Great place all the way around, food quality, value and service. Went with a group of friends and we all enjoyed the experience. Highly recommended. read more

Place has really went down hill! Ordered 3 pizzas in a empty restaurant. As we waited 20 minutes I walk to the counter to see our pizzas just sitting there. They try to hand them to us ICE cold. Pathetic at best ! read more

Your Pie is extremely similar to my favorite pizza restaurant ever, Blaze Pizza. The style of restaurant is basically the same. You pay a set price for a pizza with unlimited toppings. They build the pizza right in front of you before setting it in the oven to bake. There are many toppings options to choose from, and they can easily accommodate for those with allergies or dietary restrictions. Overall, I prefer still Blaze over Your Pie. read more

This is amazing, the food is cheap and delicious. I go here all the time! It is my favorite place to eat and it is very clean. This place is amazing and I highly recommend it. read more

Delicious! Love that you can get unlimited toppings on your pizza for only $7.99. They are very accommodating to any requests you have or if you have a special diet/allergy. The butter pecan gelato was the perfect dessert after a yummy pizza. One of the owners was walking around clearing up dishes and talking to the guests which was very nice. She requested we get the butter pecan and even got it for us. Very nice place and will be returning! read more

this pizza was about as good as i expected it to be--nothing special, definitely not authentic. like the pizza version of a chipotle. I am, however, thrilled to have another cheap and easy option in town for vegan, vegetarian, and/or gluten free folks! This place would also be a great option for a large group or picky eaters--everyone can choose exactly what they want on their own pies! read more

Gluten free crusts available and UNLIMITED TOPPINGS, build your own personal pizza pick sauce anddd they have gelato. Pizza lover? Go here.

Such a neat new restaurant! My roommate and I stopped by to bring a pizza home when we found out you can get unlimited toppings on a made-to-order pizza for $8. So we went up to the front where you custom choose your dough, cheese, and toppings. We piled plenty on with each of us having a side for whatever we wanted. The staff were very helpful, making it a fun & easy experience for us. Size-wise the 10 inch pizza was perfect for the two of us to split and be very full after. I'll definitely be back, especially to try the gelato!! read more

Great pizza - love all the choices - 3 stars because $3.50 extra for gluten free is outrageous. MOD pizza us $2 more and larger.

Disappointed. I frequent build your own pizza places across the Carolinas and looked forward to one in Wilmington. The gluten free crust is store bought. The regular crust is made in Georgia and shipped. Worst of all, both pizzas were served with cold toppings. The cheese hadn't even melted on either one. A friend had arrived earlier and told us hers, and her daughters, had cold toppings too. It's a chain so the owners have no control on the poor crust, but they could cook the pizza properly. There's another chain opening near Mayfaire. If that owner does it like the others I have visited, we don't have long to wait for good build your own pizza. read more

This Your Pie has always been a hit! They have the best gluten free pizza! The staff are always super nice and the service is fast.

I can't recommend this place enough! The pizza was so good and options were available in all aspects to please literally anyone! Craft beer and gelato options were also excellent and prices were very reasonable. I'd also like to call out the excellent customer service by Jon, who checked on our table to make sure everyone was happy. That's rare at a counter service place. He was so nice and welcoming, somebody get that guy a raise. read more

So many choices! Crispy light pizza pie with frash choices.. Tastie Yum. Fast and friendly service. Definately will repeat.

This was my first time. I bought total 4 pizzas 1 cheese 1 pepperoni,1 pepperoni and sausage, 1 nat. Not impressed. The pizzas had very little cheese and taste wasn't that good. For $35 dollars I expected more. read more

I have been to several of these types of "build your own pizza" restaurants in different areas of the country and I was excited to try this one out. I will say that the pizza itself met my expectations and may have been one of the best I've had, taste wise, however it seemed like the staff was a little undertrained. Everyone was very polite and pleasant however, so I wouldn't call it bad customer service. Overall it's a great spot! read more

Love the speed of service, quality of ingredients, price point, and friendly staff. Great place where everyone gets what they want on their own personal pie! Awesome draft beer selection, just wish they had more of a local selection since Wilmington is packed with so many tasty brews. We recommend this place to families, for date night, for groups of friends, or solo for a quick and easy bite! Your Pie-My Pie-Everybody's Pie! read more

Overall Phenomenal! Love the customization possibilities, the vibes, and the taste of the food and gelato! Will be back to try the beer and wine! Also, great options for those that are health conscious, vegan or vegetarian! read more

Loved the pizza selection here. Vegan friendly options. The staff is super friendly. The gelato is great. The size of the pizza is great and fills you up. read more

Went to Your Pie on Saturday (St. Patricks Day) for supper. We loved it!!! It may be the best pizza I have EVER had! Everything was so fresh. Every bite just seemed... well, fresh! The service was great and very friendly. It was cooked in a fire over to perfection in just a few minutes! It was so good that we went back the next day for lunch! I HIGHLY recommend Your Pie to anyone! They have white, wheat, and gluten free dough. Several sauces (maranara, olive oil, bbq, buffalo, and alfredo). Tons of veggies, meats, and cheeses! I just hope they will build one in Leland! If not, it will be worth the drive and time! read more

My husband and I was very impressed with Your Pie and will definitely be returning. I love the ability to choose your own toppings, as many as you want. They also have free dipping sauces which includes delicious Ranch dressing. I didn't ask if it was homemade but it tasted like it. We opted to get the combo which I believe was $3.99 extra for a drink and small gelato with our pizzas. The gelato was great as well. I can't wait to bring our daughter as I am sure she will love the concept of choosing her own toppings even if that only consists of the 2 items she eats on pizza. The owner Jada came over and asked how everything was which I really appreciate. The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable. read more

I had lunch here today with a friend, it was so delicious! It was cooked perfectly, and the toppings were so fresh! I love how each and every thing on the menu shows the amount of calories too. Great concept, very quick, perfect option for lunch or dinner. Oh, what did I eat? I had a pizza with wheat crust, marinara, mozzarella, spinach, sun dried tomatoes, extra black olives, mushroom, basil, and garlic. read more

I love how quick and tasty this place is! My boyfriend and I ordered 3 pizzas and cheese sticks and got our food easily within 5 minutes of paying. Everything tasted great and very good for the price. We will definitely be coming back! read more

This place was absolutely amazing my pie was out of this world it had exactly what I wanted on it and I'm going to become the back over and over and over again ...loved it! read more

Delicious! We came in when it was pretty packed and the line was almost to the door. We needed the time to decide what we wanted, but once we made it to the line the customer service was fantastic. Our pizzas were made quickly, and soon after we took a seat all four of our pizzas were ready. The flavor was great. I recommend the buffalo chicken pizza. read more

Super good for a quick, yummy, and filling dinner. Everyone gets their own pizza, which makes it easy when people can not agree on toppings. In addition, by the time we paid and got our drinks, we had our pizza within 5 minutes. We walked in at 8:15 last night (They close at 9) and service was still good. The only negative I would give Your Pie is that there seemed to be a lot of workers just walking around and not taking orders/checking people out while there was a long line in the restaurant. They could have definitely been more attentive in that aspect. read more

Finally found a great pizza place in Willmywood! My husband and I have been here at least six times already and it just keeps getting better! read more

Good atmosphere. Good price - unlimited toppings, one price! They are generous with toppings, fast service. Children friendly. Can be healthy with wheat, vegan options. Good for casual outings with friends or family. Worth a visit! read more

I love that place. Great hot fresh ingredients pizza! Great service she friendly staff.

Fantastic! Also, very open to taking precautions for people with allergies! They have the ingredients posted so it's easy to find something safe! My personal favorite place for a personal size pizza! read more

Service was slow, had a to-go order that was forgotten about and only offered half hearted apologies and cold food. Won't be back‍

Great pizza and I like being able to build my own. Service was friendly and helpful. Would eat there again. Only negative was that the spinach in my caprese salad was a bit gritty; could've used another rinse. Still I would go back for the pizza or panini and just skip the salad. read more

Your Pie isn't bad but it's not good, the pizza was not the highest quality and tasted bland. It's cute and is nice to sit outside if you're not being annoyed my geese. read more

We have eaten at this place about 35 times is a little over a year and previously left a 5 star rating, but last week was the final time.  The owners need a brain, someone needs to tell then that the loud music that the customers are forced to endure is not what we want.  We were one of 3 different couples eating there in mid afternoon, meaning it was slow, yet every body at every table is yelling at each other because of the stupid music.  We left there is bad moods and will never go back.  I don't get it do they really believe that people want to hear something that is so dominating?  Wake up you are driving customers away.  Oh yeah they are also cutting back on the cheese. read more

Nothing but greatness here! I've been at least 5 times in the passed few weeks. Service is super good and very helpful! I want to shout out Bryan and Lex for always being really nice and attentive whenever me and my boyfriend come in. Also not sure if I just pick really good toppings but the pizza is always to DIE for!!!!! read more

Just tried this for the first time last night. My pizza came out with a small portion missing from the crust and the manager insisted on making me another to take home. Service was great as was the food. Not going to Your Pie is your loss! read more

Fresh seasonal ingredients, friendly service. The peach prosciutto pie was delightful. They have online ordering that is actually timed so the pizza is coming out of the oven when you arrive to pick up. read more

Ordered bbq chicken pizza on wheat, add jalapeños. Crust, sauce, cheese and chicken was good. The jalapeños were scarce and cut in such small pieces, I could almost not tell the difference between them and the cilantro. Also, the side salad was tiny. For $12.82 including water, it could have been better. Service was good and restaurant was clean. read more

This was my first time here and it was FANTASTIC!! We will definitely be back! So delicious and such a friendly staff!!

Great pizza and friendly staff! The ingredients were so fresh! Was worth the little line we had to wait in!