fo, and besides it's a great name for a sandwich. Steak Beastie is excellent, and not the best Rueben ever, but VERY solid. My teenage son gets the Bad Lieutenant every time. Don't skip the tots. read more

Valhalla Sandwiches - Damm that's a good Rueben - Sandwiches Near Me - Mercer Island, Washington

Came here for lunch yesterday. Got the Ragnar, it was delicious! Would definitely come back again.

Very good sandwich, service was quick and staff were helpful. Parking garage is around back which would've been nice to know before showing up. read more