When my husband and I walked it, we were immediately welcomed by Vinny. The shop is the bakery/deli with a few shelves and cooler for store related items. We ordered and subs and Vinny got right to work, very efficient. I got the Italian assorted sub and it was very good. It was like a taste of summer. read more

See all

I certainly won't ever come back to Vinny's. Drove 15 minutes to Vinny's only to find they closed up early with no forewarning. Their website indicates they are open untill 6 pm on Sundays, but when I arrived at 5:45 I found they were closed early. I won't let Vinny's ever waste my time again. Vote with your wallet, people. read more

Convenient location Quality food Great pricing I want to give Vinny's a 3.5, but that's not an option. It's a small mom and pop shop. Not too many left now a days. We stopped by on a Monday afternoon to pick up subs for lunch. We walked from Perinton park and back. Service was great. As soon as we walked in, I assume Vinny was behind the counter taking our order than into the back to make it. Sub ingredients seemed fresh. Shelf's had items in boxes still and the shop looked a little bit in a disarray. Maybe they are retiring soon? Not sure, but location is great if you are at the park/skate park with kids. read more

See all

An adorable little Italian Bakery run by a sweet older couple and the wife's sister - everything is delicious but their fresh baked bread is amazing for sandwiches! read more

Always visit when possible, a good staple deli to have in the area. Such friendly service. read more

See all

I'm going in for back-to-back reviews; not usually my jam but the world needs to know. This time, for the Genoa salami sub that Vinny made with such love! The bread was outstanding and exactly what you want from a classic hoagie - a crisp, snappy crust, and pillowy soft on the inside. Although I really wanted the large, I restrained and ordered the medium....lesson learned, always go with your gut. My sub was made to order and packed with what seemed like a pound of freshly sliced Genoa salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil and vinegar. The best sub I've ever had - flavor abounding. If you're patron of anywhere else for subs, do yourself a favor and give Vinny's a try. No, I didn't get a pic because it didn't last long enough to take one read more

The soft Rolls and bread here , when fresh, are as good as any bakery in the area. Unfortunately my last two bread purchases were borderline stale and fully stale after a few days. Doubtful I will return. read more

Bonnie and his sister are very nice. The stuffed breads are so good. They are wonderfully accommodating.

The hype is real. Please do not sleep on the pizza and vibes of this place! Nowhere in town will you find a better price to deliciousness ratio. read more

Good stuff Doesn't get any better than this. Like the good old days when all bakeries made their own bread. Wish I lived closer. read more

My husband and I had put the bikes in the car at our house in Rochester, and parked in Fairport, to ride along the Erie Canal Towpath trail between Fairport and Macedon -- we were hungry for lunch after our ride. We followed a group of bicyclists into the parking lot of Vinny's and are SO GLAD we did! After a quick peek at all of the stellar reviews on Yelp, we went inside to order subs. They were ready quickly, the owners made them for us and engaged us in great conversation while creating our lunches. Can you say DELICIOUS?!?!?! We shopped around their grocery store of authentic imported Italian foods, and did end-up leaving with a container of frozen lemon ice. The cookies and breads were SUPER tempting. We'll be back for sure, and recommend you go NOW ... so good! No reason to delay! We wish we'd known about them earlier!!! read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Italian sub for lunch after a long bike ride .... sooooooo good!!! - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

My cousin owns this place. Get it? Get it? Not really my fave place. Service wasn't great, although I respect what the guy is trying to do. Some of the prices are okay, some are a little over the top. I didn't enjoy my sandwich much, or the baked dessert goods I tried. They weren't awful. Comparing it directly to nearby Rubino's in Irondeqoit, I know which one I'd pick, but at the same time this is a little family-owned place with plenty of stuff inside for you to discover and enjoy. It's worth a trip especially if you're into Italian Delis, which I usually am. I wouldn't say it was Deli-teful, but I'll still llc them on facebook. read more

See all

Hands down is the best hoagie around Rochester. Vinny makes each sandwich by hand, shaves the meat fresh off the block, and exceeds your expectations! Try the Sicilian pizza too!! Vinny's is the best! read more

Great place to get Italian bread. They have imported tomatoes and seafood. Great Olive oil and fresh grated Romano . Great sandwiches and cannoli read more

We love his pizza! If you like an authentic crust with a crispy outside and soft center, you have to try Vinny's!

Small Italian bakery. Vinny was the only person there. Had an enjoyable chat with him. Seems to really put his whole heart into his family and then his store. There are a small smattering of Italian must haves for sale. Small selection of pastries and bread. I got a sub. The large is kind of a medium compared to like diBella. The best part of the sub is the bread - classic Italian bread with good chewiness and satisfying yet not fluff like some subs. I should have gotten the Italian meats but wasn't thinking and got roast beef. Would I go back? Yes to talk to Vinny. Not really to buy Italian goods - Wegmans and Leo's are relatively close by with much bigger selection. Possibly for the bread because I prefer his bread to his closest competitors; no for pastries - selection is limited. Maybe for the subs - I still think there is only one sub shop I would drive out of my way to go to (it's in irondequoit) read more

Vinny's is like stepping back in time when you could get authentic Italian food at reasonable prices. Vinny goes out of his way to accommodate your every culinary desire. We ordered a large pizza tonight with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions and peppers. The toppings covered the pizza... So plentiful. The crust was crisp and delicious. From pizza, to subs, to Italian cookies and pastries, Vinny is the best. ​​​​​ read more

Everybody loves Vinny ,, whats not to Love It's a great deli which supplies the local restaurants with wonderful bread, cookies, desserts, cheese, deli meats and pizza dough It's like having a uncle in the deli business if Vinny if it is not too busy ask him to sing some opera for you he was a professional opera singer 30 years ago read more

See all

All fantastic and Vinny is a gem! Pizza and the 2 subs we got were great. Next visit is for cause and lunch meat but sure a sandwich will find its way on the list. read more

First time visiting Vinny's and I will absolutely be back! Vinny personally helped me out & was so so sweet- he even let me try out some cookies before buying! The subs are so delicious & fresh... homemade bread is a game changer. I can't wait to try some of the other baked goods he had on display. Don't wait- go get some subs & treats at Vinny's! read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Cannolis & another delicious treat that idk the name of! - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

Had their pizza for the first time this evening. I called to order 3 pizzas and they were ready in about 25 minutes. The crust is a thinner style, which I love. It has the correct balance between crunch and chew. The sauce tastes like it was made this afternoon. It's not sweet and the tomato is the star with an amazing flavor profile. The ratio of sauce to cheese was a bit more sauce than cheese. I look for this and Vinny nails it. We also ordered a 1/2 pound of assorted Italian cookies. Vinny assured me they are homemade. He gave me one to try as a testament to that fact. Store-bought Italian cookies tend to be bland. These taste like nonna was slaving with a rolling pin and flour all day long. read more

Vinny's is a treasure. His subs are amazing! Today we tried the potato pizza and a pepperoni pizza. Call ahead because they make it from scratch, to order. The pepperoni pizza was delicious and the potato pizza was a unique, delicious treat - sliced potatoes, onions, and cheese between a top & bottom layer of dough. The fresh baked cookies are sooo good too! And the prices are amazing, especially considering everything is fresh & homemade. Vinny & his cousin who run the deli are so kind! read more

See all

I think that I may have found a new favorite pizzeria. Both the pepperoni pizza and the service were excellent. Vinny (I assume) was extremely friendly and courteous. I ordered over the phone and the pizza was ready within 25 minutes. This pizza was some of the best that I have had in Rochester. The quality is right up there with Nino's and the Pizza Stop. The price, simply, can't be beat. $10.81 out the door for a large pepperoni pizza of this quality is a steal. Vinny also proceeded to give me two dimes instead of 19 cents back which I really appreciated. All in all, I will definitely recommend Vinny's and I will be back. read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Underside of the crust - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

I took my sister here today to get her favorite turkey sub in Monroe County. She loves it here at Vinny's. Quiet, small but packed with lots of Italian specialties. Vinny is down to earth and makes a point to interact with each of his customers. Great place by the park and canal in Fairport. read more

If you know you know, this is the place to be. Most underrated pizza and wings around, this is my go to spot to get takeout for gameday. Actually though, the crust has the perfect crunch and chew, the toppings are loaded and fresh. The baked wings are a great alternative to the usual fried. They're saucy, well seasoned and quite literally falling off the bone while not being dry at all. If you want basic white bread or rolls or burger buns, this place has the freshest. Italian cookies aren't really my thing but they look fresh. The Italian sub here is my go to favorite. Hell the guy even makes his own homemade fresh mozzarella. This place epitomizes freshness, and is quite close to my platonic ideal of a family run small business. Ask them to do custom stuff, they're the nicest most accommodating people around. read more

Many classics deli options, all for a fair price. Pizza comes in regular and Sicilian slices, the subs are portioned well and made with fresh, great tasting ingredients and there are many dessert options to be found as well. There is also shelving for small grocery items and chips, as well as a fridge for other small items and drinks. Super friendly owners running the shop each time I've been in read more

You know what? For at least the bakery half of the store (haven't tried anything else!), Vinny's is OK by me. It's absolutely a taste of the old world. There's nothing too fancy about it, there's nothing too gourmet, hipster, or modern about it, but boy, do they make a delicious cookie. It's somewhat unassuming, but I guess that's why you don't judge a book by its cover! One of the things that makes Vinny's so authentic has to be Vinny himself. Everything is 100% homemade, and you can see it in the man behind the confections. You can see his hand-moldings on each of the cookies or the slightly imperfect twists from squeezing spritz cookies out of the star nozzle on a piping bag. You can taste it in the all-too-well-known almond or lemon flavor in each of the cookies he prepares. As soon as you walk in and meet the family, you can tell they've easily been baking for 50 years, and the taste really delivers. Of particular note, I absolutely have to commend the cucidati which are essentially Fig Newtons on crack. Super soft, tender dough filled with fig paste topped with a crisp vanilla glaze? Lord knows I'll be eating them all week. And the super soft vanilla taralli doughnuts? Not too sweet, not too heavy, and tastes just like biting into a pillow. If you've never had a real cookie melt in your mouth before, these taralli absolutely will. So I would absolutely say, give it a go! While you won't be impressed with the inside, you will be impressed by the inside of their cookies. Hot damn. read more

Good pizza and subs made by an old world man. And leave the gun.. take the fantastic canoli. read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Leave the gun... take the $1.50 canolis - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

Delicious subs, fresh ingredients, great spot near the park to grab a sub and enjoy the canal! read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Great subs! Love the homemade bread! - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

Excellent service, very informed about his products. The lemon cookies are AMAZING, and his prices are great!

Wow! Their bread is amazing!! DiBella's/Wegmans subs had been top notch with me for years but Vinny's blows them away! I moved down the street over a year ago and have been wanting to get to Vinny's for some time. I finally stopped in this past Saturday and will probably be back one day this week to pick up some more mouth-watering food. Vinny and his wife are the sweetest. When I walked in, Vinny was sitting and catching up with a friend. Before the friend left, while my sub was being made by Vinny's wife, Vinny walked over and grabbed a sampling of Easter bread. He offered to his friend and the 3 other people in line, including myself. Wow! So warm, friendly and inviting AND they make delicious food. Thank you for Vinny's for being the perfect stop for food and baked goods. read more

Lives in Fairport for several years and enjoyed Viinny's food. Moved away 5 years ago but was in town for a few weeks and was able to get a meatball sub. Yummy! Meatballs were great as was the sauce. Of course the bread made on site was soft and delicious. Topped it off with some Italian cookies and I was happy. read more

Great mom n pop Italian shop. We love the subs here, and when we visit Fairport every year we always make a point of eating here at least once. read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

See all

Sadness could be described as a soft cannolli. I also bought a spinach bread to share with friends. I can't say there was a lot of flavor, there was spinach represented but it also didn't seem fresh. I guess I may be partial to the garlicky, oily sauteed spinach bread I used to have as a kid, sometimes with sauce brushed on top so it was tarter than dipping it in. read more

Vinny is a great guy that makes a killer sandwich. It's my go to steak sauce. This place is more than just subs though. Pizza, breads, desserts, etc. read more

Vinny ALWAYS greets me with a smile, a joke, and a damn good sandwich! The other stuff here is good as well and you cant go wrong with the down home feel you get with talking with the owner. The prices are reasonable and they have a small area you can sit and eat and just let the rest of the world pass you by for a little while. Definitely worth stopping in! read more

I have had subs and cannoli mainly but a few other baked goods here and there. Chocolate filled cannoli are a pregnancy craving right now and these hit the spot every time. Soooo good, and my goodness The two folks in there (i think cousins) are an amazing team and are some of the sweetest most hospitable people I've ever met. I am so glad I live so close we will be regulars and I can't wait to order party trays of pastas when my family comes to town (I'm not Italian I would rather buy from an amazing cook than make my own sad pasta) read more

Vinny's Bakery & Deli LLC - Delis Near Me - Fairport, New York

i wish the owner would stop giving out his political and racial views as I will no longer shop here. food here is very good but I do not need nor want someone bothering me with their beliefs and ramblings! read more

Amazing breads! If you need a quick sandwich or some last minute pastries I would recommend this place. The bread is always fresh and it's great to support local businesses! read more

I'm from upstate NY but have moved away. Whenever I visit home and my dad in Fairport, Vinny's is a MUST! The pizza is out of this world good and I love that it's a small mom and pop place. That makes it so much better. The Italian cookies and canolis are amazing too. I live in Philly now, about a mile from the Italian market, and it has nothing on Vinny. Can't wait to go back! read more