I really wanted to like this Margarita Pizza. I had seen pictures of it and was impressed. So after a long day of work on Saturday, we picked up a 12-in margarita pizza for about $23. It was hot and fresh and we immediately ate it. Unfortunately the crust had very little flavor and was very soggy. The cheese had become curdled. Either this pizza was executed poorly or the ingredients were not quality. Whatever the reason, this was a mediocre pizza at best. Sadly I do not believe this to be the quality of New York style pizza. Maybe they were just having a bad day. read more

See all

I didn't actually goto the physical restaurant. I instead used door dash. Because I'm an elder millennial and I am not too big on going out any more, but that's beside the point. Lemme tell about how good the pizza is. It's fucking fire. My buddy was eating with us from upstate New York. He said it was pretty damn close to the pies he used to get back home. I'm just gonna say it was pizza perfection. So good. 10/10 would definitely order again. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Possibly the best pizza to date I've had in California - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

Wow! Pizza and wings were delicious! I wish I knew about this place sooner. I ordered for pick up it was ready within 20 minutes. This pizza was very different from other places it had a unique flavor. I highly recommend getting pizza from here, I'll definitely come back to try more. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Half chicken pesto and half ny pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

We throughly enjoyed this entire meal. My wife and I are both from Brooklyn, NY and this hit the spot.

When you walk through the door, you realize that this place can't seem to decide what it wants to be. We were expecting a sit down pizza restaurant which it kind of is, but it's also a game room with only three places to sit at. The arcade takes up 1/3 of the restaurant and there are only two tables that seat 8. It has all the ambience of a double wide trailer with uncomfortable furniture. Obviously, this is more of a to go place than dine in. We decided to sit at one of the eight tops and ordered two lunch specials, which is basically two slices and drink. My two New York style slices were covered in toppings and was worth every penny. My wife's two veggie slices looked like an organic garden sitting on a pizza. These are big slices and it's hard to get two down. If you need a drink to wash it down, you can get either a soda in a can or beer in a bottle. They do one thing well, pizza, which gets four stars from me, but get it to go. Informative photos included. read more

See all

I don't know why we haven't ordered from this place in the past, but we are making up for it now! It's not only great pizza, but the value, especially based on other pizza places prices, is outstanding!!! Love this place. Our new "go to" when we want pizza!! read more

Gotta love Warrior New York Pizza! We love this place, whether for delivery or eating in inside their spacious area. With delivery they're pretty reliable. There has only been a couple of times where the wait has been extremely long. Inside is great for group gatherings because they've got big tables. They also have air hockey and some video games but they are always unplugged when we go in. One time a kid plugged them in himself and they seemed to work just fine. The pizza is great! We always get the Gluten-Free cauliflower crust pizza and it never disappoints! My child can polish one all himself if I don't stop him. read more

Never ready when they say..... pizza is good but the service sucks!! I won't be coming back here anymore

Delicious New York Style Pizza. The crust is amazing. We ordered large Warrior with extra mushrooms. Would recommend 100%, only apologies is that we ate it so fast we didn't take pics. Also they got a lot of cool crane machines and games installed. Looks like a fun place to hang out. read more

When I saw a piece of the Big Apple was in Rodeo and close to my house, I had to get a slice of the pie. Ordered a large New York pizza that came w/ pepperoni, sausage mushroom and mozzarella. Absolutely loved it! Any New Yorker would be proud and the pie did justice. The pizza was very tasty and easily fed my family of four. Oh and by the way, the slices were HUGE. Two slices and I was already on the couch passed out. The price came out to $31 (including tax) which I thought was very reasonable. Nowadays for the same size pizza from Roundtable or Mountain Mikes is like $50. Also, the customer service was great. The guy at the front counter was incredibly kind and even gave my son a token for one of the arcade machines in their parlor while we waited for the pizza. Called in and the pizza was ready in 15 minutes. Next time, I'm craving pizza, will definitely be calling Warrior New York Pizza!!!! read more

Warrior New York Pizza - New York Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

Pretty good thin crust pizza which is hard to find in these parts. Garlic Parmesan wings were outstanding - crunchy and too salty! read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Garlic Parmesan wings. Really good wing. Not too salty - really tender and crispy - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

See all

I was so excited to try your pizza. Your establishment had been recommended by a few people. So last night I ordered, for delivery, your 18" Manhattan and added sausage. The pizza came and it was visibly over cooked, with over half the pizza having charred large air bubbles. There was a very scant amount of toppings on the pizza. As we all began to eat the pizza, we also noticed that it appeared to have no base white sauce, causing the crust to be very dry and really crispy. I was very disappointed in your pizza and will not recommend it to anyone. I also called those who recommended your pizza to me and told them that I was highly dissatisfied with their suggestion. Someone needs to check who was making and cooking your pizzas last night and retrain them, if you want to keep or draw business, because this pizza was totally unworthy of the high price I paid. read more

I was visiting a friend to watch a tv series and we wanted to pick something up for lunch. We checked around the area and decided on pizza. Looking around some more, we settled on this place for delivery. Bbq Chicken: I didn't realize how big New York slices were and these were quite the size. The bbq chicken pizza was really good and presentation wise was appealing. The sauce was not too sweet and the rest of the toppings complemented each other. New York Pizza: We chose this one mainly for the namesake. The pepperonis were crispy and delicious and there wasn't too much oil on them. The mushrooms and sausage were also a good mix as well. The pizza sauce was tasty and overall not too bad. I would consider ordering from here again read more

Warrior New York Pizza - BBQ CHICKEN - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

See all

This is definitely a solid pizza place! I've only had it for take-out, so I can't comment on the dining experience, but the food is really good! I've tried the garlic parmesan wings and the margherita pizza, both of which were great. I really liked the wings, so I highly recommend you try them. They were juicy and very flavorful. The pizza was also solid, and I liked that the crust wasn't too thick. Definitely check out this place! read more

Warrior New York Pizza - MARGHERITA PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

See all

First time in a while that I visited Warrior Pizza but we really try to support our local businesses, so when pizza to go with the Giants game tonight was the ticket, we chose our local place. Definitely pleased. Called it in and they said 30 minutes, and they were true to their word. Pizza looked and tasted great. Perfectly cooked. We got the large and it is indeed large. Good value. Will definitely go back. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Combination - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

I came to Warrior Pizza in Rodeo for lunch yesterday (returning customer), and what should've been a simple meal turned into a deeply offensive experience. A worker there called me the N-word, then tried to brush it off by pretending he had an accent and that I was misunderstanding him, all while laughing about it. There is absolutely no excuse for that kind of language or behavior in any setting, especially from someone representing a business. Racism whether casual, coded, or joked about is never okay. I left feeling disrespected and stunned. This kind of experience has no place in our community. This employee (AJ is his name) should be held accountable, and I hope this incident is addressed immediately to ensure no one else is treated this way. I really enjoy the pizza heat so I hope this issue is resolved. read more

Stopped by here the other day after never really trying their food and WOW, it was delicious! From the different games people can play to the amazing ambience, I loved it . I ordered the cheesy garlic bread with bacon & jalapeños and it was outstanding! From the flavors, quality, everything! I definitely recommend stopping here for a quick bite ! Service was also great! read more

See all

Had to write this review because Honestly this is probably some of the best pizza in the whole area. #1 in my opinion. Employees are always very polite and welcoming. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Half pepperoni & half Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza added jalapeños &sausage - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

You have to take a trip to this hidden gem in Rodeo. They have the best pizza and folks need to know about them. The way their sauce is seasoned is really good and their sausage is really good. If you're ever in the area, check them out. You'll like it. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Super good pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

See all

Heard a lot of good things about Warrior New York Pizza and finally got a chance to try it out. We got the New York Pizza. Pizza base was a super thin and crispy crust. Pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom toppings were plentiful and good quality. Cheese and sauce were on point. Overall, a delicious pizza. Wings were tiny little bone in drums and flats. Crispy and with good flavor. Liked the garlic Parmesan slightly more than the Asian style (a bit too saucy for me). The restaurant itself was a bit lacking as they're currently remodeling. It was a HOT day and the doors were open with no air conditioning. There were a bunch of arcade games unplugged and even the restroom was out of service. If you told me this location was used for a post-apocalyptic film set, the interior would make sense. I'd recommend ordering food to go unless it's fair weather outside and you don't need to use the restroom! read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Cannoli - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

I was a little scared at first visiting a small town and took the chance on this pizza and it was very good! If I'm ever passing through again, I will definitely stop for a slice. The pizza was authentic and tasted really good. I ordered the combination pizza it was very good. read more

DELIVERY: I ordered from the website and had a question so made the call. The person who answered the phone was helpful and we squared away my order. A little background, I'd ordered from here during the early COVID years and I thought I was ordering a gluten free pizza (completely my error) and the pizza was so good, I couldn't believe it was GF (yeah...it wasn't). So I was pretty disappointed when I learned that I'd made a mistake and the pizza of my dreams was not to be. Fast forward to last week, my son (owner of The Loony Bean) said " Warrior Pizza has a new GF crust. I knew I had to try it. The stars aligned and it happened today and DAYUM! THAT PIZZA IS AMAZING! It truly is as good as their regular crust. People laugh at me when I say I want the "blistered crust" and they nailed it. I had the NY pizza (pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushroom) and added bell pepper and onion. I ordered a regular crust for my partner and the GF for me. When I opened the boxes I couldn't tell by looking which was the GF pizza. THAT NEVER HAPPENS! Fortunately, the wrote GF (see pic) on the inside of my box. The toppings were perfectly balanced to the sauce and the cheese. The crust was NOT SOGGY! This is the best pizza I have had in years. I'll have to level up my exercise cuz I'm about to do this once a week. Excellent service. Excellent delivery. Excellent food. I'll have to stop in there one day on my way to get coffee. read more

Great food and even better prices! It's really a hidden gem that deserves more attention!

Good pizza. Has a little arcade section. The staff were friendly and they have Jarritos. read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

Pass me that slice! Sooooo goooooood! The combo pizza and pepperoni pizza are EXCELLENT. I've been at the actual restaurant once and I love the fact that they sell pizza by the slice because sometimes you just want that. I ordered for delivery and the pizza was just as great when I had it at the restaurant. I requested ranch, red pepper, and parmesan and they didn't forget! Their ranch is good. All ranch are not created equal. I hate when the pizza is delivered and the requests were forgotten. THANK YOU! *I ordered this to be delivered to my house before the Warriors game. The restaurant quickly prepared it and had it ready for pick up on time! You can trust this place to order pizza for a game day/night. Delivery was via Uber Eats. Thanks to the owner for surprising me! He upgraded the pepperoni pizza size on the house! Support your local businesses! read more

Warrior New York Pizza - Combo. - Pizza Near Me - Rodeo, California

See all

At the outset, the location looks a bit deserted and sketchy but once you get past that and go in, it's a cool pizza joint in the small town of Rodeo. Since it's close to my place, I decided to walk over. Inside had a bunch of booths and pictures in the wall. I was starving and decided to get a small pepperoni and mushroom pie. Unfortunately, they were closing soon so I had to get it to go. On the walk home, I couldn't wait any longer so I opened it up and it was a glorious sight of hot melted cheese, ample pepperoni and fresh mushrooms baked on a crispy crust. I ate 2 slices with one hand while I held the pizza box in my other hand and it was so good I burned my tongue! It's a solid pizza but the crust could be better so I took off a star. I'd like to try the calzones sometime - I'm a sucker for those! read more

See all

Best Pizza around the area . The pizza is just perfect . The crust is thing and enough cheese and marinara sauce . The service is great . I will be coming here more often. Also the prices are fair . read more

Friday night pizza night ! We order online for pick up. There is a dining area, however we prefer to take ours to-go. Our favorite is the specialty pizza, New York Pizza. The large pizza is enough for 5 people and if you like meat and the NY style pizza, this is a good one to try. We also like to get the Cheese or Supreme Calzone. The calzone is generously filled with meat and cheese, they don't skimp on the filling. This is a local pizza place that's easy to order and easy to pick up and go. Good for busy families. read more

Here's a balanced review from your perspective: Warrior New York Pizza - Solid, But Not Quite Excellent Stopped by Warrior New York Pizza after hearing good things, and overall, it delivered a solid experience. The pizza had a good crust--nice chew with a bit of crisp--but it didn't quite hit that perfect New York-style balance. The sauce was flavorful, though I wished for a little more punch, and the cheese lacked a decent melt. Toppings were fresh, and the slices were well-proportioned, but something about the execution kept it just shy of top-tier. Maybe it was a touch too stiff, or maybe the seasoning didn't pop as much as I'd hoped. Either way, it was definitely enjoyable, just not the kind of slice that leaves you craving more the next day. Would I come back? Sure. Would I go out of my way? Probably not. 3.5/5. Solid, but not life-changing read more

I was out near Martinez buying motorcycle parts that I totally don't need for motorcycles that I never even have time to ride lol. I was craving pizza and I love searching for new spots when I'm in an unfamiliar place. I searched for slices near me on Yelp which lead me to Warrior pizza. They do serve slices but only at lunchtime. I arrived around 8 pm, so a large pie it is.  The inside has a retro feel to it with large booth seats and nostalgic decor. A bit dated and dark but it adds to the vibes. They have some fun arcade games as well. If you're looking for a divey pizza spot, this could be it. My pizza was ready in about 17 minutes. Per the name, it's a thin-style NY pizza. I wasn't expecting much but was blown away. Insanely good pizza! Great flavor, quality cheese, and a nice bake to the undercarriage. Not overly greasy either. It's a bit far for my normal pizza run but I will certainly get it again the next time I'm near Rodeo. read more

See all

Holy wow! I've been looking for a good local pizza spot for a little over a year now. This is my new favorite pizza place! Not only is this pizza thin, the sauce to crust ratio is perfect for me. It's a well balanced between cheese, sauce, and toppings. Tasty tasty pizza and very affordable! I was so surprised at the prices of their pizzas. I loved that you could get a full pizza or a slice. I got the 12" New York pizza and a love of the Long Island pizza. Both were so yummy and thin! Even on "thin" pizzas most places don't make it like that New York thin style and this is it. It was nice and simple with good ingredients that just hit the spot. Go for it and support this local business! They deliver and of course have pickup as well. This was fast service and I am not disappointed! read more

Incredible pies. Amazing wings. A slice of NY in Rodeo, CA. Who would've thunk. Friendly neighborhood pizza joint. Our go to for pizza night. read more

Very good pizza thin crust was perfect was ready for me when I got there enjoyed it thank you

This same is such a mom and pop pizza shop. It was a bit dead buuuut I will definitely be back with my family or even have a pizza family night here because it's was some good a** pizza. Family night Affordable Con: wait tjme. Maybe if you do come in with a big group call them to let them know so they can prepare the food ahead of time, even tho I placed my order ahead it still took some time. read more

I hardly leave reviews ever but this one deserves it ... i never felt so sick in my life immediately after eating this pizza i ordered it last night at 7:45 pm by 8pm i was sick with sweats, diarrhea, and vomiting all night until now at 9:15 am this place dont even deserve a star as it literally is spreading food poisoning order at your own risk read more

Best local pizza so far here. Closest thing to authentic delivery style pizza in the east coast. Never have any issues with ordering, takeout, delivery, or quality of food. Overall this would be the number 1 place I would recommend to anyone in the area for what is closest to New York style pizza around here. read more

Updated review on my latest experience here : Great customer service & great food! My order was for take out. Cute little place for a simple date night or family night nothing too fancy but it's cute !! They have their signature chicken bacon ranch pizza that I get every-time ! I usually get a specific pizza but in this case it's that good that I'll get it instead! I definitely recommend their " chicken bacon ranch " pizza ! I don't think they sell this one by the slice so I have to get a whole pizza each time, that's a bit inconvenient. The crust on it is a bit harder so I just don't eat it most of the time , but that's not an issue for me. They also sell red sauce pizza by the slice if you don't feel like eating a whole pizza / or your on a diet!! Bathrooms are closed currently along with some claw machines & the game room due to the new covid variant. So many pictures of the customers in store they truly care about giving great customer service. As I'm writing this it is a bit chilly in the restaurant so bring a jacket! Has multiple little machines to get things from as shown in the pictures. Very attentive to your needs. Pizza took a bit ( we usually order on the phone and show up when it's done so it felt like longer since we were here LOL ) , but it was fresh & delicious per usual and never too oily !! Thank you so very much for always staying the same , AMAZING! Well worth the money you pay for it would definitely recommend! read more

See all

This place has great pizza that I would say is NY style, crust is yeasty and great, cheese and toppings are fresh and pies don't come out greasy! read more

Pizza was really good. Based on the bad reviews, ya'll stay hating. I had placed a huge order recently, and I had ordered the Brooklyn, New York, half & half Veggie and BBQ Chicken in 18" sizes. It was fresh and couldn't stop enjoying the crisp of the crust. Hands down, owner was the only worker at the time I came during open hours. He did his job as a pizza owner and satisfied the customer. Would come back to visit again! read more

Best pizza I've had in a while. We tried them when they first opened and it was no good. They were probably still gathering the right vendors for quality ingredients as well as hunting down a decent crew. At any rate the margarita pizza was good, it would've been great if there were sliced tomatoes and a little more fresh mozz but the cheese was good, the sauce was good and basil was being basil, lol. We ate the whole pizza, no slices wasted and no crust wasted either. Price was a tad more than I wanted to pay, I'd be happy at $30 vs the $36 or $38 I paid but, it was a big pizza so I just can't complain. read more