Went today for a redo from a former (not so pleasant) visit and this time was beyond outstanding! We didn't tell anyone about our previous experience when there and we were so happy with literally everything! From the moment we stepped in until the time we left, service was amazing and food was delicious! Espresso Martinis were a delight (shown in the picture) Overall a 10 on my must visit scale! Thank you for the wonderful experience! Oh! Almost forgot about the beignet's with the sauce were so good!!! Yummy read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Chocolate Martini, Espresso Martini, Dirty Martini, and Wine - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

See all

Always a favorite!! Best cocktails ever and their pizza!!! It's brought over from their sister venue next door--baked in a real wood fired brick oven!! It's amazing!! The crust is both chewy and soft!? Great sauce and toppings and very reasonably priced! Always good, friendly service and atmosphere!! read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Try "the bourbon drink" - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

See all

Wow! What a hidden gem! I accompanied a friend to drop off a rental and was tasked with finding a nearby place for dinner. Needless to say, I thought the menu looked good, but I was blown away by the space. Although it was cold and wet that day, the outdoor patio area looked like a place where I would spend a lot of time. Upon entering the restaurant, the interior with its wraparound booths and velvet curtains set up an intimate and upscale feel. Our server for the evening was polite and knowledgeable. I ordered a dirty martini, which came out perfectly briny for my taste. For an appetizer, we shared the fry plate with three dipping sauces, all of which were delicious and accompanied by an abundance of fries for three people. I also had the Manhattan-style clam chowder and a Caesar salad with a perfectly balanced homemade dressing. A dinner companion ordered the grilled romaine, French onion soup, and a side of grilled cheese dippers, which consisted of Texas toast grilled cheese cut into thirds. Everyone was happy with their meals, and this is definitely a place I will visit again the next time I find myself near Elmira. read more

See all

Don't go to Rye for brunch unless you are married. I had no problem waiting half an hour for a refill of what would be "very bottom" mimosas. I was genuinely happy after one hour when everyone else received their food. Then I was informed that they were out of pancakes. Not sure how that is possible, but I don't run a poorly run restaurant. After an additional half-hour wait, I received French toast with the added benefit of having no discount on the bill. I left appreciative of my wife offering half of her waffle while everyone else ate. read more

A beautiful hidden gem tucked in Elmira. The service was outstanding, both the bartenders and servers being super welcoming and personable. I ordered the fish fry special which was light and airy; it practically melted in my mouth. The cocktail menu is extensive offering plenty of creative options (especially the drink of the day). Will be coming back!! (also don't miss their popcorn machine--it's a fun little bonus while you enjoy your drink) read more

The bae was curious about this relatively new Elmira restaurant, and I'm glad we went! For appetizers he got a hummus plate and I got a duck-goat cheese thing that was in an egg roll type covering and a berry-based sauce. For mains he got a burger with onion rings and I got the Ithaca salad (couldn't resist it, as I'm currently based in Ithaca) and it was as phenomenal as it sounded with a good ratio of ingredients. They also have a drink-of-the-day special, which is a $5 drink. I had a Manhattan Rye that was so strong it made me slightly drunk and giggly (this is a good thing, life is too short for weak dilute drinks). The ambiance here is romantic (you'd want to cuddle with your partner in a booth) and it's a perfect place for a date. read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Ithaca Salad with grilled chicken, Manhattan Rye (drink of the day) - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

We had delicious cocktails and amazing service. I had a steak that was on special. Service was courteous. We were on our way to a show, and they made sure we made it! read more

Food was great. Very nice staff. Outdoor seating with the dog was wonderful. Food came out quickly despite being busy read more

The Rye Bar is a staple in Elmira, where restaurants are found few and far between. The brunch is always scrumptious, and a few of my favorites are the blueberry pancakes, chicken and waffles, and eggs benedict. I would recommend a reservation for brunch, as it gets very busy. The bloody mary is delicious, and if you're with friends I would definitely recommend the bottomless mimosas. I give 4 stars because the food can occasionally be only lukewarm and I love my food piping hot. Otherwise, I certainly recommend coming here! read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Eggs Benedict - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

Have not been to this place for a number of years. Last Thursday friends invited us to join them for dinner there. Glad we went! The food was terrific as was the service. They had a trio playing, which was nice, but a bit loud. Made it a bit harder to have a quiet conversation. Otherwise ourc3xperiencecwasxreally good. We will definitely go back there. read more

My husband and I went to the RYE for dinner. Service was very good server very pleasant. We were not impressed with our food. My husband ordered a burger medium rare. The burger came well done. We made the server aware of this. Only comment made was sorry to hear that. I had the fish fry, fish was dry . Costly meal . We could have went to fast food and got a better food. read more

Delicious food, great service, a great place to eat. Pricing was reasonable. The ginger cake for dessert is a must have. Yummy

I called the restaurant on 6/21/25 at 7:15pm to ask if they had outdoor seating and when the kitchen closes. She said there was outdoor seating and said that the kitchen is closed. I asked "doesn't the restaurant close at 8?" She said yes. So I asked, "how does that make any sense". Her response was "idk". I asked her what the issue was and she goes "we're just really busy right now and don't want to take more people". The exchange really just sounded like she didn't want me to come in despite still being opened. Do better read more

I have gotten very good at looking at a menu and finding a way to create my own vegan option and that's exactly what I did here. If you're vegan you know brunch is one of the hardest meals to find options but when I went to Rye with some friends for Sunday brunch I noticed they offered grilled tofu and had huevos rancheros on the menu as well. When I asked the server for all the accommodations to the huevos rancheros (hold the chorizo and sub grilled tofu for the eggs) she didn't even blink once! I was so thrilled with what came out- it was exactly what I was picturing and tasted so good!! It needed a little salt for my taste and I added hot sauce but I will say if you're vegan this "menu hack" worked perfectly!! Also all the people I was with enjoyed their meals as well (the bagel platter with lox, eggs Benedict with lox and the burger). Overall, I'd definitely recommend Rye if you need a satisfying vegan brunch. read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Customized the huevos rancheros (no chorizo or eggs and add grilled tofu) - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

The atmosphere is nice, the servers friendly and the food outstanding. I have never even seen halibut on any area menu. Don't miss it! read more

Casey is such a greAt waitress! The food and drinks are always exceptional . We e never had a bad meal and the service is always excellent! read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Best dinner! Casey takes such good care of us! The best salmon is at Ryes! - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

service was poor despite the place not being busy. They didn't take our order for over a half hour and we had to find someone since our wait person never came back. Our (very simple) order didn't come out for over an hour. I ended up getting ill from the food for an allergy that they said they could accommodate but unfortunately, they did not. Again, this place was not busy at all. Very disappointed as I've been looking forward to going there for quite some time. Never again. read more

The staff are always kind, and the food is always made up to par. The interior reminds me of a restaurant in Soho and gives me the city Village vibe. Nice spot. read more

The best in the area! They have a top notch staff, excellent food, expertly made drinks and offer an amazing indoor or outdoor experience. The Garage is a fun relaxing cafe by day and a destination night spot. The seating and ambience varies by style preference. There is a perfect place to sit and something on the menu for everyone. read more

Fantastic food! They change their menu around holidays for special things. The chefs are constantly trying new things and posting the photos on their Facebook page. The staff is away super nice and attentive. The owner keeps dumping money into the restaurant so it always looks great and very clean! read more

Went for brunch on a Sunday. It took 26 minutes for me to get my drink from the bar (my food came out before my drink). There were only two other tables of people when we went. The bartender was just siting at a table with people joking and laughing. Our waitress had to tell him to go make my drink. Food was okay. One person wanted no pickles on his sandwich (got pickles). The other person ordered over medium eggs (they were rawer than sunny side up). This place has potential but the service is awful. read more

Grossly overpriced appetizer of three scallops wrapped in bacon $35. Most entrées in the $35-$50 range. Nothing special about the food. Expected to pay a bit more but I really was shocked read more

We stopped in at the Rye Bar when we found our go was closed for the evening. Nice atmosphere & good food. We will definitely be back.

We had a pre show dinner. Delicious fresh salad and light vinaigrette. The prime rib was the best I've had in years. Interesting cocktails. Our garlic bread was made with excellent, soft, flavorful bread but we didn't taste garlic. That's why the 4. read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Prime rib - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

Had some dinner at the bar, and enjoyed some wine and good live jazz. The staff was excellent, nice local crowd, and the food was decent. read more

Rye Bar & Restaurant - Salmon dinner and nice glass of Zinfandel - New American Near Me - Elmira, New York

Been a while since I last reviewed this establishment. Did Sunday brunch today and it was very very good. While it was busy and the server seemed preoccupied with his other clients the food did not disappoint. And once again, as always Charlie made us feel welcome. Have introduced several of our friends to Rye and all have enjoyed their visit. Looking forward Tom visiting on St Paddy's day. Thanks again Charlie for making the visit. read more

Dined here for the first time on a Saturday night. The restaurant smelled great, looked clean and all of the staff was friendly and attentive. Ordered the marinated olives and ratatouille as appetizers, as well as a raspberry cocktail that was Michaels own concoction due to a lack of blood oranges on the house's signature margarita. The cocktail was delightful and for only $6 the plate of olives were a fun and enjoyable conversation piece. The ratatouille ended up arriving with the entrees but with one cocktail and some wine the wait wasn't noticeable. As for the entrees, the Statler chicken had a bit of an overpowering crust on it with the spotlight piece being the mashed potatoes, and the snap peas a strong supporting side. I can vouch for the very savory Medium Rare Faroe Salmon perfectly seasoned, accompanied by respectable handmashed potatoes and sautéed Bok Choy. I enjoy having a mix of flavors with each bite, nevertheless eating these ingredients separately was a palatably pleasant experience and enjoyed the individual flavors and textures. A bit of a rarity in my experience. As a tip for those that would like to try this salmon dish, the three daughters moscato made for a match in heaven. Overall a truly delightful experience. Will definitely be coming back here when visiting Elmira, New York. read more

Rye Bar is a solid restaurant in Elmira. Excellent option for a date night or work lunch. They do Sunday brunch, which is difficult to find in this area, and they do a good job at it. Anything with salmon is fresh and cooked well. Salmon and risotto for brunch and salmon BLT for lunch are both great. They also have one of the better burger in this area. Fries are great but would be perfect if they didn't over-salt them. They pair them well with some great sauces. Awesome ambiance. read more

Best food in Elmira. Great, attentive service, a parking lot available, and a nice ambience. Everything you could ask for in a restaurant. Food and drinks are delicious and fairly priced. The mac n cheese that comes with the Thursday fried chicken is to die for. The chips that come with the French onion dip are also delicious and massive. The Ithaca salad was large and had the perfect amount of dressing and ingredients. I would like to come back here and try everything. I can't say enough good things about the place. 11/10 recommend. read more

Waited 20 minutes before I called a server to our table. Food was good. Music was the best part, 4 stars for the band

Garbage. The people and the food. Way over priced for some bland eggs Benedict and a couple mimosas. Stay home and cook. Being mean to me and my dog doesnt' help their cause either. They said they like how I treated my dog and I shouldn't be a pet parent. Bella (my pup) was minding her own business out back with me and I ordered her some scrambled eggs. Neither of us did anything until they wouldn't let her in for me to pay so I went outside and they were calling the cops on my for not paying for the drink at the bar. I should habr have your tip cover it. People were completely wrong in how they treated me. Thumb down. I won't be back. read more

I absolutely love Rye Bar. All of their ingredients are so fresh. It reminds me of a farm to table dining experience. As a San Francisco native, I also get all the vibes of dining in the city. We have ordered almost everything on their menu. Everything is great. From their grilled wings, Caesar salad (best I've ever had), peanut butter jelly burger, to their salmon (OMG TRY THE SALMON), everything is amazing. This restaurant is definitely our favorite in the area. 5 stars only because I can't give them 10. The service is also above and beyond. Don't forget their amazing cocktails too! You just can't go wrong with this place. read more

See all

Disappointed Menu description doesn't match what you get Had the "steak frites" with "chimichurri" "sauce-first of all-not a sauce It was chopped parsley, green onions and red bell pepper-piled on a very small portion of sliced beef The "frites" took up 3/4 of the plate and were barely edible-salt was dumped on them. Even my table mates were grimacing from the amount of salt on these. A lot of money and wasn't worth it Won't be back read more

Yes. To everything. Yes! Always perfect. Charlie is a wonderful host. Go for every occasion.

Ahhhh, mixed. Went on a lovely jazz night. Got the impression that the server, nice lady prob early 40's had never done this before. read more

Food always good, service always slow, slow to be greeted, slow to be recognized after seated, slow to be checked on.

Great atmosphere great drinks. Great food if you're not having the overprice pork chop you're missing out it's worth every penny

Pricy; however, Food and service are excellent. Manager takes an active role in insuring customer satisfaction. Open for Brunch on Sunday. Handicapped access is a problem. Restaurant does not have a ramp. read more

Excellent food. Never had a bad meal here. Service is great. Restaurant is clean and neat. Very nice place. Definitely recommend.

Smaller menu but very well done. Food was excellent, service was impeccable and the atmosphere was very comfortable. Loved it.