I agree with the person that said if she lived closer she would not own dishes. Good food. Plenty of it. Very friendly people.

Out for a ride on the motorcycle with the misses and hey, why not stop at your typical American roadside diner? Located just west of the village of Palmyra on Rt. 31 this seemed like a great place to grab dinner on our way back to Roc city. I promptly ordered up the fried chicken and mashed potatoes, while my other half dove into the ceaser chicken wrap. The wrap was more than she could handle portion wise, so I got to sample that as well. Here's the downlow, the chicken was very tasty. Juicy on the inside and a very interesting crispy coating on the outside. If I had to give a negative here it's that of the four pieces given two were rather small and left me still just a bit hungry. The homemade coleslaw was great. And the mashed potatoes were just as expected. Typical diner potatoes. The ceaser wrap....Oh the ceaser wrap. While certainly moist it and full of juicy chicken, I questioned the choice of dressing. But don't get me wrong. Still very good. All in all a spot on diner to grab some evening fare. Dinner for two with water and one giant (oops almost forgot the homemade out of this world strawberry shortcake) came to $25 bucks. Our waitress Robin was great, super friendly and a wonderful smile. I was hoping she might break out with a "kiss my grits" when we placed our order, but alas, my TV fantasy diner was not realized in its entirety this trip. Perhaps next time we're here. And yes there will be a next time. read more

Yellow Mills Diner - Diners Near Me - Palmyra, New York

First, don't worry about deciding whether you want Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing on your salad. You'll get the non-descript white creamy dressing. The food was mediocre, but the funnest part was when the bill came and charged us too much for one of the dishes. The manager "apologized" that the prices on the menu were wrong, and tried to make the price stick. She finally relented, and reduced the bill. read more

Me and my wife went here for breakfast, let me say its clean and a very nice atmosphere. They do not have alot on there menu, I am sorry to say the food was not good. I was real sad CZ alot of people told us how great it is there. It was not that good at all. read more

Your average local diner. I live nearby so I've been going here since it opened. Sandwiches and wraps for lunch, typical American and Greek dishes for dinner. Good milkshakes depending on the server. I've never had bad or slow service there. read more

Great gyro but gross potatoes. Service was slow. Milk shake okay. May be one of the best places this small town has to offer?

This is one of many hit and miss places in the area. Food is not something I would go out of my way to eat.

This quaint restaurant got us right in. The food was priced well and was delicious. We got the bacon cheese burger, tuna melt, chili bowl, steak sandwich and pastrami sandwich. Everything was yummy! The mashed potatoes were home made. read more

Do you like homemade soup like your mom would make you? Their chicken with pasta soup tasted like a piece of heaven on earth. Maybe that's cause Palmyra is such a spiritual place. Anyhow, their prices are extremely reasonable, the menu is large, and they serve breakfast all day. Hey now, you're probably saying, "Well, Denny's serves breakfast all day and look at the quality of their food?" This ain't no Denny's. the food is freshly made...my wife's turkey sandwich was made from freshly roasted turkey breast, not a cold cut out of a package. The only reason I deduct one star is because the service was just o.k. and had to grab napkins from another table and get the waitress's attention to refill our drinks. read more

Typical Greek diner. Great variety. Had spinach omelette and hubby had eggs Benedict. Large portions neither of us could finish. Very yummy. Waitress was efficient and friendly. Price reasonable. read more

Great service and food. Loved the salad bowl. Great resturant to breakfast,lunch,or dinner

I love coming here Saturday mornings with my family...they are like another family to me. The Spinach and feta omelet is amazing, and I've had dinner here a few times as well. The mousakka was awesome, first time I had had it, and I want more! read more

Great dinner after a long day on the road. We wanted comfort food and got plenty of it here. Great hand-dipped chocolate shakes, good soups, and delicious entrees. Wife got Alfredo with shrimp. I got chicken and biscuits. Huge chunks of fresh veggies cooked in with the chicken and cream sauce. Topped it off with a very friendly, quick, and attentive waitress. After a horrible experience last night with painfully slow service elsewhere this was a welcome change. We would gladly stop by again if we are ever back in the area. read more

I have been here for breakfast solo and for dinner with a group a few times. I had an issue a long time ago which was never remedied or apologized. I gave them a second chance but this time I had the Chicken Parmesan. As I cut into it I notice on the underside black spots. Then I saw a piece of aluminum foil. The server never apologized or ask if I wanted a replacement or something different. Just not good business and that is the last time I will go there. Being ignored means I am not a valued customer. The same server also was at the cash register. read more

We like Yellow Mills Diner. Our favorite stop for breakfast.....lunch and dinners are good too. Never had bad service or bad food.....always leave satisfied. "Dad can we go to Yellow Mills?"....I get that often enough. one of our fav places. read more

Excellent service and food. We got some breakfast food, kids spaghetti, Philly cheese steak, and fried chicken and all were very good. The prices were very low too. I'm from out of state so this type of food would easily be 5 dollars more there. read more

Not a fan at all place had a funny odor when we walked in. I love diners, the food the atmosphere all of it. I didn't get the fun diner vibe I was looking for. The service was polite but not overly friendly. The food was mediocre at best portions were smaller than other area diners. I went a second time thinking maybe it was just an off day. Still same odd smell (what are they doing in there?!) same service, different meal but same quality... The prices weren't too bad if there were no other choices close I'd suck it up and go back but thank goodness we have choices :) read more

I love this place. They have a really great turkey dinner. Their scallop dinner is excellent too. Soups are good and salads are good too. Highly recommended. read more

We really like Yellow-Mills and send people over to patronize them often. I really like their burgers and my wife loves their wraps. We are glad that Yellow Mills is part of the Community. read more

Basic diner, decent food, no surprises. No complaints. Waitresses are wonderful gals.

What a treat. Stopped here with my family and couldn't be happier to find this hidden country gem. The service and found was impeccable, chicken parm was so delicious and portion was huge. Not to mention my bill was under $25! Can't wait to try them again for breakfast. read more

I'll say Yellow Mills Diner is A-OK because I've only been there for breakfast/brunch, and it's been good every time. The pancakes and omelettes are always good and the portions are generous. The servers have always been friendly. I have no complaints! read more

Went to dinner for business, I ordered a steak sandwich,which was cooked great. The other 2 people that I met for business also enjoyed the food. The atmosphere was very nice and and service great. The big surprise at the end was the billing. The Pricing was very reasonable for what was served. Thanks again for the service. read more