Pizza here is great. Delicious. And if you're lucky you may get a friendly host to prepare your pizza without making you feel inferior as you choose toppings. If you're really lucky they will generously make you a solid pizza. Sometimes, unfortunately, you're not so lucky. The gluten free crust is a nice bonus until you find out it costs your left kidney. We got three 8" pizzas gluten free crusts and our total was $40. That's a hefty chunk of change. So if you like paying for overpriced yet tasty options for your gut give it a shot. read more

See all

I have been a few times to grab myself a pizza and binge watch some TV. I found my "go-to" my first time and haven't tried anything else since - so I recommend "The Nat" with both pesto and marinara base. I feel they are generous with toppings and service isn't too bad! The food isn't anything special, but prefer it over any other personal pizza place nearby. Also if it is busy and you get your food to go, you probably won't find a place to sit so you'll stand and block the fountain drink section. read more

My husband and I wanted to give this place a try due to loving this style and concept of pizza. The making of the pizza went perfect, the young man behind the counter was very kind and respectful. The topping area was clean which was a comfort. Too bad that I cannot say that about the eating area! Whoa!!! It was BAD! EVERY table was dirty so we had to clean one off to be able to eat there while 4 girls stood around talking and on there phones right behind the counter. As we ate I started looking around and the floor was disgusting!! So, I did what any Yelp reviewer would do, I started taking pictures. I think they caught on to what I was doing and they started swarming around "trying" to clean. One picture I took early on was all the trash and food around the trash can. Well, you will see in another picture I took after the girl was "cleaning" she literally swept the trash and food UNDER the trash can!! Another girl was wiping tables down and wiped all the food and papers on the floor... AFTER the other girl had already swept the floor! I got a brownie and when I went to unwrap it I noticed the bottom corner wasn't wrapped and the brownie was hard on that side so I left it wrapped and went to the counter and asked if I could trade it for a different brownie. I just randomly grabbed a brownie and as soon as I flipped it over to check the wrapping a bigger section than the previous brownie was unwrapped also. So, I had to dig through the brownies and give the girls the ones that were unwrapped before I could find a brownie that was fully wrapped and not hard. When I went to fill my drink I also took a picture of how dirty the drink station was with all of the spray of pop/soda that had not been cleaned. Then the final straw was when my husband passed all of the employees, standing behind the counter talking, as he was going to go use the restroom to only get in there and have to turn around and come right back out because there wasn't any toilet paper. Just no work ethic, hard brownies, and filthy!! We were really hoping it would've been a great experience. Nope. read more

See all

Overall it's was just okay. The staff was super friendly, but lacked speed and efficiency. There were about six people in line, 3 tables sitting and every other table in the restaurant was dirty. They haven't been opened long, so somewhat understandable. They need to work out the kinks. My husband and I shared a Greek salad and pizza. The Greek salad was great. The pizza was lacking, the crust doesn't have much flavor nor does the sauce. I didn't dislike it it, but far from my favorite pizza place. I will definitely give them another try! I think my kids will enjoy it, but I will most likely stick to the salads. read more

My wife and I visited on a Friday night around 7 pm and there was a line leading almost to the door. However, the line moved quite quickly, but of course how quickly it moves is relative to the company you are keeping. We were pleased with the menu options and the variety of crusts. My wife was able to get a gluten-free crust and I could get a wheat crust. It felt like there were a plethora of toppings available. Our time ordering was normal and the staff, while not a fine-tuned machine was adequate at their task. We had no complaints with the speed of service. Our orders taken, we sat down and enjoyed some good conversation. Our pizzas were out in a very reasonable time, although I didn't time it exactly, it felt like it was quick. The pizza is tasty and whether you think it is awesome or not really boils down to personal preference. My wife and I really enjoyed the taste and I appreciated that my crust wasn't burnt. (That happens more than I'd like at other places.) The restaurant and bathrooms were clean and overall it was a very good experience which left us feeling like we would definitely come back. There was one negative, which really isn't a big deal, but when asked if I wanted an email receipt I entered my email (and yes I double-checked the accuracy of what I entered) but yet I never received an email receipt. No big deal in the grand scheme of things but if you say you are going to do something, you should do it. We will be back. read more

I got a build your own pizza and my boyfriend got the Southern Heat... they were amazing! Friendly staff and delicious pizza! Don't skip the gelato! read more

Your Pie Pizza - BYO pizza and Southern Heat - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

See all

Came in and was very impressed! The management is phenomenal and keeps their whole staff in order. All workers are friendly and will go above and beyond in helping you enjoy the food! One worker named Adolfo is the best! He's always making sure my pizza is made with extreme care! Definitely try the Alfredo pasta! It is great especially if you add sausage! Best pizza place by far! read more

My husband and I ordered take out and were disappointed. We ordered one build your own pie, two side salads, and an order of cheese sticks. The order wasn't ready when I got their to pick it up so I decided to have a beer while I waited. 3 out of the 6 Taps were not working. (Also, if you're going to say you serve craft beers, you should do better than SweetWater 420, Bud Light, Yuengling, Sam Adams, and Blue Moon.) The side salads were skimpy at best. The cheese sticks were super light on the cheese (over half did not have cheese). The BYO pizza was good, but lukewarm by the time I got home and I live less than 3 miles from the location. Needless to say, this was not the best visit, but we will try them again in about 6 months after they've had time to work out the kinks. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Skimpy salad - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

See all

Food is delicious, but the staff is rude. The new $6 upcharge for gluten free and cauliflower crust is ridiculous. Pizza maker smacked gum and had a bad attitude. read more

Hot as hell in restaurant. Owners need to turn AC down if operating a pizza oven. As I'm eating my pizza, find a piece of plastic. No one came out to apologize or take meal off bill. Won't be back. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

Good food! However, I am curious where the adults are? I have no issue with younger adults or teenagers, but the process for ordering food was chaotic and unclear. read more

Wow wow wow...... 1. Bad Management, very disorganized place, he really look like that he doesn't know how to Manage this place. Im not going to given more of the negative points here on my review for FREE, they need to figure out with hard work or change the Manager. I did order 2 pizzas, they are very smaller if you compare with Blaze Pizza size and ingredients to make your own, than the price is about the same, and the young workers there still need to learn a lot more. I do believe in opportunities and given opportunities to others who understand really good what they are supposed to be doing, specially if is my business and I put the money. I made my own pizza as a pepperoni and I put a good portion of pepperoni when server was making the pizza, and when I open the box, it was very disappointed because it wasn't the pizza that I order, it didn't came 1 pepperoni, plus the pizzas the ingredients has no tasty, Spoke with Manager the day after I order the pizzas because when I got home it was already more than 10pm, they were closed, I "tried" to explain to him that the 1 pizza that I did order it was uncooked, and the other came wrong but he's very impatient to hear me, and Rude, at point that I just told him that; Thanks for been so nice and left. It's So RUDE, he isn't a good exemplo to his coworkers and this new generation of youngest people that working there. Definitely not recommend to anyone who Love a great pizza and great customer service. read more

Grand opening day for the Your Pie at the new Durbin Park. They had a opening day special price for their personalized pizzas so the place was booking. Order up at the counter, pick your dough and sauce, choose all your Ingredients (they're fresh; your choice of any and all). Very quick & efficient, your pizza made in their brick oven and brought out to you. Fountain drinks & tea. Have a small but decent variety of beers, all on tap. Everything we had tasted very good! Will try this place again at later date and update this review. read more

Had a rough start with this place two years ago but it has gotten much better. Also, even if the food is good, an establishment is only as good as its employees. Shout out to Lordes, who is so sweet and took the time to verify the ingredients when I called ahead before ordering UberEats. She really cares about her customers. Five star employee. read more

My whole family got food poisoning. I called the store 4 times now for a call back from a manager and nothing. We got 2 kids meals and a Greek salad. I've even emailed. Now I have disputed my purchase with my bank because of management ignoring me. read more

We stopped into this new location in the Durban area. You walk up to the counter where you get to pick your pizza crust, sauce, and any of the toppings for a set price. Then they bake it and bring it out to you in just a few minutes. They have a tap THAT has about 5 different beer choices and some wine choices too. I really enjoyed my pizza, my husband liked his too. We went early on a weekday probably about 5 and there was no wait. I just got a coupon in the mail to try their pasta for free so I'm going to try that next, and they have salads too that I saw many people getting. read more

Your Pie Pizza - MY Pie and Beer - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

I absolutely adore the "make your own pizza idea". They are always so busy but ready to help you nicely. The pizzas are amazing!! Love this place. Always a go to! read more

Ordered a barbecue *chicken* pizza and was sent this. For $19, no thanks we will not order from here again. read more

Your Pie Pizza - No chicken - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

Stopped by last night for two pasta bowls to go! These were good, and I bet they are better if you eat them there right when they come out of the oven. The basics are pasta, Alfredo sauce & cheese but you can have any of the regular pizza ingredients put on the bowl as well. Service wasn't fast but not slow either. You go through a line to order as you go, mich like a moes or subway... but u take a number and wait for your food to cook. You can get personal pizzas, cheese sticks, salads and a lot more here. read more

Really easy and simple way to order pizza,get to choose your own dough and toppings, and the staff was helpful and Informative. We have taken family and friends there several times when they visit us. Pizza does taste good it cones in individual personal pan pies and the dough isn't to thick or thin it's jut right. read more

My husband and I had lunch here and it was fantastic! The service was great and food was delicious! We did the pizza and salad combo. I should of taken pictures! Everything was fresh! We'll definitely be back! read more

I stopped going here about 8 months ago because they consistently started burning the bottom of the pizza. I decided today to try it again and guess what.... burned again. It was much better when they first opened, but the managers that were here at the time and no longer here. read more

Your Pie Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - ST JOHNS, Florida

Food is great, friendly staff, and the place was clean. Ordered 5 build your owns and a pasta.

Not sure about the bad reviews here. You are basically telling the staff what you want on your pizza- you want extra pepperoni, ask for it. All the ingredients are top notch,; crust and sauce are great. Service is prompt once you get up the line to order. We are big fans and this is our go to pizza place. P.S. the pasta is good as well! read more

This was our first time at Your Pie and was really looking forward to it. After waiting in a short line we started the order and was disappointed to find out that they didn't have vegan cheese available. One would think that since it's the grand opening weekend that there would have been enough product on hand and running out wouldn't be happening. We might be going back to give them a 2nd try someday. read more

Went Day 2 and service was fast and the pizza was delicious. Would give 5 but the salad portion was very small and the pizza is a little pricey. But I loved the pizza and will go back. read more

Ordered a carry out, pasta was cold, missing items ordered for make your own. Front entrance windows are absolutely dirty with finger prints and smudges all over them. The place wasn't busy at all, they couldn't find the online order that I placed, it was sitting out in the open, got back to the office and it was cold, with crusty cold cheese on the top. Will not order here again. read more

First visit on Sunday 7/21 for early lunch. Can't give them props for this visit as they were out of plant-based cheese. Seems odd. Maybe we'll try again. A nice gesture would have been a coupon for a future visit...but maybe because of the newness and staff still getting their feet under them, it did not occur to offer. read more

Mod pizza is our usual joint but we heard your pie had vegan cheese & happened to be in that area, so we decided to stop in & give it a shot. Your Pie not only met expectations but totally exceeded them! Caitlyn (sp?) helped make the pizza & panini, and Bryan helped us at the register. Both were incredibly friendly and helpful. The ingredients were all fresh and totally customizable. I loved the gelato bar and how it had equal parts gelato/sorbet options, and was entirely GF. The veggie panini I customized was out of this world! Perfect amount of sauces veggies and cheese. They use Follow Your Heart, which is one of my personal favorite brands. Much better than daiya! Overall this experience was wonderful and while I live walking distance from Mod, the 5 minute drive to Your Pie is TOTALLY worth it read more

I went to grab pizza to go around 6pm and didn't have to wait in line. I loved that I was able to customize the sauce and toppings. The employees provided fast friends service. Overall it was a great experience. read more

I really enjoy your pie pizza they have very good food but every time I order from DoorDash the order is burnt cut and evenly and just all-around not a great pizza consistently when ordering through the DoorDash app it seems as if they don't put in the effort read more

Big fan of another Your Pie location. Came here for their Grand Opening and they did not disappoint. Well organized and delivered quality food made quickly and with care. Toppings were fresh and delicious. Crust was perfect. Staff was friendly and attentive. Highly recommend!! read more

I ordered online through their website for pickup. Once I arrived, I checked to make sure I was not early for the estimated time my order would be completed (which I was not).When I asked to pick up my order they could not find my ticket and advised my meal was not prepared. I asked for a refund, which they gave me but they said they could not refund the tip amount I added online. Then I had to go back in for the rest of my check amount as the refund total was not correct. Just irritated as I ordered on the business' website not through an app like Grubhub or DoorDash and they had issues receiving my order. read more

Went there opening day! Everything ran smooth like they've been open for months! Comfortable dining, great pizza, friendly staff. Will definitely be our new favorite! Great job y'all! read more

Clean, affordable place serving great food. I suggest checking the menu before getting in line. Similar set up to chipotle. Build your own or pick a feature dish. Salads available at the counter as side as well. read more

So incredibly slllooowww! Been in a small line for 20 minutes now. Amateur hour compared to other "build your own" pizza restaurants.

Pizza was good & the kids loved it. It was an added bonus to have beers and wine at the location. Service was excellent and we enjoyed gelatos for dessert. read more

See all

Really hard working owner! Pizza was great and fast and fresh salads there was a bonus! Grey addition to the area

Went there for lunch. Had the lunch special. 1/2 penni chicken, bacon and ranch, with salad and drink. They made the penni and then cooked the whole thing, I wasn't a fan of the cooked spinach and tomato. The salads are ok. read more

Omg!!! Kathrine was just helping me the other day and she is the best. She went the extra mile to make me happy. I will be back soon thanks to Kathrine. read more