One of my last stops in Ketchum was Wiseguy Pizza Pie and I'm so glad we got to try it out! It was one of those evenings where the only thing I wanted was to enjoy a nice down-to-earth meal in a relaxed setting. While there is some indoor seating, the restaurant offers some seating outside that appears to be shared with the KB's Ketchum Burrito place. With that said, there's plenty of places to sit outside and once you place your order inside, they will bring your food out to you! One major remark I have about this place is the heavy pour of wine they had to offer! In addition to beer on tap, they also offer a small selection of wine on tap and you will receive a large serving! NO complaints from me on that, haha! It was a good quality Rosé too! For food, we ordered the following: Garlic Knots - these were delicious! They pull apart really easily and weren't too garlicky. I really enjoyed the marinara too as it didn't taste like it was from a jar or can, even if it was! Buffalo Wings - the buffalo wings were cooked well and had a slight crisp to them which was nice! They could have stood to have a bit more buffalo sauce on them, but were cooked well otherwise! Margarita Guy Pizza (add jalapenos) and Pepperoni Pizza - both pizzas we order were great quality! The dough wasn't too thick or too thin and wasn't burnt at all. In fact, the consistency was spot on for how I like my pizza! Golden brown with a bit of crisp and without being overwhelmingly crunchy. Great spot for great quality pizza in a small town! read more

See all

I dropped by to pick up two pieces of a Hawaiian pizza to take home. The guy taking the order was very nice small chat and all that, but when I got home to eat the pizza, it was so overdone it was burnt and it just tasted horribly because it was overcooked. I don't know if I'm a one off or if this is a trend there but WOW I'm not gonna try it again. Thankfully there's other options. Guys don't overcook pizza and don't wrap shit up that isn't gonna taste good for your customers.... that's really a nasty thing to do. Just admit you burnt it and redo it NO PROBLEM read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

The pizza was very good and very hot staff was friendly and a good beer selection open late and a big selection of specialty pies read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Cold beer - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

See all

On a walk with the kids and someone says they're hungry... this place has slices for like $3.25 and it's probably the cheapest meal in town. We all left happy and honestly, the pizza is delicious. Wood fired with that thin crust flavor and we rated it a high A. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - This is 2 half slices (bought two and cut them to split with my kid). Good sized slice. - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

The metro guy is AMAZING! A super burst of flavor. We were able to eat outside on the patio with our pup and that was awesome. Definitely recommend this pizza spot! read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Metro Guy and Wise Guy - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

The pizza was better than dominos or those other chains, but nothing special. The service was ok, when we walked in the person at the counter was on their phone, but when our pizza was delivered they were all decently friendly. The vibes were mid, not a whole lot of decor. Just stop by if you need something quick filling and good. STAR DEFS-- 5 stars- best I have ever had almost life changing 4 stars- pretty delicious and really good 3 stars- good but nothing to rave or go out of your way for 2 stars- just ok nothing special or good, go here only in a pinch 1 star- just don't read more

Awesome! Pizza! Very small inside, only 4 tables but larger tables seat 6. The pizza master was so really nice and you can tell he takes pride in his masterpieces. You can buy pizza by the slice, which is huge or you can buy a 14 or 18 inch and this pieces are big as well. read more

If New York style pizza is what you're after ......look no further than Wiseguys Not my flavor..... being from Chicago Sauce is mediocre, sausage is sliced not small chunks like I'm used to All ingredients sliced SUPER THIN , can't knock there style not worth 30-ish $$ for a large read more

Wise guy pizza was good Veggie pizza was good Margarita pizza was good Ready when ordered Large had 12 slices read more

Definitely a restaurant for family! We love getting pizza here, made with love with quality ingredients, in the most beautiful little town. The staff are friendly and the shop is very modern and well kept. read more

Visiting Sun Valley and was recommended Wiseguy. Waited 30 minutes for pizza on a Sunday afternoon. All the employees were eating a slice of pizza while working and either drinking beer or fountain drink while working. It was just unprofessional and not sanitary. Easily grossed out by someone eating a slice of pizza over my pizza. That pizza was ok but it's wasn't something to rave about. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

Great food, great service, great energy, me and my family of three ordered a 8 slice margarita and a family Caesar salad. It was absolutely delicious, enough to feed us, and I got to spend some quality time with my amazing family. read more

Great pizza. Horrible ability to tell you when you might get it. Working on an hour sitting here waiting.

Just finished a great Italian hoagie here. Staff was friendly and fast. Counter was good for some friendly banter and chat.

Great pizza. A little heavy on the tomato sauce but better than none. Gluten free crust was really good.

BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD! Two of us split the 14" fun guy pizza. I wish I would have come here for all of my meals in Sun Valley/Ketchum. Cool atmosphere if you can snag a table inside and grab a beer. read more

Fat guy pizza from WiseGuy Pizza Pie. Seriously disappointed. Just sprinkled a little bacon in the middle. Not busy when I picked up, maybe this is why. Seriously disappointed. The only reason it's not one star is because the pepperoni we ordered was ok. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Fat guy pizza from WiseGuy Pizza Pie. - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

Worst service ever they over charged me 35$ for a pizza i didn't order.... and when i went to call to tell them they daid nothing can be done. I just wanted a refund for a pizza i didnt want nor am i gonna eat. Very disappointed. If i could leave 0 stars i would. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Thats the pizza i paid for didnt order and im not gonna eat because i dont like the stuff on it. - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

I enjoyed the pizza. Pizza was crisp and the sauce was flavorful. I didn't have stuff falling off my pizza. Price was good. Beer was a plenty. Would go back. read more

Pizza is always super tasty with fresh ingredients. The service is outstanding and you get your pie quick. I like the setup now during Covid times as well. Call and get your pie today. Enjoy! read more

See all

Really good pizza. They have NY style pies but they get them really thin, without that thick chew to some NY pizzas. They are also still able to fold and not cracker thin, it is weird but I loved it. Garlic knots were great too. Kids already demanding a 2nd visit before we leave. read more

As many here, I don't understand the bad reviews. Love this pizza. Perfect crust, delicious sauce, excellent quality toppings. Customer service was great! Liked it so much we ate there twice while staying in Ketchum. Fat guy and wise guy were our favorites. Their pepperoni pizza is fantastic as well. Looking forward to next time! read more

I ordered to the wrong location! They were so very sweet about making the food and having the other order canceled. Not from here and just totally got it wrong. The staff is super friendly and attentive. They were busy, but made sure they acknowledge me in their every step. I get it, it's busy. Loved that they knew I was there, made me happy to wait. The food was so good and look forward to going back! Thanks again!! read more

Looking for some quick takeout and Wiseguy fit the bill. Ordered online with pickup in 40 minutes. Arrived and my online order was no where to be found. No big deal. Kitchen was great and made order right away. Cheese pizza and White Trash Guy Pizza (Ranch dressing, bacon, potato chips, Mozzarella). They were both decent and White Trash was unusual but fun to eat. Chicken wings were enormous! I didn't eat any but was told they were good but very spicy. I've had better and I've had worse so I think a solid three is fair. I'd go back. read more

Perfect place to stop for either a slice or a whole pizza! Super friendly staff and relaxed atmosphere. Pizza is made right in front of you and you can sit at the bar and watch as they make it! They were super thoughtful and even cut our pizza into smaller slices for the kiddos! read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - The pepperoni pizza up close and personal - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

See all

Was told our food would be ready in 15-20 minutes and I had to wait for an hour and half. I watched 3 employees take breaks before my food was ready. The pizza is alright (nothing special), but the lack of customer service and the amount of time I had to wait for an overdone pizza is something I cannot ignore. The restaurant atmosphere is absolutely horrific, and if I can't even sit down and enjoy my food, I would hope to God it wouldn't take an hour and a half. If you're planning on ordering pizza from here, don't. Trust me, save your night and enjoy yourself at someplace else. read more

Gluten free? They've got you covered. Yummy cauliflower crust, no cardboard gluten free crust here. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Gluten free Fun Guy - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

We got 5 different pizzas for our group of 15. Every pizza was fantastic and the groups favorite was the Spicy Chicken lemon pizza. But really all where fantastic. read more

Great little pizza spot. We stopped here for lunch and we really enjoyed our Beer and pizza. I was surprised by the low Yelp reviews. We loved the Wise Guy and Hangover pizza. You can order by the slice or full pizza. The cheese sticks and garlic knots were really good as well. read more

See all

Bottom line: Dave Portnoy would give this pizza a 4.8. Pizza sauce lacks flavor, no crunch in the crust, and the flop is so bad all the ingredients fall off. Papa Murphys would be better. I understand why a lot of people come here because the price is reasonable and you can buy just one slice late at night after a few drinks. Other than that, the pizza is average. Staff was nice but is was totally overwhelmed and stop taking orders an hour before closing. It's pizza worth a short walk when options are very limited but I would drive to. read more

Very good pizza. Escaped California and ate dinner here with friends and family. Had the White Trash Guy and Metro Guy plus a salad. Awesome crust. read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - Empty pizza plates. - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho

If you need some pizza pretty quickly, this place can help you out. We arrived at a time when they seemed to be really busy, but the guys in the back were really accommodating when I asked for a couple of custom slices (ham and mushroom, if you were curious). My friend ordered the garlic knots. They were pretty tasty, I won't lie! We split a salad that was pretty decent as well. This place is incredibly casual, not especially friendly, but gets the job done. read more

Nothing to write home about, run of the mill vacation town pizza. Good to feed lots of hungry kids I suppose. The crusts and sauce were sub par and toppings were alright except for the bone dry chicken. I love brick oven and wood fired pizza, but this was not great. Friendly staff & the spinach salad is pretty good. Note: I've given Wiseguy Pizza at both Hailey & Ketchum locations many tries. read more

Poor service - unfriendly staff - pizza nothing special. They could do so much more with the location they have. An anomaly in an otherwise very classy town. read more

In a city that lacks great food, this is pretty great. Pizza by the slice is a quick apres ski pick me up. Great place to get a pie for the family. read more

Damn good pizza. The staff was friendly and cranking out the pizzas despite the heat, which was impressive.

Small eating area but great pizza! They have lots of beers to choose from and they have wine as well as fountain drinks. Our family loves stopping in for a pizza after skiing or getting take out when I don't want to cook. read more

Read the reviews prior to visiting this place and thought to myself, "how could it be that hard to make a decent pizza?" We'll I got my answer-not that difficult. The crust resembled cardboard and the sauce tasted like bland and like it came out of a can. Fortunately the craft beer made up for an otherwise lackluster experience. read more

Probably some of the worst pizza I've ever tasted. I've tasted better frozen ones. I would not recommend the pepperoni and olive. Gave it 2 stars as the Caesar salad was decent and the garlic knots were decent. First night in Ketchum and 0/1 on a quick good meal read more

The WORST customer service I've ever experienced. I ordered pizza online and was told it would take an hour or so. My family waited patiently as long as we could. After 15 mins of trying to check the status via phone I had to drive to the pizzeria where the staff and manager refused to even give me my tip back. Really bad service. Rude people. Did I mention the pizza was COLD when it arrived. They should be embarrassed!! read more

Wiseguy Pizza Pie - THE PIZZA WE HAD TO REHEAT - Pizza Near Me - Ketchum, Idaho