Moved to West Islip and have been in search of a good bagel place for a year and we finally tried Wally's and it's everything weve been searching for. It's clean and they have good af bagels!! They line is always very long but I don't mind waiting for a good bagel! read more

Lots of help behind the counter so you don't wait long to be served. Bagels are good and soft.

Best bagel store in north Babylon, monster sized bagels and killer egg sandwiches, staff is efficient and knowledgeable.

The best bagels I've ever had. Soft and fresh; with a great verity. They follow Covid protocol very well and are excellent in customer service. read more

You WILL have to wait on a probably very long line to get dough shaped into a circle, and you WILL NOT regret it. I moved off of the island a few years ago and every time i come back i INSIST wherever i am that i have to stock up on bagels- only from Wally's. Growing up on Long Island i have had my fair share of bagels, time and time again i will always go back to Wally's. read more

Like their egg bagels, which have softer outside than most New York style bagels. Their strawberry and bluberry cream cheeses are also good. I live in the neighborhood and have been going here for years. Do not like Toast app they use to pre-order for pickup. Accidentally ordered 2 dozen when the app added my previous order to my current order. There was no option to cancel or revise incorrect orders in the app. Wally's does not have "light" (lower calorie) cream cheese, which is available at other bagel stores in the vicinity. read more

I call bull on everyone shitting on wallys bagels If u don't like the food then u don't know good food There's penalty of other shit hole in the wall where you can go cry at read more

Very busy local shop in our area. When things are busy you know its good. Being able to consistently get fresh soft bagels is very difficult to find nowadays. I travel for a living and can honestly say there are no bagels like wallys. The kids wont allow us to order anywhere else. I highly recommend Wallys read more

I've lived in the area for over 10 years and this place USE to be great .... They Clearly state there hours are 5-5 so when I call to place an order for pick up at 4 ... a whole hour before they close and the phones are being ignored while employees should still be working is ridiculous no wonder people I know have told me they started going else where the customer service and even food taste has gone down so badly in the past couple years at Wally's better off going to NB bagels they treat you much better and only 3 minutes away ! read more

This place has decent bagels and sandwiches but the service is extremely slow and servers rude. I ordered 5 sandwiches on the phone and this was a big mistake. Not only did they get the orders wrong, and put wrong meat in a sandwich, they insisted and argued that I ordered 6 sandwiches. If there were other delis open everyday, I would not choose this one If you are not a patient person with a lot of time to spare don't come here. My experience had been less than satisfactory. read more

Good sandwiches, bad omelettes. I just got this and before someone asks, I did not drop the bag nor did I get into a car accident before I opened this. This is the way I got it. This is my egg white omelette with spinach , feta and tomato. SMH read more

Wally's Bagels - Egg white omelette with spinach feta and tomatoes. - Bagels Near Me - North Babylon, New York

One of my favvvvvorite places to get a breakfast sandwich on Long Island! If I'm in Western Suffolk I'm definitely going to Wally's to get my bacon, egg & cheese, with salt, pepper & ketchup. This picture does not justify how good my sandwich was & looked. read more

Wally's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Great bagels, I've been a customer for years... they have so many variety of choices to choose from with bagel options and cream cheese... never had a issue. Best bagels around ! read more

The best bagels on the Island...always a line out the door which makes me thankful that they now accept phone orders. Probably the only good thing to come as a result of covid 19. read more

We are long term customers that will not be back after this visit. Each time we returned they have gotten cheaper each time. This time I had ordered a turkey egg whites and cheese on a scooped out and toasted bagel. THIS is what i received. can you even find the turkey? because it was one slice cut in half to fit the bagel. i understand the bagels are big however when ordering an egg sandwich and paying the price i did, i would expect for there to be a little more to it. it also wasn't toasted. you can't really go wrong with their bagels with cream cheese but egg sandwiches are a HARD NO. don't do it!! don't waste your money!!!!! wasn't worth the calories so i just ate the tiny bit of egg and turkey that was on there. absolutely ridiculous. read more

Wally's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - North Babylon, New York

See all

The lines might be long, the bagels are worth it!!! Huge variety of bagels, flagels & bialys to choose from and don't let me get started on cream cheeses!!! Hot breakfast sandwiches, cold hero's, fresh pastries & THE STAFF IS BEYOND AMAZING!!! read more

Love this place. Good food, they are fast even with the large lines and wait. Wish the shop was bigger and another location. Yummy everything read more

Loved the bagel,the service,and the commitment too keeping patrons safe from the pandemic. Left my local bagel place for this amazing place. I recommend too anyone who wants good service and a good bagel. read more

Wally's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Wally's is an institution. I hope they stay open forever and change nothing. The platonic ideal Long Island bagel, excellent breakfast sandwiches made to order with no detail missed, fast service, and impressive efficiency behind the counter. A traditional post airport pickup before coming home for years now. read more

If you are looking for the best bagels on Long Island come to Wally's! The bagels are amazing, they have a huge selection of bagels. The only down side is the bagel shop is very small and always busy. So get ready to wait, but It is worth the wait. read more

The food is always amazing from here. Lines can be deceiving, they do move quickly! They added online ordering too which I think helped them out a lot! Trust me, you won't be unhappy read more

Food is usually great. I love that they have curbside during this time. Only thing I didn't like is the complimentary juice/water is only offered with breakfast sandwiches containing meat although what I order is usually the same price or more. Other than that nice place for a breakfast sandwich. read more

I used to absolutely love Wallys. The last two times I went there though I ordered the chicken salad and I'm pretty sure the chicken went bad and it's addition to that it was dry and flavorless no big deal not everybody can do everything perfect I know they have a huge menu. But, my boyfriend ordered a bacon egg and cheese and while he was eating it she bit into something hard we took it out and ended up being almost like a pebble the food has gone down and quality 100% and not everybody there is wearing their mask correctly at all times in addition to that while their food quality has gone down the prices have gone up and the back area doesn't look so clean with different meats just in open air with no wrapping around or anything stay safe read more

This place is great from the service to the food. Top tier deli on LI might i say the best.

Not worth the hype. Over crowded just for a bagel. I don't think they taste any better than other bagel places I have been to.

Best bagels on Long Island hands down. Only down side is the line is always out the door. I always get a sausage egg and cheese on an egg everything bagel and the home fries are delicious. read more

When I am craving a fresh bagel, this is my go to spot. Not only did I work here years ago before these owners but I live within walking distance. During the week, at 6 am there is never a line and everyone is super friendly so early in the am. I love the everything flagels with veggie cream cheese. The cream cheese is whipped with chunks of veggies, the way I love it. The weekends have lines out the door, but they are fast and the breakfast sandwiches are huge. read more

Feeling disappointed...been customer (personal and business) for several years. This last month sent bagels to hospital staff at Good Samaritan Hospital where my sister is fighting COVID and the medical team has been outstanding. Went to place another order for today for Good Samaritan Hospital and was told I cannot get the store discount. Why won't Wally honor discount for Good Samaritan Hospital workers who are front line doing a tremendous job during this COVID pandemic? read more

Their food is delicious but anytime I get a bagel and order "the right side with butter and the left side with cream cheese" they mess it up every single time. Idk how to be more clear. They put butter on the top of the bagel and cream cheese on the bottom on the same side. . So then I have to go back in and re explain to someone else how I want it (the same way I explained it to the other girl) and then they get it right. Sorry for the rant but it literally ruins my morning every time because I keep hoping it'll stop happening and it doesn't. read more

Nice place very clean very busy cream cheese was fantastic. The bagels taste like a roll with a hole though, not bad just not what I had expected. Breakfast sandwiches are very good. read more

Super soft bagels, their everything bagels had a ton of everything and everything was overall delicious!!! My boyfriend and I had scallion cream cheese everything bagel with bacon and jelly. Definitely going back! read more

I really don't know where else you'd get a bagel. They've got lots of bagel types, great egg sammies, and amazing homemade flavored cream cheeses like chocolate chip and bacon cheddar. Expect a line out the door but don't be intimidated - those people move FAST. Find a buddy, order a toasted french toast bagel with blueberry cream cheese, and a toasted whole wheat everything with low fat veggie cream cheese. Swap halves and enjoy. read more

Be prepared to step into utter chaos. Tiny, claustrophobic bagel spot in North Babylon to come grab bagels, breakfast, sandwiches etc. The tired looking staff works like a brigade to get you in and out as fast as possible in spite the horrendous crowds in the morning. The bagels are as great as anywhere in lower NY. Tried the raspberry crumb cake which was a tad too sweet. If you're craving a bagel and don't mind chaos, this place is just fine. read more

See all

I've grown up going here. It's by far the best bagels on Long island. I always get an everything bagel with chive cream cheese and bacon. I love everything here. The line can get pretty long on the weekends but it's always worth it. read more

The best bagels I've ever had! Never a let down. Always amazing. The lines on weekend mornings are well worth it. Highly recommend.

This place is great, great service, the cream cheese is absolutely delicious , I don't even like cream cheese, but my daughter does and I tried hers, blueberry flavor, heavenly. Bagels are light and very tasty!!!! read more

i love wallys bagels. theres no other bagel place like it there bagels have a orginal taste that no other can compare to so when im in the area no matter what time it is i have to have a egg bagel with one egg cheese tomato and black pepper. i discovered this gem in high school and i been hooked ever since the owners have been there forever but i love the women. we know each other by face and she always greets me with a warm smile and is always welcoming. i wish that they opened up a wallys by me.. read more

Wally's Bagels - Bagels Near Me - North Babylon, New York

Beat bagel store on the island. Egg sandwiches ok, known for long lines and bagels but I won't hold it against them for having a small store they move very fast. read more

Wally's is one of my favorite places to pick up breakfast. Everything I've tried is pure deliciousness. I'll admit, I usually only come here before leaving for a road trip. I really should start coming here more often. Their vegetable cream cheese is amazing. All of their bagels are always fresh. Tons of bagels to choose from. Where else can you get a strawberry bagel? I'm a fan of Wally's for sure. The lines are always to the door but it goes by super fast.Good quality and service. read more

Wow. It was so soft and delicious I was moaning. Not the crunchy kind, rather the fluffy kind.Clean and great service