Today was the first time I've ever had goods from Wemlock and they were pretty good. We had apple cider donuts which were good and oatmeal raisin cookies. I would consider trying again and seeing what their other baked goods are like! read more

Their baked pies are the best. The pies are a little pricey $12.50 per pie) but these pies are worth the extra money. These pies are so delicious. They are also very fresh. The apple crumb pie that I bought was cooling off when I bought it. It had just come out of the oven. I highly recommend Wemrock Orchards. read more

See all

Love Wemrock. My friend and I went last week and she bought the apple crumb pie and it was DELICIOUS.. Maybe Kevin T. just had a bad pie, could happen. Nothing is perfect, but damn near. Wemrock also has a lot of old fashion candy, which I love. Fresh bread, pies, cakes, also jar's of spices, and frozen food. Reminds me of a little country market. Can't wait to go back. Maybe today. read more

Went today for the first time - WOW - better prices than Delicious Orcahrds - same great quality items. Apple cider, pumpkin pies, and donuts all for sampling were delicious - staff is very friendly and accommodating. HUGE bonus: Tomasello Winery wines are sold here. Try the pomegranate - so delicious! We will definitely continue to come to Wemrock Orchards. read more

Purchased apples today. Did not think it was appropriate to squeeze. All were soft.

Very disappointed.. I've been coming here for years buying their pies .. two days ago bought an apple pie and this morning found mold in it... also the apples were mushy and a weird grey color.. read more

Nice relaxing day corn maze was cool, pumpkin selection should've been better. I had a great time with my family here. The general stores pies could not be fresher, right off the oven rack. The peach, and cherry butters are awesome. The general store I would say is the best part here... Stay off the picnic benches! read more

Wemrock Orchards - Pick Your Own Farms Near Me - Freehold, New Jersey

Everything is absolutely delicious!! Love the homemade pies, cakes, jams and my personal favorite..... Cherry Jalapeño Salsa dip. Wonderful country store!!! read more

I am only here to rate their apple pie. Their apple pie was quite bad. The filling was soggy and too sweet, and their crust was mushy and undercooked (both the crust on the bottom, which was basically inedible, and the crust on top, which was only barely cooked) I recommend going to the Battleview Orchard store to buy their Apple Pies. They are significantly better tasting there. read more

Hey so I buy a blueberry pie. Had to be the worst pie I ever ate hows a blueberry pie taste like cinnamon what the hell paid good money an threw it in the garbage . BUYER BE WHARE. THIS PLACE SUCKS . read more

During the Thanksgiving's, a friend of mine brought Cherry Pie from Wemrock Orchards, I normally don't like anything that is Cherry flavours, but the Cheery Pie from Wemrock Orchards just changed it!!! I love it soooooo much that I asked my friends to pick up more pies for me and they got me Apple Pie, Blueberry Pie and Pecan Pie. I love every single of them and could have finished the Blueberry Pie in 2 days on my own. They were sweet but not too much and the crust was a bit chewing yet crunch. They were perfect! I absolutely loved the pies from here and just wished that they were not so far away from me! read more

Going here for 30 years. I am never disappointed. Staff is always courteous and helpful.

The elderly man making the donuts was incredibly rude and lacking skills in dealing with the public. The baked goods were average, at best.

Apple Crumb pie 2 bags of apple Cider donuts & bag of my favorite potato chips( Charles Chips) Woo Hoo was I a hit at home ! Thanks to the friendly crew here for making my family smile! read more

Charming little store with everything ranging from local honey to salsas, baked goods and more! They have a little section to get some foods. Also, they ate host to one of Tomasello Wineries outlet. You can do a tasting for I believe $5. They have so many options and their Ranier wines are amazing. read more

I hate to be negative, but their customer service lacks any merchandise skills. First of all their pies aren't made fresh there. They come from Ohio and aren't always fresh. They give you such a hard time to exchange a steal pie. One of their managers should not work in retail because she has no idea how to please a customer. She clearly is not a people person and should work in the back and not in the store. I feel badly for the owner who has no idea what she is doing to His name and store. I have been a customer for over fifteen years and will not shop there any more. read more

We just got a blueberry pie with apple cider and the pie was so fresh that we are now debating on eating the entire thing or getting dinner. The correct choice would be to eat the entire thing of course but then we would have no more pie.... cannot wait to go back 10 out of 10 recommend. read more

This place has the best pies! Picking up a pie every Thanksgiving from here is tradition!

Bought the apple cider donuts & OMG AMAZING! Their apple cider was delicious as well! Bought some homemade raspberry jam and a pumpkin tart that I have yet to try! Loved the look of the store and I enjoyed walking around and seeing everything they had. I was checked out by a very sweet girl at the register ... Highly recommend this place! read more

So just an update to my previous review.. My neice who happens to live in freehold was at wemrock orchards recently.. apparantly she didnt read my review lol. So anyway she walked in and she had her dog with her.. the dog was on a leash.. and out of nowhere the owner richard giunco (his picture and name was on the store website and my neice pointed him out) started yelling and screaming at her to leave the dog outside. Not only was he yelling and screaming at the top of his lungs at a 15 year old girl but he was also using profanities.. the F word and so forth.. cursing and yelling and screaming at a 15 year old girl.. for walking in with her dog on a leash... seriously their is something wrong with this guy and this whole place of business. Not only will their food get you sick but the owner is apparantly someone who thinks its ok to curse out a 15 year old girl.. hope this place shuts down.. the people of freehold should seriously boycott this place read more

I've been coming here for years, and always get their apple cider and apple cider donuts whenever I'm in town. I'll have to admit I don't usually get their pies or other baked goods, but they often have samples and the few I've tried all tasted great. They also have a lot of local products that I occasionally pick up, and great customer service - everyone is friendly and warm. read more

Overcooked, dry, and crumbly are not the words I like to use to describe chocolate chip crumb cake. I just bought the worst cake...ever. The donuts are ok and so is the cider but I do not like that they include preservatives in their cider. Both the donuts and fresh cider (no preservatives) are much better at Delicious Orchards. I'll continue to travel the extra distance to DO in the future. read more

Love their apple cider donuts! Also tried some of their sweet & spicy pickles which were great. We used a Groupon for a wine tasting at Tomasello Winery (which is located inside) and had a wonderful time. Staff is very friendly. Wish they had a bathroom for customers though - had to go outside and use a porter potty in the parking lot. read more

Enjoyed the wine tasting room. I've had better donuts though. I'd like to go back & give it another shot, but the shop was pretty small. They did have some cute painted pumpkins though. read more

For every one of the past 19 years I have with pleasure driven (70 miles each way) all the way from Scarsdale in Westchester County, NY to Wemrock Orchards to purchase their Thanksgiving pies. These pies in our family's opinion are the best pies in the North East, actually may rank as some of the best Apple and Pecan pies in the country. The faculty and staff at Edgemont Jr. Sr High School have had their favorites all these years and we have been blessed to be able to share these pies with them. It has become a tradition to sit down at our Thanksgiving dinner and enjoy these pies with those we love. Thank you to the staff at Wemrock for the incredible effort and love they bake into each and every pie. Mrinal Jhangiani Scarsdale, NY read more

The worst apple pie i ever tasted!! I knew as soon as i cut into it, the apples were grey and totally mush. Don't know how they could have any repeat customers if all their pies taste this bad. read more

Probably the worst pies in the world. Every Thankgiving this place has a sign on Rt 33 advertising to pre-order your holiday pies. DON'T! They are awful. All of them. Had apple pie and pumpkin pie two years ago and what a disappointment. I guarantee you that this place sells the WORST pie you have ever had. read more

I was quite unimpressed with the store here. From the outside, it looks very nice. The signs say "cider" and "donuts" and all sorts of other things. It looks nice and homey. But it is less a "come in and have a fall snack with us" type place and more a "come in and give us your money and take your snack somewhere else" kind of place. We wanted cider donuts for 4, but they don't sell individual donuts, so we had to buy a bag of six. They were good, but now I'm stuck with two extra donuts I didn't want or need. And we wanted to get some cider, but they don't sell cider (their own cider!) by the cup, like they do coffee. You have to buy a bottle from the cooler. So I was happy to buy the half gallon from the cooler and asked for cups. I was offered tiny little dixie cups, or told I could pay for the larger cups they serve coffee in, $ .25 each. Not that that is a lot, but the point is that I am buying YOUR overpriced cider and it would be nice if you could give me a cup that is bigger than what I use for mouthwash. Overall, I just felt that the staff was not all that helpful or friendly and just wanted to nickel and dime me for everything. Maybe my standards are too high, but I don't think so. There are plenty of apple orchards all across New England, and other parts of the country, that offer a much nicer fall experience, with more personable staff. I don't anticipate returning. read more

Though I probably pass this place a dozen times a week, I have not been in for at least 10 years!! Well today, that streak ended. I really do love the feel of this store.It feels like an old farmhouse and even has that old smell mixed with the scent from the bakery. Yankee should make this one of their candle scents!!! They have quite a few baked goods. Pies, donuts etc... Lots of jarred items like dressings, salsa, pickles honey. There is a candy shop in one room. They sell hard ice cream.You can grab a cup of coffee. Let's not forget..........WINE!!!!! They are a showroom for Tomasello Winery. You can do a tasting there if you'd like. A selection of fruits and vegetables. While not a huge amount of any one type of item, a little bit of everything like you'd find in an old general store. They may have their hands full with what I think is the best pie around over at Battleview, but this is a cool little place with a feel that the others all lack. read more

Needed a sympathy basked. They did the most wonderful Job. It was so beautiful. I have always had good experiences at Wemrock. Thank you so much read more

Got a peach pie and an apple pie , not great, filling was really over cooked on both pies just mush , I prefer the fruit to be tender not mush .When I buy a freshly baked pie I expect it to be better than a pie bought from a super market .I've had better cinnamon apples at Boston Market read more

Great Customer Service. Apple Pie and Donuts are delicious. Marty is very pleasant to deal with.

Went the general store on a summer Sunday afternoon after a trip to nearby Monmouth Battlefields. Looks and smells like a country store...fresh pies, all natural soups and other goodies. Nothing is cheap, but everything I tasted was delish: blueberry peach cream pie, tomato soup, spinach and chicken orzo soup, salsa dip, and vinaigrettes. For my tastes, the blueberry crumble pie at Battleview was better, but blueberry peach pie from Wemrock was really good, too. I think I have to go back to both stores to sample more pies to declare a clear winner :) Planted the 3 kids with their ice cream cones (kinda pricey at $4 for 2 smallish scoops) at the cafe. Hubbie and I went to the Tomasello Winery retail shop (separated by a glass pane wall from the cafe, but still an arms length away) to try their tasting ($5/person for 5 tastings with a free wineglass.) The wine lady was very sweet, generous, and knowledgeable. There were quite a wine variety available. We are NOT wine snobs and lean towards sweeter wines. We were surprised to find we liked most of the wines we tried and ended up buying 5/6 bottles including a yummy ice wine. We will definitely be back again. read more

I have tried all the local places and this store makes the BEST pies around here. Nobody even comes close!

I've been going to Wemrock Orchards for years. I get their Blueberry crumb pie and oatmeal raisin cookies I was just there today to get a pie, and a women raved over their crumb cake. I'll try one next time.. Very good. I'm a dessert snob, so I only go back if it's really good. I had a problem there years ago with a coconut custard pie which tasted burnt because they had a oven problem. They rectified the problem and gave me a free pie and still didn't like it. I've been to Battleground Orchards. I had the worst blueberry tart, it had so much gelatin that it would wiggle. Battleground does have very good scones, if anyone is a scone fan. read more