Best fast food burger I've had in a long time! As close to Homemade burger you could get, Juicy, full flavor, great sized portion burger that does not leave you hungry an hour after eating. Very Tasty! Burger gets a 5 star The sides I had, onion rings and fries, were a little undercooked May have just been my luck and didn't eat quite as quick as I should have since I couldn't get enough of my bacon cheeseburger. Trying the tots next time! My service was great. Staff were friendly and pleasant to speak to while waiting for food. Was surprised by how nice the place was being in a strip mall. Very well decorated and clean. Reminded me of a place I used to go call Backyard Burgers before they went out of business.Can tell the employees liked the job they were doing and took pride in the results. Definitely recommend this place! read more

BURGERS FOR BREAKFAST!! New find, great shop, great service, and great fresh food. will be back. thanks to the 11/1/24 morning crew read more

Wayback Burgers - American Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Greeted by very friendly staff. Portions are huge. The burgers were juicy and flavorful. The onion rings were delicious. read more

See all

It was a good hamburger and the tater tots were great. Overall a good experience and I would eat here again if I am in the area. Also the staff was very friendly and helpful. read more

Wayback Burgers - American Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Impossible melt was good but not worth $10 The cheese fries were 5/10 Could've been more crispy and flavorful. read more

Wayback Burgers - IMPOSSIBLE MELT - American Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

See all

Good food. I had the A1 Steakhouse Burgers and some chili fries. The chili was a little bland but overall everything tasted good. Counter service. Out the door my bill was under $20. They have lots of burgers, including some unique flavors, and other handhelds such as cheesesteaks. They have shakes and salads. I enjoyed it. One last thing - they have a rewards system that you have to enroll in via a QRS code that's epically confusing. I couldn't figure it out. So don't feel dumb if it stumps you too. read more

Ordered online and was ready when I walked in. Chicken was tasty and crispy. Shake was great. Didn't care for the sauce that came with the Cajun tots but liked the seasoning on the tots themselves read more

Wayback Burgers - CRISPY CHICKEN - CRAFT YOUR OWN, CAJUN TATER TOTS, REGULAR MILKSHAKE - CHOCOLATE - American Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

We ordered take out and the food and service were great! We ordered burgers and they were all good. Fries were good too.

After four years of not returning, I tried it again. Both of our burgers tasted very good. The tater tots my wife ordered were also prepared properly prepared and cooked. My onion rings tasted fine and probably were good for my diet because they hardly had any batter. Time will tell if I go back. read more

The food was excellent the service was great and the price was good, very friendly and fast service

I love Wayback! The burgers are really good, not something you'd normally make at home! The service is quick and they get you your food relatively quick so you're in and out read more

Would have rated a 3 but the service and employees were wonderful. The burger was good, but not great. Fries were pedestrian.

This place has the freshest and tastiest burgers I've ever had, absolutely delicious. And the also have hot dogs!

In town from Louisville, Kentucky on a work trip and spotted Wayback Burgers across the street from the Drury Inn so my co-worker and I came here for dinner. This is a fairly basic burger spot, with plenty of seating and several burger options. They also have chicken tenders, hot dogs and several varieties of milkshakes on the menu. We both got the single patty burger in added our own toppings. Both of us were happy with the size of the single and agreed it had a good flavor. We didn't add fries or onion rings but we both indulged in a milkshake. A black and white for my co-worker and a cookies n' cream for me. The milkshake is incredibly filling and will throw you over the edge if you've already had a bunch of food! If you are watching calories, the menu is very transparent on every item including things like mayonnaise, ketchup and other condiments. Everything adds up! The service was also extremely friendly. We didn't go to the register right away but took menu to the table to decide what to order. The associate at the counter very patiently went over options and specials with us, and shared specials coming up later in the week. The reason to be at a four-star review has more to do with the atmosphere. The music above us was really loud and I found it distracting during conversation. Also, the ventilation in the building isn't great. The burgers are made fresh and this accumulates smoke and the smell of grease in the building. After sitting in there for a while I begin to question if my hair and clothing smelled like a Wayback Burger. If I was going to a destination after eating, this would make me think twice about eating here. Definitely see this being a good spot for families given the variety of options for burgers and sides. They also have a kids meal menu. read more

Was looking for something a little different than the usual stuff. Thought this might be it, but, not quite. Food was good. I got a cheeseburger with bacon, lettuce and tomato. Side order of fries and a drink. Burger was good sized, on an egg type bun. (Yellow bun) cooked right and had good flavor, moist, but not sloppy greasy. Which is good. Tomato had a good taste, not like some that look good but have zero flavor. Fries were, well, fries. Not greasy. They were fresh and hot. But nothing special. Place was clean and not too noisy. I'd say, for the $, it was good. Would I recommend it? It wouldn't be my first choice, but I wouldn't stop someone from going there. read more

I've been on a bit of a burger craze lately, and just been continuously disappointed. Steak and Shake, 5 Guys, Red Robin, Wendy's all disappointing. So Wayback was a breath of fresh air. The burger was fresh and juicy, unlike anything else I'd had recently. A pleasant surprise, almost a shocking reminder that making a quality burger isn't that hard. Fresh beef, cooked right, is delicious as all hell. The bacon, cheese and Cajun sauce didn't hurt either. Too many places think you can hide a crap burger with the extras (you can't), here they accentuate a great burger. My only complaint was my tater tots were undercooked. Need that crispy exterior. read more

Update: I have spoken to the manager and he was unaware of how his team preformed and by no means do they reflect what he wants his business to be. I try to eat here when in town. The food is good and fast. Tonight however the employees are completely out of control and rude to each other. If the owners do not come in and fix their employee issues people will stop coming to your business. read more

I'm always excited to try a new place for burgers! Menu was small and easy to navigate; I ordered a burger and tots and my boyfriend ordered a chicken sandwich. Staff was friendly, but not very professional or organized. After we had paid and ordered the staff let us know they didn't have chicken and it was still frozen. He opted to then get a burger. We had a long wait for the food, however once we received our food we thought it was pretty good. Atmosphere was lacking, as it wasn't the cleanest. read more

They had a courteous staff, but they seemed to lack direction, seemed confused, and really slow. The place needed cleaning, the bathroom toilet was broken (I fixed it) and the soft drink fountain was half functional. Probably won't be back. read more

Great tasting food. Everything is made fresh when you order, but still served quick. Many options for toppings, and has quite a variety of items- it's not just burgers. I've been here twice so far, and I will be coming back! My only negative- they play "Oldies" music. read more

Wayback Burgers - The Menu.. Not just burgers. - American Near Me - Evansville, Indiana

Super awesome "The Cheesy" burger and sublime onion rings. Person at the counter was polite and helpful - rang up my order two different ways to ensure I got the least expensive total for what I wanted. I also got a hand-dipped milkshake. Maybe I'm tainted from being accustomed to machine shakes, but I found this one to be a little on the runny side. Still tasty, though! Great tunes!!! 50s 60s - appropriate volume, too. Could still have s regular conversation but hear music. I plan to return - burger was TOO good to not return! read more

See all

I love the build your own burger. My boyfriend got a build your own chicken and he said it was fantastic. Their onion rings are also amazing. Will be going back quite a bit read more

Okay, so I usually never have had a bad experience at Wayback, but tonight was bad....my boyfriend and I ordered Wayback....he didn't want a burger so he ordered chicken strips and mac'n'cheese bites. He was asked for a dipping sauce for the strips and he chose ranch. I ordered just a regular burger and fries and a unsweet tea.....then we also ordered milkshakes to complete our order. Well when the food got here my boyfriend didn't get his ranch that he got charged for and our food basically fell out all into the bag as if it was all just lazily put in there and our milkshakes were like water...I was also given sweet tea instead of unsweet. read more

Been here a few times. Always good food and good service. Not a horribly extended menu so no need to agonize over whatcha gonna get! The onion rings are good. Love their cheeseburgers. The lemonade is terrible and the worst part is no Coca-Cola products! UGH! #PepsiSucks Overall I do recommend. Bathrooms clean and restaurant is always clean! Excellent service. Food hot and fresh! Best burgers in town! read more

Won't be back! Our food was cold. Drinks were nasty. The service was fine but we ended up throwing our food away. Save your money!

The burgers are good but nothing spectacular. The service was super friendly. The setting wasn't anything fancy and I would definitely take my family here over common fast food places. The shakes are very filling so come hungry if you get both. read more

Food was pretty good I would go back forsure. It's a little over priced in my opinion. The workers were not very welcoming but I think we all are here for food not customer service. Not the best but really good fries so 4 stars. read more

Visited the Evansville location 8/20/17. Terribly disappointing. Being close by made it an easy late night choice. Getting the order took nearly 20 minutes for 2 single cheeseburgers and fries. Ingredients were fresh, but the cheese should have been melted. Get a double burger, the bun completely overwhelms a single. Maybe grill the bun, too. Fries had a weird after taste, only had a few, then gave up on them. The saving grace was the chocolate shake, which arrived almost immediately. I can see why the original, old school McDonald's would put a place like this out of business. Overall, the Wayback Burger should have stayed there. read more

I LOVE the burgers at Wayback Burger. They are absolutely delicious. That being said, the last THREE times we ordered delivery from Wayback they have left items out of our bag. Is 2 too high to count for the employees? First they left out a fry. The second time a burger. This time they left off ANOTHER burger. Maybe it was left Wayback on the grill or in another bag. Either way order somewhere else. read more

The Philly cheesesteak was awesome. Lots of meat and terrific flavor. My son had a bacon cheeseburger and said it was fantastic too.

If you like greasy food, this is your spot. Hands down, has the best onion rings in Evansville

https://goo.gl/search/News News, burgers0 they have great big burgers you can't get them all you can eat them all. read more

I like Wayback Burgers. I like the veggie burgers. The veggie burgers are frozen and deep fried. There are lots of toppings for the burgers. There are homemade potato chips. The onion rings are really good. The milkshakes are good. The customer service is good. read more

For fast casual burger place, these guys are pretty good! There burger was awesome and the fries were good too. The topper was the milkshake. If I were a boy, it would have brought me to the yard. Blackberry chocolate? Yes please. Just the right consistency and super yummy. Plus, the staff was friendly and quick. Well done, Wayback. Well done. read more

You need to eat here. I travel extensively nationwide and have eaten at tons of burger joints like this one. This is Top Ten. The beef itself is great and it's cooked exactly how it should be. Delish. Onion rings are great too. Evansville doesn't get lots of local restaurants that are great...this has always been a chain town. (This may be a franchise? but doesn't act like one if it is) Support this one! read more

I'm not sure where to start. It took 4 people 25 minutes to make three burgers and two orders of fries. My total bill, including a shake was $29. On top of that, I apparently got someone else's order too, because when I got home, there were 5 burgers, 4 fries and an order of chicken strips. My shake was made by the person at the cash register who took my order. I got it within 4 minutes of ordering. Then it sat there for another 20 minutes. When I pointed out that I had been waiting 20 minutes, all I got was an eye roll and "Sorry". The food is good, but hardly worth the hassle to get it. read more

My family and I placed a large order online ($100+) , burgers , chili cheese fries and a kids meal. Personally I had the Philly Burgers and Chili Fries, both were quite horrid. Mushrooms were overcooked and the edges were hard. Burger was overcooked as well, very dry. Chili Fries were decent but very little chili, looked like maybe a teaspoon worth of chili on a full size order of chili fries ($4.99) This past evening we decided to have Rally's, pretty much the same sized order , 2 burgers and fries each , saved $40 and was a much better burger and Rally's is not stingy with the chili or cheese! Save your money, go get a Big Buford from Rally's. read more

First time visiting Wayback Burgers. I ordered a classic double with pepper jack cheese, reg fries, and a soda. Food was excellent, service was great. I will return. read more

We haven't been here in a while. Used to be very clean and efficient. The cook appeared out of no where. Wasn't sure we made a mistake even ordering. On a Friday one would assume they would be packed. As soon as we eat I guess will know. I thought the food preparers were supposed to wear gloves? Well the main guy did but not his helper. Food was good. Will try this place again to see if it was just an off night. read more

Nice place for a burger. Great taste. The staff was very friendly. I would definitely come back.