They have pizza by the slice made to order for any of the available toppings …read more Big slice that heated up for crispy texture and sliced. Tasty. Would come again. Only qualm was it took 20min to get our slice and no one else was there... FYI 4% credit card fee

First time at Calixtos Pizza. I placed a phone order. Originally, I wanted a Canadian bacon and…read morespinach pizza. Bummer - no spinach no artichoke hearts available. I ordered a Canadian bacon and tomato pizza. The pizza was tasty. My true test of good thin crust pizza is the next day out of the refrigerator. The pizza held its shape. And, the cold pizza was yummy. My favorite pizza in SoCal is Big Rob's Sicilian Pizza. But, Calixto's Pizza is another option to try. I think it would be great to take on a road trip stored away in an insulated bag.

I've been to the Warner location tons of time but just moved and closer to Magnolia location now,…read moreand after today won't be back to this location. The food was great as always but we walked in and asked to order food to go and was told to wait by the barrels. We waited there while multiple employees looked at us and walked past without saying anything. Not a big deal i get it they were busy. But after a while i asked someone if we could order and she took our order immediately. We ordered a slice of cheese, slice of pepperoni and mozzarella sticks. We got the slice of cheese then the mozzarella sticks 5 minutes later then i literally started a timer and got the slice of "pepperoni" 14 minutes AFTER the mozzarella sticks. The cheese slice was already cold at that point. When i asked how long the pepperoni slice was going to take the gentleman was nice and said "they may of had to make a new pepperoni pizza" that's fine i just want it all to come out hot and generally around the same time. Then when he gave us our pepperoni slice we were so over waiting so long we didn't check the box and when we got home it was just a cheese slice no pepperoni... will not be back to this location. Whoever is FOH manager needs to figure it out. Warner location has it figured out

Simply the BEST Pastrami sandwich I've EVER HAD!!…read more Our server Shannon was fantastic. This is a MUST visit if you're in HB/Sunset

I've been looking for a basic pizza that didn't taste like cardboard. Was slightly overcooked on…read morethe edges and have those pepperonis that curl up and are a little overcooked on the edges. I've been to most of the pizza shops within about 4 miles of West Grove. This is it! Sort of a NY style pizza. Great ingredients. And nice people that work there. This might be a regular place for me.

Pros: fresh ingredients, tasty pizza, yummy Caesar salad and dressing…read more Cons: super soggy crust, tip machine starts at 20%, lettuce a little wilted, but not brown. I find it absolutely insane that a FAST-CASUAL restaurant would START THE LOWEST tipping button at 20%. The only thing the staff does for service is bring the food to your table and bus afterwards. You get your own utensils, your own drink and refills, and you order at the counter. The audacity of starting the tipping buttons at 20% for that is insane. It's part of a greedy mindset that turns me off from any fast -casual business that would do this. And that's asking for a minimum of 20% off a fairly expensive meal. I don't blame the restaurant for that. Everything is expensive these days, but I certainly wouldn't call the food a value, just on the expensive side of fair.

Loved the food, service and Ambiance!! We had. arugula salad it was fresh, goat cheese was fresh as…read morewell in salad. We had pear gorgonzola pizza it was well done and yuuumy, i jad with sad on top. It taste great. Next we had tiramisu( first time they were offering dessert) yummy as well melt in you mouth, not overly sweet. Very fresh. Hidden gem in HB, glad we tried it. Will comeback soon to try pasta. Ciao!!

Great food, fair prices, locally owned, and I heard Audioslave and System of a Down playing in the…read morebackground Staff are friendly even when it's packed. What's not to like?

Pizza is phenomenal!!! Great crunchy crust ingredients taste like quality! Would definitely…read morerecommend to anyone who likes pizza

parking is limited but the pizza is worth it!…read more best pizza ever! must get the white garlic sauce!

Having a get together/birthday party/Super Bowl Sunday/bbq? Get the giant Manhattan pizza! Get it…read morecut into squares, extra crispy I've always ordered in advanced over the phone and haven't had any issues with whoever picks up and takes my order. I've ordered right when they open for pick up later in the afternoon and also ordered a day before with no issues. You can mix and match your pizza for extra cost but so worth it for the quality and the well dispersed toppings. Our pizzas always come with cheese and red pepper flakes as well. We spent about $100 on 2 giant Manhattan pizzas, with 4 different speciality toppings so there was something for everyone. Leftovers taste great in the air fryer.

This place is closed sadly, I uploaded a picture of the note left on their door. I am bummed out…read morebecause this was one of my favorite spots for giant pizzas so this place will be missed . Picture taken on Dec 6, 2025

Hands down, my favorite pizza in all of Orange County -- and honestly, probably anywhere! Every…read moretime I come here, the pizza is incredible. The crust, sauce, cheese, and fresh ingredients all come together perfectly. My absolute favorite is the Rocco's Pie. It has so much flavor and is one of those pizzas you start craving again as soon as you leave. I would come back just for that pizza alone! In all honesty, the menu can be a little difficult for me to read, but that is such a small thing compared to how amazing the food is. If you love great pizza, you definitely need to give this place a try -- and make sure you order the Rocco's Pie! Easy 5 stars from me. One of the best pizzas I've ever had!

Arrived and walked into the RR to wash up. Rr was clean with a slight bleach smell, always love…read morethat! We arrived just before the lunch rush so we were seared right away. We ordered Rocco's pie. When my husband ordered it. He asked to have it cut and that request gave me a flashback to our trip to Naples a few years ago. But I didn't think too much about it until the pie arrived. Wow!! The crust along the outside had a dry look to it which also took me back to Italy on my mind. My husband laughed at me as I tried to put a slice on a plate because you can't do it. Which is truly authentic. In Naples you eat pizza with a knife and fork because the crust is paper thin in the middle. And the outer crust is eaten more like a piece of chewy bread to sop up the sauce. This place is the real deal. Even the salt & pepper is imported from Cheflu. The crust had a lite crunch on the outside and chewy center, the sauce had the perfect amount of bite to it, the ricotta was soft and fresh. Very delightful experience! I love it so much and it reminded me so much of the pizza in Naples I went to the back to thank the chef. I'll return again and again! It was perfect!

Been wanting to come here for quite a while and it did not disappoint. Only wish we came sooner…read more Decided to sit in for the Caesar salad and take home the pizza for later. Chewy was our pleasant waiter, very friendly and attentive. Fresh cold water when we sat down and a nice short easy menu to peruse and decide from. No frills, no uneasy decisions. Simple greatness is all that's needed. I'm guessing every table gets the Caesar salad, which was a botttomless pile of fresh lettuce, tons of delicately grated smoothe Parmesan cheese, delicate crumbles of breadcrumbs, with an absolutely decadent Caesar dressing - pleasantly spread throughout the whole entire plate of goodness. Next time I will try the fresh loaf of bread sliced thick with a bowl of cherry tomatoes. Whoa that looked great. Every plate that walked by us whispered 'try me' next time!! Saved the salami Calabrese pizza for home directions on the box which provided the most perfect texture for a reheated pizza we've ever had. Delightful! The pizza. The crust. I can't even believe a whole table while we were eating there skipped the crust of the whole pie. You can't! That's a sin! Greatest sourdough pizza, dare I say delicate but hearty? Perfectly crisp yet soft where it's necessary. I can't wait to try more flavors. Such an adorable place at 'the Camp' -quaint yet plenty of seating outside too for a larger party. It's all you need for a perfect slice of heaven! Thank you Folks! We will definitely be back!

So so disappointed by this place. We were served pizza with a chemical, dish water taste. It was…read morevery noticeable in the dough and whole pizza, which tasted very chemically and much like the dirty, unfiltered type of water that you would get from a moldy sink at a sketchy place. It stunk too. We were theorizing that the dough was made with dirty water, but there was also a possibility the serving pan given to us was used unwashed. Honestly wish we were able to send it back, but there was no time for a remake as it took about 30-40 mins for it to come out in the first place. The Caesar is also very, very depressing. The dressing is missing authenticity and tastes so bland and like pure lemon, the croutons are crushed up crumbs, and it was very hard to get through for $20. We left it behind as a group of 4 with full plates. I literally got fast food fries after this to fill the disappointment and void, and I'm a health conscious eater. The only saving grace was the meatballs. They were very good, and sadly the first plate that came out as everything went downhill. Should've known as this was the only dish that stood out to us when we ate here a few years ago. We decided to give it another proper try but it does not live up to the hype at all. If you want high quality pizza with a variety of ingredients and Caesar salad, go down to X Eats inside Brewery X. Half the price of the Caesar here, and so much better. Theirs comes with proper dressing, fried capers, freshly grated pecorino, and delicious sourdough croutons made in house. The pizzas are about the same price range as here, but pepperoni is like $6 less than here, and they are much, much larger, fresh, and drool worthy.