Winsor is Wonderful! I see that Yelpers do not love Winsor due to the low ratings and reviews but I have to ask why. What I will say is if you read these bad reviews you might be surprised at what people complain about. But, on a more positive note, this will be my 3rd time dining here and everytime has been wonderful (hence my title). The food, ambiance, drinks, etc. you really can't go wrong with any of them. And, the drive there is also stunning. Duxbury as you know is a beautiful beach and golf city with million dollar homes along the way. Cha-Ching! I arrived a little early while I waited for my friend to arrive. The restaurant was not overly crowded which was good for a Friday evening. We sat right near the fireplace which was super nice. When my friend arrived we started with some drinks. Then we were so torn as to what to order so we started with their Tuna Crudo. My favorite since it was super fresh, melt in your mouth sashimi. Yummy! Then we shared a salad which was just ok. For entrees, she ordered the Linquine Vongole which looked good but a huge portion. I ordered Fluke for the first time and although it wasn't what I am used to, I still enjoyed it. We passed on dessert and had coffee with amaro; they have some nice after dinner drinks. All I have to say is go see for yourself that this gorgeous, south shore spot is perfect for any occassion. Or even if you want to grab a glass of wine/drink and sit at the bar, that sounds good too! Cheers~! read more

I'll start with the highlights. The restaurant itself is beautiful, and our server, Riley, was friendly, attentive, and wonderful to work with. We were there celebrating my aunt's birthday, and the team did several things that made the evening feel special. They had all signed a birthday card for her, gave her a complimentary glass of wine, and were very accommodating about allowing us to bring our own cake and helping us with everything we needed to serve it. Those thoughtful touches were genuinely appreciated. Most of our meals were also very good. Our party ordered a variety of dishes, including the bluefin tuna, salmon, and burger, and everyone was pleased with those. Unfortunately, there were also several misses that surprised me, particularly because I've dined here five or six times over the years and have always thought of this as a higher-end experience. One person ordered the King Caesar with fried oysters, and the oysters were extremely small and over-fried, with very little actual oyster left inside. I had also requested a fried oyster for my burger because I remembered how delicious the burger used to be served that way years ago--with a beautiful, substantial fried oyster on top. What arrived this time was tiny, crumbly, and overcooked. I'll include a photo because I think it speaks for itself. We also paid the additional $9 for the cast-iron bread, but unfortunately the entire bottom of the bread was black and appeared to have been badly overcooked. Drink service was another issue throughout the evening. Drinks were extremely slow to arrive. After dinner, two of us went to the bar for one last glass of wine and waited approximately 20 minutes. The bartender explained that he was waiting for a glass, which seemed surprising for a restaurant of this caliber. There were some other service details that felt off as well. When our meals were brought to the table, the person delivering them didn't know who had ordered what, so I ended up directing him around the table for each plate. It's a small detail, but at this level of restaurant, those details are part of the experience. Overall, we enjoyed celebrating my aunt's birthday and really appreciated the kindness shown to her, particularly by Riley and the team. But compared with my previous visits, this was definitely my most disappointing experience. There were simply too many lapses in food preparation and service for a restaurant at this price point. I've enjoyed coming here over the years, but after this visit, I would pause before making plans to return. read more

Winsor House - Photos of the inedible fried oysters Island Creek Oysters Island Creek Oysters - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

Lovely setting, food was excellent. We had the street corn appetizer, avocado salad, tuna entree. Good for families, we sat inside but the outdoor garden is beautiful. Prices are in line with higher end restaurants, best meal we had in Duxbury and Plymouth for sure. read more

We wanted to try something a bit different for Valentine's Day and came across a prefix dinner with 4 courses at the Windsor house. The ambiance is what you would expect from a house built in 1803. Our server Erica was most delightful and was very attentive considering how busy the restaurant was on a holiday. The appetizers were plentiful commencing with oysters, scallop cerviche, and lobster salad. We both chose lamb chops which were plated very nicely. The finale was an amazing raspberry and hazelnut tiramisu. Each course tantalized your tastebuds. All and all a very pleasant holiday celebration! read more

Winsor House - Raspberry and hazelnut tiramisu - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

very imaginative bar and kitchen. Locally owned by an actual Oysterman. Love the apps.

Went there with reservations on Friday night. Place is beautifully decorated for Christmas. Fireplace was burning. Tons of people there so glad I had reservations. Staff was friendly and helpful and great. Drinks were amazing...I ordered a cranberry mule that wasn't on the menu ...so good. My dinner was exceptional as was my husband's. I had a sirloin steak and it was cooked perfectly and tender . Garlic mashed with it. Only thing missing was complimentary bread or rolls. My husband had a lamb ragu I believe, he said it was great. The atmosphere was just great and what I needed. Highly recommend! read more

Being local, this is a restaurant that we go to every so often. We've been 4 times in the last few months alone (twice for brunch, twice for dinner) and each time has been an increase in disappointment. As a result, we will be taking a long break. A consistently good experience has been the oysters and starters. Fortunately, it's easy to cross the street and eat at the ICO raw bar or bring some oysters home to shuck. That will continue. Cocktails are usually good. But Winnie entrees have been consistently under seasoned and underwhelming these last visits. On our last visit, one dish was so bad that much was inedible (and even what was consumed was mediocre). Vibes are good, so maybe just come for a drink and apps at the bar. Treat yourselves to a full meal elsewhere. read more

I had dinner here last night at the bar. Service was great. The burger, however, was disappointing. It's described as a double "smash burger" and I ordered mine without a bun. In hindsight, I should have sent it back. The meat was overcooked, nearly charred, and each burger only about 3" In diameter. I expected better quality from Windsor. read more

Came here on a Thursday evening with friends and a great experience. The food was delicious and the space was beautiful. Service and Staff: - All of the staff members were very nice and professional - We had a reservation and were seated immediately Food and Drinks: - Winsor fries: the garlic mayo was so good and made these fries even better. Would order this again - Tuna and beef tartare: can be shared with multiple people as it's on a large piece of toast. Flavorful and light - Lobster ceviche: little bit on the smaller side (either a meal for one person or an appetizer to share between two to three people). Refreshing, light, delicious - Pork belly clam chowder: definitely a unique dish that you should try. It's hearty and flavorful and comes with a good amount. - Linguine vongole: your classic clam pasta. Comes with a good amount for one meal or to share - Oysters: they have a variety of oysters to choose from - Figment of Imagination: they have some very fun sounding cocktails, but I ended up going with this one and enjoyed the slight kick to the drink Miscellaneous: - Indoor and outdoor seating available - Parking available via a parking lot (definitely recommend coming before the dinner rush and / or making a reservation as it got crowded, even on a Thursday - Make sure to take a look at the interior as it has a lot of details (looks like it was potentially previously a home) read more

See all

This was our first visit this summer and it's been a while since I reviewed. In my opinion, this is the best restaurant in the South Shore. I don't understand the reviews that say otherwise. It's expensive because it's an elevated experience. DH tried three different types of oysters and loved all of them. Each with distinct flavor. The crudo was impeccably seasoned. I had the Tommy Noble gin cocktail, which is a complex and delicious cocktail. The orange wine served by the glass was bright and crisp and perfect with all of our dishes. The seasonal grilled peaches and burrata bruschetta is not to be missed. We were big fans of the old "driveway" clams dish, but the new "surf" clams are just as good. Big chunks of pork belly and savory broth. Finally the stripped bass was incredible. A beautiful thick piece of fish perfectly cooked and served simply with a salad dressed with a ginger vinaigrette that complimented it so well. We saw Skip checking in with the raw bar team, which is always a nice touch. His influence shows. Thanks for another great night. read more

See all

Came for the weekend brunch and was impressed with the food but found the service to be mediocre,we had two servers One was very friendly and welcoming but the other server wasn't all that interested,it was nearing the end of the brunch shift so maybe that had something to do with it. Owned by the folks at island creek oysters it's located right across the street in a storied old inn that was warm and inviting. Of course we started with a selection of local oysters,perfect... onto the smash burger on a English muffin with cheese and a "big Mac"style sauce it was the perfect brunch bite with fries and garlic mayo. Also had the New England breakfast of two eggs,crunchy delicious potato rosti and bacon with grilled sourdough bread. Price point was decent. Will be back to try dinner in the warmer months. read more

Winsor House - Smash burger - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

This place is a 20/10 in every category. Food service culture ingredients quantity ambiance cleanliness timeliness, it's honestly a world class experience. I cannot believe it's in duxbury. Easily one of the most unique places in all of Massachusetts. We had one of the best meals of our lives here. It was beyond, we will be back for every special occasion. read more

See all

Pros: Very nice server doing her best. A bit slow getting going but we could see she was totally slammed and once she knew we were in a rush (we had a play to get too), she totally stepped it up and was perfect. Definitely not her fault, it was pretty obvious, the place was packed. Food was excellent. Drink was excellent (I had the mezcal cocktail with the aperol, maraschino and lemon -yum! If you are a Paper Plane or Naked and Famous person I recommend.) Adorable place, great ambience. I'm sure it would be lovely in the winter and the outdoor seating is also quite fetching. Con: SO SO noisy. I don't know if it's possible to do anything but we could not hear each other. Very large and loud party next to us, but that happens, and even after they left, it was still too loud. Some kind of remediation (doors between the small rooms would really help) is needed. We won't go back for this reason and only this reason. Otherwise, totally recommend! read more

Our appetizers of crab lettuce wraps. Crab cakes. And shrimp cocktail. Stole the show. Absolutely amazing. Our server Raymond was outstanding in every way. Our entrees were ok. But every other bit of our night was outstanding. Would highly recommend read more

Creative menu, delicious food, Artfully presented. The atmosphere is New England meets hipster NYC. Service is professional, our server knew the menu and specials and was able to make top suggestions. read more

The new Version of the Winsor House is awesome. Since Island Creek took it over the food is better, the service is great, the ambiance is relaxed and welcoming. This place has become our winter go-to Sunday brunch spot. I take back everything I said in my scathing review from years ago. This is now a regular rotation, looking forward to eating here spot. read more

This was an impromptu dinner on our way home from a weekend at the Cape. We will be back! Service, food, cocktails, ambiance are all top notch! Fresh raw bar selections, delicious Caesar salad topped with the most delicious fried oysters (apparently coated in salt & vinegar chips rather than traditional breading- OMG!), perfect halibut, incredible cocktails... can't wait for the next time!! read more

Staff was Great, oysters fresh and very tasty, believe it or not the fried Chicken was delicious (special) Fried Clam and Onion rings needed to be cleaned better (sand)! read more

We love Island Creek oysters and were really excited to try Winsor house. We were seated at a little two top by the door and the hostess got water for us. I am glad that we arrived early as the space filled up quickly. There are several dining rooms, all simply decorated but very nice. Our server was lovely and did her best. Dinner took about two and a half hours for oysters, two courses, and dessert. The food was phenomenal. We had a dozen oysters, sliders, corn, arancini, driveway clams, and the chocolate cake. The server told us they were out of ice cream but we saw some at another table. The staff are kind, but it is hard to identify who works there and who does not. The hostess was wearing sweatpants and the host oversized jeans. There was no sign of anyone who might be management. read more

Food was all very good - burrata is a must order it was soooo good! Arancini, steak and linguine were all good too! Service was good & ambiance was outstanding with all of the holiday decor! read more

See all

Incredible! Do not skip this place. The oyster and clams were delectable and well worth the trip to Duxbury. The service is amazing with a down to earth vibe and all in a historic house built over 200 years ago. A MUST! read more

My 3 year old daughter and I stopped in for a girls brunch a few weeks ago. We got right in, no reservation and sat down. The waitress was incredibly kind and was quick to take our order. We had a delicious brunch and the waitress was so patient with us. She had a big room of busy tables and yet she was so attentive. Winsor hour is a beautiful spot, it was all decorated for Christmas and all the things to see around the room really kept my daughter entertained. Wonderful spot, delicious food, and great service. read more

Went here on Valentine's Day for dinner and was projectile vomiting for 2 hours after. Definitely won't be back which is too bad because it looks nice and has a a cozy vibe but food poisoning is not acceptable. read more

Went here for our anniversary and had some of the best service I've had at any restaurant, anywhere. They were so accommodating, quick, and welcoming. I had the chowder which was INCREDIBLE. The pork belly stayed crispy while still being submerged in soup?? Magic. I had the arctic char and I really enjoyed it, the flavors were delicious. It had an apricot and pea salad topping. My husband had the burger which he really enjoyed, but the french fries were the star of the show! Going back tonight with friends, will update with our selections! read more

See all

We had an amazing dinner and I have to give a huge shoutout to Kelsey! She was absolutely the best. From start to finish, Kelsey made sure my experience was nothing short of perfect. Her knowledge of the menu was impressie and she made spot-on recommendations and answered all our questions with ease. On top of that, her attention to detail and genuine care made us feel so well taken care of. It's rare to find someone so passionate about what they do, and it truly showed in the service she provided. Because of Kelsey, I will 100% be back! She is a gem, and the Winsor House is lucky to have her. Highly recommend dining here and asking for Kelsey if you can! read more

Overall I absolutely loved the Winsor House. The service was great, friendly and prompt. Very quaint and comfortable inside, classic New England feeling. The food was delicious but the menu was quite limited (dinner) we would love to come back for their Sunday brunch. read more

Winsor House - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

Limited menu. Poor selection caused us to walk out and go to Oysterman. There wasn't even a lobster roll on the menu.

I love everything about the Winsor House. The cocktail menu is unique and delicious and the raw seafood options are extensive. We had a group of 8 and we were able to order plate after plate for the table and enjoy a little bit of everything. Maybe the only thing that was not loved was the meatballs. Everything else was devoured! read more

Great food. Great drinks. Wonderful people. A must stop when in Duxbury. Amazing people!

I enjoyed trying out this restaurant with friends! Absolutely beautiful restaurant with multiple rooms. Everyone enjoyed what they picked and loved the oysters! I do with they have more normal breakfast options on top of what they currently have. The coffee was delicious and drank every sip of it! read more

See all

First time at this restaurant and we had high hopes. Drinks were excellent as were the oysters. The fried clams were the worst I've had in a while. They were way too dark, soggy and I had to root around to find a belly or two. Salad was served on top of the clams and onion rings making it even more soggy. The clam chowder was very good but all other meals and apps were just okay. Service was excellent but the addition of 8% for staff did rub us the wrong way. We gave a 20% tip so adding the 8% makes things a little too expensive for what we got. Unfortunately we will not be back. read more

Winsor House is elite. Menu can be intimidating for some but almost everything is excellent. Will not find better oysters anywhere. Burger is terrific, high quality sourcing & A+ prep on nearly every dish. Cocktails are great too. read more

Oysterman Burger + a fried oyster never disappoints! All-around great vibe, bar, and cocktails. read more

See all

I'm uncomfortable with a mandatory 8% service fee prior to walking in through the door. So basically when dining and you're a generous tipper (I.e. 20%-30%) on entire bill (including alcohol)...the restaurant operates to price gouge their customers even further. I purchased two expensive bottles and two cocktails along with dinner and noticed a mandatory 8% (defined as tip for the back restaurant employees). Restaurants that mandate gratuity generally have 20 percent and call it the day. They don't state that it's 8% excluding the usual tip for front workers. This restaurant commands higher prices and still expects you to cover their overhead. SMH every time I think about my visit. Left such a bad impact on dining out. It far surpassed the food and service. Covering a restaurant's overhead is not the responsibility of its patrons/customers. Owners/management team should account for such costs when operating a business. I left thinking...are we (customers) paying for their oyster bar expansion and remodeling?! read more

Where to start. When were visiting family and they took us out to dinner. We ordered oysters then tried to order a bottle of wine. They only have one bottle of Chardonnay on their wine list, at a seafood restaurant, and they were out of it. One person ordered a bowl of chowder and her entree. Waitress asked if she wanted soup before the meal and she said yes. Then the entrees, which are so OVERPRICED came out and no soup. Halfway through the meal they brought the soup out and was told to take it back and off the check. Waitress looked like a deer in headlights. Now the entrees are such small portions and so overpriced it's not funny. Only two of the four of us said theirs tasted good ( we both ordered the same thing). One said the sea bass which was flown in from California, WHY??? You can catch sea bass here in the Atlantic Ocean, tasted fishy. The grilled tuna was 1/4 inch thick and tasteless. The only thing that tasted good was the attic char. But was smaller than a snickers bar. Needless to say we did not order dessert and all left there still hungry. Not to mention they add an 8% "Heart of House administrative fee" Save your money and go somewhere else better. read more

Winsor House - Crazy fees. Just pay your employees for what you charge for crap - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

This is my absolutely favorite restaurant in south shore area!! Service is always amazing, and foods are beyond great! read more

See all

Where do I start! The food was out of this world! From the presentation of plates, vast selection of fresh seafood, and perfect ambiance, look no further for the perfect date night spot! We had a lovely night, starting with a platter of oysters. For dinner, a burger (with fries) and hamachi crudo. I should also mention our drinks were fantastic! Kudos to our server for the evening, Olivia M., for providing us excellent service and tasteful recommendations. The chocolate cake is a must-have!!! read more

Winsor House - Old Fashioned - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

Sunday brunch at the Winsor house. Sat at the bar, had great service from our bartender. The Ambiance here is fun, historical yet modern, (if that makes sense). The brunch menu is eclectic and unique. Not your traditional eggs Benedict menu. It's creative but make sure you take a look before going. Would definitely go back, but probably not for brunch. read more

Winsor House - Locally sources Oysters - Pubs Near Me - Duxbury, Massachusetts

See all

A gorgeous place that offers both a historic and a contemporary setting. The food is fab - we had the oyster po-boy and the burger. Friendly servers too. Will return soon! read more

It was my first time in a few weeks ago on a Saturday and it was really fun. From start to finish, my family and I had a blast. Lots of laughs and just a really good vibe. My brother made the reservation and told them it was my 'birthday'. It wasn't technically, but we hadn't celebrated it earlier in the year so I guess it was fine....but the server (who was professional, hilarious and absolutely adorable) wrote happy birthday on all of the menus and was quite funny about the occasion. We ordered a few courses and had a few rounds. The food was delicious and the drinks hit the spot. I hope we didn't take the table up for too long, but we were having a great time. Looking forward to return again sometime! read more