Very convenient location in Soho. The show room is very comfortable and intimate. Dylan was super helpful and narrowed down various options for the perfect engagement ring! Prices are very reasonable. I highly recommend With Clarity! read more

This company sells crappy products and has no shame. I suggest buying elsewhere. I am writing about my experience buying a necklace online. I ordered a diamond bar necklace. It arrived quickly but when I opened the box and pulled it out, the necklace snapped in two like a twig. When I inspected the jewelry I could see it was poorly made. The stones were unevenly set. The diamonds were only soldered together in their settings. There was no reinforcement on the piece either in the back or the top to make it more secure. It felt flimsy and cheap. It felt like I could keep bending it and popping off diamonds with little force. I emailed customer service and they admitted the poor quality of their jewelry. They said they would redesign the item to make it better. They even provided illustrations of the updates they made to the item. However, I didn't feel like I could trust them. Why would I trust a company that sells substandard jewelry? The only reason they thought to improve the quality of the item was because it broke. Who knows how many other flimsy pieces of jewelry they have on their website? I explained that I wasn't satisfied with the bare minimum resolution to this issue and expected a discount for my time and inconvenience. They refused. I decided not to proceed with the purchase. I don't believe this is a company that can be trusted. They are selling substandard products. And, even more embarrassingly, they have no shame. Lab diamonds are getting cheaper by the day and they have many competitors. Please look elsewhere for quality jewelry! read more

See all

My fiancé and I visited the With Clarity showroom to design my engagement ring. Their team hit it out of the ballpark with a customized design in rose gold with a gorgeous east west oval setting and two pear diamonds and fleur de lis on the sides. I'm absolutely in love with this ring as much as I am this man! 1000% recommend! read more

With Clarity - Rose gold East/west set oval (1.53 ct) - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

They promise 2-day shipping. I ordered jewelry labeled "ready to ship" on Wed for Fri for a special occasion. I found out only after ordering that "ready to ship" means it's ready for them to spend two days farting around before they ship it. Which means it gets here in four days instead of two, ruining my special occasion. Thanks, WithClarity! read more

Great communication. Very competitive pricing. Highly recommend these guys! Wonderful Experience. A+

My visit to With Clarity was a great experience. I went in thinking I wanted one specific ring style, but the jeweler took the time to show me other options that completely changed my mind--in the best way. I'm so happy with the ring I chose, and it turned out to be the perfect push gift. Highly recommend! read more

Good location and well decorated. Space was quiet and allowed for introspection of the diamonds.

I was looking up online where to get my engagement ring from, and I happened to read an article in Forbes that the best place to get your natural diamonds are from With Clarity. I got excited to know they have a showroom in SoHo, booked an appointment, and had the best consultation with Renee! A few days later, I finally decided on my cut and setting, and found the perfect natural diamond. Placing the order was very seamless with so many natural and lab grown diamond options. Prices were also reasonable, huge plus! I got excited to place an order, that I forgot to add an engraving (for free). I reached out to customer service and they gladly helped me out with that. Customer service was very helpful, and Renee, with all my inquiries. They offer a lifetime warranty and insurance, and free cleaning! My ring was delivered as expected -- timeframe and quality. I got teary-eyed when I opened the box. I wear it every single day. read more

From the moment I walked in they were extremely attentive. They walked me through the process of selecting a ring and showed me all the selections tailored to my taste. Highly professional, knowledgeable and attentive individuals. Prices were a little out of my range and thats the only reason I went to another place. read more

We purchased our engagement ring and wedding set with Clarity. I could not be more satisfied with the service, value, and quality. The staff was very attentive and helpful. I still look at my rings with awe everyday and get compliments often, even from strangers! read more

Great experience at with clarity. Lots of options for settings and diamonds! Dylan was very patient with our group and help us narrow down our choices! read more

With Clarity was a beautiful showroom! The team was so helpful and kind. My fiancé and I went to the showroom to try on engagement ring styles and cuts prior to getting engaged. They had a wide selection and allowed me to try on a variety of rings. My fiancé ultimately purchased the ring from another jeweler (an out-of-state family friend), but With Clarity helped us find the perfect cut, size, and style. read more

My husband bought my engagement ring here. It was a 4.5 round cut single solitaire diamond. The diamond fell off the setting after a few months. Thankfully I found the loose diamond. A local jewelry looked at it, and said it was poorly made and never going to hold the diamond it came in. With Clarity fixed the setting, but one year later, the prongs holding the diamond are completely bent. Not sure how or why a platinum setting would bend like this. I am having to get an entire new setting made somewhere else because I do not trust the craftsmanship of this ring. I regret buyin read more

With Clarity - You can see the bent prongs - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

My fiancé and I had a great experience visiting the showroom to pick out our wedding bands. I had a vision upon coming in and the team was super helpful in showing me styles that matched my vision. I absolutely love the band that I ended up purchasing! read more

My partner (now fiance!) and I came in for an appointment in the showroom over the summer to look at engagement rings. It was super easy to book a time online and the experience was wonderful! We were also the only ones in there (it's a pretty small and private showroom). We were complete newbies to the process so we appreciated how patient and willing the team was with walking us through the process and what to consider. We tried on a couple diamonds and bans, learned a lot and were out of there within 45 mins. We received a followup email within 2 days with links to the options we liked the most, with not much pressure to buy anything. No annoying phone calls or incessant emails to make a purchase thankfully. When it came time to make a purchase my fiance bought the home preview first and then eventually the real thing. Amazing experience overall!! read more

They were very responsive and helpful through the whole process! They listened to our thoughts and feedback and brought back pieces that was based off of that! read more

My partner (now fiance) and I scheduled an appointment at the NYC SoHo showroom and had an AMAZING experience. The showroom was immaculate and beautiful. They also offered us tea and water. Our Jewelry Specialist was Renée Dussek and she was very professional, knowledgeable, patient and attentive to all our needs. She measured our fingers and turns out my fiance's ring is supposed to be 0.25 size bigger. 1-2 days after the visit to the the showroom, Renée sent us the link with personal orders and we ended up getting both of my engagement and wedding rings (amazing customer service, great products with reasonable prices-there was no reason to not order). With Clarity, thank you so much for making our experience extra special for this new chapter in our lives :) read more

I just got my 2 carat diamond stud earrings. I was so excited, I'm 66 and these are the biggest diamonds I've ever had. Sadly, it was disappointing from the start. The post are terribly flimsy and the end of the post is just sawed off. Just rough metal. Got the other earring out, the post is bent. Tell me one pair of earrings you've ever had that had a post that would bend without a lot of force. This is a deal breaker. I'm not spending this kind of money for subpar quality. I spent hours online trying to decide who to buy from. So disappointed. I gave 2 stars only due to the diamonds being beautiful. They barely thread in. After much trouble I got them both on. It was torture trying to get them out. I thought I was going to have to cut the post off. It ripped my piercing hole as I removed them. read more

I was told the estimated shipping was September 5. Got an email on August 22 saying it was being crafted. Reached out today to see where it was in the process and I'm told that it will ship out on September 15. No emails or anything to tell me about the delay. Just saying that it had to be 'recrafted'. No explanation for the lack of follow up. If you need it by I certain day like I did, I would not recommend. read more

My fiancé and I scheduled an appointment with Dylan. The place was very elegant. Dylan welcomed us and was very pleased to meet us and ready to help us. He is very knowledgeable and he had a lot of variety of wedding bands to show us. The price of each bands is very reasonable. Overall experience, Dylan was very helpful with great customer service. I highly recommend this place to the other couples. read more

My partner and I came to look at wedding bands since we used With Clarity for her Engagement ring. The attentive staff helped us determine what kind of wedding bands we wanted, and we loved the selection they came up with! They even shined my fiance's engagement ring for free! read more

Wow. where to even begin. My mans got me this ring in October of 2023. I needed the ring sized down half a size so we sent it in immediately. Little did we know, this would be a huge mistake. the company had the ring for over a month due to the ring not passing inspection after the resizing. they completely re-handcrafted the ring and sent it back at the beginning of december after having it for 40 days. Mind you, this is now past the 30 days return policy. Thus, we never had the ring for the time that it was allowed to be returned. Early January of 2024, the center stone was loose so I sent it in to have the prongs tightened. Again in July, the center stone is very loose and able to be pulled out of the setting. They fixed it and sent it back in August. Now, december of 2024, the center stone fell out at my kitchen table while i was playing cards. CARDS!! not even a rough activity. We are trying to get a refund at this point because the company will not add any halo or gallery rail to the ring to prevent the prongs from getting loose. this is absolutely ridiculous. Additionally, this company does not cover the center stone, so it seems as if this is a ploy to con people into buying multiple stones over their lifetime. this company does not even guarantee their own products. luckily we have a family member that is a lawyer and we will be reaching out asap. these rings are not worth their value. spend a few more bucks and find a local jeweler who has similar prices and a better warranty. read more

My partner and I had a great experience at the NYC Soho showroom. Great selection of engagement rings to choose from at a reasonable price point. We also got to look at a few wedding bands. The specialist was very helpful and informative about the settings, diamonds, as well as their warranty policies. read more

These lab grown diamonds are stunning The quality is great and the sparkle is phenomenal! I love the kite set 2ct pendant, it's gorgeous in person. read more

There's a reason With Clarity isn't one of the big online retailers. I placed an order for their Home Preview. It seemed like a great idea. I planned to propose soon and wanted to see what a rose gold setting would look like with white gold prongs for a two tone look. What I received was an all white gold replica. Frustrating but let's see what they can do service wise. I emailed them the morning I received the kit to express my concerns and see what they could do. No response until the next morning. I was still prepared to purchase, just waiting for their response. Well, the next morning they had a sale begin. Great news right?! The setting I wanted was not only not on sale, it increased in price by about $150. So I was no out an extra $150 if I purchased since they failed to respond the previous morning. I called to see what they could do with the price. I figured they'd just honor their previous price especially since they screwed up my home preview and we'd get production rolling since I was going on vacation in 3 weeks and planned to propose. Remi (service rep) kept insisting that I send screenshots of the previous price for the setting, even though I stated what the price was previously. The only thing they offered was to send me another home preview kit in 8-10 business days which is the exact same time frame as if I ordered another home preview on my own (mind you, these are free so I wasn't comp'd anything). After voicing my frustration further, there was no further communication until I told them I was going to purchase elsewhere. There's a reason why companies like JA are where they are and WC is where they are. If With Clarity, couldn't even get a simple home preview kit right, how could I be confident that they would get an actual engagement ring right? I can't believe I was still willing to purchase after they sent me the wrong ring. Their customer service finally helped steer me in the right direction, away from them. I rarely ever post negative reviews. I work in customer service myself and am very understanding. But when your company just wants to do the bare minimum for their customers, it's simply not good enough. Do better. The ring I purchased from elsewhere is absolutely stunning and I can't wait to purchase wedding bands from them as well. WC dropped the ball in a big way. read more

With Clarity - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

I want to thanks special to Renne. She was absolutly profestional, patient and very empaty. Thanks because the standard of this store is amazing. Chris and Alma read more

the process of buying a ring was really simple. we went to the showroom and were able to easily narrow down the style of ring that we were interested in. the salesperson was relaxed and didn't pressure us into buying. when we were ready to make the purchase online, doing so was extremely easy and straightforward. I would highly recommend With Clarity! read more

With Clarity - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

Scheduled an appointment at the NYC SoHo showroom and had a great experience. The showroom was very nice and renovated. They also offered us coffee and sparkling water. They did not have the ring I wanted to see in stock, but they showed alternatives. I was able to try on both engagement rings and wedding bands. They sized my finger as well. The jewelry specialist we were meeting with was late to the appointment and we had to wait outside in the rain, so that was a little disappointing. read more

My new fiance and I could not be happier with the ring I purchased from With Clarity!!! The ring is simply beautiful!!! We shopped at many mall and box stores and could not find better quality and/or price anywhere. The same quality diamonds at other online stores were anywhere from 50% - 200% higher in cost and I really doubt "With Clarity's" customer service can be topped. Gemologists Joe and Adam worked hard to expedite my order while providing me top notch service! Communication was excellent throughout the ring's preparation/creation process and Joe ensured I was going to be absolutely pleased with the finished product. The look on her face as I proposed, combined with the multiple compliments on her ring following our engagement, assured me that I had found the perfect ring!!! I highly recommend With Clarity!!! They most certainly have gained my trust as well as my future business!!! read more

With Clarity - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

My fiance got my engagement ring from here and it is so stunning. They were super helpful throughout the whole process and even replace the small diamonds on the band. read more

this was a great experience. really loved how in depth they went as it wasn't first time buying a ring and I was not aware of many things associate with it. highly recommend! read more

Don't risk 10's of thousands of dollars on this shady website. We're not talking about buying potatoes here. It's a big purchase, once in a life-time. Why risk it on a shady company? This place was originally called Fourmine, just a few months ago. All of a sudden out of nowhere, without any warning, they just changed the entire company name to "With Clarity". All the logos, names, everything was changed overnight, with any explanation. Would Apple change their name to "With Quality" overnight? No way. Only a shady hot dog joint in a back alley would change their name. Not the kind of place where you spend $10 thousand $. No reputable company would just change their company name and give up their old brand reputation all of a sudden. It's likely something very wrong happened to the old company and brand. The old company doesn't have good reputation otherwise they wouldn't just bury the name without warning. I originally saw a ring setting and diamond I wanted to buy on Fourmine, and had a coupon code that worked. Then without warning they changed the company name, and the promo code doesn't work anymore. Also, the prices increased. The new website broke all the time (see photos). I am a web developer, and I can see the error on their website is saying With-Clarity is using some really outdated software framework from 2010 (AngularJS) that is no longer supported. Basically they are still using the web software equivalent of Windows 98. It feels very dangerous to risk $10s of thousands of dollars on their outdated website. It breaks all the time, and does NOT feel very secure or safe. I don't want to get hacked while making a big purchase. They should at least invest on developing the payment website so it is not using outdated software? After all, they are asking people to send them $10s of thousands of dollars through the website, so why be cheap on website development? Not very trustworthy. I also made an order for 2 rings using their home-preview. For some reason, not all of their rings support home-preview. I made the order, and after 2 weeks, still haven't heard from them, so emailed about the status. Apparently they still haven't shipped after 2 weeks! Wow, at least let me know the status so I am not sitting here waiting week after week! The level of customer service is very disorganized. I cancelled the order and never look back. Overall, I will not risk 10s of thousands of dollars on With-Clarity. There are plenty of other companies out there, with decades of much better reputation, and with similar prices. I ended up buying a 13k diamond ring from another website. I am not going to risk large sums of money on a shady company like this. It's not worth the risk for such a big purchase. Better to stick with some other reputable company. read more

See all

incredible service and very open and non judgmental space. very transparent pricing. found my dream ring! thanks so much!

I purchased an engagement ring for my girlfriend and it came out wonderful! Dylan and the team did a great job with the customization I wanted. 10/10 reccomend. read more

I just wanted to let you know that I ordered a 2.9 carat ring with a 14k gold setting. I just want to convey to you a rather challenging, and frankly horrific experience with your product. 1. Your product shipped to me 14 days after it was promised to be shipped due to a variety of errors, including not telling me about when the duties were due (I live in Canada) 2. Your ring's prong broke in 6 days. I'm not kidding. I proposed on Dec 25 and on Dec 31, a prong broke. We had a horrific episode on an airport where our diamond dropped off the prong, and we were so close to actually losing our 2.9 emerald cut, perfect colourless diamond. From there, customer service wasn't super responsive and it seemed like it took a while for them to understand how badly this situation has affected me. You've turned onto of the happier moments of my life into a stressful one; my fiancé basically had a panic attack on the plane read more

With Clarity - the prong broke within 1 week - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

See all

My boyfriend and I were very pleased with our visit to With Clarity. Dylan who helped us was kind and professional, and answered all of our questions. We had shopped for an engagment ring at a few other places and we were a bit skeptical with some answers we received regarding questions about integrity of the band even if it is thin, and Dylan told us straight up what was the truth and why the answer we were given was not true. We really appreciated this. We did not end up going with a ring at With Clarity but we especially enjoyed the selection and the variety Dylan let me try on to see different things. Would definitely recommend With Clarity! read more

Customer service is not great. I received earrings as a gift that I cannot wear because of the metal and having an allergic reaction. With Clarity refused to consider any options for returning or exchanging the earrings. I also emailed their customer service email to which they responded once, and then stopped responding to my replies. read more

I had a great experience with Dylan in the lovely and elegant SoHo showroom, which I decided to visit while traveling to NYC. (I had been tempted by several WC anniversary-type rings online but figured it would be better to see in person.) It was easy to make an appointment and he was very welcoming and knowledgable. He had most of the rings I had wanted to see available for me to view/try on in person (though my own would need to be ordered to my specs), and I was so glad I saw for myself as I ended up choosing something totally different than I thought I would! Dylan stayed in touch directly after my visit and sent me a link to my personal order. It was no pressure and I was happy to make the purchase (which felt very reasonable in price, even with an upgrade to platinum that was considered custom). Good communication from the company at every step and I got the ring promptly. It is beautiful! read more

With Clarity - Trying on rings, and my choice! - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York

Wide range of options with helpful staff. Good value for the money that you spend and he/she will appreciate your gift or engagement ring.

I had this idea to propose to my puzzle-loving girlfriend with a replica ring and then take her on a detective-style puzzle hunt to find the "thief" who stole and replaced the real ring. Claudia helped me purchase a ring and replica and it was a great customer experience. Also, after my now-fiancée said yes, I went to the website and found that they didn't sell the matching wedding band for our engagement ring. However, Claudia made it happen! Very happy with my experience and with all three rings (including the fake one!). read more

With Clarity - Jewelry Near Me - New York, New York