Good pizza with fun toppings. Their chicken wing pie was really tasty, as was their supreme. We ordered for pickup and the food was ready in about 15 minutes. read more

The guy at the counter taking our order (around noon on Wednesday, August 12, 2026) was very rude and impatient with us, making it a bad experience, our first to this business in Hammondsport. Yes, we're from out of town, but we grew up on Keuka Lake and brought our grown kids here to visit family. The worker belittled my husband for not hearing him correctly, and didn't want to know what I DIDNT want on my sub. However, he was very friendly to the construction workers behind us. Not a great look for the town. read more

i would give a zero if I could. the phone service was awful. They've delivered to us twice but we tried to place a large order and they say they can't service us due to the address. Go somewhere else!! read more

In all my years eating pizza this was the worst by far it made Ellios look like Filet Mignon. The cheesesteak was such poor quality my friend spit it out on first bite. The wings had zero sauce on the and the box was filled with grease . $70 for this garbage it all went right in the trash. Do yourself a favor pass by this gross joint. Dogs eat better food read more

Pizza was delicious, but on a Barstool scale maybe in their-high 6's. Great that they deliver, except the driver never made it and we had to pick up. Things happen, but this small town pizza shop brings great quality pizza to the area and it will keep me coming back! read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria And Subs - Plain Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Hammondsport, New York

Pizza was solid. Ordered with no issue and got it pretty quick. Your typical pizza stop ambiance. Would definitely recommend

Foods good. Always a bit greasy but not bad. Wait staff are always nice! Normal pizza place vibe.

We stopped in to Wise Guys Pizza while visiting The Finger Lakes. The staff was very friendly, helpful and welcoming. Great customer service! We ordered and the wait time was not long at all. Our pizza came out hot and fresh. And, this pizza was absolutely delicious! One of the very best pizzas I have ever had and I grew up in an Italian household with really good cooks! If you want a great pizza, be sure to stop here. read more

NY style thin crust! Very good pizza. Had a pepperoni that was tasty. Had a dill pickle pizza - staff was kind enough to make it though not on the menu. It was awesome! read more

Good pizza and great chicken wings. Pick up the food to go. They also deliver but we are just out of their delivery distance.

Our goto place for pizza, wings and etc. when we're in town--great value and delivery!

pizza is always great! Tonight I was greeted by a kid with somewhat shaggy hair that was visibly highly stoned out of his mind, he couldn't get what he wanted to say out and asked me what I ordered which was weird because they take names for orders so having to recall my order threw me off on the spot. my order included one pizza 4 sauces: 2 ranches two blue cheeses... upon getting home I open the box and the pizza looked like it was cut by a five year old very SMALL pieces and very LARGE pieces of pizza WICKED absurdly cut were what I got which is alright it's just one other person and myself eating but if it were for more than one it would be hard to divvy out evenly... i seldom ever review anything but this seems to be a growing trend among business especially restaurants in the area. I'm fine with people smoking pot if they can function and do their work great good for them no judgement but maybe some people should maybe only do it at home and not at work and mess up peoples orders and do sub par performance... not a good look Wiseguys.. hope the kid gets either help or a good straightening out. pizza was still insanely good tasting as always. read more

The pizza was hot, the crust was thin, the cheese was delicious and the all meat lovers was yummy. Great service too. I highly recommend you give it a try. read more

Great job on the supreme pizza tonight Wise guys. Good balance of toppings and crust was right on. Delivery was worth it!

We were in Hammondsport in the off-season, and couldn't find many places that were open for a quick bite. Wise guys was delicious. Try the lasagna pizza. read more

We ordered from here twice while in Hammondsport. Both the subs and pizza were good and reasonably priced. Staff was friendly and helpful. Orders were ready in a timely manner. Would eat here again if in the area. read more

We picked up chicken finger, Buffalo chicken finger, and The Stinger subs the day we got to town for our vacation week. They were so good that we ordered dinner for a family birthday celebration 2 days later!! That night there were 7 of us and we ordered calzones (veggie, meat lovers, and chicken wing - all so good!!), subs, wraps, garlic knots, and fried pickles! Everyone loved their dinner! We decided to have it delivered and it turned out that the owner was the one to bring our food!! Really nice guy and we'll be sure to order again!! read more

See all

First of all, "Jim E" and "Linda" Who wrote the one star reviews are incorrect. This pizza is your traditional New York style pizza-- cheesy, hand tossed crust, perfectly cooked, so flavorful, hot, fresh. Sure, there's some grease, but that's what you get with this style of pizza. I can't imagine how this place could ever get below 4-5 stars, and I'm surprised they don't have more reviews on Yelp-- they were very busy, but so efficient and had excellent customer service. read more

Wiseguys Pizzeria And Subs - Extra cheese pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Hammondsport, New York

See all

I was just passing through and ordered a personal size supreme - looking for an alternative from all the hoity-toity tourist establishments in Hammondsport. The pizza was excellent! Great toasted crust, loads of toppings, tasty sauce. Highly recommend- hope I get this way again. read more

Please note: this review is written by a chef of 21 years with two NYC Michelin stars under his belt. My family has owned a house here in hammondsport for 15 years now and I've always found it hard to recommend restaurants to friends, family and guests despite everyone asking me. This is no one's fault in particular, it's simply that local talent and skilled labor are hard to come by in a town who's population changes with the seasons. Wise guys pizza is the only exception to this. For years they have been rock solid in the consistency of their product. And that product is good. Really good. In fact the pizza is up there in the very top of my list in best pizzas in America (once again 2 Star Michelin nyc chef saying this). To the owners and staff: bravo, well done! You are literally the only food recommendation I will make in hammondsport. read more

Great vegan pizza. I was in town for a few days but managed to have it twice. Also loved the garden salad

Passing through this Finger Lakes town, we stopped by for pizza and opted for a small meat lovers pie for two. We waited about 15 minutes, and it was well worth the wait. This is hands down the best meat pie we have ever had, and we a veteran pizza lovers. Highly recommend this place to anyone visiting the Hammondsport area. You won't be sorry! read more

Great NY style pizza. We were traveling from Philly and pleasantly surprised. Easy to get to right in town

Had takeout so accounting for a 15 minute drive, I will say the pizza and wings were very good. The crust on the pizza was not overly well done(I would have given extra points if it was) but it had a little bite to it and the sauce was not overly sweet. The hot wing sauce was very tasty in the buffalo style and my only criticism is that the wings could have been cooked longer for a crispier texture. They were done but would have benefited from another 5 minutes in the fryer. We will visit them again and will be more specific when we order. That should resolve the issue. read more

We got our order to go. The food was so tasty and the service was great. Would definitely come here again.

The location and building itself well throw you off because it doesn't look like much but the actual food that comes out of this place is pretty good even if it is the only real take out option around. Also for my wife the fact they had gluten free options was great! After a day at wineries the pizza, wings, and fries really hit the spot. If you are staying on Keuka Lake, near Hammondsport this is a great option for a quick dinner. read more

We love Wise Guys pizza!! The meat lovers calzone is DELICIOUS! Wednesday chicken and biscuits are amazing too. Great service and food.

Solid pizza after a day of wineries and breweries! Pizza was on point as well as the Stromboli and Calazones. Filled us up and delivery guy was great! read more

Went there for a couple of slices while here on vacation. Absolutely the worst pizza we ever had. Greasy and the crust was like cardboard. If a decent pizzeria opened, they would be out if business fast. read more

Really Delicious Pizza! This place doesn't stick out and if you don't know where it is you will most likely drive right on by - its just a little south of the square. The parking lot is a small but expected for Hammondsport and in such a lovely little town you don't mind walking. The decor is that of a small pizza place and nice and clean. The service was friendly and they happily explained our questions about the menu. We started with the mozzarella sticks and they were perfectly crunchy, cheesy and delicious. For our main entree we ordered a large pepperoni and black olive pizza. The pizza smelled and looked amazing. I took my first bite and was greeted with the tasty flavors and texture I was expecting. The food is really good, the service is quick and friendly, and the prices are decent. The wraps and french fries are delicious too. I highly recommend this place. read more

We were heading to the lake for the afternoon and wanted a quick bite to eat. We called in a pizza ahead to save time and when we got there, they said they never got our order. We ended up ordering subs to save time. They did get the subs done quickly and they were very filling. It just would have been nice to have what we wanted when we got there. read more

Was excited to finally have pizza delivery on the lake. Pizza was supposed to be delivered 7:30. By 7:45, I was trying to call to see where it was, but they don't pick up "when they are busy" per the recording that I got the 10 times I tried. Decided to drive there, where I was told by manager/owner that the driver couldn't find my house, so he just brought it back to store. He claimed the driver called, but he did not. The pizza (that is now 2 hrs old) was practically thrown at me and I was only refunded the $2.50 delivery fee. I will absolutely never return here and will tell everyone who asks what my experience was like. read more

We live locally and I continue to hope that I can get a consistently good pizza from Wise Guys. I find that they think a good pizza has burned cheese and a very dark crust . They are also very salty and have minimal toppings for the price. We have ordered approximately a dozen pizzas from them and 2 of the 12 were good. Both of those times I had to ask them not to leave it in the oven too long, and not to be so stingy on the toppings. I'm finished with Wise Guys! read more

We wanted a quick bite to enjoy by the lake and a local resident recommended this place. He didn't steer us wrong as the sub was great! Generous portion of meat and toppings. read more

Great pizza but probably the absolute best Stromboli we have ever had! Excellent service, quick and courteous.

Not a customer focused business. When they want to charge $50 for a large pizza and two dozen wings, that is highway robbery! Then when you want to give them another chance and they refuse your business, I guess they think they are invincible. If you want to pay more then you need to or want to be treated rudely, this is the place to go- I was always taught you work for the customer, guess not here! read more

The pizza was greasy. The crust was over cooked and like paper. The dark haired girl was extremely rude that ran the cash register. My father who has 2 artificial knees asked for a knife and fork and she just pointed to them on the other side of the restaurant and walked away. read more

We came in for Dinner on 4/15/2105. Ordered a medium pizza, with a dozen wings. Asked for the pizza 1/2 red sauce, 1/2 white (garlic) same with the wings - 1/2 hot, 1/2 garlic. Counter person said we can't do 1/2 and 1/2 pizza - "No problem we'll get Garlic. After a few minutes the "Manager" went to the register, and stated to us - "You ordered the wings? we said yes, she stated "he rang them up wrong, he should have charged you for 2- 6 piece wings, I'll let it slide this time" (with a very rude attitude, like it was our fault) She then proceeded to the kitchen, and yelled at the staff with multiple "F" bombs which everyone in the DR could hear, that the order was rang up wrong. After listening to her rant and use profanity for 5+ minutes, we asked for a refund,. "Why do you want a refund?" I said I didn't appreciate you using profanity in the restaurant and treating the employees in that manner. She responded with " Sorry you feel that way (with attitude) The employee made a mistake - hey it happens - he didn't need to be spoken to in that manner and we didn't need to hear it. We would have gladly paid the difference in the wing pricing. On Thursday, I called and asked for the owners name, the manager (female) responded with "why" I said I would like to speak with him. she responded with "we're closed" and hung up on me. We will not be vising this pizza place again. read more

Absolutely ridiculous. Called to complain about the order the guy who made it argued with me as I was telling him it is burnt and hard . He continued to say it wasn't and what would you like us to do about it. If I had noticed it was burnt I would of been getting my money back. This isn't the first time and I don't even know if I will go back now read more

Love their chicken bacon ranch pizza! Their calzone didn't have much meat in it at all but had way too much cheese. Their subs are quite good. Also the only place in the area that delivers. read more