I had read about this place in an Elin Hilderbrand book and wanted to come to see what all the hype was about. I am an early morning riser so I didn't think that it would be too crowded at 7AM but boy was I wrong. There was already a line and they were already sold out and bak ordered for their famous morning buns. The young ladies behind the counter were working hard to keep everyone happy. We lucked out and despite a two hour wait for morning buns at that time in the morning they were able to accommodate our order for a morning bun and two serve yourself coffees. The coffee and the morning bun were divine! In this case the hype is definitely worth it. read more

Bought 6 Toads in a Hole yesterday morning to serve for breakfast and the dough and sausage was raw. A lot of money wasted and a health risk. read more

Wicked Island Bakery - Raw sausage - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

3rd time visiting Nantucket and have never been able to score one of the famous morning buns. We almost didn't try this time because we called ahead and were told "we're out right now". After some research, we decided that meant they would be making more, so we walked there and sure enough, there was a fresh tray! We debated about splitting one but got one each and it was totally the right call. They are so good, a bit like a cross between a popover, a croissant and a churro. Worth the wait! read more

Wicked Island Bakery - Morning bun - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Phenomenal bakery on the island! If you staying over night, for a week, or even just a day trip... you've got to make your way to the Wicked Island Bakery! What is good? Ha! What is NOT good? Organic and genuine. No negatives whatsoever. Yes, order in advance and online... welcome to the 2000s! Pop in and pick up. Great selection. Plenty of parking. A very nice and wonderful staff. read more

This place is always busy...and they always set such high standards! Food, service and appreciation is 120%!

Wow the morning bun is certainly worth the wait. We were advised to go early and no joke... My husband went about 15-20 minutes after they opened and they were sold out but he waited for them to make a new batch. It was so good. Tastes like a croissant cinammon roll. But with super flaky layers! The toad in the hole is also worth getting. Overall a great place!! read more

Quaint coffee shop. The coffee is good, nothing frilly or fancy but it hit the right spot. We both got the Lorraine breakfast sandwich which I never thought putting caramelized onions on a breakfast sandwich and now I think I'll always have to! Holy cow it changed the breakfast sandwich game. Luckily came at a non-busy time so service was quick! read more

Had to stop with a name like Wicked how could we walk past. Just had breakfast so not hungry so we got a cinnamon muffin which the helpful lady said was their speciality. It was so flaky and delicious. Well worth the walking distance from the Hy Line dock. read more

Wicked Island Bakery - Flaky cinnamon muffin. - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Cute bakery with a nice friendly staff. Great place to go if you are an early riser because they open at 6 am. The service was great and the shop smelled lovely. Had the lemon blueberry scone and a drip coffee. They had three drip coffee options and lots of milk, cream and milk alternatives. It's worth a visit for a pastry breakfast. read more

Wicked Island Bakery - Don't forget to get your coffee. - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Congratulations! I have to say, after 15 years of coming to Nantucket, I have finally found the least competent business on the island! Beware customers: the morning buns that are out are not for you! They're for people who already ordered them. Guess what? You're going to have to wait at least an hour to ~maybe~ try an elusive morning bun. Wicked Island - Don't put morning buns out if they're already sold. It's messed up. Also, saying "I don't know how long the list is" when you have it directly in front of you is extremely rude @the people working behind the counter. Take online orders. Take phone call orders. I understand that you are a small family business, but I come from a family that has owned two different small businesses, one of which was a bakery. I understand the concept of stock and inventory, but your system is ridiculous and ruins the mornings of the customers who are only here for a few days and are looking to grab a pastry and go. If people are raving about your buns, why wouldn't you optimize your system to actually make everyone happy instead of catering to regulars? It seems the system is "if you know you know" and everyone else is left in the dust. Looking forward to making my own morning buns! read more

I unfortunately cannot even attest to the quality of the pastries as I was denied entry. I come over at 7:45 am (1:45 after then open), and the lights are all off, the door is locked, and there is nothing out. When I pulled up, a woman who I assume is the proprietor of the business did as well. I call the store multiple times, no one picks up. I am knocking on the door and making eye contact with the woman, and she slowly closes the curtain while making direct eye contact with me. Not to mention, it is pouring rain and I am soaked. I was going to this bakery to get morning buns for my friend's birthday, well I guess not! Not to mention, google and yelp said they were completely open. read more

This review is for the morning buns. Easily one of the best things on the island. I don't even know what a bun is, but it's incredible.

We walked about a mile in a drizzling rain to get some morning buns and they did not disappoint. We also tried a honey bun- way too sweet and a scone that was just ok. I think because it was raining we had no problem getting the famous morning buns and no wait at all around 7, but it was quickly forming a line. read more

I had a similar experience to some other reviewers - staff did not explain their morning bun "process" well and it was very confusing. They were also fairly rude. Another patron who was waiting outside asked one of her family members to go inside to ask for napkins because she was afraid to go in and ask them another question because the staff "weren't very friendly". On the day I was there I went and asked about the morning buns - this was around 630 AM and they said they'd be out in 45 minutes. They didn't explain their "numbering" system where they give you a card until I went back in to ask about a bathroom (which they do not have - kind of absurd for a cafe asking you to wait up to an hour on site (they told me I shouldn't leave the property if I am waiting for the next batch)). About 20 minutes after I arrived morning buns came out, but the told me my number was for the "next tray" of buns and it'd be 40 more minutes. All of the other people waiting said they were confused and unsure of the process - this was about 4 or 5 other groups, so there were many confused patrons waiting around. The staff should to be able to clearly explain the system better. The morning bun was very good! But definitely not worth all of the above. I would only go there if you have time to kill and don't anticipate needing a bathroom during the hour they may ask you to wait on site. read more

I have been going to WIB since it opened and have never had a bad morning bun, almond croissant or any other item from them. Yes many times they are not available because they are so popular and can sell out in minutes. The staff even when overrun with customers are polite helpful and friendly. The owners are always a delight to talk to and work incredibly hard to make these delicious treats. You might see me there as I've volunteered to help move on angry and rude customers who throw a fit if the product is unavailable. Please grow up and act like an adult and you will be treated like one. Again always delicious food from these guys and long may it continue read more

Nice little shop, but a bit of truth in advertising is needed. Many reviews say their morning buns are great, but the shop should indicate on their web site that they are really only available between the 6:00 am opening and maybe, 6:30 am! After that the morning buns are pretty much no longer readily available. Maybe they'll make more, maybe not, and they can't tell you when they might. You can get on a wait list for the buns, and wait around, but as their employees say " there's no guarantee". Did get a blueberry muffin that was quite good though. Owner needs to train their staff in better sales technique. When someone comes in for the morning buns, and they're out, perhaps have your staff friendly say, " I'm sorry, but we're out, but perhaps you'd like to try a (name another product they do have available at the moment). They would probably get more customers to try other items from their menu, rather than walking out the door after just getting blank stares from the employees who are just sitting, waiting for the customer to say something else. read more

This is a great place to get a great cup of coffee and some yummy doughnuts. The bread is amazing.

Wicked Island is one of the best bakeries on Nantucket! Their most popular item is the morning bun, which is like a cross between a croissant and a cinnamon roll. In the morning, they come out warm and gooey with a crispy, flaky exterior. They're the most decadent morning buns I've ever had and they feel really heavy (probably from all the butter!). They're so popular that they sometimes limit how many you can purchase. Along with a familiar selection of cookies, muffins, croissants, and breakfast sandwiches, they have specialty items like maple bacon donuts and "toad in a hole," which looks like a kouign amann with an egg and ground sausage in the middle. Selection is hit or miss depending on the time of day. If you get there when they just open, the baked goods may not all be ready, and in the afternoon they might be sold out. I found the bakery a bit hard to find the first time I went here. Don't give up if you can't find it right away! read more

Disappointed. Of course everyone wants to try the morning buns but they can only make so many. I got there around 7:15 AM but Once I heard them tell the lady in front of me that the entire pan in the oven was already purchased I got a raspberry muffin. There were only raspberries on top. Otherwise nothing caught my eye. Too bad. read more

Wicked Island Bakery - "Raspberry" muffin - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Ok. The morning bun. Yes, it's delicious but, do not sleep on the donuts!!! Those little guys are the bomb! I've had the sugar in the past which were amazing and today I tried the glazed and OMG they are little cakey flavor bombs! I wasn't much of a donut lover but, this place has changed my mind! Also, pretty damn good breakfast sammies too. read more

Wicked Island Bakery - The famous morning buns, fresh out of the oven! - Bakeries Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

See all

Great doughnut, breakfast sandwiches, coffee. Definitely get Breakfast Bun or Morning Bun, it's just great.

Amazing ham and cheese croissants, banana chocolate chip muffins, coffee friendly staff. HOWEVER the morning bun situation is a bit out of control. I'm 0/10 trying to get one I've been there at 7 AM- 10 AM. The times on the board of them coming out 10/10 times have all been accounted for or pre bought? At what point do you just make 1,000 of them? Very frustrating because they are so good ... read more

This is a 5 star bakery! Amazing scones! Looking forward to having the vanilla & chocolate birthday cake layer today!

Service is wonderful, people are great, morning bun go fast but are made throughout the day and they are as good as people say!

Arrived at 930am and the shelves were all empty. They had some premade breakfast sandwiches left in some warming shelves but I would have preferred made to order. read more

two words: morning bun. get it, got it, good. top two best bakeries on the island. they also have awesome some pre-made goods. Back in December we got to try a truffle mushroom dip which was phenomenal. Wicked Island has easily become a go-to for us when on Nantucket. read more

Morning buns and nitro coffee. Week in ACK made. We walked here almost every day and tried something different. Quick service -- just go early. read more

Pretty freaking boss bakery. Get here early for The Bun. Fast service, great coffee, bomb baked goods.

Tried to go in for an pastry assortment and was met by really unpleasant folks. Three different people took over my order, no one was clear about what pastries were "available" or not. I wanted more but ended up leaving with half the order I was supposed too because I felt so awkward. I was abandoned at the register and scowled at by a manager when I asked after 5 minutes if I was good to go. Update after eating: Pastries were almost $4 each and really dry. I think they gave me left overs. Not going back. read more

I am so incredibly disappointed with this bakery. We came here because the items we had last trip were of excellent quality. Members of my family and I went here 5 times in one week and EVERY time they were out of ALL croissants, morning buns and most muffins. At 7am. So we tried earlier. And then 820. The sales staff were unrepentant. They sold out a whole tray of morning buns (their signature item) in less than 2 minutes. They told us to come an hour later to then be told they sold the whole tray for preorders. Everyone in line with me said they had the exact same experience all week and were furious. Total waste of my personal time. Don't advertise a service that you evidently cannot provide. read more

It took me 3 days to finally get an opportunity to purchase the morning roll. Being a fellow Chef and understanding the many layers of the food service industry, its extremely odd their production is this antiquated. It's fun to have a mystery, but when it becomes an inconvenience the novelty will be lost. That said this Small roll was good but at the price of $6. each ...not so much! read more

Love this bakery! They moved from their last location to a new really nice space. When we did find it it didn't disappoint. Best everything here...especially the morning muffin. Fantastic!!! read more

Their fresh baked bread and morning buns are incredible! Always delicious and still warm from the oven!

Ive been coming here for years, used to be a great place for the coffee and pizza or anyting but lately the quality of the food has gone really bad. They pizza is really bad, tasteless, greasy and the dough is raw. Place is not clean at all. read more

Every year the experience goes down and today was the last straw. Hour wait for their signature product, super rude staff, an all around disaster. I get it's a busy weekend, doesn't explain the rudeness. read more

I can't rate the food because when we (my wife and I) walked in, the counter person was too busy chatting with an obvious friend. After five minutes of waiting and several confirmed eye contact moments, we left. At a time of year when you would think every customer counts, we didn't. read more

Everybody who knows knows this is THE breakfast bakery. The variety of scrumptious pastries is impressive. Love it!

Perfect. Morning buns always a welcome treat when we come to ack for R&R Coffee is delicious Great service today!!! read more

I called to see if they had any of their amazing cinnamon roll donuts left. I called because we have stopped by several times at various times and they were always out. They were out again, it was 6:30 am. New batch ready in 30 minutes. I was already en route so I thought I would just grab coffee and wait. As I walked in, I was blasted by the heat in the store. I poured a coffee and milk. The milk was bad. Another employee remarked how awful it smelled. I poured it out. Another customer asked after the donuts, wanting to pay for them and wait. The counter person snapped that he couldn't prepay and would need to wait in line with everyone else. I promptly left. They need to figure out their production schedule, customer service and temperature monitoring on dairy. No donuts for you! read more

Best morning bun / sticky bun on the island. Toasted coconut donuts are moist and tasty. Want your pick of baked goods? Get there early or be prepared to wait for the next batch to come out of the oven. With the demise of Petticoat Bakery, WIB is now our go to for fresh baked delights while vacationing on our favorite island getaway. (To minimize the guilt factor of this guilty pleasure, try biking there in the early morning before the mid island traffic gets too crazy). read more