Pizza was excellent! The crust is on the thinner side but stayed crispy. Clean dining area to sit and eat or convenient to take home. We will be back! read more

Great food, wonderful service, attention to special requests. And they have gluten free pizza!!! The garden salad is amazing with romaine lettuce!!! read more

People are really nice here. I come here after work for a refresher and they are always so kind. As for the food, It's a pizzeria; fish n' chips with savory, ketchup and fries yummm... read more

Don't get pizza here. The crust is not hand made dough. Its been frozen like Pizza Hut. The sauce is inferior grocery store grade but still costs $25 for a medium pie. Not worth the money. read more

Super unfortunate experiences given the location. Extremely over priced. Might be okay if the management was nice.... They are extremely rude...especially towards men. Mess up our order every time... which we say is fine and still have attitude. We boycotted months ago after a couple small pizzas, mozz sticks and a salad cost us over $100! read more

Decent option for the area. Pizza is acceptable. The chicken parm sub is good. Sauce is good. Everyone is friendly and they have beer.

I think this place has average pizza and the workers or whoever talked to my mom when she stopped in was a complete ass hat and was very rude and so I was definitely not impressed by the environment. read more

Was passing through and stopped for pizza. Crust was crispy, fresh sautéed mushrooms, lots of cheese, and perfect amount of sauce. Appreciate the friendliness of the staff and the clean establishment. Will definitely be stopping by again! read more

I order an Italian sub. What's so hard about making an Italian sub suitable? It's not complicated. You need to know what's in it, and if you have it on your menu, you should know it's in it! here's what I got a couple of pieces of salami, some American ham with some lettuce, tomato, and if you can believe this jalapeño that was it, that's about a far cry from an Italian sub if I've ever seen. On top of that whoever took my order had such a sullen look on his face I'll never go back to this supposedly sub shop! And on top of that with tip I spent $13 on the sandwich which I would've happily paid had It been decent. save your money! read more

Disgusted and appalled. I ordered a pizza before 8pm on a Thursday night - along with a salad and garlic bread. I waited until I got home to open the pizza box. Upon opening the box, I noticed the cheese wasn't really melted or cooked - but I was hungry, so looked beyond that and took a bite. I discovered they had taken a small cheese pizza that was CLEARLY cooked much earlier, and sprinkled new cheese and pepperoni on top of it, and tossed it in the oven - long enough to overcook the crust, and barely melt the cheese. I cannot believe I was charged for a pizza when I was clearly given leftovers. Don't waste your time or money here. read more

See all

...twenty-four bucks for spongy cheese, and I'm not picky when it comes to pizza. I'll take the Cumby's two slices for five (and die just as quickly). Might want to also update the website that talks about Italian style pies for half the price. And so it goes, another day in zen paradise. read more

This place is awesome. I'm from out of town and it seems like the greatest little place for late night greasy pizza and baklava. Food was made quick but fresh, and was so good I finished my pizza in one sitting. read more

Pizza was decent. Owner or whoever took my order however were far less pleasant, blatantly lied to my face about quantity and cost. Watched them handle my slice in the back like it was going to be fed to my dog. Would not recommend if you like being treated like a human when you go to get your pizza lol read more

Pizza was good but the guy on his cell, while he prepares and touches the pizzas, is just gross. He kept switching the phone from hand to hand while heating up our slices and YUCK. Cell phones are literally dirtier than toilet seats and how the heck is it even ok for him to use his phone while touching food? Yikes. read more

Stopped in to get some pizza, on our way back from a ski trip, my son had to use the bathroom first, the owner flipped out and slammed the door on us. The guy has noticeable anger management issues. To add insult to injury, the pizza was horrible and overpriced. $6 for a tiny slice and water. I would avoid this place. read more

When we moved here from Pizza City, we experienced a real shock. Kind of like going to anywhere and getting Maxwell House in a nation with wall-to-wall Starbucks and other fine coffees. Like, why? We tried all the pizza in town and it all pretty much fell way short (based on what we like in pizza). Thank God we found this place. Imagine Italian pizza! Go figure. The kitchen staff are super and we have never had bad experience ordering or picking up. A few deliveries were kind of odd (they couldn't find our house which is one of the easiest to locate in Brattleboro). But if you are visiting Brattleboro and are a discriminating pizza head, this place is the place to call. read more

Pizza is good. It's also the type of pizza that is as good, if not better, when you heat it up the next day. It is expensive but you get what you pay for (a large pizza is A LARGE PIZZA). Had a chicken gyro as well, it was DELICIOUS. SOOOOOO GOOD. Highly recommend the sandwiches as well. read more

West Brattleboro Pizza make some delicious pizza! This pizza shop makes amazing veggie pizzas, and the crust and topics are always done right. The last time we went we purchased 7 pizzas for an event were were hosting, and had to say that they were consistent across the board. Their meats pizzas are also incredible, and it is obvious that they always use fresh ingredients. The staff is always great and we generally have little wait time when we order here. The only downside to this location is the fact that they used to deliver, and no longer do. This is one of the reasons that we don't get pizza as much from this shop. read more

Tasty sandwiches, but my meatball sub was cold and I had gotten it to go. So that was unfortunate. The cheese wasn't melted. The employees were friendly, but they ignored me for a while when I first walked in because one of them was helping someone else and another was on her cell phone. I'm a big fan if eye contact and an "I'll be right with you." read more

Was very disappointed to see some of the employees not wearing masks. Not sure I'd feel comfortable going there again.

The greatest pizza in the Brattleboro area. Their crust is perfect and crispy, they top the pizza to the edge and their sauce and cheese is delicious. Their pizza is not greasy at all. We drive from Putney to West Brattleboro (past many other pizza places), it's worth the drive! read more

This is hands down the worst pizza I have ever had. We only stopped here because it was the first place we came across while searching for food one night and I honestly wish I had forgone food altogether rather than eat here. We asked for the two-slice special and they told me they were all out of slices (it was 8pm and this is supposedly a pizza place...) so he suggested making a personal pizza for us instead. The pizza was so covered in sauce that all of the cheese and toppings kept sliding off. Everything was completely tasteless and the crust was sopping wet in some spots from the excessive oil and sauce. I've truly never had worse pizza in my life. Do yourself a favor and avoid this place at all costs. read more

Based on reading a couple of other reviews and also what I was told by someone who used to live in this area, I think that this place may have been very different under previous ownership. I was told that this place has what was very close to New York style pizza, and that they also offered pizza by the slice which is hard to find in New England outside of big cities. Well, they do offer pizza by the slice, but the pizza taste pretty much the same as every other small town New England pizza joint. If you're used to small town New England Pizza, this place will be exactly what you expect. But, if you're expecting anything even remotely close to a New York slice, you're not going to find it here. The people were very friendly and the place was clean. If you're looking for the average small-town New England style pizza that's exactly what you're going to get here. read more

Pizza is awesome. Delicious. The woman here however is rudder than most. Almost makes it not worth the pizza at all. She is not very helpful. All around a rude experience. Wouldn't go again read more

Pizza's really nothing to write home about. The fact that they deliver all the way to Marlboro College is admirable, although there was one incident where the driver quit on the spot when we phoned an order in. read more

This was our first time trying West Brattleboro Pizza, having recently moved to the area from in state. We found their website online, and saw they delivered locally. Quote from the website: "Free Delivery Darci, Matt and Shay are ready to deliver your food. They are commited to delivering your food hot and fast. Surprise your loved one with a delivery at work from you. If you get delivery, why not for an extra menu for your neighbor. Not everyone knows we deliver!" When we called, the woman answering the phone was very firm they DID NOT deliver. When we asked why they would advertise that on the website if they did not she simply repeated they didn't deliver. Hmm... We shrugged it off, being only a quarter mile down the road and continued with our order. We inquired about the "homemade" sauce ingredients since someone in our household has a severe food allergy. Again the website promised: " We can't help but be a little saucy about our sauce. After all, ours is made with a special blend of herbs and spices combined with diced, vine-ripened Roma tomatoes from California. This all guarantees a very distinctive taste and texture that tastefully separates our sauce from the rest." Apparently they ARE a little "saucy" about their sauce. We were told the sauce comes "In a can." Special. Sounds like they need to either improve their service or update their website to reflect the current level they are willing to offer. False advertising is a good way to lead to disappointed customers. When we went to pick up the food, after the usual "twenty minutes"... the order wasn't even started. When we received the food, it was burned on the outside and cold in the middle. Save your time and money, go to one of the dozen or so other corner pizza shops in Brattleboro. read more

Sauce was over seasoned with oregano and no sweet flavor. The crust was almost great but just under cooked. I will give another try.

Guy behind counter was rude, made me pay a dollar for the bathroom! I'll never be back

Stopped in by chance. We had the antipasti salad. It was wonderful... the dressing was the best dressing I ever had. The owner makes it fresh every day and when complimented him he gave us some extra to take home! Very nice man and we had great service. Wish I could it 5 stars.... but we did not try the pizza!! oh Hell giving it five anyway!!! read more

Basic pizza, place is a little creepy... But cheap and easy. I live down the road so it's always an option. Wish they still delivered....

We had two nice pizzas, not delicious, but tasty with good vegetable toppings. The restaurant also has large salads and a few beer and wine selections. read more

Stopped coming back from Bennington, VT. The sauce and crust were really good and the price was right!

BEWARE, CREDIT CARD FRAUD! After calling ahead and ordering a pizza off of the menu, I arrived and was told by a large and very angry cashier that I had to pay extra, that the menu was wrong and it was my fault. I was intimidated, threatened, and finally forced to throw away the pizza or pay extra for it. When I returned home I saw on my credit card statement that I was charged twice. If you want to pay over $40 for a pizza, be yelled at and treated poorly, this is your place. If not, AVOID THIS RESTAURANT AT ALL COSTS. read more

We own a house up here and this pizza place is quite the spot to eat. Very friendly and very tasty of course. It's cheap and they are very consistent with everything. They're quick with every order. I ordered 2 large specialty pizzas and they were done within 20 minutes. This place is the pizza place to hit when coming through this town or the place to stop off of I-91. Very good and impressed every time. read more

Stopped in here on our way to Okemo Mt to ski. The staff was very friendly, attentive and cheerful. We ordered a "Special Pizza", basically a supreme or everything style pizza. The crust was the perfect thickness and the ingredients seemed fresh. Not too greasy and done pretty quickly too. We also enjoyed a Switchback Ale (local brew) but it was nice to see beer other than Bud Lite. The only negative is that the pizza is kinda expensive, although we got a Med and it was more than the 2 of us could eat. Ok atmosphere, clean, but not really decorated. We would eat there again. read more

ordered our dinners and salad,asked for extra sauce which we paid for,and did not get,the little lady at the counter does not even comprehend english! lot of money for very mediocre service,called owner he got got confrontational with me,im going to stop in there and get my money back.Do not patronize this shit show! read more

Just had lunch there while we were passing through town. The lady who took our order handed ( with no gloves after handling money) my pizza slices to a gentleman who was taking an order over the phone who was also not wearing gloves. Ick. The food was so so and a little pricey for 2 slices of pizza and a turkey sandwich. read more

Have to agree with the City Pizza review. Been in town for years and have come to figure that the area must have more pizza per capita then anywhere, but none any good. This place does the best job around. they are able to replicate the NYC thin crust better than any other area pizza read more

If you love under cooked pizza and a tyrant based atmosphere, this is the place to eat. Sandwiches are so-so and salads are okay but not much to offer in the way of pasta dinners. Everything about this place is sub-par plus they no longer deliver. read more

I have been highly disappointed more than once. I have gone in well before closing many times, last night for example I went in at a little after 9pm and everything was shut down for the night. As posted they don't close until 10pm. Now why would any legitimate business have all their grills shut down an hour early. I am also not the only person I know that this has been happening too. You guys either have very lazy workers or just don't care how to operate a business. Needless to say I will no longer refer or take my business there. read more