B is for Bella's Pizza…read more I was between 4 & 5 stars, more of 4.5 stars. But rounding down only because it's not outstanding pizza, but is very good and better is at a cheap price point. A group of us were going up to Rochester in April 2024 for an unofficial wedding, love ceremony for the total solar eclipse. On our way, we ate a late lunch here. They sell pizza by the slice. And the prices were surprisingly reasonable. We had some sticker shock coming from the more expensive Maryland-Washington DC area. The staff was very nice too. The pizza was solid, not quite top notch pizza, but was above average for this cheap pizza. I got 2 slices: mushroom & chicken. The chicken were large chunks put on top. Both slices were delicious. There was some talk about stopping here again on the way back 3 days later, but we ended up eating dinner in Williamsport, which will be a 2-star review when I get to the letter J in this alphabet series. If I'm ever in Selinsgrove, I'd try to come back to this place for sure for the reasonably priced & delicious pizza.

This is a wonderful little pizza place in the 'old town' part of Selinagrove. Servings are huge--a…read morelarge anything is for sharing, as are many if the other items. Side salad comes on an huge plate, stacked with veggies, generous dressing, and half a loaf of bread with butter. We tried the veggie Stromboli, which despite its large size, was devoured completely. Great balance of fresh vegetables, gooey cheese and crisp crust.

Fresh make pizzas and good subs and really good tasteful Italian pastas yum also there salad are…read moredelicious to that there nice employees provide a well good service. I absolutely recommend this place for a good day even on a nice cold or warm day.

Our service was okay, but when the food came out it didn't look right. Now my family is facing food…read morepoisoning. MAKE SURE YOUR MEAT/ CHEESESTEAKS ARE COOKED!! will not go back.

Went for lunch. Was seated immediately. Over server was great and very attentive. I ordered the…read morecrab dip. Cheesey and creamy. It was delightful. A perfect little lunch.

Great food and service. Loved the fried zucchini. Portions for price were good. We got cherry…read morelemonade and peach lemonade and they were fabulous

We had a great waitress, Hannah who had impeccable timing, was helpful with the menu and knew her…read morestuff! The steamed class were the first thing we ordered and they were great. Next the Clams Casino, which I only ordered one because I got the steamers but I would highly recommend get 2+ because they were really good. Next we got the crab cakes and they were super tasty and had tons of meaty crab. Highly recommend the place due to the energy and overall casual but modern ambiance, food and staff.

Im giving it 3 stars because ive had 4 star meals here. Not last trip…read more Date night with my breathtaking girlfriend. We got calamari which we usually both love. This one just didn't hit.. fried with jalapeños witch seemed alittle odd and the marinara to dip in was very thick My girlfriend got the bogo chicken sandwich and she enjoyed it. I got Caesar salad with anchovies which was simple but good and french onion soup First french onion soup that came out was clearly burnt and my girlfriend said i hope your sending that back ( which i can not tell you the last time we sent anything back ... like ever) The waiter said yhea it looked burnt i was hoping you were a burnt cheese fan. Correct i was not a burnt cheese fan. The second soup came out quickly i mind you and was toasted much less. Good call since i just got one really dark. This soup was uneatable. It was beyond salty. I had my girlfriend try it and she agreed. We sent this back too and just said im good. The waiter did take the soup of the bill and gave us a free bongo dip for a future trip in the next 90 days. Which we gave as a present to the kids grandparents that were making date night happen Id go here again because generally i have a good experience here... but it might be awhile

I had a wrestling team of 22 leaving camp and so I called in 9 pies with an ETA about an hour and…read more15 minutes from that moment. I asked if they can accommodate that many and they said yes. When we arrived, all the piles were hot and ready and tasty. All staff were very friendly. AC was not working well but they warned me over the phone. We didn't mind too much because we spent the previous 4 days at camp without it. The prices were unbeatable compared to other places in the area.

This place is really good! It's always clean, the staff couldn't be any more helpful, and super…read morefriendly (even when they're crazy busy), they don't skimp on toppings, and it's ready when they say it will be. I love Pappas!

Got the Meat Lovers Pie and it gave me food poisoning... I am a student athlete who just came back…read morefrom winter break and it screwed me way behind in the start of my semester... won't be getting dominos again for awhile, especially here.

Pizza that I complained about in store to be told they received new dough the day before. Quickest…read moreway to lose a customer with how horrible it looked and even tasted. The employees were not helpful and they didn't want to make it right, corporate does not want to make it right and the store has not wanted to make it right. I used to order on at least a monthly basis.

One Star: Mother's Day Mistake…read more We should've taken the hint when every other sit-down restaurant had a waitlist on Mother's Day -- and McAlister's Deli looked like a ghost town. Turns out, we didn't stumble on a hidden gem; we wandered into the culinary equivalent of a trap. The "loaded nachos" were only loaded in the sense that someone accidentally dropped a can of dog food on some stale chips and called it a day. The chili-flavored meat product (and I use that term generously) was clearly reheated -- probably several times -- and tasted like regret. The sandwiches? Let's just say they looked nothing like the pictures, unless the pictures were taken in a parallel universe where ingredients are fresh and sandwiches have dignity. Ours were flat, sad, and suspiciously cold -- kind of like the service. For the price, I expected at least one item to resemble real food. Instead, we paid sit-down prices for drive-thru disappointment. First time here... and definitely the last.

Don't bother trying to order online. When I finally figured out how the online system worked, I…read morewent through the entire order with the automated system. After the entire order was complete, they said they couldn't connect with the restaurant. Somehow they managed to magically put me through to a live person at the restaurant, who was very nice. After going through the entire order again (except for the Cuban sandwich, which the computer told me they didn't have), they asked how I wanted to pay, which I said cash. They said they couldn't do that for a phone order, so I gave up. All in all 30 minutes of my life I'll never get back. Perhaps they could have said upfront they don't do cash for online orders?

Not bad for a Subway ... its close to where I live so I love the convenience of it .. they keep it…read moreclean. Decent.

The person working was super high energy and very sweet. I absolutely HATE mornings. waking up…read moreearly is horrible in my opinion. but seeing him super high energy and his very nice and sweet personality while talking to me was enough to make the day worth it and the food was immaculate