We've embarked on the Hamilton County Tenderloin Trail this July and Wolfiea in Geist was our 1st stop. 4 of us are doing the trail this year and each of us got the Tenderloin Sliders with fries. Two of us added a side wedge salad We were very satisfied. The sliders are just the right size, easily manageable and the taste was excellent. The breading could have been a tad more crisp, but it was fine. The buns were a tad larger that the tenderloin, but we were happy with the portions. There are 3 sliders with the combo and we actually split two order among the 4 of us. Adding the salad was wise as we all were quite satisfied One order came with fires and we had the onion 'straws' with the other. The variety was nice and made us enjoy the total order better. Our server was great and made sure we got our Tenderloin Trail discount up front. Couldn't have been more accommodating! We sat inside as it was miserably hot and humid outside. The indoor seating was nice and pleasant. We were surprise that the restaurant wasn't busier on the night we were there, but we heard that the turnout for other places was lower on that night due to the heat. We were very happy that we went and that we chose Wolfiea in Geist to start the trail. We truly enjoyed the fries and the salads. read more

Took my lunch partner out for an early birthday lunch at Wolfies for a good meal with a nice water view. We started with the crab cakes... Sorry no pic of those as we were all hungry and dug right in. These were good. Not the best I've had, but I'm originally from a coastal state, so tough bar to reach. One in our party had the fish and chips. She said they were good, nice and hot. Breading was a little thick, but tasty. Another in our party had the baja shrimp tacos along with the jalapeño creamed corn. Said both were very good. I tasted the creamed corn and it was excellent Finally I had the Wolfpack Supreme pizza. Very tasty, fresh toppings and very crispy crust. Could have used just a bit more sauce for my taste, but was still excellent. Parking was easy and the view was worth the trip. Service was very fast and courteous. read more

See all

Got together with some friends from our car club. Had some great appetizers and dinners as we socialized on this rainy night. Staff was able to find us a table for 10 people in the corner even though they don't take reservations. Since it was a rainy night and we were placed in a corner which normally would be great views, it was still very easy to talk to each other and interact. As we gathered and trickled in, our waitress was very attentive to our food and drink needs and did a great job. Everyone around me had orders that turned out wonderful. My beer, chicken wings with dry rub with hot honey and blue cheese dips was yummy. My Fiesta Lime Smothered chicken was also very tasty. Better than I expected. Couldn't finish it so I had a good lunch the next day. My wife enjoyed her Cobb salad. Firehouse Cheese sticks were excellent even though I am almost certain they are NOT good for you. This is a regular place for us and the food is consistently good across their restaurants I've been to in the last couple of years. read more

See all

Beautiful location. Great views of the reservoir. Nice interior with low top tables, booths, and high tops. Service was attentive and made sure to keep drinks refilled. The food was absolutely tasty. Just not very handicapped accessible and the bathrooms were not super clean. read more

See all

The view at this restaurant is amazing. Highly recommend sitting outside on the patio or in the heated patio to see the water view. Service was great. Our server was super attentive and nice. Food was okay. Brussel sprouts were very good, but the fries were alright. Even though there's a huge parking lot in front of the restaurant, it can get full super fast, but there's usually a spot open. read more

See all

Popped in on a Friday night and was very happy with most of the food items. The pork nachos were a great appetizer. The Brussel sprouts are delicious. The country fried steak was so good, and the portions were crazy big. The service was fine, only a few small hiccups The patio area looked very cozy with the fire. One issue I had was the cleanliness of the bathroom- that should definitely be being cleaned more frequently. If you're looking for some great food, good service, and a great bar menu, this is the place. read more

See all

Our family decided to stop in here for a birthday dinner and overall we liked it a lot! The stars of the show were: the steak and the Philly Cheesesteak. They were both full of flavor and tasted very good! The wings we ordered were very bland, the nachos were very cold. The service and overall the vibe of the restaurant were really good. Over all a 3.9-4.1 is a proper rating for this restaurant! Might come back. read more

See all

This was my second visit to Wolfie's in Geist. I was here last year for a Halloween event and loved the location and the vibe. It was not as pleasant outside (in late October) as it was this visit so we were able to enjoy the atmosphere outdoors this time. It's fun and beautiful to see all the boats on the water as the sun is setting. The food is pretty good and quite reasonable --especially considering the waterfront views and live music! I had the Brussel sprouts and Blackened Chicken Southwest Salad which were both delicious. The hostesses are very sweet and accommodating. Our server was friendly and the food came out pretty quickly considering how packed it was on a Friday night. They don't reserve tables through Open Table but we were still able to be seated on the patio right away after peak dinner rush around 9pm. My only complaints are 1: that there were only TWO (somewhat disgruntled) bartenders for the ENTIRE outside beer garden. The place was packed so the lines were loooong to order a drink outside. Secondly there is VERY limited seating in the beer garden despite being a pretty big space with the capacity for a lot of people. Looking forward to trying the other Wolfie's locations soon. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - View of the waterfront from the beer garden. - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We stopped in for lunch as a family. All the food was good. I got tacos and it was perfect for lunch. We also shared a cocktail - when in Rome. Service was speedy and it was very comfortable and inviting on the covered patio. Even with some chillier weather. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Lemon drops - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We just had drinks and appetizers which was good. Our server was great! He suggested drinks for us and was very pleasant. Love sitting on the outside porch over looking the lake. read more

Average to below food(breaded tenderloin, crab cake sliders, nachos) - poor service (3/4 of meal brought to table, no refills on drinks, had to get server from another area), restaurant as a whole was dirty(deck,bathrooms, overall area) hostesses were nice and receptive. No plans to return. read more

Above average bar food, well served, with decent happy hour options! Wolfies Geist has a sports bar vibe (Based on other Indy-area Wolfies location, that is the goal). The bar team of Brittany and Evan were professional and pleasant. I was happy to see Evan wiping down the bar top and keeping it in order (basic food service... keeping it clean). I had my usual Manhattan along with Brussel Sprouts and Fish & Chips. The fish was hot, crispy and flavorful. I will def return for Happy Hour, on future Indy work trips. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Fish & Chips - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

First time in, figured we would give it a try. He started with a dirty martini and I had water. I was driving so no drinking ... be responsible I ordered the Cobb salad and he ordered the blue pecan side salad and we shared the hot honey pepperoni pizza. Food was great! Food came fast. Salad was huge I took half of it home. Pizza was delicious and crust was great. Not too crisp but not doughy. His pecan salad was really tasty. The martini wasn't as good. We've made better, no disrespect. It just wasn't really tasty and seemed a bit watered down. Hostess area was really nice. All welcoming and friendly. The server seemed very busy and in a rush so didn't catch a name and he was nice but wasn't exactly welcoming, just kind of there working. The bar area or something like an outside enclosed area was ehh loud and too many conversations echoed so I would have opted to sit elsewhere. Not sure I'll go back: food was good though. Just wish the person who took our order was not in a hurry and maybe had more personality. Would have given the 5 just didn't feel right since social interaction with servers is important. My better half still tipped well I just don't want anyone to think he was punished for it. We always tip no matter what because it's still their livelihood. read more

See all

I hosted guests from Arizona for the Wolfies Grill experience. We decided on the Geist location for the view and ambiance. It was a chilly Fall night and our party of four choose the enclosed patio. Our fantastic server was Karly. She was more of a guide of the menu than server. She is definitely someone I would request by name on a future visit. We decided on onion rings as our appetizer. Delicious recommendation. Everyone's entree was well-seasoned, a good temperature and tasty! The wine list is okay. Our resident wine experts, thought the wine list needed more selections. That is the only reason for this being 4 stars and not a "5." read more

See all

My first visit to Wolfies was a phenomenal experience. The service was quick and our server named Jay was literally the best server I have ever encountered. He served 14 of us and moved like lightning. He was courteous and spoke well. We celebrated my sister's 70th birthday with an all day boat excursion and lunch. He was handsomely tipped because of his amazing service. read more

Good service. We were greeted when we walked in. There was plenty of parking. The food was decent for the most part. The cauliflower was mushy and there were spider webs everywhere on the railing when sitting outside. read more

Wolfies Grill-Geist is a fantastic venue on the Geist Reservoir that serves excellent food and cocktails. It is a huge restaurant that has an outdoor stage and deck with an outdoor bar for entertainment and live music. I want to see Stella Luna and the Satellites Friday night for live music on the outdoor deck and it was very entertaining. I do not know how I have not been to Wolfie's Grill Geist before, because this is an excellent restaurant and a great venue for live music. The food is high quality and top notch, especially the hot honey pepperoni pizza. The buffalo chicken nachos are also superb. The staff are terrific and very professional. They are on top of everything and do not miss a beat when it comes to drinks and refills on water. I have found my new hot spot in Indy, because who does not want to have dinner on a gorgeous patio overlooking the Geist Reservoir. This is absolutely breathtaking on a gorgeous day, and can be considered romantic if you bring that special someone here for dinner. Wolfies Grill-Geist is an amazing restaurant. Everyone should take the opportunity to dine here for lunch or dinner, because it is worth the view of the Geist Reservoir. Simply marvelous is the best way to describe the experience at Wolfie's Grill Geist. Come check it out! read more

See all

We met a party of ten. We were welcomed right away by a friendly, smiling wait staff member. The real reason for good stars at all. I ordered a Kim Crawford savigon blanc. It was old and tasted like I was poured a Chardonnay. I left it. It was by the way a 4-6 oz pour We eat at Wolfies on 96th st and the wine there is fresh and a generous pour. As a matter of fact I ordered shrimp tacos on 96th. They were blackened in soft flour taco with good seasoning At Geist the shrimp were thawed out raw shrimp. No seasoning piled on top of Guacamole. Looked like a teaspoon slopped into a hard flour cold taco shell. My husband got Maui-Maui. Same thing at 96 th it was grilled and crisp served warm over warm rice with salsa. This fish was barely cooked. No brown on cold rice My husband and I left our food. Since we were a group we didn't complain. While leaving 3 others complained about how bad the food was The service was wonderful and as I started earlier the representative who waited on us was outstanding. Too bad no one was there to back her up. It will be awhile before we dine here again read more

Outdoor service is great but limited menu. The outdoor restrooms were terrible. I've seen truck stops better. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Broken barrel upstairs for adults. - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Saturday night, of course we had to wait little. Food was good, not expensive. Chill atmosphere. Also nice severs. We will go back again. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Fish and chips - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Super impressed for our first visit this weekend. Really awesome service and the food was delicious quick and affordable. It's winter and the vibe feels like Minnesota or Michigan. I am sure the summer vibe will be amazing. Can't wait to return. read more

We couldn't resist taking out if town friends to the Wolfies with a view! 7pm dinner time so we could enjoy the view of the water. The only negative ... glad I had a jacket! A little chilly sitting by the window. Our server, Karly, was delightful and very honest about her recommendations. Service was reasonably quick (not a huge crowd on a Monday evening, we were seated immediately - thank you Daniel). Food was good. Atmosphere was good. I wouldn't go for the wine list as it was limited. And they don't take reservations, so be prepared in nice weather on a weekend to wait a bit. That said, the special blue cheese dressing was a hit and my pork tenderloin was delicious. Too full for dessert although the choices looked fabulous. read more

See all

We've been here MANY times before and it's always good! Was pretty empty today, just a few people, but comfortable. We got the Jalapeño cheese sticks for aps, interesting and delicious! My Mom got the fish and chips and said the fish was just a little too fishy tasting. I got the country fried chicken with pepper gravy. Both were perfectly fried and crispy and THAT is what's important. My chicken came with Jalapeño creamed corn, wasn't for me but my Mom loved it. Lastly our server Chris was super nice and all around amazing! Keep it up Wolfies! read more

See all

Solid food, consistently poor take-out service. Every time we've visited, our order has been wrong or missing something entirely. It's become so routine that we've started factoring gas money into the cost of the meal--just to go back and fix their mistakes. We're not looking for a freebie or a fix. We won't be back. Just sharing this so others can make an informed choice. This review likely won't affect them...they're always busy, and clearly don't care. But maybe it'll save you the frustration. read more

Such a good spot and right on the water! The service was great, bar and table seating available. I love that they have an open and closed patio. Food was great as well! read more

See all

Wolfies was such an unexpected gem! I don't live anywhere near Geist so I never heard of it. My friend invited me there and the views were amazing! The food and their prices were so good. The burger I had had their special sauce on it and it was really good. We also had the Brussel sprouts. Very very good! Everything tasted freshly made. The service was cool. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Amazing atmosphere on the water! Great selection of food. I would highly recommend popping in for lunch or dinner!! read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Bar - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

EVERY TIME I eat here I want fish and chips. Has potential to be outstanding but, it is soooo greasy that the bottom of the fish/ breading is soggy with oil. I keep hoping it is a one-off situation but, it is literally every single time, and we eat here at least twice a month. Same with the Fisher's location. Maybe get better oil? Drain fish off more before plating? Put fish on a piece of bread to soak up the excess grease? Not sure but they really need to figure it out. read more

Although we were a group, Wolfies were given advanced notice but it took almost one hour for our table to be fed. A table on their deck turned over three times before our food arrived. I only ordered soup and salad. Soup was cool and salad was way too salty (I attribute to so much blue cheese crumples). Ambiance was nice but did not make up for the experience. Not intending to dine there again. read more

Robin was absolutely amazing, super funny, very attentive, super accommodating, she made our visit! Great food too, as always

Nice ambiance inside. Great view of Geist Lake inside, nice bar sitting area. Spacious outdoor patio and you can order from your boat where they bring the food to you on the water. The Broken Barrel Bourbon lounge is located on the second floor open Tuesday- Saturday. Steak salad 10/10. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Giest lake - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

It's been a bit since we've been here but food and service were good as always. Started off with French onion soup and the hubs had a side salad. The soup could've used a little more cheese but had good flavor. Decided to split the American burger. The burgers are always a good go to. Service was great. If you get a chance to have Robin as your server, she'll take great care of you. read more

See all

If you are looking for waterfront dining in the Indianapolis area, this would be one of my top picks. Located directly on the Geist Reservoir, you can choose to eat inside or outside. Either way you will get a great view of the water. The Parking lot is spacious which is nice for such a popular place. The menu had a lot of tempting options. I highly recommend the Wolfies Chips that are made in house. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Shrimp Taco's and Wolfies chips - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Absolutely outstanding service! My wife and I, along with some other friends went out to eat here. We come quite frequently. But, our waitress, I believe her name was Chloe, was absolutely amazing! She was very attentive, caring, and humorous! The food was also delicious. I always get the Pan crushed chicken meal and it is always exceeds my expectations. read more

Good service, went around 4pm on thurs, pretty slow. This is where Bella vita used to be. It sits on the Geist marina. The menu is decent. I got the blackened shrimp tacos. I thought they'd be a bit more seasoned. They were good but could have been better. The ranch is soo good (drinkable). The moz sticks are good. They have a nice kick to them. They aren't huge either so nice for an app. Great views of the marina. Lots of seating: indoors, covered patio, patio. read more

See all

I went here on a Friday night at 6:30 and this place is apparently the place to be, it was already packed, (I would advise coming earlier if possible) luckily I was meeting with a group and we had reservations, there was still a 10 min wait but we were soon seated outside. This restaurant sits right off the Geist Reservoir which is a perfect location and quite scenic. I ordered the Peanut Buttercup Martin and it was delicious, like a dessert in a glass! I also had the Baja Shrimp Tacos with a side of broccoli and both was very good. We were a party of 12 and our server did a great job accommodating all of us. We then moved down to the lower deck where a live band playing (Foxxy & Friends) and they were really good, full of energy and played a variety of music. This was a drive for me but I had such a great time and cannot wait to go back. read more

See all

Just moved to the area and finally decided to pop in for lunch. Food was great and our waiter was so nice.(Thank you, Quintin!) Also can't beat having a great view of the water. We will definitely be coming back regularly. Thank you for an awesome lunch! We ordered the following, all were 10/10 and would order again. Smokehouse BBQ burger Brussels Sprouts Chicken salad sandwich Chicken bacon club sandwich Wolfie chips read more

I held a surprise 80th birthday party for my husband with about 30 guests in the upstairs balcony. I was so impressed with the ease of setting up the event with Brian the manager. He was polite, worked with me, and provided me with an event that exceeded my expectations. Several of our guests asked me if I have had other events there because it was so well run. I had not. Our quests also commented on the bartender, Gage. Again, the things that you would expect but don't always get - pleasant, engaging, and provided exceptional service. The food had been removed during cleanup, but Gage brought me a plate of hot chicken fingers from the kitchen. Between the open atmosphere, the excellent food, and the ease in setting up this event, I highly recommend Wolfies Grill - Geist. Dee G. 4/5/2025 read more

We met some friends for dinner and were seated on the patio with no wait. The place is directly on the water and we watched boats come in and go out. Very cool setting. We ordered some drinks and they were very good. I had the fish and chips as the waiter said they were very popular. Have to say they were not great. A little soggy and I found a piece of Saran Wrap in the last one on the last bite. But not a huge deal. Everyone else liked their dishes. The table had the club sandwich, pan seared chicken, shrimp tacos and tossed wings. Overall a very good meal and it was very affordable. Would go back again if we are ever in the area. read more

It's really about the location here - Gorgeous view, huge bar, arrive in style by boat! We sat inside at the bar, I had the Buffalo chicken salad and hubby had the fish sandwich. My salad was pretty good, standard Buffalo salad - fish sandwich was just ok, nothing spectacular. We used to come here long ago when it was Bella Vitas, so it was a little trip down memory lane for us. The bartender was a super friendly guy and service was good. We were here on a weekday around lunchtime and it was pretty busy, I can imagine this place is packed on the weekends when the weather is nice. read more

Wolfies Grill - Geist - Buffalo chicken salad (grilled) - American Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all