If you're into classic arcade and pinball and a fantastic burger this your place!…read more Bring cash for the tokens to play!

Easily my favorite burger in Rochester. I will need to remember to get a double next time, because…read morethe single while so delicious, goes too fast. You are able to customize your toppings, though some add ons may add to your cost such as bacon or cheese. Fries and a milkshake make for a perfect pairing with the burgers. Everything is made to order. Don't forget to grab the house made ketchup to go with your fries. We arrived relatively close to the kitchen closing and the person taking our order was pleasant. We did not feel rushed and enjoyed our meal in the wide open dining area. After eating we checked out the two floors of games. While we didn't play any on this visit, we have in the past and it always makes for a fun evening.

Convenient to my parent's home when I visit Rochester but not a place I would return…read more Pros: + Great for groups. Ample space both upstairs and downstairs. + 2 of the 4 sours I had were decent. + Great for kiddos as they have an outdoor space that's family and dog friendly. It was very busy the day we went with a fun atmosphere outside. + Historic venue with a nice restoration for the brewery. The less great: + The setup means long waits. Having to wait in line for beers in a completely packed brewery with two bartenders is not a way to run a business. They need to consider a new strategy for ensuring they can accommodate the volume they are currently doing. + Had a bite of someone's burger and found it more or less inedible. + My parents had attempted to organize a large family gathering on the day we were there and while I wasn't involved in the planning, there seemed to be missteps and miscommunications along the way that weren't met with much empathy or customer service in mind. Too many great breweries in Rochester to waste time on spots that aren't going to ensure guest satisfaction. Great location though! This place is so, so busy it's obvious the east side isn't brewery saturated (somehow) quite yet.

What a gem! If this is not the best brew pub in Rochester, I need to know, because Rising Storm…read moreBrewing is one of the best breweries I've been to in 26 states. First off, the food. Wow. The Detroit style pizza is phenomenal! Perfect crispy crust. I was there on a Friday but came back the next day to try the tomato pie as it was sold out on Friday. It was delicious! Think focaccia with tomato sauce and Parmesan cheese. So tasty! But what is brilliant is that of four pizzas, one rotates each week and changes. I had one of the rotating pizzas: pepperoni, banana peppers, garlic sauce, and honey. It bears repeating, wow! So great! The beers? There's something for everyone! So many hazy/New England IPAs and sours. Great seltzers too! The space is great with room for private parties. Such friendly staff. I hope to come back again before leaving!

Love this place on a Saturday night to sit at the very energetic and entertaining bar with our…read morefavorite bartender / mixologist "Allison" and her fellow awesomely friendly & inviting other bartenders "Leo" and the rest of the staff there. We always order the same thing to share and it is always PERFECTLY cooked and delicious, "The Steak"! Thank you Good Luck for always providing a delicious and fun experience! Matt & Renee (Red) ;)

Good Luck was a great experience from start to finish. Service was top notch, and the atmosphere is…read morelively, fun, and energetic without feeling overwhelming. We tried the pizza, saganaki, and spinach salad--everything came out fresh and really well done, perfect for sharing among a group of four. The standout was definitely the burger: huge, juicy, and served with a generous pile of fries and a really solid dipping sauce on the side. It's also a great spot to grab a few drinks and hang out for the evening.

Always love stopping in at Gate House. It's one of my partner and I's favorite go tos for a quick…read moreand easy night out. The Caesar is out of this world and so are the burgers. It can get a little steep price wise and somewhat loud at times but overall I love it here. Easy to slide in usually and grab a seat at the bar if you don't have a reservation during the week.

Kayla was a sweet and attentive server. We ordered a few different things and everything was pretty…read moredecent. Standout shareable dish was the mash potato and leek croquette. I like how they have a lot of healthy options as well as decadent dishes. Their portions are quite big as well. There's definitely something for everyone. Next time I look forward to trying their pizza! The interior was warm and welcoming.

Met up here on a Monday evening and was excited to try it since I had never been. I got the fries…read morewith preserved lemon aioli - these magical bites somehow stayed hot and crispy through the whole meal. I tried (& loved) their Belgian triple since it had just won a silver medal at the NYS Craft Brewers awards. It was well-deserving of the honor it received! Staff was friendly and attentive, and it was easy enough to get a bartender's attention for a refill. Seating area was bright and spacious with great atmosphere. Parking situation is kinda hairy - extra tight spaces in a small lot, but it was manageable for a Monday, and there's street parking if you don't happen to get a space in the lot. Cheers!

Great atmosphere and even better pizza! We were here in November, and the seasonal salad was to die…read morefor. I love the family friendly feel of a brewery. It gives our family a chance to get out without the stress of kids having to be perfect.

Just what we needed for some girlfriend time after going to the coffee shop needed a cocktail and…read moresome good lunch. Thank you Michelle. I don't know how you do it. It was a room full of people and you handled us all.

Friday was our first time there. We were seated right away for some drinks and a late lunch…read more Service was outstanding and I enjoyed was the atmosphere at the bar. Many seemed to know one another and it reminded me of a modern Cheers type feel. We ordered the turkey wrap with waffle fries and the Korean Good For Your Soeul Burger and tater tots. Everything was absolutely delicious and enough for two meals. I would highly recommend the Old Stone Tavern. That extra crisp on my tater tots and melt in your mouth flavor on the burger was on point!

Came back for a 2nd go after how good it was the first time... absolutely amazing Pub Burger! I…read moredaydreamed of it! If you are "lucky" enough to have Haley (hopefully spelled it right) as bartender she was great! Atmosphere is awesome, calm and slow music, happy hour is awesome, food is awesome, great conversation with the other patrons... it is rare to find a place like this! I encourage everyone to go try it ... oh and the fries!!! Can't forget about the fries!!! No photos this time - burgers were gone so fast!!

Came in on a Saturday night around 6pm without a reservation. Highly recommend making a reservation…read moreas they are super busy. Luckily we were able to sit at the bar. There's many drink options including a bartender's choice option. Ian our bartender serving us made an excellent drink with the flavor profile I gave him. I also ordered the burger and fries which with the house sauce was delicious. While lucky's is a more casual vibe than Good Luck, the quality of food is still up to par

Here on a very quiet Monday night. Our server was lovely, friendly and very efficient. I had the…read moreCajun burger. I asked to have bacon for the burger and tater tots very crispy came perfectly as ordered. As burgers go it was hand pressed and very tasty. My companion ordered the Pourman's Platter with a side order of the bacon, cabbage, Brussels sprouts hash. She liked it very much. My friend wanted to play the quick draw and was told very rudely by the bartender that he doesn't do anything with it, It's all done by a machine and brusquely pointed at the machine. When she went to check her ticket on the machine, it spit it out and sent an error message. Again ask the bartender for help to retrieve our her winnings, he said he really didn't know how to do it and he tells people just don't play. When she said the machine was sending an error message. He then took the card from her and suddenly knew how to check the ticket and give her the winnings. So why the subterfuge?? There was no need for the rudeness, and she felt disrespected. The surroundings are typical tavern vibe and seemed clean and ordered. Beside the bartender everything else was fine.

Great food selection! Great Service! GREAT PLACE TO WATCH BUFFSALO BILLS and Your Favorite…read moreCollege/NFL Games! Many screens! Very nice Environment!

I've been here twice - once to pick up and order and other time to dine in - and I had a good…read moreexperience both times. The pick up was for a plate and while it wasn't the best garbage style plate I've had, it wasn't bad at all. Didn't ruin the name. The dine in order was a burger and that was pretty darn good! The sweet potato fries were delicious too. I had the Rochester Snow cocktail and I drank it so fast I wished I could reverse time to savor it more. My boyfriend got the milkshake and my lord it had everything but the kitchen sink! He also enjoyed his meal. Oh and make a reservation. This place gets BUSY.

My daughter has a sweet tooth and when I found out that we had a place in Rochester that makes…read morecrazy big milkshakes, I figured she would love to come get one for her birthday. Things started off great. The servers are very welcoming! We got some water run over, I don't love that they don't have menus and that you have to use your phone. I understand the "convenience" but it's much more convenient to just have a menu. So, we ordered and the pretzel came pretty quick which we got as an appetizer. Four stars it was very yummy, honey mustard was good, queso was good, too much salt on the pretzel though, way too much salt lol, but it was good. Then there was a bit of a wait for our burgers, not forever but a little bit of a wait. The portions are interesting. The fries are shoe string which I personally think is the crappiest form of fry in existence so that's one strike. One of our fries was normal and one of them was bacon and cheese. It was okay but it's a fairly small portion of fries for a $20 dish. As for the burgers we got a plain burger with mozzarella cheese and we got a double burger with onion rings bacon and barbecue sauce on it. They were both good, buns were good, burgers were good, No real complaints but also not like wow I want this again. A bit pricey for what you're getting especially with the slow service.I would say the burgers are similar if a little smaller than Bill Gray's. Then we had a bit of a stumbling block. At this point it was about 5:40\ 5:30 and they were in full swing for dinner Rush on a Wednesday and very understaffed. After half an hour of waiting for our server to come back, I had to get up and go to the bar to order the milkshake. At one point someone came and cleared our dishes and asked us if we wanted more water to which we said yes and they never showed back up. That's definitely a very strong second strike. Bill came to $72 which seems utterly ridiculous for a couple of burgers and fries, a pretzel and a milkshake even if it's a very impressive milkshake. I don't think it was a $20 milkshake. It had an ice cream sandwich on it, two brownie bites and a cosmic brownie. Frosting along the rim with some little candies kind of pressed into the frosting. It looked great and it was good, I just don't think it was $20 good. $15 probably would have been fair. Even though it took them a while to get our order and to get us our milkshake and I had to go track someone down in order to order it they were pretty quick to take our money when it was time to pay the check. They also do one of those awkward things where they have a handheld credit card machine that they pop your card into and set it down while they stand there and watch you put in the tip which I never love. All in all was it interesting? Sure and she really enjoyed it and that's what it was about. I don't see us going back frequently. Small side note for the colder months it's a relatively small restaurant and the front door opens to the street so every time someone either comes in or goes out a freezing gust of air blows through the whole restaurant so come dressed for cold weather.

Great martini. Good food. Nice atmosphere. It's a nice place for casual dining. The bar looked…read morelike it would be a fun place to meet new friends.

We went on a Wednesday to celebrate our 54th anniversary …read more My husband has a hearing problem and the waitress changed our table to a quieter corner to accommodate his needs. Our dinner was delicious from beginning to end. The cocktails were perfect. The calamari and our main course were also quite good. The chef bakes the bread daily as well as all the desserts! Both were outstanding. Warning- come hungry. Portions are large!