This ice cream shop is busy for a reason. There was a line out the door when we went after dinner…read more They have shelves with candy, snacks, and merch near the entrance. Super smart because I ended up grabbing some candy as I waited. There's some interesting flavors like Shark Attack, and I chose the Nerds flavor and classic vanilla. I liked it way more than expected. The portion size was reasonable for the cost. Would definitely come back.

Mad Martha's is a really solid ice cream place with some classic flavors and exciting specialty…read moreflavors. I loved the Shark Attack and especially the Catboat Crunch, a delicious chocolatey toffee ice cream that I will be thinking about for a while! Good size portions but still felt a little overproduced. Overall, if you're looking for a sweet treat this place won't disappoint.

Massive line but totally worth the wait. This is not your stereotypical ice shop with regular…read moreflavors so do be mindful of that. However, this is the creamiest and BEST ice cream in Edgartown. Another note - A little tough later in the night (after 9pm) because a lot of the flavors were out by the time we got there so come which multiple flavors in mind. HIGHLY recommend the strawberry (it was the real, not syrupy/fake kind). The maple walnut was great with big chunks of walnuts. And the cookies and cream had the most cookies in cream I have ever seen.

SUMMER ONLY and worth a step in for a selection of the most unique flavors on the island. Some are…read morea bit too creamy for my liking, but always natural and hearty flavor. Creamsicle is a perennial favorite but I have enjoyed others over the years as well. Mint and cookie dough would be right behind. Wish there were more opportunities to get these sweet delights ... but on the other hand, their limited availability helps make every taste count!

Cute ice cream shop on the harbor. Lots of ice cream options in town but this one has the added…read morebenefit of being a candy shop. Lots of ice cream flavor options and a lovely view of the harbor from the back porch.

Sweets Shop by the water in Edgartown [Martha's Vineyard MA]…read more This is a cute little shop both inside and outside. It actually looks like a house with horizontal wooden siding (they call them clapboard houses). The backside has benches where you can sit and enjoy your ice cream with views of the waterfront. This is your one stop shop for your sweet tooth. Their 2023 season opened on May 5th. How fortunate that we were able to support! Their candy shelves are well stocked. They have candies of all sorts, truffles and chocolates, and, of course, ice cream! Coffee ice cream for the hubby and chocolate chip for me. So creamy and delicious with lots of chocolate chip flakes. Nom-nom-nom! Of course, when available, I always get milk chocolate peanut clusters. One of my favorite chocolate to munch on. Have a fantastic 2023 season! Review #3026

This place is the touchpoint of so many memories over years of family summer trips. It's better…read morethan Mad Martha's and there's something so satisfying about being able to grab a seat outside, eat too much ice cream and watch the world go by. And it hasn't changed in all of these years. The memories make me cry. Thank you Ben & Bill's.

I got 2 chocolates: 1 dark chocolate mog bar and 1 milk chocolate whisky truffle.Both were super…read moretasty. Came out to $5 which is very affordable for hand made chocolate. The staff here is also so friendly.

Love it. Old school ice cream parlor on the Cape run by kids with their summer jobs. Doesn't get…read morebetter than that summer time Cape Cod feeling. Plenty of seating inside and out! Ice cream is delicious!

This place is obviously a favorite for so many people but for any newbies let me fill you in on a…read moresecret - go to the inside line! We didn't realize there was an inside line and legitimately waited for like an hour and a half outside. We watched so many people come way after us and leave much before us. However, we were too committed to leave. The service was great and they had ample seating at picnic tables around. For us the ice cream wasn't worth the wait but it was still great ice cream. They definitely cater to all folks (dairy free options, vegan options, sherbet, sorbet, etc.) We both got mini splits which was a fun option and delicious but we are just as content at places with a much shorter wait. I would also recommend walking if possible because parking looked to be an absolute disaster. They even had people attempting to direct traffic and parking.

The absolute best ice cream in the island, in my opinion…read more As you leave the Whaling Museum, you will get the scent of waffle cones filling the air. Intoxicating! The kin is out the door, but moves quickly. All sort of traditional and unique flavors. Very good and high quality ice cream - and the only time I ever eat ice cream.

The Juice Bar in Nantucket is a must-stop for amazing homemade ice cream, fresh waffle cones, and…read morefun island vibes. So many great flavors to choose from, and everything tastes super fresh and rich. I'm giving it 4 stars only because the wait in the summer can be long -- lines often wrap around the block -- but the ice cream is definitely worth the wait at least once a trip.

This is my all-time favorite ice cream place. I do not even live super close to here, but when I…read morewant a good ice cream, I will make the drive over. I now live on an island - and you bet that when I went off-island last week I requested that my dad stop here on the way home from Hyannis. My dad had to say yes; having worked in the ice cream industry in his youth, he knows a good cone when he sees one and Somerset Creamery tops his list as well. Embarrassingly, we got there 10 minutes before they opened. We camped in the parking lot. When it was time to go in, I already knew what I was getting. Chocolate mint ice cream in a waffle cone. First of all, it is the best ice cream flavor ever created. Chocolate and mint ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces. What else could you ask for?? And then their waffle cones and made fresh and they are oh so good. The service is always great, and they now take credit cards!! I cannot recommend this place enough. The only downside is that they do not have any dedicated seating, inside or outside. There are some planters of sorts that you can sit down on. Once I sat on one for three hours for a first date - can't say I recommend that. But if you want good ice cream, come here! (Yes, it is better than the Barn in my opinion).

The special flavor Carrot Cake is SO good!!!!! I came here for the first time this past week. I…read morecannot believe I have never been here! Cannot wait to come back this spring & summer! The staff was super friendly, and it was a nice environment.

What a hidden gem in South Chatham! We stayed at a Cape house just down the block from Short N'…read moreSweet, and I am so glad we did. This ice cream is awesome! We visited twice. The first time was a Sunday night in May and the line was literally out of the door! And I quickly understood why. Their ice cream is soooo good. Like seriously AMAZING. And even better? The bang for your buck! This is some of the most price favorable and high quality ice cream I've ever tried. Their XXL, which is 6 scoops and huge, is $8.90. I am shocked! Staff is also super nice and explained all of the flavors we had questions about to us. I tried their chocolate, strawberry, raspberry chocolate chip, s'mores, and phantom berry ice cream. All were amazing. My favorites were definitely the chocolate, s'mores, and phantom berry ice creams. All amazing options, I would seriously recommend this place!

This remains my favorite ice cream spot. Their ice cream is from a farm in Mass. They have 3 areas…read morewhere you can order the ice cream, the front, inside and a window in the back. Easy parking. Additional flavors added to my favorites list: -Phantom berry -Butter crunch -Orange pineapple -Watermelon sorbet The grapenut custard is fantastic and hands down my favorite. It is weird to say that since I don't like grapenut cereal, but here we are!

The ice cream barn never disappoints. There is often a very long line, but it is worth the wait…read more They are incredibly efficient even when the line is wrapped around the building. The staff is always super nice. The waffle cones are made fresh in front of you and are so delicious. There are lots of great flavors but the Reese's Heath bar specialty flavor is my favorite. They used to have several dairy free options but those have been off the menu recently so definitely check before waiting in line if that's what you're looking for.

I have been a few times years ago, and lately there's been so much hype that I had to go back…read more I ordered an apple pie & pb oreo Sunday with whipped cream. It was ok, I was definitely expecting more of a flavor bomb with the apple pie. It was sort of bland. I wss hoping for crazy cinnamon and apple flavor.

Who wants wonderful Cape Cod ice cream, and/or even more?! This is the place to make the stop, and…read morewon't regret it. I've personally never heard of it, until I was mentioned about it. The options speaks for itself, a lot of variety and topings to choose from, which you can go basic or go with their customized offerings. There's something here for everyone, and it's okay to take your time. The layout is very nice, with the inside being fairly small, but enough to fit to order and eat outside. Plenty of chairs are provided, set up extremely nice. The colors add the whole atmosphere, and feel. Pricing is decent for what you get, and for a non-chain, come for it!

The whipped cream on me and my boyfriend's milkshake made us sick. Please be wary if you want to…read moreadd it on your ice cream or milkshakes unless you like feeling sick