Delicious ice cream and they DEFINITELY don't skimp you on the oreo! We ordered the regular oreo and coffee oreo- $6 each for a sizable "small" serving. Service was fast and there were a few outdoor tables to pick from. Ice cream tastes creamy and homemade and worth the stop! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

This spot was busy every evening during my trip. After giving it a try, I totally understood why there were lines - the ice cream is good! There were plenty of flavors to select from. I chose a special, S'moreo, in a kiddie cone that was surprisingly filling. The ice cream was creamy and had the perfect amount of Oreos and marshmallow swirls. Overall, it was a good experience - the lines moved fast and the ice cream was delicious! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Great local spot for some yummy ice cream! It seemed very busy but the line went by quick. Quick and efficient service but with a smile! and the colors are so welcoming. My friends and I tried various flavors including the special and we loved it! we were able to sit outside and enjoy our ice cream with the night breeze. Would definitely come back!! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Cookie Monster Ice cream (Kiddie Size Cup) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

So good, we went twice in one trip!! Got the brownie sundae w/ coconut chip and the honeycomb lavender in a cone, both were delicious. it's a small space in the actual store but there's sm seating outside Def recommend xx read more

See all

I ordered from the outside window. I first tried the cape cod sand mystery flavor. It was delicious, and I'm not sure what's in it. I had a small scoop of death by chocolate. It's a big scoop for $5.37. There's plenty of outdoor seating on the deck. The server said this is the only location. read more

See all

If you're like me, you will not be able to resist a goodie. First off, you will not want to forgo delicious house made ice cream, as there's something for everyone. Sorbet, low fat yogurt, vegan dairy free... They have your tried and true flavors here as well as creative ones depending on your mood. Size and cone choices and toppings etc available and so on. Nothing better than a break on a nice outdoor patio, to stop and enjoy your treat. And oh boy, do they scoop up a generous sized serving! No complaints here, and I will happily have at it!! read more

See all

I have been coming to ice cream shops for decades, and I have never in my life seen prices this outrageous. Fifteen dollars for two small ice creams? Absolutely ridiculous. Whoever decided those prices must think money grows on trees. I apologize for the following graphic language, but after ordering the Cookie Monster flavor, I spent the rest of the evening glued to the toilet, and to my horror everything was bright green. I nearly thought something was seriously wrong with me before realizing it must have been all the food coloring. Between the outrageous prices and that unpleasant surprise, I can honestly say I won't be returning. There are plenty of local ice cream shops that charge fair prices and don't leave you questioning your life choices afterward. read more

Walking down Main Street in Cape Cod Hyannis, saw this store Katie's Homemade ice cream, they have many different combinations of ice cream. We ordered three scoop flavor ice cream, Cape Cod Mud, (coffee, fudge swirl, almonds, oreo, chocolate chips, Salty Caramel, Coconut Cheese Cake limited time special. The ice cream was smooth and creamy good flavors, good portion size serving. read more

See all

Such a quaint little ice cream shop that offers a load of flavors. There's something for everyone who wants to enjoy ice cream. They offer choices including regular ice cream, sorbet, sherbet, dairy free and gluten free options. There were a ton of flavors to choose from! I loved they offer a peppermint ice cream in August. Usually I have to wait for the holidays, so this was a special treat. They also have chocolate dipped waffle cones as an option, very tasty! Peppermint ice cream: 4 (good flavor but could have used some peppermint chunks) Chocolate chip ice cream: 2 (bland chocolate and bland ice cream flavor) Coffee Oreo: 4 (lots of cookie pieces) Caramel Macchiato: 4 (exceptional flavor). Butter Pecan: 4 (nice ratio of pecans) Cookies and Cream: 4 Maple Walnut: 2 (too sweet) All the ice cream s homemade. The young people who worked there are friendly. Service was pretty speedy. There are places to sit outside but not inside. They do offer some water and other drinks. read more

Was so excited to try Katie's. When I saw they had an old favorite flavor from childhood, butter crunch, I couldn't wait to taste it. We went around 2:30pm on Sunday, August 10. There were only a few people in the shop, no crowd. The cashier didn't look up when she said "can I help whoever is next". I said hello and ordered the 2 butter crunch cones. The ice cream was soup, so she put them in cups and stuck the cones on top, not the experience we were looking for. When I tasted it, the flavor was good, but there were no little bits of "crunch". I went back in to tell her, thinking maybe she used the end of a bucket and could open a new one. She just said that the caramel must have softened the crunchy bits. No offer to make it right by giving us something different, or an apology. Yummy, sweet soup, but overall very disappointed. I love to support small businesses, but they need to up their game. read more

The ice cream was delicious of course, I had the Cape Cod Sand and the Cape Cod Mud, both of which satisfies. Katie's considers most of their signature ice cream with "secret ingredients". The place is cute with plenty of seating outside. The service is good however a bit slow causing people having to wait outside and lines to form. I get it, it's all hand made and prepared plus if someone gets a banana split or the like it can be time consuming. The prices are what I expected for the Cape. All in all a good stop for a sweet tooth :) You can trust me, I've been to an ice cream shop or 20 ;D read more

Katie's Ice Cream - I'll have the Cape Cod Sand :) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

We passed Katie's Ice Cream on our way to dinner so its presence on our walk home so we had the subsequent hour and a half to think about passing it again on our walk home and you already know how that turned out. They have a very large patio outside the small interior which was absolutely jam packed with people eating ice cream. It's quite a scene. The ice cream gods were looking down on us because somehow there was only a line to the doors on the inside of the place which moved quickly. They have a GAZILLION ice cream flavors, a million soft serve flavors, and even VEGAN ice cream flavors. I was considering switching it up and going for one of their vegan varieties until GF brought to my attention that they have my soul mate ice cream flavor COOKIE MONSTER which I proceeded to order in a cake cone. One scoop was $5.50 or thereabouts. The ice cream is definitely tasty but as GF pointed out, a touch on the sweet side. When we left, the line was wayyyy out the door so I guess timing is everything. Don't think I wouldn't go back. read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Cookie monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

What a unique shop! Hotdogs AND ice cream?!? We stopped here and tried it all - the fellas in our group had hotdogs and sausages, reporting them as tasty though not the crunchy kind you get when steamed. My gal pal and I tried the ice cream. I delighted in the vegan chocolate truffle and was totally pleased. For a vegan flavor I was very impressed by the smooth texture, the taste had no hints of the base so I couldn't tell what kind of milk was used which is a tell tale sign of clean ingredients and careful mixing! Great spot, lots of outdoor seating, worth a visit! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Hot sausage! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

Don't ask them what the Cape Cod Sand flavor - my guess entry level staffers will now be seasoned top secret government workers after working here. Their Cape Cod Mud has coffee, so we asked if the Sand had coffee too as we didn't want to have any of the kids to sample coffee late at night. Again the stock answer of they cannot disclose anything. The head scratcher it will be if you sample / order. It is delicious but hard to say what it is, it definitely has bits of chocolate, and cookie/crumb dust that makes the sand(it did not taste like coffee). If you are worried about allergies, I doubt they would even reveal much(at least regarding the Cape Cod Sand, they had descriptions for the other flavors). That said, the ice cream is rich and flavorful. It's tight inside to order but there is outside porch with plenty of tables and seats. read more

So many flavors. Even had soft serve in different flavors, but it was a bit melty. Very cute place. Vegan and allergy friendly options. read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Strawberry soft serve special and vegan passion fruit - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Oh my god I will always love Katie's. But!!! I got the root beer vanilla ice cream drink that I was expecting to be a rootbeer float but it wasn't it was BETTER. They blend the rootbeer and ice cream together so it all becomes the foamy part of the float which I think is the best part. It made it so there was always the perfect ratio of rootbeer to creamy ice cream flavors and I loved it. Their dairy free caramel my friend wasn't crazy about and said it was more of a sherbet but I've had their regular dairy flavors and they're all very good. Small inside just enough to order and then seating outside, and there's an outside window for quick ordering of more popular flavors. read more

Not bad at all. Standard ice cream shop. Watermelon sherbet! Chairs not sticky. Great location.

The scoops here are HUMONGOUS, and the prices are very good. Very underrated icecream place. Katie's is a must try if you are in the area. read more

Katie's Ice Cream - dark chocolate chip and cape cod sands - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Ok Katie's Ice Cream how I love thee... alwys made on propertee.. fresh and creamee. I took my pops here tonight. It was his first time, but not mine by any stretch of the imagination. He ordered his "usual", a scoop of strawberry. I had the brownie Sundae, which was fantastic (as always!). They never have a lot of seating, so, it's even a bit less now, you know.. Covid. So, that just means, take those yummmmmmmy snacks to go, and find yourself a nice spot on the beach or somewhere else in nature. There are tons of places to explore. The flavors are still on point amazeballs, the staff is fantastically sweet. If you're in the area, stop by. And by "in the area" I mean like. 50 mile radius. read more

See all

Very good ice cream and service was great. Great location downtown Hyannis. Worth the trip.

No complaints to be had! Prices seemed reasonable for the area. We were recommended this place at dinner by our waiter at "Tugboat". We also read online that this ice cream place was one of the better places on Cape Cod. The ice cream was good. The service was fast! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Sign - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

My mom and I were looking for an ice cream spot in Hyannis, and I'm so happy we decided on Katie's! This homemade ice cream spot has so many cool flavors! The inside is small, but they have lots of outdoor seating with tables and chairs. I had to get a waffle cone because they were making them fresh and the smell was too tempting! I got one of their special flavors. I can't remember the name, but it was salted caramel ice cream with chocolate cake, caramel swirl, and pretzels. OMG was it amazing! The texture of the ice cream was perfect and the combo of flavors was perfection. The waffle cone was equally as amazing! My mom loved the salted caramel flavor, which is on their regular menu. We were said we were only in Hyannis one night because we wanted to go back for more Katie's ice cream! Definitely a must try in Hyannis! read more

Just rename "Death by Chocolate" Maybe Death by Beige or Bored to Death. No chocolate color or flavor. This place is way overhyped and overpriced. But it's pretty and it has a nice patio so if it's more about the experience than the ice cream, this is the place to go. read more

On our most recent visit to Katie's we got a ton of attitude for wanting to order a frappe, which is on the menu. I get that they take longer to make but then why have it on the menu? With so many options around I probably wouldn't come back. read more

I have an allergy and they were able to double check. Sadly, I was allergic to most things on the expansive menu. If you have an allergy I wouldn't recommend due to the limited options. My partner got ice cream and enjoyed it, so would recommend for non allergy people. read more

Love Katie's ice cream. Coming to the Cape means multiple trips here. I am usually a hard ice-cream fan but something about their soft serve has me coming back for more. However, you're here to hear about the hard ice cream because there are so many flavors to choose from. They have a menu that stays the same and then they have an additional menu that changes month-to-month which is fun. The ice cream is so fresh and they make their waffle cones/bowls around the clock--which means you're going to smell fresh waffle cones whenever you stop in. read more

See all

Human and pup cups were amazing. I got the special recipe sand ice cream. It's a small place there was a line when we got there but it moved really quick! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Most epic pup cups! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Amazing ice cream. So fresh and delicious. Highly recommend stopping here if you are in the area.

Awful awful service. Girls behind the counter did not help the one girl serving us. One tiny tiny scoop was $6???? Crazy, subpar & awful.g read more

Katie's Ice Cream - A rip off - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

This home-made ice cream is definitely super good! We got the vanilla soft serve with Oreo crunch. The ice cream was creamy and not overly sweet. The portions were also pretty generous. They also have an outdoor seating area where people can relax to finish their ice cream once the order it and pick it up from their indoor space. Would definitely recommend for anyone looking for a solid ice cream place! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Vanilla soft serve with Oreo crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

June 2021 Lots of flavor choices. Friendly staff and outdoor seating. So many flavors to choose from. I went with lavender honeycomb and coconut raspberry. Both flavors were delicious and not too strong in flavor (Lavender did not taste like soap to me. How do I know what soap tastes like? I bet you would like to know.) Other family member had pistachio and that was tasty also. The kids scoop size is a perfect size and not too much. read more

Katie's Ice Cream - June 2021 Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Katie's ice cream make all of their ice cream and cookies in house, so that's a plus for me! Ordered pistachio hard scoop ice cream (kids scoop). Unfortunately, the flavor tasted more like almond and wasn't as creamy as I would like. But I would come back here again and try a different flavor. They have a variety of selections of what you can order. I can see this place is hoppin' during the summer in Hyannis. read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Pistachio - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

After spending a little time on the Cape I see they really love their ice cream here. So much so, it should be called "Cape Cone". I dig it.. I too love ice cream. I love Katie's (I also have a couple of cool friends named Katie I really dig as well). I kinda stumbled upon this place by walking down the street I saw Katie's was really hopping so it made me think they must offering up something really special. Checking out the menu and seeing the interesting flavors confirmed I needed to try some. Had a taste of the Cape Cod Sand because it is their secret recipe - my wife and I both enjoyed it so she got a cone. I decided to go with the Cape Cod Mud in a freshly made waffle cone to try something different. It hit the spot! I love these independent ice cream spots - Katie's is one of the better ones. Stop in and give it a try - everyone else is! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Cape Cod Mud in a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Up in Cape Cod on vacation and after a long day of exploring "appy hours" in downtown Hyannis, it's time for ice cream! We don't want that Ben & Jerry's, Basking Robins or Carvel stuff... we want that REAL homemade in-house one-of-a-kind stuff! So here we are! Atmosphere/Appearance: Right on the Main Street with a big sign out front and a huge open deck to welcome you in, you have this place. Inside it looks like... well, an ice cream shop. Lol. Plenty of flavors to choose from and a large sitting room for you to scarf down your favorite desserts. Don't forget to check out the flavors that are in the metal containers behind the glass freezer displays. It's easy to miss them. Service: Everyone was so friendly and helpful. No matter how many samples Tiffany and I wanted to try, they gave them to us with a smile while even recommending others for us to try. This made wanting to grab some dessert from here even easier. Food: I went with 3 scoops because I wanted more variety. I went with Cookies & Cream on the bottom (were I normally save the best for last), Cape Cod Sand in the middle and Cookie Monster on top. Each flavor was SO delicious and packed with flavor. You could really taste the love and passion in each bite. I also had them all in a waffle bowl for easier eating and whatever melts just goes right in the bowl... then you taste the flavors all over again! Value: Three scoops in a waffle bowl ran about $8.00. That's quite pricey, but you're paying for quality and the service here. Certainly worth it. I loved this place. It was a great way to finish our very first night in Cape Cod and I'd totally come back here in a heartbeat. read more

I'm glad we stopped in and got homemade ice cream here rather than down the street at Ben and Jerry's, which I could find at home or in my local grocery store. All three flavors I tried in my large cone were pretty good. I admit it wasn't my favorite ice cream ever, but it was pretty darn good! The girl who helped us was nice and let me taste probably 6 flavors before choosing my 3 to go in my waffle cone. Oh, the waffle cone was so good...when on vacation...just go for it! I got scoops of cape cod sand, coconut almond chip and...one of the coffee flavors. Yum! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Three scoops in a waffle cone is $8. Would be $6.50 in a regular cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

Great, quality ice cream, located in a quaint renovated home. Try their flavors, they have some unique ones like honey lavender and ginger lemon cookie. Eat ice cream on the wooden deck or front... And have a nice time with family! Ps, don't miss out on the homemade delicious waffle cones! Once you smell them, you'll want one too! read more

Katie's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

See all

BEST ICE CREAM IN NEW ENGLAND!!!!!! SOOOOO yummmmmy. I'll drive to cape cod any day, just to get this ice cream read more

Katie's Ice Cream - outside of restaurant - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Hyannis, Massachusetts

It was ok but not worth the hype honestly. Maybe I'm missing something? The pistachios ice cream felt odd in texture. Sorry!

There are no words to describe this ice cream. Lavender and honey crumb flavor beyond this world!

A must stop if you are walking the main streets of Hyannis. It's pricey but memorable. Sample a few flavors to cull your curiosity and then get a cone of real ice cream. read more