Lucky Penny is an old small bar in the heart of Waukesha that is charming, clean & inviting…read more The menu is small but everyone in my group of 7 was very pleased with what they ordered. I had a grilled chicken sandwich which was very tasty. Nice place, I would definitely go again

Stopped in for lunch on a Saturday. Ordered at the bar and sat at a table. Waited an hour twenty…read morefor steak sandwiches. Not sure if the order was forgotten. It certainly was not busy. Steak had no seasoning. Fries tasted only of oil. Had high hopes but will not be back.

First time here since the ownership change. Heard they were not going to change much, and I have…read moreto say they have kept their word. Two of us ordered the Backyard BBQ burger, one without sweet potato fries and the other with tots. The third person ordered the Pizzaz burger with breaded mushrooms. All were cooked medium as requested and were very tasty. The sweet potato fires, breaded mushrooms, and tots were also very good. The breaded mushrooms were strips of a large mushroom as opposed to mushroom cups. The only issue we had was both Backyard BBQ burgers were servered with sweet potato fried instead of one having tots. Our server, Olivia quickly corrected the situation by bring us an order of tots. Olivia did a great job, was personable, pleasant, and provided great customer service! Inside the ambiance hasn't change and is still pleasant and comfortable. They have a nice mix of regular height and high-top tables. Plenty of TV's are placed throughout, including on their very nice outdoor patio. They have claimed to have the best burgers in town, and they continue to provide burgers that meet that claim.

We went here a few weeks back with some friends. The last time we ate here we had a great…read moreexperience, but it was probably over a year ago. My husband decided to order the meatloaf. Which I guess could be kind of odd to have on a bar menu, but if it's on the menu, you would think it would be good. The second it was put down. It looked like it came out of a prepared TV dinner. The meatloaf was thin, sliced, and tasted did just like a Salisbury steak. And kind of chewy. Not appealing on the plate either. He substituted a side salad instead of fries. The side salad was super tiny and not worth it. I ordered wings. When they were delivered all 12 were drummies. I didn't get one flat. The waitress then brought me out some flats mins later when I asked for them and showed her my plate. As for beverages, I ordered a tap of spotted cow and it was very flat and not cold. We won't be back anytime soon.

I was really looking forward to trying this place, unfortunately most of their food was burnt. I…read morehad the Fish Fry Fecta and the potato pancakes were so overcooked, they broke apart. The cod tasted burnt , and one of the other fish was mushy. I was told the Reuben and the Quesadilla Burger were good, but the onion rings were overcooked. I won't be back.

Visiting from Ohio... For my first time here, I'll go 4/5…read more This is DEFINITELY a great homey-vibe place to go, especially if you love football. The atmosphere was amazing and so was the food! A bit loud, but I am NOT complaining! I know what cheering for your favorite football team is like. :) I got the Chicken Pesto Panini.. Great if you love cheese (we're in Wisconsin, it makes sense). Everything was cooked to perfection. Fries were good! But lacked salt... Could be a little warmer, but they were good nonetheless. Paige was our server. Very very sweet. She greeted us with a smile and didn't leave us for too long before coming back again. Will definitely be back if I visit this area again.

Fourth visit since new ownership took over. Each and every Food item from Friday fish fry, baked,…read morebroiled, hand breaded, cod, perch, appetizer, to steak dinners every menu option is Delicious, Drinks Refreshing, Service Fast, Friendly, Enthusiastic Ambiance Clean, Bright, Refreshing. They have definitely turned the former Eric's Steak House around! It's now a thriving, vibrant, fresh and delicious. Make time to stop in and explore this exciting experience with your favorite family members and friends. Bon appétit. PS. Say hi Cara the youthful, bartender that is quick to refill that refreshing drink Or take your food order at the bar so you don't have to give up your convenient comfortable seat.

I recently visited Mayor's Restaurant with a group of friends for a light meal the other evening…read more I really appreciated our server, Salina. She was witty, resourceful, accommodating, engaging, and kept our beverages full, despite the large number of us. She had our party in one room and then other tables through the restaurant (our group occupied one of the rooms due to its size). As someone who has spent a career in the hospitality industry, that kind of service is VERY hard to find since COVID. And we had separate checks, she rocked it no problem. Again, hard to find. It's a charming building, and the new look is fitting for the menu and atmosphere. The crafted drink menu and tap beer selection were respectable, and nothing outrageously priced either. That went throughout the menu; it's not huge, and the price points are average, but it's done right. The bulk of my party ordered burgers; the Mayor's burger and brisket burger getting several nods apiece. Another ordered the Cajun pasta with crispy chicken (recommended by Salina) and he loved it. BLT was enjoyed throughly as well. I ordered the Blackened Cajun Chicken sandwich. Having filled up on mozz sticks and my fries (I hate cold fries) I could only finish half of it, but I was impressed. The chicken was seasoned good without overdoing it, and filled the entire French roll, which itself was very good too. The bread held up to the ingredients, including lettuce and tomato, which I usually avoid in case I don't finish like this visit. Didn't matter, the next day the bread still had that great chew, tomato still dripped out when I bit down, impressive. Didn't get all slopped up from sitting in a container overnight. I'm looking forward to my next visit.

Tonight we went to tally's tap for their Friday night, fish fry…read more I have to say my husband and I both enjoyed it very much. The fish fry was excellent and as far as I know, they served homemade potato pancakes that were the bomb. My only complaint is that water the fish and the potato pancakes could use just a hint of salt. But sometimes when you ask for that you get a whole salt shaker dumped down and we certainly don't want that either.!! As I said, we did not go in so I cannot tell you what it is like on the inside but that fish fry sure was good! We will keep going back! Also, the buns were really good!

Impressed that my food came out rather quickly right after ordering…read morePrices seem to be spot on for most of the menu Service fee is added on for credit card users Tables filled up rather fast for a Friday lunch hour Nothing really stood out for me to consider this as a top restaurant on my list

Some of the best wings I've had and I've had a TON. As a former Marine, everyone there is extremely…read moresupportive of the troops and some of nicest staff I've met. Make sure to stop in for their wings or fish fry - absolutely worth it.

Visiting my daughter for the weekend - we were looking for a place to have lunch... we read some…read morereviews and thought we would give it a try. When we walked in, we were not greeted so we grabbed a table. Many minutes later, someone came over and asked if we were there to eat or drink or both. We told her we were mostly there to eat but a few beers would be needed for the over 21's. A couple of people on our party ordered wings and a someone had chicken fingers. Someone ordered a burger and someone else ordered a wrap. I had the French Dip and shared it with my daughter. The food was good; typical bar food. Prices are great. Drinks were cold. The bar is cute with a lot of history. Service was terrible... but that's okay, we weren't really expecting much.

Great bar, good friendly service with a nice atmosphere. They have a nice selection of beers.read more

First time here. Atmosphere was nice and very pleasant VERY friendly staff and the owner could not…read morehave been nicer. That was all excellent. Got a history lesson from the owner about the connection to Les Paul and his family who owned the place originally. The food is the extreme problem here. There were two people in our party one ordered a Rueben the other had a build your own burger. The burger was fantastic the Rueben was horrible. The burger went with tater tots which were also phenomenal. The Rueben went with onion rings which were completely forgettable. When the food came there was no silverware with it. I asked for some from the bartender who looked at me completely puzzled. I also told him I would like some ketchup. He brought some ketchup which was half full BUT it was better than empty like the first one. The silverware was also the problem as the bartender brought over a dirty plastic container that was 1/4 full of black plastic forks and handed them to us. I was a little taken aback to say the least. Based on this visit I cannot recommend the place.

Great bar food Pizza is delicious and the bartenders are…read morealways friendly and fun Place can get busy, especially during meat raffles and sports events. Great place to stop after a day on Pewaukee Lake !!!

Nice water view restaurant! Friendly and fast service. They were out of crab Rangoon rolls so we…read moretried the crab Rangoon nachos. Wow! Delicious, but very rich. Good patty melt and chicken bacon ranch wrap.

Went here 7/2/26 and ordered sweet BBQ with my chicken tenders and I got the wrong sauceread more

Arrived for lunch at noon on Monday, August 3rd. Greeted by a hostess, told her we had a party of 6…read moreand would need a high chair. She said it would be 10 minutes as they only have one server and he's already behind. As far as I could tell there was one other table sitting. Why not seat us and have the manager or hostess step in and get drinks started? You lost a large lunch tab, and we won't be back.

This is always a good stop and a cool hang. Service may be slow at times but that's because the…read moreplace is always packed. The staff never stops moving. It would be frustrating if they were standing around/goofing off but that's not the case here. There are some standouts on the menu: any of the smoked meats, the Rajun Cajun, the Tenderloin Sandwich, always a good burger, the wings and any of the specials. Always delicious specials.

Nikki was great and so much fun. Ive always loved visiting this bar when in town. Great little placeread more