First time here and I was very happy about my experience all around! The bar is in the middle of a nice residential neighborhood which is cool. The interior is nicely decorated but still casual. Only one bartender working, but she handled the bar and multiple tables with groups that filled in after us fast and efficiently. Super nice and welcoming too. Meatball parm sandwich was up there with some of the best ones I've ever had. The seeded roll was crispy on the outside and soft on the inside...which held the meatballs and sauce together perfectly. The meatballs were well seasoned. Wife loved her chicken sandwich. The chicken was cooked perfectly. Mozzarella sticks are a must here! Can't wait to to come back. I'll definitely be a regular for sure. Outdoor seating in the back when it's nice out and maybe catching some live music sounds super chill. read more

See all

Visited this pub for dinner and drinks. The drinks were good, and our bartender was friendly. However, the food was not good or seasoned well. I ordered a cheesesteak, and it unfortunately was pretty tasteless. Overall, we would come back for drinks. read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

It nice not great but really nice. The staff is sweet and personable with the clientele like a good corner bar should be. Our waitress was great, carding my son 2 or 3 times ( he dose look young). They have light music playing and some TVs with the game on. There is a good selection of specialty cocktails and Michelob Ultra on tap!!!! I had the Chicken Cesar salad with a side of cheese fries and my wife and son got the French onion soup and camp fire burger. Cheese fries were on par and the Chicken in the Cesar salad was purdy good. The family thought the soup was very good. My son liked the burger but the wife thought it was supreme. Just goes to show you different strokes and all. We will come back to this neighborhood pub for the food but mostly for the as you say je ne sais quoi. Remember we had French onionSoup;) read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - Retro - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

See all

Had excellent chicken parm on Thursday evening. Good salad for my wife and good soup for me to start. Even the spaghetti & gravy side was excellent. The chicken was done to perfection. Portions were large and the desserts were also good. Service was top-notch and we are looking forward to their prime-rib one of these weekends. read more

We had a great meal here last night! Slack Tide Angry Osprey on tap started it off with my favorite local IPA. A nice warm loaf of sesame seeded bread with butter was old school warm and inviting. Stuffed mushrooms were generously filled with crab, and the butter sauce was to die for. The Prime Rib special was a thick, perfectly cooked portion that was so tender. This is old school at its finest, we can't wait to go back! read more

Overpriced service was mediocre. Ambience hasn't changed in 30 years needs refreshing.

Nice server. The food was over cooked. The restaurant interior/decor needs cleaning/updating.

I ordered the crab cake sandwich and my fiancé ordered a burger. He really enjoyed his food and I could tell my crab cake was fresh! The service was decent, my only critique would be for ambiance and that it was very dark inside. read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - Crab cake Sandwich - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

.always a great meal and good service. Been going there for decades and was never disappointed.

One and done, won't be back, poor service, burger wasn't cooked, inattentive waitress, place had a odor to it especially where we sat, very limited menu, no , I'm done. read more

Our first time here and we probably should be ashamed of ourselves because we only drive by this place every time we go to the shore by the way we're beach bombs. The place is very homey very personable employees owners will speak with you which is so great. So we had to crop bites and they were awesome so far. So we had to stuffed eggplant Parmesan with ricotta cheese it was very tasty the marinara sauce was tasty. So I would definitely suggest you stop by if you're riding through Mays Landing read more

Food is always good. The menu is so small now though. Hours are cut back too. We used to enjoy going mid week for lunch when the kids are at school. Service is always fast and the drink selection is nice read more

Food and service was excellent. First time here. The French onion soup was among the best I've had. Sorry no pictures I ate it too fast.

Red clam chowder had NOT ONE CLAM, and did not even have a smell of clam. It was red broth vegetable soup. Pub Nachos, after a long wait, arrived COLD. Beef was cold and seemed not very fresh. Refused the meal, with no apologies from staff. Left after finishing drinks. Wine was a generous pour. Will not return read more

The food was just okay - it probably would have been better if the food was hot. We ordered the dinner special sandwich but it didn't come with anything extra - not even coleslaw. The waitress never returned and we had to ask for beverage refill by waving her over. The dishes were literally cleared as we were still eating ... it makes u feel rushed. The place was half empty - so there was no reason. read more

Always wanted to check this spot out and we finally had the opportunity to. We went around Happy Hour time and they had a few specials. Drinks were discounted and $5 apps. The $5 apps were full size portions. We decided on the buffalo shrimp and an order of fried clams. Both came out hot and fresh. The shrimp were a good size and the clam strips were as well. Nothing was downscaled due to it being a happy hour menu item. We decided on a burger and a "Trooper" sandwich. Again both of these orders were not lacking on portion size. Had we known this we would've only ordered one app. The Trooper was not on the menu the bartender had suggested it after I had seen pics of it here on Yelp. Both the Campfire burger and roast beef sandwich were excellent. Full of flavor. We got here around 430pm and by 530pm there was a full parking lot, full bar, and people waiting to be seated. That seems to be their busy time. read more

See all

This review is a update of all the past reviews on this place. It's old and just okay. I wouldn't go out of my way for this place, I just ended up here with some family members because it was at a cross roads between our houses. I had soup and fries which was fine. The rest of the plates at the table were a decent size but just no wow factor for this little pub like place. read more

The hostess is always really nice and we've been here about 4 times since moving to the area a year ago. Wait staff (L.) not so friendly and seems like she's just putting in her hours. Menu is a plain white printed piece of copy paper (not a good look) and the interior is seriously outdated. Still have fake poinsettias up everywhere in March, the carpet is sooo old as are the tables, paneling, etc. Really feels old and not-so-clean sitting there. Food nothing to complain about but the cost of a drink is higher than most places-I'll only order water next time. Would go here again in a pinch, but not the first place we think of. Truly hope they refurbish and freshen the place up soon - might get more business. The name truly fits 'Ye OLD Pub". read more

I want to like this place, but it's gone down hill over the years. The food is mediocre at best lately. Last time I was there, I had to wait for 30 minutes fir my check, despite asking for it twice. The decor definitely needs to be updated read more

What a great place for dinner . Food is excellent and prices are reasonable . The nachos are the best !

Truly spectacular service and drinks and very good food Our family of four stopped in recently for an early supper. Unlike pretty much every other review I've written I have to start with the service and drinks which were truly spectacular. Nick, the owner, chatted with us about what we might like and made some excellent suggestions. The two drink specials we ordered - a Blackberry Bourbon smash and a Cucumber Mint martini - were 'Made by an Manhattan master mixologist' perfection. The food was quite good but not quite up to the same standard. The buffalo wings were delicious - naked and hot would be my recommendation. And the pub nachos were very tasty with homemade tortilla chips, real cheese, and yummy toppings...but the beef wasn't that great. We also had a pair of sandwich specials. The 'Trooper', roast beef w/melted cheese on a brioche covered in homemade brown gravy was actually pretty amazing. Not the kind of thing I normally go for, but Nick strongly recommended it and he was right. Sadly, the pork 'french-dip' on a Kaiser roll wasn't as tasty - the pork was dry and somewhat bland and the sandwich depended on long 'dipping' for flavor. But the 'comes with' - broccoli rabe and long grilled peppers - were worth the price of admission. read more

I haven't been here in a while and was looking forward to it. Now that I hear the owners have changed I can understand why it's changed. I went with my husband and kids. The prices are high, food is mediocre. My kids had spaghetti and meatballs. The meatballs were burnt on the outside. I had chicken Parmesan and it was cooked to death. My husband had seafood combo and he said his was good. The prices are comparable to maple wood for sub par food. It is truly a dark and depressing atmosphere too. It needs an upgrade to the decor. Probably won't be back. read more

Love love the food and friendly atmosphere. Jen and Tulla are the best bartenders. Locals love this place.

So this place really went the extra mile tonight. It's Father's Day, I had called a couple days ago to make sure they were still doing their prime rib specials on Saturday Sunday and Monday which they are, and we intended on going to dinner Sunday night to celebrate Father's Day. We got there at about 6:50 p.m. were seated promptly. Waitress came over and said I'm sorry we're closed they shouldn't have seated you the last seatings we were taking we're at 5:30. At first I thought she was joking but clearly she was being honest. She went into the kitchen and came back a few minutes later and said absolutely no problem we still have plenty of everything and there's no problem serving you. First this is exceptional, It wasn't their fault because they only decided the day before that they would close at 5:30 because that was their last reservation time that they had accepted. Thus this was not conveyed to me when I called a couple of days before. But they were going to accommodate us and they still had prime rib, rare the way I like it. My wife had the veal parmesan I have course had the prime rib and everything was exceptional.This place out did themselves. Thanks to all at the restaurant for being just the way we've always seen you be in the past. Keep up the good work we love you. read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - Prime Rib - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

See all

Came here on a Sunday after church and had to wait till 1pm for them to open. Specials of lobster and shrimp ravioli or prime rib both seems very high at $27.95! I had a delicious campfire burger, served on a day old bun that was cracked in half on the bottom and just shredded on the top while I tried to eat it. It was a frozen burger patty with an old flavor, but toppings took over and the flavor rocked! Dinner prices seemed a bit high for such an old-fashioned little restaurant. (Spaghetti and meatballs for $16.95). If I were to go back for a burger, it would have to be covered with sauce to combat the "old frozen" burger taste. We go there for memories and French onion soup (which I did not have this time). The place is a bit overrated. Booths are small, a bit dark inside. Mainly senior citizens from the neighborhood frequent this place. read more

We've been Friday regulars for years! New owners took over a few weeks ago and the service SUCKS!!! We were not greeted at the door as we are accustomed to. No more drink specials! Sat at the bar with my empty plate and empty wine glass for over 20 minutes! Waited an additional 20 minutes for our check! So very disappointed! read more

We went here with a group of 4 for a late dinner. We we were greeted by the bartender who ended up being our waitress for the night. For drinks we had martinis, which were the perfect. For apps we had calamari, it was very heavy on the bread to calamari ratio. The shrimp scampi was delicious, the butter was not overpowering and the noodles were cooked very well. The sauce on the stuffed mushrooms was a little salty for the tables preference, but the actual crabmeat balls were slightly soggy but delicious. The chicken Caesar salad was absolutely massive, chicken was well cooked and well dressed. They were also able to accommodate for my veganism and made a veggie quesadilla. The best part of this excursion was the bar tender. She was extremely helpful, and took on our table which was across the way, so I applaud her. read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - Titos martini with cherries - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

It's a nice pub. I ordered the cold cuts sandwich which I thought was bland. The cheese was cut on the thick side. The others in my party stated that their liver and onions was a little dry despite it being covered in gravy. Also, I wasn't a fan of our server. She wasn't friendly or all that attentive. The best part was the complimentary bread. That was delicious! That's the only reason I'd want to come back. read more

Heard a lot of good things about this place and I finally went for dinner. I had the chicken Oscar special and it was delicious! Asked for the house Cabernet and it was the Smoking Loon and it's now my new favorite, and for dessert I had their homemade cheesecake and it was great. Our waiter was very professional and funny, well be back! read more

Ye Olde Mill Street Pub - American Near Me - Mays Landing, New Jersey

Been there many times. Was good. Tonight not so. Prime rib special was chewy and cold. Manhattan clam chowder was all broth. Mentioned this to our server. Nothing done. Not sure we will be back. read more

My husband and I went to the Ye Olde Mill Street Pub last night for our anniversary. I got the Prime Rib special for Monday evening which was a big slice of "English Cut" prime rib, soup and salad, two sides, dessert and coffee all for only $20! I love prime rib and order it everywhere I go that has it and I must say that this is probably the best prime rib I have ever had. It was cooked perfectly and so delicious with hardly any fat on it. I had a side of mashed potatoes and gravy and the potatoes were real, not instant. The soup was creamy Tuscan sausage and was delicious. The salad was extremely fresh tasting with great homemade dressing. My husband had crab cakes which he said were delicious without a whole lot of filler. We had such a great meal with great service that we will definitely be going back again! read more

First time. Friends live nearby. Great dinner! Great Service! Thanks! Menu has plenty offer. Stuffed mushrooms were superb!

This establishment has changed so much! It was amazing about 7 years ago! Then it changed so much, staff went to the gutter. Just wish it were better staffed! read more

Do not go if you have any disability! I am only weight bearing on one leg and i had a door shut on me.my husband pulled up the car for easier assess and they complained. When my husband went to explain a waitress didn't want to hear the explanation she started yelling. I do not recommend this restaurant and find them very hostile. read more

This was the best meal I have had in a long time. I ordered a Deluxe Mushroom Swiss Gourmet Burger with a side of mashed potatoes. My husband ordered a Hot Roast Beef sandwich with mashed potatoes. Both were excellent but the gravy was AMAZING!!!!! The gravy tasted like a prime rib roast. The staff were friendly and efficient. We haven't been there in a long time but we will be back! read more

Had the sausage sandwich. My wife had a chicken wrap. Both were well prepared and flavorful. The service detracted from the meal. Waitress seemed bothered by our presence. There are many other places to eat in the area where your patronage will be appreciated. read more

Quiet and cozy atmosphere. Inside could use a little updating as it is showing it's age. Otherwise, a great place for a good meal.

apparently this place at one point was awesome, then crappy for a stretch, and now is awesome again. i've been there several times in the past year or so and it's an absolute HOME RUN each time. the prime rib is win. the beef pastini soup is win. the chicken parm is win. the pub burger or whatever they call it is amazing! the crowd is mostly old guard, but i can't blame them. the prices are great to boot. read more

I took my family to dinner tonight. We eat out a LOT and this was by far the worst meal we have had in years. The one bright spot was that they had a solid beer selection on tap. The decor is terrible unless you're trapped in the 1970s. The food was awful. Everything we had tasted like it was frozen or came out of a jar. The ravioli that both of my kids got barely had any cheese at all in them and my wife's fried flounder was dry and tasted like it was fried in burned oil. The only compliment I can give is that they did remove it from the bill. We will never eat here again. read more

I lived in Mays Landing for over 5 years and I have ordered their take-out on several occasions. They are a little above average as far as price is concerned, but they have typical steak, seafood, chicken, pasta, soups and salad platters. I always ordered the prime rib with the mixed vegetables and mashed potatoes. Their french onion soup or soup of the day is always very good. I have had better, but they rank in the top for South Jersey especially in this area. Family owned and operated and the service is always good. The bartenders are extremely cordial. read more